New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Benghazi Simplified

So it is "lefty entitlement

So it is "lefty entitlement" then? This permanent station you seem to have which lets you do EXACTLY what you accuse others of doing and/or cautioning them not to do?

Is that correct?

Why is it you can never discuss the subject? Not a word about the investigations, not a word about the consequences...not a word.

Just...about me.
 
IMHO the responsibility lies with many....starting with Obama. Hillary, in her corrupt political wisdom, decided to claim responsibility, thereby covering Obama's butt. In return she will find herself free of punishment for her email SNAFU. It all works out. Everyone is happy, and the corruption continues.

Even Trump would be a better candidate than the corrupt Democrats. I'm not saying Republicans are not corrupt, but I think the dems are more so.

Think about this. Electing Trump would be an unknown. If he starts screwing up badly he could be impeached easily...both parties would go along with it. On the other hand, the VERY corrupt Hillary would never be impeached. It's only on this basis that I could possibly vote for Trump. ANYBODY but Hillary.
 
Why is it you can never discuss the subject? Not a word about the investigations, not a word about the consequences...not a word.

Just...about me.

Like me, Rick has probably realized that trying to rationally discuss any subject with a fanatic is pointless.
 
Trey Gowdy's 2-year probe was summarized in an 800 page report that I'm sure everyone here read cover-to-cover before commenting on it. I know I didn't. Some have commented that the report was partisan. They even say this as if it were a profound statement.

Of course it was partisan. Just as everything done by any group of liberals is partisan. Or as the kids like to say, "Duh!".

To me, Benghazi comes down to a few simple facts, which are not in dispute by anyone:

1) Someone in the Obama administration sent Chris Stevens to Benghazi.

2) Someone in the Obama administration was responsible for Chris Steven's security detail.

3) As it turned out, that security was woefully inadequate.

4) The attack that killed Chris Stevens and three others took place on September 11, which is a date when one would think the US would be on heightened alert, especially in a part of the world like Benghazi.

The second part of #4 is not a fact but an assumption, but it seems like a reasonable assumption, at least to me.

So, should more have been done to protect the ambassador? Again, the answer is "Duh!".

Whether or not anyone should be held accountable seems like a moot point to me. No one will be held accountable, because that's just the way things work.

The President, of course, whether his name be Obama or Bush or anyone else, is ultimately responsible for the what happens in his or her administration. It comes with the job.

That doesn't mean that those with power are going to hold themselves accountable. For anything. Ever.

And that's just the way it is. So I've moved on. Whether or not you do the same is up to you.
Here it is in even simpler terms:

We have over 300 foreign missions, and as a result there are fairly regular attacks on such facilities. When those attacks take place, traditionally we study what happened to identify ways to improve security in the future. This time, though, the Republicans decided they needed a scandal to pin on the administration, so even as one investigation after another came back giving them nothing to work with politically, they simply responded by launching even more investigations.

Of course, as with ANY successful attack, we can look at it with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight and identify things we could have done differently that would have had better results. But, it turns out, in this case, the administration didn't do anything that looks unreasonable when considered in light of what was known at the time. The Republicans just really wish it did.
 
Why is it you can never discuss the subject? Not a word about the investigations, not a word about the consequences...not a word.

Just...about me.
Look how spectacularly incapacitated your introspective awareness is!

How is anyone supposed to be able to post you regarding "subject" when you afford yourself a permanent non-reciprocity card. It's pathological stuff. You won't abide the rules of discussion that you expect/request from others.

And you can't see it. Amazing case study.

You guys have a ball with this Benghazi "consequence versus taking responsibility" nitpick-fest. I was just interested to see if...just once...Craig could say something like, "Gee, your right...I did just tell others what they think and then tell them not to tell me what I think...".

Weird stuff. Massive insecurity or unprecedented self-entitlement. Maybe both - who knows.
 
It means I haven't called for any. You asked how many investigations I needed, and so I answered. Which part of that bothers you so?

You seem unaware of all the investigations and their analyses. You state...you have no idea who messed up...or why. So...what's the point?

I'd say it was messed up from the first, beginning with the placement of a temporary diplomatic mission and the CIA safe house operating in such a dangerous area. We've had quite a number of these types of failures through the years, yet no such investigations have never been held...and I can't say I know of another Secretary of State who was asked to resign after an embassy, consulate, or diplomatic outpost was bombed.

So...what's the real and true problem? US intervention in the world? An out of control foreign policy shared by a vast number of politicians who believe the USA a preeminent force? A video? The failure of Congress to assign blame?
 
actually the top of mind questions are:

1 - Who fabricated the "youtube" cover story, and why?

There was no fabrication. There were genuinely plans to protest the video at our embassies and consulates. So, when the facility in Benghazi was attacked on the very day when our embassy in Cairo had been stormed by people protesting the video, the initial assumption is the Benghazi attack was also inspired by the video, or at least that it opportunistically used a protest as cover. It appears now that wasn't the case, but given the chaos that followed the attack, it understandably took a couple weeks to get a clear picture. Truly bizarrely, the right-wingers seized on that brief and meaningless interlude of message confusion as some sort of fabrication, imagining that somehow it would have been beneficial to the administration. They're deeply weird people.
 
She's a politician. All politicians get negative things said about them. Sometimes true, sometimes not.

