New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Bergdahl guilty......

that's the charge, not the verdict. but likely it will eventually be the verdict. military judges are very strict.

that said, i favor giving bergdahl a dishonorable discharge, parole for time served in taleban captivity, and a free ambulance ride to a mental hospital.

this is a low IQ mentally disturbed guy who never should have been allowed to enlist in the first place. in fact, he was already discharged from the coast guard when the army recruiters thought he might make a fine US soldier.

this is a recruiting failure. make sure he's a "person prohibited" from ever owning a gun, send him to a psychiatrist, and hope that regular visits by his family (who he reportedly has "issues with" might help bring him around.

yes, he did know right from wrong. no, he didn't kill anyone. he simply wasn't army material, and ran away. he's mentally ill.
 
It's about time!

And Obamahole released 5 Tali-terrorists for the POS Deserter!

We both know that's why it's taken so long for him to be charged...he's another Obamafailure.
 
that's the charge, not the verdict. but likely it will eventually be the verdict. military judges are very strict.

that said, i favor giving bergdahl a dishonorable discharge, parole for time served in taleban captivity, and a free ambulance ride to a mental hospital.

this is a low IQ mentally disturbed guy who never should have been allowed to enlist in the first place. in fact, he was already discharged from the coast guard when the army recruiters thought he might make a fine US soldier.

this is a recruiting failure. make sure he's a "person prohibited" from ever owning a gun, send him to a psychiatrist, and hope that regular visits by his family (who he reportedly has "issues with" might help bring him around.

yes, he did know right from wrong. no, he didn't kill anyone. he simply wasn't army material, and ran away. he's mentally ill.
Your headline is at odds with a story that says we're only at the stage of him being charged.
Yes, I realize it was a misquote, and I apologize for that. But he has been charged, and that means they have evidence to charge him with desertion. I have no doubts that he will be found guilty. I also believe that will be followed by a presidential pardon.

I don't think there is any question that he is mentally unstable. His life as a young man before entering any sort of military service shows that.
 
Yes, I realize it was a misquote, and I apologize for that. But he has been charged, and that means they have evidence to charge him with desertion. I have no doubts that he will be found guilty. I also believe that will be followed by a presidential pardon.

I don't think there is any question that he is mentally unstable. His life as a young man before entering any sort of military service shows that.
My guess is that he'll be found guilty and that rather than being pardoned his sentence will be commuted to time served.
 
My guess is that he'll be found guilty and that rather than being pardoned his sentence will be commuted to time served.
You're assuming that he will be sentenced to 5 years. Part of what he is being charged with can mean life. Nope, I think a presidential pardon will take care of it.
 
You're assuming that he will be sentenced to 5 years. Part of what he is being charged with can mean life. Nope, I think a presidential pardon will take care of it.

I do remember hearing someone saying he might get time served for the 5 yrs in Afghanistan. But I doubt that. I think he'll be pardoned too. But even if he isn't, if he's free to roam, he'll be back in Afghanistan first chance he gets. He has a job to do.
 
You're assuming that he will be sentenced to 5 years. Part of what he is being charged with can mean life. Nope, I think a presidential pardon will take care of it.
A commutation would work regardless of the relative lengths of the sentences. That would allow him to remain guilty as charged, while accounting for the long, hard imprisonment he's already suffered.

The model would be GW Bush's commutation of Libby's sentence, after Libby betrayed the American people by disclosing the identity of one of our intelligence assets. Libby's guilty verdict stayed on the books, and he was required to pay his fine, but wasn't imprisoned. Personally, I thought that was a terrible move by Bush, but I probably would have been content with it if somehow Libby had already spent years suffering at the hands of Islamists as a result of his crimes.
 
How could you have missed the FACT that he has been charged but she said he was GUILTY? Before you tell others how to look up things all you have to do is read her top post and see that she misquoted (or whatever)...maybe just wishful thinking on her part.
 
I do remember hearing someone saying he might get time served for the 5 yrs in Afghanistan. But I doubt that. I think he'll be pardoned too. But even if he isn't, if he's free to roam, he'll be back in Afghanistan first chance he gets. He has a job to do.
He has to be found guilty first. Maybe they'll have the trial in FL and he'll walk free.
 
You're assuming that he will be sentenced to 5 years. Part of what he is being charged with can mean life. Nope, I think a presidential pardon will take care of it.
You sincerely hope Obama pardons him if he's found guilty...you and every other con here. More fodder for your Obama hate.
 
How does that disagree with the statement that he has been charged, not found guilty?

I didn't notice the actual thread title. So yes, I do have to agree that the word guilty shouldn't have been used. Even though some of us are pretty much 99% sure he is, he hasn't been found guilty.....yet. I apologize, I was wrong and should have paid more attention to that. But Charcat got some attention with it! :)
 
A commutation would work regardless of the relative lengths of the sentences. That would allow him to remain guilty as charged, while accounting for the long, hard imprisonment he's already suffered.

If he willingly deserted to join the Taliban, would you still consider it a "long, hard imprisonment"?

Of course you would...to do otherwise would be to insult the honor of your godlet and violate your fealty.
 
How could you have missed the FACT that he has been charged but she said he was GUILTY? Before you tell others how to look up things all you have to do is read her top post and see that she misquoted (or whatever)...maybe just wishful thinking on her part.
Please see my response to Middleview.
 
If he willingly deserted to join the Taliban, would you still consider it a "long, hard imprisonment"?

Of course you would...to do otherwise would be to insult the honor of your godlet and violate your fealty.
If it was a long, hard imprisonment, why would the circumstances that led to it change that? And what are you talking about with this talk of godlets and fealty?
 
Back
Top