New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

austerity works

this latest from the Eurozone: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/16/b...l=1&adxnnlx=1329339618-f8cszt1ecwwoiZjWZde2gQ

The euro zone economy shrank slightly less than expected in the last three months of 2011, but five countries including Italy fell into recession as the sovereign debt crisis discouraged consumers from spending and businesses from investing. sovereign debt crisisdiscouraged consumers from spending and businesses from investing.

Growth in the 17 countries that make up the euro zone fell 0.3 percent, Eurostat, the European statistics agency said [PDF] Wednesday. But the pain was most acute among smaller countries and in southern Europe — ground zero of the debt crisis.

...“It could have been worse,” Martin van Vliet, an economist at ING Bank, said in a note to clients. The figures “clearly indicate that ‘core’ euro zone economies generally were less affected by the escalating debt crisis than peripheral economies, which seems to make sense given that the financial turmoil and austerity efforts are concentrated in the latter part of the region.”
In case you were wondering whether even hobbled stimulus efforts matter, here’s the context with which Eurostat framed its update:

During the fourth quarter of 2011, GDP in the United States increased by 0.7% compared with the previous quarter (after +0.5% in the third quarter of 2011)...Compared with the same quarter of the previous year, GDP rose by 1.6% in the United States (after +1.5% in the previous quarter)...


So in the real world despite what the Repubswill tell you, or Paul Ryan, slashing demand in a recession is an astonishingly stupid thing to do.

UK jobless claims rise http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-...oyment-holds-at-highest-rate-in-16-years.html

Problems:http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/15/b...rts-may-be-a-warning-for-greece.html?_r=1&hpw

Greece:http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentis...ce-return-economic-death-spiral?newsfeed=true
Yes, as we can see austerity works when you lie in bed with the red lipped doll of Ayn Rand and substitute human pleasures with fantasies
 
Question: when our economy "grows" ... what is happening? Has more people gone to work? Has our factories produced more with the same amount of employees? Have our farmers planted and harvested more crops? Or is it all smoke and mirrors from Wall Street as they printed more money?
 
another reason to remind ourselves how fortunate we are to have Pres Obama steering the ship of state.
 
Question: when our economy "grows" ... what is happening? Has more people gone to work? Has our factories produced more with the same amount of employees? Have our farmers planted and harvested more crops? Or is it all smoke and mirrors from Wall Street as they printed more money?

all of the above, Days, including WS
 
any one of the above, or any combination of the above, or all of the above. But you can never be sure if growth was really growth.... especially when Wall Street functions with bigger chunks of money. As long as Wall Street is part of the picture... and they always are... any thin percentage of growth is probably decline.
 
Now, during the presidency of GWBush, we were actually in steep decline. We were shedding manufacturing jobs at an alarming rate. But Wall Street was loaning out mammoth amounts of home loans, and home builders were building lots of new homes... so it looked like a lot of growth. But when the smoke cleared and the mirrors went dim, we had declined, not grown, we had all gone into hock over our eyeballs, and we had all these giant new houses that were (and still are) vacant.

We screamed our heads off about that every day over in moneybox and I was labelled <whatever idiocy> in BotF to discredit it, because the plain truth is, loaning out money is not and never was equal to capital investment... it can go into that, but it can go into a lot of other pockets, just as easily... so you have to run down (follow) the money to figure out what those figures really are alluding to. When Bush lowered taxes on the rich, they took that money and invested it... into the Pacific Rim. When I posted that was what was happening - back in 2002 in moneybox - Publius called me an ignoramus. Who was the real ignoramus? Time has proven he was. The irony of that was it happened in response to an article Gross did on the actual tonnage booked on the freighters crossing the Pacific. Gross had done the leg work, was showing us point blank that those ships were full of goods coming to our shores and returning empty... hence we were headed for a trade imbalance... and here I was breaking that down into reality; the Bush tax breaks were getting invested overseas; their manufacturing jobs are exploding and we are declining, we are killing ourselves giving out those tax breaks... Publius was a Republican.

These dingbats are constantly explaining to me how dumb I am and how ignorant I am and how everything I point at in the real world isn't really happening, because that's just my latest conspiracy theory. When you post with wombats...
 
So, I take it, you favor massive, untenable government debt?
What is it that makes it "untenable"? Recovering from the Great Depression Debt/GDP ratios hit 140%+ and yet there were no long term negative effects. We could do a $5 trillion stimulus and not hit that ratio.

I've asked you before. I'll ask again. Name ONE, JUST ONE regulation or policy in the Congressional Biills that are supposedly "job creation" bills that if enacted, would result in YOU hiring an extra person in your company. Or which would increase your revenue within 1 month of enactment.

JUST ONE.


(oh yeah on Greece? no they didn't try it. Their problem is a 40% tax compliance rate when they pretended it was 80% - that and they don't controll their own currency... two major differences)
 
I didn't want to blow his brain with that. Plus there's the added cost of paying for the new loans (which they simply tack onto the principle) so the debt itself is growing also.

Greece is rioting for a reason.
 
What makes it untenable is that it's selling a lie.

And that lie being that 16 Trillion in debt doesn't matter.

I've asked you before. I'll ask again. Name ONE, JUST ONE regulation or policy in the Congressional Biills that are supposedly "job creation" bills that if enacted, would result in YOU hiring an extra person in your company. Or which would increase your revenue within 1 month of enactment.

Beats me, I'm not up on the jobs bills you speak of. However, if you want to get me to hire more...end federal gasoline taxes. Paying an extra quarter a gallon, in my business is a job killer.
 
You can't even come close to comparing post WWII era with today.

Not even close.

Because why?
Becuase the current crash was a bigger loss of US Wealth than the Great Depression?
Because more jobs per month were lost in the current crash than during the Great Depression?

is that why?
 
What's the alternative to austerity?

Keynesian stimulus - just the same that has pulled the USA out of every crash for the last 120+ years. and in the process reduced the frequence of crashes by a factor of 3 and the duration of the average recovery by a factor of 8.

History is clear
Deficit spending WORKS. and it WORKS WELL.
 
Simply because we had a monster capacity to manufacture at that time. And we had a world war to win, or had just won. Everyone wanted to be here, or get something made here.

To put it another way, our best days as a global power were ahead of us. Not behind us.
 
Back
Top