New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

BBC versus NPR

Further, there is, outside of Fox News, no "right-wing media landscape" in the United States.

Sure there is. For starters, Fox News is just the tip of the iceberg of the Newscorp empire of right-wing propaganda outlets -- Murdoch's got a whole series of vile tabloid outlets from which to spew his hatred, including the disgraceful New York Post. There's also the Wall Street Journal, ever since Murdoch bought it and degraded it from a respected source for business journalism into a right-wing tabloid. Aside from that, there's a whole infrastructure of conservative media outlets that aren't connected to Murdoch, but are very much focused on keeping the conservative base stoked: the Moonie cult's house paper, the Washington Times, for example. Or the Weekly Standard, National Review, Breitbart, The Blaze, the Daily Caller, Drudge, WND, CNSNews, and nearly the entirety of political talk radio.

Then there are the corporate outlets, which aren't typically conservative on social issues, but are focused on making their disproportionately wealthy shareholders richer, generally by way of helping other big for-profit corporations sell crap to the market. The pro-capitalist and pro-consumerist bias built into that incentive pushes them right on economic issues, resulting in hostile coverage of labor, powder-puff coverage of corporate malfeasance, and boosterism for deregulation, free trade, immigration, and tax cuts. Even when their biases are in line with my own political beliefs (e.g., I support free trade and immigration, too), it's hard to ignore how heavily they're tilting the coverage. That would include most major newspapers, all the big news channels and nightly broadcasts, except Fox, as well as most magazines and major news websites outside of the openly conservative ones.

Then there's the pro-war tilt. Possibly because war drives ratings and circulation up, or possibly because it's a great way for journalists to make a name for themselves, or maybe for some other reason, major corporate outlets are always eager for war -- which, in this country, means they tend to side with the Republicans on foreign policy issues. Consider Bush's bizarre decision to conquer Iraq, back in 2003. There was no sane justification for it, yet one after another the major outlets fell in line, with transparently silly pro-war arguments. Remember when the New York Times editorial page falsely announced that Iraq wasn't disarming (in fact it had already disarmed), and they demanded that the Security Council clear the way to "call in the cavalry to get the job done" (in other words, green light Bush to carry out his whim)? And the NYT was nothing compared to the WaPo, the very epicenter of neoconservative warmongering in America.

More than 70 percent of all journalists poll as liberals

That may well be part of the issue. Liberals feel insulated when it comes to tearing into fellow liberals. Go off half-cocked with an inaccurate attack on, say, Hillary Clinton, and it's not going to hurt your career at all. People won't assume it was political bias that drove you. In fact, your error may help you, in that it will beef up your "bi-partisan bon fides." By comparison, if you dare speak out against a conservative politician, you'd better make sure all your ducks are in a row, or it can end even the most illustrious career. Dan Rather was the most decorated journalist of his generation, and just letting a little questionable documentation slip into an otherwise accurate piece that was critical of Bush was enough to effectively end his career. Journalists know that's how things work, so they're painfully cautious when reporting anything that might reflect badly on Republicans, while it's like the wild west when they go after the Democrats -- shoot first and ask questions later.

I defy you to find a single conservative interviewed by prominent NPR interview host Terry Gross in the past decade.

I don't listen to her, so I don't have a clue who she has been interviewing. As I recall, mostly she goes with artists, novelists, comedians, and assorted celebrities, so I wouldn't imagine there being a lot of conservatives in the mix, just by nature of the topics. Doing a quick Google search, I see she's interviewed Amy Adams recently, and Adams is a conservative, but there aren't a lot of artistic types who are. I'd also imagine that after Terry Gross demolished Bill O'Reilly's weak talking points so thoroughly when he came on the show, it's hard to book conservatives. Conservatives aren't exactly used to such challenging treatment.

BBC is its own thing. People think it's "independent" because it's not US, but really it's an arm of the British government and it tends to reflect the views of that government

During the lead-up to Bush's conquest of Iraq, the position of the British government was to support the warmongering effort, but I found the BBC World Service to be a welcome change of pace from the constant drum-beat for war we got here in the US. They actually had voices on that were skeptical about the supposed slam-dunk WMD evidence and the threat those WMDs supposedly posed to the West if they existed. They also were much more serious about the issues of international law at play if an invasion were launched without a UN authorization, which the US media brushed aside. Similarly, as you note, the overall tone regarding Brexit on the BBC is consistent with the mainstream expert opinion among economists (that it'll be bad for the UK), but very much at odds with the UK government view in support of Brexit.
 
