New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Balancing the Budget

Arkady

President
The right-wingers are set to begin pretending, yet again, that they give a crap about deficits. They will do this while simultaneously demanding a delay of Obamacare and an elimination of the medical device tax (two things that would increase deficits) because... well, because they're liars or imbeciles. But since they're thinking about holding the credit worthiness of the US hostage to get some items from their political wishlist, they need to pretend they care about debt.

So, let's play along. For those here who say they don't want our debt to rise above the current ceiling level, what changes would you propose to prevent that, SPECIFICALLY?

To eliminate deficits, you need to do one or more of the following things.

(1) Raise taxes. I put this one first, because it's the easiest, economically. The US currently has tax rates that are well below what is normal among wealthy nations, and below what we had for much of our modern history, so we know these can be raised considerably without any disaster ensuing. According to the OECD, in the US, less than a quarter of GDP is collected as government revenues (24%), which is less than any economically developed countries other than Mexico and Chile. Typical rates among our wealthy peers are in the 37% range, with rates rising as high as 48.2% (Denmark). So, if we raised our taxes by half, we'd then be average for a wealthy nation (in line with Germany), and even if we doubled them, we'd still be within the spectrum of other wealthy nations. Nothing that major is needed, though. We could raise our total taxes by a little over a third, to 32.6% of GDP, and that would be enough to balance the budget, without making a single other change. We'd then be taxed a little heavier than Canada and a little lighter than the UK, and lighter than pretty much everyone in continental Europe. We could do it primarily with taxes on the wealthy -- remember, the top bracket is currently paying half what it did during our economic golden era of the 1960s.

(2) Cut military spending. I put this second, since it's also easy, economically. Currently we spend well over four times as much as the next-closest country on our military, and about three times what a typical wealthy nations spends as a share of GDP. If we cut our military spending by 2/3, we'd still outspend every other nation on Earth by a huge margin, and we'd save $450 billion per year. That's not enough to eliminate the deficit, but it would cut it roughly in half.... enough that we'd expect a return to decent economic growth to be enough to eliminate the rest of the budget deficit, in the years to come. The other advantage of cutting part of the military budget is that a lot more of the military budget gets spent abroad than other parts of the federal government budget, so you get less of a negative economic hit for money cut there than you do for cutting money spent within the US economy.

(3) Misappropriate Medicare or Social Security funds. Medicare and Social Security are funded by their own taxes, so it's impossible to fix the deficit either by raising those taxes or cutting benefits (or postponing eligibility age, means testing, etc.), unless you allow the funds collected in the name of those programs to be spent on other programs. If we were to allow such misappropriation, it would effectively be a way of using regressive taxation to avoid additional progressive taxation -- basically, avoiding hiking taxes much on the millionaires by instead hiking them disprporitonately on the middle and lower classes (or cutting into their retirements). Medicare and Social Security are big enough spending areas that you could balance the budget this way, whatever you think of the moral implications of it.

(4) Eating our seed corn. There are various areas of government spending that have long term returns: infrastructure improvements and maintenance, R&D, conservation, and education. We could neglect those areas, buying ourselves some short-term budget-balancing, at the cost of long-term GDP suppression.

(5) Snipping the safety net. We spend a great deal on various kinds of social services -- primarily for poor children, the disabled, and veterans. We could save on that. However, the US budget is already extremely austere, relative to other countries, in terms of non-military spending. For example, between revenues and borrowing, the total government (state plus federal) spending in this country is 29.4% of GDP, of which 4.4% is military. So, all government spending, other than military, works out to 25% of GDP. The next two biggest economies of wealthy nations are Japan and Germany. Their non-military spending works out to 37.4% of GDP and 35.8%, respectively. And those are hardly the biggest non-military spenders. In Scandinavia, nearly half of all GDP takes the form of non-military government spending. So, understand that if you want to cut in this area, you're cutting away at an area where the United States is already bone-thin compared to any other major advanced nation. We could, of course, do this, in the blind hope that it's possible to maintain a prosperous nation with non-military government spending levels that are far and away lower than has ever been shown to be compatible with general prosperity. But, if that's what one advocates, be clear-eyed about the fact that it's a radical socio-economic experiment, with no real-world successes for encouragement.