I'm talking real consequences. Have there been any? Should there be?
What "consequences" were there for Bush and Cheney for lying us into war with Iraq and thousands killed. These 4 lives were precious as well....but you cons just shrug off what happened in 2003 and after that. Did the two that blundered into Iraq face anything at all? Hell...you even re-elected Bush in 2004. If Hillary wasn't running for the Presidency the GOP wouldn't be screeching BENGHAZI while ignoring the fact that more died in attacks on embassies during the Bush adm. Did the "Leftys" (as fools here call them) spend millions of dollars investigating them? Did Bush have to sit for 11 solid hours and answer questions about it?
 
You seem unaware of all the investigations and their analyses. You state...you have no idea who messed up...or why. So...what's the point?

I'd say it was messed up from the first, beginning with the placement of a temporary diplomatic mission and the CIA safe house operating in such a dangerous area. We've had quite a number of these types of failures through the years, yet no such investigations have never been held...and I can't say I know of another Secretary of State who was asked to resign after an embassy, consulate, or diplomatic outpost was bombed.

So...what's the real and true problem? US intervention in the world? An out of control foreign policy shared by a vast number of politicians who believe the USA a preeminent force? A video? The failure of Congress to assign blame?
And like the Ambassador's wife said....Congress denies funds where needed. Yet you know they get raises every time they turn around. They hate Hillary more than the dead man's family does and that says something. This is all partisan sliming of Trump's opponent. Pathetic.
 
No, you are incorrect.

If she is responsible for four men's deaths, then of course there should be consequences. If she is truly taking responsibility, she should be held accountable. But, of course, she is not taking responsibility for those deaths, or their lack of security, or for putting them in harms way. To my knowledge, no one is.

And yet, someone did send them to Benghazi with inadequate security (Who that person is, I cannot say with certainty - no one seems be be owning up to it). A simple vague declaration of taking responsibility for nothing specifically and accepting zero consequences isn't very impressive. Except, perhaps, to you.
How about she gets the same consequences Bush and Cheney got for the over 4000 dead in Iraq. That whole "mission" was nothing but a farce.
 
You seem unaware of all the investigations and their analyses. You state...you have no idea who messed up...or why. So...what's the point?

I'd say it was messed up from the first, beginning with the placement of a temporary diplomatic mission and the CIA safe house operating in such a dangerous area. We've had quite a number of these types of failures through the years, yet no such investigations have never been held...and I can't say I know of another Secretary of State who was asked to resign after an embassy, consulate, or diplomatic outpost was bombed.

So...what's the real and true problem? US intervention in the world? An out of control foreign policy shared by a vast number of politicians who believe the USA a preeminent force? A video? The failure of Congress to assign blame?


My point was that someone provided inadequate security for Chris Stevens, and as a result, he died. I don't know who made that decision, and I likely never will. It's all there in the top post. If you're having difficulty comprehending it for some reason, I don't know how much can be done to make it clearer for you. The entire post is less than 300 words, contains no technical or medical jargon, no Latin or foreign terms, and no complex concepts. You can try reading it again, perhaps with a helpful friend, but that would require a small amount of effort so I really don't expect you will.

Don't fret; I'm sure others understood it with no difficulty.
 
How about she gets the same consequences Bush and Cheney got for the over 4000 dead in Iraq. That whole "mission" was nothing but a farce.

Yep...and of course, the same consequences as Colin Powell and Condoleeza Rice suffered.
 
How about she gets the same consequences Bush and Cheney got for the over 4000 dead in Iraq. That whole "mission" was nothing but a farce.


A great topic for another thread if you care enough to start one. This one is not about that.
 
My point was that someone provided inadequate security for Chris Stevens, and as a result, he died. I don't know who made that decision, and I likely never will. It's all there in the top post. If you're having difficulty comprehending it for some reason, I don't know how much can be done to make it clearer for you. The entire post is less than 300 words, contains no technical or medical jargon, no Latin or foreign terms, and no complex concepts. You can try reading it again, perhaps with a helpful friend, but that would require a small amount of effort so I really don't expect you will.

Don't fret; I'm sure others understood it with no difficulty.

Have you moved on? Really?
 
Have you moved on? Really?


Yes. I feel we are unlikely to ever know who made the crucial errors, so I've moved on. That would explain why I haven't singled anyone out, called for anyone's head, or all the other things you've seemed to assume I was doing. It's important to read with clarity before making assumptions, is it not?
 
Yep...and of course, the same consequences as Colin Powell and Condoleeza Rice suffered.
Yep. Never heard all this carrying on about the thousands of lives lost in Iraq under the Bush adm. Comparing the number lost they should be going on about it to their dying day, if they weren't doing this all for partisan reasons.
 
A great topic for another thread if you care enough to start one. This one is not about that.
That topic would never be started by a con. And cons would ignore it. But I can see why it would bother you. It should
 
Yes. I feel we are unlikely to ever know who made the crucial errors, so I've moved on. That would explain why I haven't singled anyone out, called for anyone's head, or all the other things you've seemed to assume I was doing. It's important to read with clarity before making assumptions, is it not?

OK...I'm satisfied. Just needed to make sure, because I moved on nearly 4 years ago. But these investigations kept appearing...

I feel we know enough about the attack and knew enough years ago, to say it's merely the circumstances of a bad plan, exacerbated by lack of foresight in running a CIA safe house and a temporary domestic outpost in such a volatile area during volatile times. Budget cuts would also clearly play a part, as we don't have unlimited resources in either humanpower nor finances to fully protect every outpost, especially ones trying to be a tad more covert.

This is part and parcel of the game...the spy game, the foreign policy game.
 
Back
Top