Of course you're dodging
No, as you see I'm not. I'm highlighting your anti-Semitism. I know that makes you sad, but there's a simple solution for that: cut back on your Jew-baiting attacks. If you stop behaving like an anti-Semite, you won't be called out for your anti-Semitism.
 
Sure there is. For starters, Fox News is just the tip of the iceberg of the Newscorp empire of right-wing propaganda outlets -- Murdoch's got a whole series of vile tabloid outlets from which to spew his hatred, including the disgraceful New York Post. There's also the Wall Street Journal, ever since Murdoch bought it and degraded it from a respected source for business journalism into a right-wing tabloid. Aside from that, there's a whole infrastructure of conservative media outlets that aren't connected to Murdoch, but are very much focused on keeping the conservative base stoked: the Moonie cult's house paper, the Washington Times, for example. Or the Weekly Standard, National Review, Breitbart, The Blaze, the Daily Caller, Drudge, WND, CNSNews, and nearly the entirety of political talk radio.

OK, I acknowledge that these right-wing outlets exist. I thought you were referring to standard news outlets such as ABC, CBS, CNN, NYT, etc. as "right wing," and that simply isn't trure.

Then there's the pro-war tilt. Possibly because war drives ratings and circulation up, or possibly because it's a great way for journalists to make a name for themselves, or maybe for some other reason, major corporate outlets are always eager for war -- which, in this country, means they tend to side with the Republicans on foreign policy issues. Consider Bush's bizarre decision to conquer Iraq, back in 2003. There was no sane justification for it, yet one after another the major outlets fell in line, with transparently silly pro-war arguments. Remember when the New York Times editorial page falsely announced that Iraq wasn't disarming (in fact it had already disarmed), and they demanded that the Security Council clear the way to "call in the cavalry to get the job done" (in other words, green light Bush to carry out his whim)? And the NYT was nothing compared to the WaPo, the very epicenter of neoconservative warmongering in America.

There is no "pro war" tilt. Journalists like wars because it's good for their careers. It's usually "we're covering this war we oppose" as it was with Gulf War II. (BTW, "conquest" includes "keeping possession" of something. Bush conquered precisely nothing, nor did he plan to).


That may well be part of the issue. Liberals feel insulated when it comes to tearing into fellow liberals. Go off half-cocked with an inaccurate attack on, say, Hillary Clinton, and it's not going to hurt your career at all. People won't assume it was political bias that drove you. In fact, your error may help you, in that it will beef up your "bi-partisan bon fides." By comparison, if you dare speak out against a conservative politician, you'd better make sure all your ducks are in a row, or it can end even the most illustrious career. Dan Rather was the most decorated journalist of his generation, and just letting a little questionable documentation slip into an otherwise accurate piece that was critical of Bush was enough to effectively end his career. Journalists know that's how things work, so they're painfully cautious when reporting anything that might reflect badly on Republicans, while it's like the wild west when they go after the Democrats -- shoot first and ask questions later.

Rather was a good journalist up until he was fired from the CBS evening news, where it must be said he was a poor anchor. After that, he kept getting further and further into areas that were simply editorializing, the worst of which was the forged documents in the Bush matter. Liberals bring a liberal spectrum bias to the work they do. In journalism, they exemplify the statement by William F. Buckley Jr. that "Liberals who claim to tolerate other opinions are shocked and outraged to find their are other opinions."

I don't listen to her, so I don't have a clue who she has been interviewing. As I recall, mostly she goes with artists, novelists, comedians, and assorted celebrities, so I wouldn't imagine there being a lot of conservatives in the mix, just by nature of the topics. Doing a quick Google search, I see she's interviewed Amy Adams recently, and Adams is a conservative, but there aren't a lot of artistic types who are. I'd also imagine that after Terry Gross demolished Bill O'Reilly's weak talking points so thoroughly when he came on the show, it's hard to book conservatives. Conservatives aren't exactly used to such challenging treatment.

Through scheduling, I seem to hear her show most days (it airs at lunch time around here), and she's never booked a conservative in the past 10 years, that I've heard. And her lines of questioning reveal her political views -- for example I hear her interviewing a rock star about a photo book of his early years, and she said, "In this picture you're processing a bunch of marijuana, and there's a pistol on the table -- why did you have that there?" Why, I ask, is she questioning the legal ownership of the pistol and not the illegal ownership of the marijuana? Her own biases, of course.