(6) Ending the war on drugs. Currently, the US pays to house a larger share of its population behind bars than any other nation, largely due to the war on recreational drug users. We jail about ten times the share of our population as most other wealthy nations, and that has a huge budgetary impact -- as does all the associated spending on our courts, law enforcement, etc. Unfortunately, since a big chunk of that spending happens at the state level, cutting here wouldn't directly affect federal deficits much -- at best, we might save $30 billion per year. However, reforming federal drug laws, and pressuring states to reform state drug laws, would free up a whole lot more money at the state level, which could allow for lower state taxes, indirectly benefiting the federal budget. In this same area, there are savings to be had by scaling back on "security theater," NSA spying, etc.

(7) Shifting spending to the states. If you want to lower the deficit, you could get the federal government out of any number of functions and shift the obligations to the states. Unfortunately, this really just moves the issue. The states would then need to hike taxes to do the work, and the exemption on money spent on state taxes would hit federal revenues, wiping out the deficit advantage. In fact, you might actually make things worse, since you'd be losing the economies of scale. To take an example from business, picture if McDonalds decided to improve their bottom line at the national level by getting out of the advertising business -- leaving it up to local franchises to hire people to make ads, write jingles, etc., and paying for all that themselves. The result would be lower profits at the franchise level, which would hit the national corporation, and you'd lose all the synergies and bulk-buying advantages, so you'd have to spend a lot more money at the local level for the same per-franchise value of the former national spending. In the same way, devolving government spending to the states would be expected to mean higher overall spending was required to maintain the same average quality, once you wiped out the economies of scale.

(8) Currency devaluation. The government has long-term spending obligations, associated with its debt. In theory, you could just print a ton of money and pay off those debts with that money, effectively eliminating the interest on treasury debt, and thereby wiping out nearly half the deficit. However, this would cause inflation problems and there are moral concerns with this trick, as well. And it would screw over future generations, who'd likely be unable to borrow at reasonable interest rates in times of war or economic crisis, since investors would be wary of another such devaluation.

Those are the main ideas I could think of. Can you think of others? If you're in favor of cutting the deficit, which of those do you favor?
 
C'mon, RKD - any rightwingnut will tell you all we have to do is eliminate entitlements and all our budget problems will disappear! Don't tell me you doubt them?
 
The right-wingers are set to begin pretending, yet again, that they give a crap about deficits. They will do this while simultaneously demanding a delay of Obamacare and an elimination of the medical device tax (two things that would increase deficits) because... well, because they're liars or imbeciles. But since they're thinking about holding the credit worthiness of the US hostage to get some items from their political wishlist, they need to pretend they care about debt.

So, let's play along. For those here who say they don't want our debt to rise above the current ceiling level, what changes would you propose to prevent that, SPECIFICALLY?

To eliminate deficits, you need to do one or more of the following things.

(1) Raise taxes. I put this one first, because it's the easiest, economically. The US currently has tax rates that are well below what is normal among wealthy nations, and below what we had for much of our modern history, so we know these can be raised considerably without any disaster ensuing. According to the OECD, in the US, less than a quarter of GDP is collected as government revenues (24%), which is less than any economically developed countries other than Mexico and Chile. Typical rates among our wealthy peers are in the 37% range, with rates rising as high as 48.2% (Denmark). So, if we raised our taxes by half, we'd then be average for a wealthy nation (in line with Germany), and even if we doubled them, we'd still be within the spectrum of other wealthy nations. Nothing that major is needed, though. We could raise our total taxes by a little over a third, to 32.6% of GDP, and that would be enough to balance the budget, without making a single other change. We'd then be taxed a little heavier than Canada and a little lighter than the UK, and lighter than pretty much everyone in continental Europe. We could do it primarily with taxes on the wealthy -- remember, the top bracket is currently paying half what it did during our economic golden era of the 1960s.