During the lead-up to Bush's conquest of Iraq, the position of the British government was to support the warmongering effort, but I found the BBC World Service to be a welcome change of pace from the constant drum-beat for war we got here in the US.

I didn't get to listen to the BBC during that era. I hear it most afternoons now, and as I said it remains an arm of British government as it has always been. It's not bad, per se, but it's not significantly "better" than U.S. coverage. It's merely different.[/QUOTE]
 
I've no interest in turning anyone against Leibowitz. I'm merely pointing out the poor man had to change his name to get Jew-haters like you to watch his show. You're a fan of Jon "Stewart", right?

Are you a fan of Weiner Nation....sorry...I meant "Savage Nation"?
 
There is no "pro war" tilt. Journalists like wars because it's good for their careers. It's usually "we're covering this war we oppose" as it was with Gulf War II.

I can't speak for all outlets, but the ones I was consuming in the run-up to Bush's conquest of Iraq were the NYT, WaPo, and CNN. The first two came out and editorialized in favor of it expressly, while CNN led with neoconservative warmonger Wolf Blitzer's breathless threat-hyping. Blitzer is one of those talking heads who labored in relative obscurity until he rode a little war to the top of the profession, and he positively oozed with excitement at the prospect of getting the killing started again.

(BTW, "conquest" includes "keeping possession" of something.

Not permanently. The Germans conquered parts of France and yet had lost control of them within a few years. Similarly, the US conquered Iraq, but ultimately relinquished those territories in the face of many years of determined resistance against our occupying forces. Of course, we didn't officially acknowledge it as a conquest -- we had our Vichy regime, which we were there to support.

After that, he kept getting further and further into areas that were simply editorializing, the worst of which was the forged documents in the Bush matter.

If he had unknowingly hyped forged evidence in support of conservative aims (as many journalists did in the run-up to the conquest of Iraq), he'd have been fine. That Niger memo's a forgery? Oops. A quiet correction when it came to light would have been enough. But covering anything that reflects badly on conservatives is a much higher-stakes move....get something seriously wrong, and your career is effectively over.

"In this picture you're processing a bunch of marijuana, and there's a pistol on the table -- why did you have that there?" Why, I ask, is she questioning the legal ownership of the pistol and not the illegal ownership of the marijuana?

Asking why he has a bunch of marijuana on the table would be an odd question, since the answer is obvious. He's not planning to mulch it. The pistol, by comparison, could have a number of different explanations. Is he a collector? A sport shooter? Does he feel he's under threat of violence and needs it for self defense? That's a question that opens up possible avenues for interesting discussion, which is the whole point of interview questions.
 
No. It's not a matter of me seeing the media inaccuractely. I work in media relations and understanding the media and what it's doing is key to the job. Further, there is, outside of Fox News, no "right-wing media landscape" in the United States. More than 70 percent of all journalists poll as liberals and bring a liberal perspective to their coverage -- this is part of the ABCs of my profession. If you compare NPR to them, you find much lower coverage of conservative content and fewer conservatives interviewed, etc. I defy you to find a single conservative interviewed by prominent NPR interview host Terry Gross in the past decade.

BBC is its own thing. People think it's "independent" because it's not US, but really it's an arm of the British government and it tends to reflect the views of that government -- currently its commentators are in an obvious state of disruption because they are personally anti-Brexit, and the government is firmly pro-Brexit.

Wow...that was easy. Terry Gross interviewed Gene Simmons, Bill O'reilly, Pat Ferrell (president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious ), Grover Nordquist...and she was pretty harsh in the interview with Hillary Clinton....
 
Wow...that was easy. Terry Gross interviewed Gene Simmons, Bill O'reilly, Pat Ferrell (president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious ), Grover Nordquist...and she was pretty harsh in the interview with Hillary Clinton....

In the past decade? Is so, my local station isn't airing all of her interviews, because I've heard her daily during that period with very few breaks.
 
In the past decade? Is so, my local station isn't airing all of her interviews, because I've heard her daily during that period with very few breaks.
feel free to do a search on her guests...I did not note the dates of those interviews. Certainly her interview with Clinton was recent.
 
Back
Top