(2) Cut military spending. I put this second, since it's also easy, economically. Currently we spend well over four times as much as the next-closest country on our military, and about three times what a typical wealthy nations spends as a share of GDP. If we cut our military spending by 2/3, we'd still outspend every other nation on Earth by a huge margin, and we'd save $450 billion per year. That's not enough to eliminate the deficit, but it would cut it roughly in half.... enough that we'd expect a return to decent economic growth to be enough to eliminate the rest of the budget deficit, in the years to come. The other advantage of cutting part of the military budget is that a lot more of the military budget gets spent abroad than other parts of the federal government budget, so you get less of a negative economic hit for money cut there than you do for cutting money spent within the US economy.

(3) Misappropriate Medicare or Social Security funds. Medicare and Social Security are funded by their own taxes, so it's impossible to fix the deficit either by raising those taxes or cutting benefits (or postponing eligibility age, means testing, etc.), unless you allow the funds collected in the name of those programs to be spent on other programs. If we were to allow such misappropriation, it would effectively be a way of using regressive taxation to avoid additional progressive taxation -- basically, avoiding hiking taxes much on the millionaires by instead hiking them disprporitonately on the middle and lower classes (or cutting into their retirements). Medicare and Social Security are big enough spending areas that you could balance the budget this way, whatever you think of the moral implications of it.

(4) Eating our seed corn. There are various areas of government spending that have long term returns: infrastructure improvements and maintenance, R&D, conservation, and education. We could neglect those areas, buying ourselves some short-term budget-balancing, at the cost of long-term GDP suppression.

(5) Snipping the safety net. We spend a great deal on various kinds of social services -- primarily for poor children, the disabled, and veterans. We could save on that. However, the US budget is already extremely austere, relative to other countries, in terms of non-military spending. For example, between revenues and borrowing, the total government (state plus federal) spending in this country is 29.4% of GDP, of which 4.4% is military. So, all government spending, other than military, works out to 25% of GDP. The next two biggest economies of wealthy nations are Japan and Germany. Their non-military spending works out to 37.4% of GDP and 35.8%, respectively. And those are hardly the biggest non-military spenders. In Scandinavia, nearly half of all GDP takes the form of non-military government spending. So, understand that if you want to cut in this area, you're cutting away at an area where the United States is already bone-thin compared to any other major advanced nation. We could, of course, do this, in the blind hope that it's possible to maintain a prosperous nation with non-military government spending levels that are far and away lower than has ever been shown to be compatible with general prosperity. But, if that's what one advocates, be clear-eyed about the fact that it's a radical socio-economic experiment, with no real-world successes for encouragement.

(6) Ending the war on drugs. Currently, the US pays to house a larger share of its population behind bars than any other nation, largely due to the war on recreational drug users. We jail about ten times the share of our population as most other wealthy nations, and that has a huge budgetary impact -- as does all the associated spending on our courts, law enforcement, etc. Unfortunately, since a big chunk of that spending happens at the state level, cutting here wouldn't directly affect federal deficits much -- at best, we might save $30 billion per year. However, reforming federal drug laws, and pressuring states to reform state drug laws, would free up a whole lot more money at the state level, which could allow for lower state taxes, indirectly benefiting the federal budget. In this same area, there are savings to be had by scaling back on "security theater," NSA spying, etc.

(7) Shifting spending to the states. If you want to lower the deficit, you could get the federal government out of any number of functions and shift the obligations to the states. Unfortunately, this really just moves the issue. The states would then need to hike taxes to do the work, and the exemption on money spent on state taxes would hit federal revenues, wiping out the deficit advantage. In fact, you might actually make things worse, since you'd be losing the economies of scale. To take an example from business, picture if McDonalds decided to improve their bottom line at the national level by getting out of the advertising business -- leaving it up to local franchises to hire people to make ads, write jingles, etc., and paying for all that themselves. The result would be lower profits at the franchise level, which would hit the national corporation, and you'd lose all the synergies and bulk-buying advantages, so you'd have to spend a lot more money at the local level for the same per-franchise value of the former national spending. In the same way, devolving government spending to the states would be expected to mean higher overall spending was required to maintain the same average quality, once you wiped out the economies of scale.

(8) Currency devaluation. The government has long-term spending obligations, associated with its debt. In theory, you could just print a ton of money and pay off those debts with that money, effectively eliminating the interest on treasury debt, and thereby wiping out nearly half the deficit. However, this would cause inflation problems and there are moral concerns with this trick, as well. And it would screw over future generations, who'd likely be unable to borrow at reasonable interest rates in times of war or economic crisis, since investors would be wary of another such devaluation.

Those are the main ideas I could think of. Can you think of others? If you're in favor of cutting the deficit, which of those do you favor?

Ten percent across the board. Everybody could make do with a dime less.
 
The right-wingers are set to begin pretending, yet again, that they give a crap about deficits. They will do this while simultaneously demanding a delay of Obamacare and an elimination of the medical device tax (two things that would increase deficits) because... well, because they're liars or imbeciles. But since they're thinking about holding the credit worthiness of the US hostage to get some items from their political wishlist, they need to pretend they care about debt.

So, let's play along. For those here who say they don't want our debt to rise above the current ceiling level, what changes would you propose to prevent that, SPECIFICALLY?

To eliminate deficits, you need to do one or more of the following things.

(1) Raise taxes. I put this one first, because it's the easiest, economically. The US currently has tax rates that are well below what is normal among wealthy nations, and below what we had for much of our modern history, so we know these can be raised considerably without any disaster ensuing. According to the OECD, in the US, less than a quarter of GDP is collected as government revenues (24%), which is less than any economically developed countries other than Mexico and Chile. Typical rates among our wealthy peers are in the 37% range, with rates rising as high as 48.2% (Denmark). So, if we raised our taxes by half, we'd then be average for a wealthy nation (in line with Germany), and even if we doubled them, we'd still be within the spectrum of other wealthy nations. Nothing that major is needed, though. We could raise our total taxes by a little over a third, to 32.6% of GDP, and that would be enough to balance the budget, without making a single other change. We'd then be taxed a little heavier than Canada and a little lighter than the UK, and lighter than pretty much everyone in continental Europe. We could do it primarily with taxes on the wealthy -- remember, the top bracket is currently paying half what it did during our economic golden era of the 1960s.

(2) Cut military spending. I put this second, since it's also easy, economically. Currently we spend well over four times as much as the next-closest country on our military, and about three times what a typical wealthy nations spends as a share of GDP. If we cut our military spending by 2/3, we'd still outspend every other nation on Earth by a huge margin, and we'd save $450 billion per year. That's not enough to eliminate the deficit, but it would cut it roughly in half.... enough that we'd expect a return to decent economic growth to be enough to eliminate the rest of the budget deficit, in the years to come. The other advantage of cutting part of the military budget is that a lot more of the military budget gets spent abroad than other parts of the federal government budget, so you get less of a negative economic hit for money cut there than you do for cutting money spent within the US economy.

(3) Misappropriate Medicare or Social Security funds. Medicare and Social Security are funded by their own taxes, so it's impossible to fix the deficit either by raising those taxes or cutting benefits (or postponing eligibility age, means testing, etc.), unless you allow the funds collected in the name of those programs to be spent on other programs. If we were to allow such misappropriation, it would effectively be a way of using regressive taxation to avoid additional progressive taxation -- basically, avoiding hiking taxes much on the millionaires by instead hiking them disprporitonately on the middle and lower classes (or cutting into their retirements). Medicare and Social Security are big enough spending areas that you could balance the budget this way, whatever you think of the moral implications of it.

(4) Eating our seed corn. There are various areas of government spending that have long term returns: infrastructure improvements and maintenance, R&D, conservation, and education. We could neglect those areas, buying ourselves some short-term budget-balancing, at the cost of long-term GDP suppression.

(5) Snipping the safety net. We spend a great deal on various kinds of social services -- primarily for poor children, the disabled, and veterans. We could save on that. However, the US budget is already extremely austere, relative to other countries, in terms of non-military spending. For example, between revenues and borrowing, the total government (state plus federal) spending in this country is 29.4% of GDP, of which 4.4% is military. So, all government spending, other than military, works out to 25% of GDP. The next two biggest economies of wealthy nations are Japan and Germany. Their non-military spending works out to 37.4% of GDP and 35.8%, respectively. And those are hardly the biggest non-military spenders. In Scandinavia, nearly half of all GDP takes the form of non-military government spending. So, understand that if you want to cut in this area, you're cutting away at an area where the United States is already bone-thin compared to any other major advanced nation. We could, of course, do this, in the blind hope that it's possible to maintain a prosperous nation with non-military government spending levels that are far and away lower than has ever been shown to be compatible with general prosperity. But, if that's what one advocates, be clear-eyed about the fact that it's a radical socio-economic experiment, with no real-world successes for encouragement.

(6) Ending the war on drugs. Currently, the US pays to house a larger share of its population behind bars than any other nation, largely due to the war on recreational drug users. We jail about ten times the share of our population as most other wealthy nations, and that has a huge budgetary impact -- as does all the associated spending on our courts, law enforcement, etc. Unfortunately, since a big chunk of that spending happens at the state level, cutting here wouldn't directly affect federal deficits much -- at best, we might save $30 billion per year. However, reforming federal drug laws, and pressuring states to reform state drug laws, would free up a whole lot more money at the state level, which could allow for lower state taxes, indirectly benefiting the federal budget. In this same area, there are savings to be had by scaling back on "security theater," NSA spying, etc.

(7) Shifting spending to the states. If you want to lower the deficit, you could get the federal government out of any number of functions and shift the obligations to the states. Unfortunately, this really just moves the issue. The states would then need to hike taxes to do the work, and the exemption on money spent on state taxes would hit federal revenues, wiping out the deficit advantage. In fact, you might actually make things worse, since you'd be losing the economies of scale. To take an example from business, picture if McDonalds decided to improve their bottom line at the national level by getting out of the advertising business -- leaving it up to local franchises to hire people to make ads, write jingles, etc., and paying for all that themselves. The result would be lower profits at the franchise level, which would hit the national corporation, and you'd lose all the synergies and bulk-buying advantages, so you'd have to spend a lot more money at the local level for the same per-franchise value of the former national spending. In the same way, devolving government spending to the states would be expected to mean higher overall spending was required to maintain the same average quality, once you wiped out the economies of scale.

(8) Currency devaluation. The government has long-term spending obligations, associated with its debt. In theory, you could just print a ton of money and pay off those debts with that money, effectively eliminating the interest on treasury debt, and thereby wiping out nearly half the deficit. However, this would cause inflation problems and there are moral concerns with this trick, as well. And it would screw over future generations, who'd likely be unable to borrow at reasonable interest rates in times of war or economic crisis, since investors would be wary of another such devaluation.

Those are the main ideas I could think of. Can you think of others? If you're in favor of cutting the deficit, which of those do you favor?

All for increased taxation...across the board..but heaviest on the wealthiest/.
 
All for increased taxation...across the board..but heaviest on the wealthiest/.
I say do a clawback and windfall tax. Take 50% of all the money from the jackobites here who invested in the Stock Market. Athletes, actors, musicians they should all give up their shit. Even Buffet and Gates should give up 50% of their worth to the governmet.

lol.
 
Ten percent across the board. Everybody could make do with a dime less.

10% less spent on paying for the retirement benefits earned by veterans? 10% less paying interest on debt owed by the federal government? 10% less spending on maintaining our already-failing infrastructure? I can't get on board with that.
 
10% less spent on paying for the retirement benefits earned by veterans? 10% less paying interest on debt owed by the federal government? 10% less spending on maintaining our already-failing infrastructure? I can't get on board with that.
Yes, everybody spent it everybody shares in the pain.
 
C'mon, RKD - any rightwingnut will tell you all we have to do is eliminate entitlements and all our budget problems will disappear! Don't tell me you doubt them?

I keep thinking that if I post enough variations on this theme, I'll some day get a few conservatives to engage with the actual numbers. We have about a $900 billion deficit. Nickel-and-diming that with things like the half billion per year we spend on the Corporation for Public Broadcasting isn't going to make much difference. Even eliminating a bigger program like food stamps won't cut a tenth of the deficit, despite the tragic human consequences. If they'd dig into the numbers, they'd come to see that, as a realistic matter, coming up with the hundreds of billions of dollars needed to balance the budget is going to require raising taxes or cutting military spending, or some combination of the two.

That's actually what happened the last time we moved from record deficits to record surpluses. Clinton pushed through a big tax hike and the military budget was allowed to declined a bit.
 
Children didn't spend it. Could we exempt social spending on kids... things like supplemental nutrition spending for the benefit of minors?
People are generous with their money no need for you to be generous with other people's money for them.
 
I keep thinking that if I post enough variations on this theme, I'll some day get a few conservatives to engage with the actual numbers. We have about a $900 billion deficit. Nickel-and-diming that with things like the half billion per year we spend on the Corporation for Public Broadcasting isn't going to make much difference. Even eliminating a bigger program like food stamps won't cut a tenth of the deficit, despite the tragic human consequences. If they'd dig into the numbers, they'd come to see that, as a realistic matter, coming up with the hundreds of billions of dollars needed to balance the budget is going to require raising taxes or cutting military spending, or some combination of the two.

That's actually what happened the last time we moved from record deficits to record surpluses. Clinton pushed through a big tax hike and the military budget was allowed to declined a bit.

They won't do it. They'd prefer to call for cuts to Foreign Aid and entitlements without admitting those things, as you point out, are a drop in the bucket. They can't face the reality that if they truly want to balance the budget, tax increases have to be part of the equation.

Since conservatives would rather whine about deficits than actually do something constructive about it, we're stuck in limbo.
 
I would first raise taxes specifically for paying off debt, and I mean across the board.

I would also embrace a ten percent cut across the board of our spending, it's painful ,but would at least make a dent.

I would also see where the state governments could handle items and remove the burden from the national government, thus requiring a lower budget. If the state governments have to increase their own budgets so be it.

That's where I would start, in my opinion.
 
I would first raise taxes specifically for paying off debt, and I mean across the board.

I would also embrace a ten percent cut across the board of our spending, it's painful ,but would at least make a dent.

I would also see where the state governments could handle items and remove the burden from the national government, thus requiring a lower budget. If the state governments have to increase their own budgets so be it.

That's where I would start, in my opinion.
Except for dumping on the states I agree. As long as those are real cuts and not cuts to projections and any new revenue goes to pay down the debt directly.
 
I would first raise taxes specifically for paying off debt, and I mean across the board.

I would also embrace a ten percent cut across the board of our spending, it's painful ,but would at least make a dent.

I would also see where the state governments could handle items and remove the burden from the national government, thus requiring a lower budget. If the state governments have to increase their own budgets so be it.

That's where I would start, in my opinion.

10% cuts just don't make sense to me. It's like a patient goes to a doctor suffering from obesity, so the doctor counsels cutting away 10% of each organ. Go after the fat with a scalpel, not everythign with a hacksaw.

Also, as I said with regard to the states, for every $1 you save at the federal level, you might well have $2 of additional taxes at the state level to perform the same services to the same level, thanks to the loss of the economies of scale. And that $2 of extra state taxes would mean extra write-offs on federal taxes, associated with that state tax, so you might not even have a good impact on the federal budget deficit.
 
10% cuts just don't make sense to me. It's like a patient goes to a doctor suffering from obesity, so the doctor counsels cutting away 10% of each organ. Go after the fat with a scalpel, not everythign with a hacksaw.

Also, as I said with regard to the states, for every $1 you save at the federal level, you might well have $2 of additional taxes at the state level to perform the same services to the same level, thanks to the loss of the economies of scale. And that $2 of extra state taxes would mean extra write-offs on federal taxes, associated with that state tax, so you might not even have a good impact on the federal budget deficit.

Which is why I used the model for a start. Obviously, adjustments have to be made.
 
Back
Top