New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Biden-Hur Transcripts

Judging by a special standard where … although life expectancy rose in every country that “attempt[ed] to implement Marxist ideology” … every death in those countries was attributed to “Marxist ideology” while the background rate of deaths reduced by the abandonment of capitalism was ignored. And ignoring the difference between the high tide of revolution and the backlash of the counterrevolutionary ebb.
Nope. Just slaughter.
 
First is a paywall.

The second ..doesn't appear to be what we were discussing.

Another step forward for Trump thanks to your contribution..sigh
 
Millions upon millions dead under Stalin, and communism in general...ho chi min, lenin, etc
Well, many of those deaths are directly attributable to the abandonment of Marxism by Stalin and Ho Chi Minh, or to be more specific their war on the foundational principles of Marxism and those principles’ defenders. A much smaller number can be attributed to the struggle against those attempting to maintain the murderous capitalist status quo. If you actually chose a concrete example as requested the explication would be clearer.
 
Well, many of those deaths are directly attributable to the abandonment of Marxism by Stalin and Ho Chi Minh, or to be more specific their war on the foundational principles of Marxism and those principles’ defenders. A much smaller number can be attributed to the struggle against those attempting to maintain the murderous capitalist status quo. If you actually chose a concrete example as requested the explication would be clearer.
Or, directly.and truthfully to the implementation of and subsequent failure of socialist and communist ideals.
 
Or, directly.and truthfully to the implementation of and subsequent failure of socialist and communist ideals.
Every workers’ state was previously a capitalist country. If you blame what happened there after the abandonment of communism on communism, why not blame what happened there after the abandonment of capitalism on capitalism? Then there are all the places where much greater atrocities were committed while the capitalist system was maintained …

Did communism fail in the USSR, resulting in the horrors of the Holodomor, etc.? Yes, it failed in one sense … it failed politically, that is, it failed to maintain its momentum and prevent the reversion to capitalist methods and goals revived with such awful consequences under Stalin.
 
Every workers’ state was previously a capitalist country. If you blame what happened there after the abandonment of communism on communism, why not blame what happened there after the abandonment of capitalism on capitalism? Then there are all the places where much greater atrocities were committed while the capitalist system was maintained …

Did communism fail in the USSR, resulting in the horrors of the Holodomor, etc.? Yes, it failed in one sense … it failed politically, that is, it failed to maintain its momentum and prevent the reversion to capitalist methods and goals revived with such awful consequences under Stalin.
No it was a horrific policy of Stalin's version of communism. Millions upon millions were killed. Millions upon millions were killed by Ho chi minh, millions of millions have suffered across generations because of the ideals of Communism and those that attempted to implement it. It's a sad thing reading your attempts to finesse it.
 
No it was a horrific policy of Stalin's version of communism. Millions upon millions were killed. Millions upon millions were killed by Ho chi minh, millions of millions have suffered across generations because of the ideals of Communism and those that attempted to implement it. It's a sad thing reading your attempts to finesse it.
“Stalin’s version of communism” was a counterfeit sham that went against the basic principles of Marxism due to the contamination of capitalist ideology. Many of those killed by Stalin were communists … in fact, the mass killing of communists was a precondition for Stalin’s centralization of power. Most of those killed by Ho Chi Minh who were not imperialist soldiers were communists.
 
“Stalin’s version of communism” was a counterfeit sham that went against the basic principles of Marxism due to the contamination of capitalist ideology. Many of those killed by Stalin were communists … in fact, the mass killing of communists was a precondition for Stalin’s centralization of power. Most of those killed by Ho Chi Minh who were not imperialist soldiers were communists.
Perhaps. But that reinforces the point doesn't it? Not only was communism a failure because of the millions of non-communists, who by the way had no interest in communism, wish to be free and not subjugated, but also the millions of actual communists that were killed by communism in its consumption of itself. Twice as bad huh? Damned if you were a communist, damned if you weren't a communist, dead all the same.
 
Perhaps. But that reinforces the point doesn't it? Not only was communism a failure because of the millions of non-communists, who by the way had no interest in communism, wish to be free and not subjugated, but also the millions of actual communists that were killed by communism in its consumption of itself. Twice as bad huh? Damned if you were a communist, damned if you weren't a communist, dead all the same.
There is no way a capitalist country starts building socialism without the active support of the majority. What you call “communism in its consumption of itself” is in actuality the capitalist class’s violent efforts to dispossess the majority of control and re-establish elite rule. Stalin and his emulators (Ho Chi Minh etc.) could never have taken/held power without resting on the support of the international capitalist counterrevolution against the communistic masses.

The Stalinist centrist road of seeking a middle path between capitalism and socialism, resting on the inability of either world-historical ruling class to rule securely, is a symptom of the weakness of communism in its early days of development, and becomes less and less possible as the international communist revolution becomes more powerful. Similar phenomena of bureaucratic “Bonapartist” regimes were found in the early days of capitalism (before the capitalist class developed the strength of the mature capitalist era), including not just the Bonapartist dictatorships of Bonaparte, Bolivar, etc., but also the phenomena of royal absolutism and Jacobinism. As capitalism has lost its power to the advance of communism we see the same with a renewed tendency toward Bonapartism and particularly fascism. And these regimes have been accompanied by as much violence as needed to maintain their leaders’ privilege as well.
 
Last edited:
There is no way a capitalist country starts building socialism without the active support of the majority. What you call “communism in its consumption of itself” is in actuality the capitalist class’s violent efforts to dispossess the majority of control and re-establish elite rule. Stalin and his emulators (Ho Chi Minh etc.) could never have taken/held power without resting on the support of the international capitalist counterrevolution against the communistic masses.

The Stalinist centrist road of seeking a middle path between capitalism and socialism, resting on the inability of either world-historical ruling class to rule securely, is a symptom of the weakness of communism in its early days of development, and becomes less and less possible as the international communist revolution becomes more powerful. Similar phenomena of bureaucratic “Bonapartist” regimes were found in the early days of capitalism (before the capitalist class developed the strength of the mature capitalist era), including not just the Bonapartist dictatorships of Bonaparte, Bolivar, etc., but also the phenomena of royal absolutism and Jacobinism. As capitalism has lost its power to the advance of communism we see the same with a renewed tendency toward Bonapartism and particularly fascism. And these regimes have been accompanied by as much violence as needed to maintain their leaders’ privilege as well.
Uh, Stalin took control of the grain harvest in Ukraine by killing everyone who would not surrender their grain. Then he starved millions to death...when not brutalizing and killing them that is.
 
Uh, Stalin took control of the grain harvest in Ukraine by killing everyone who would not surrender their grain. Then he starved millions to death...when not brutalizing and killing them that is.
Yup. Very similar to the methods used in previous centuries by capitalist reformers such as Cromwell and Peel for primitive capitalist accumulation, and a vicious repudiation (made possible by the defeat of communist forces by the forces of capitalist counterrevolution) of the Marxist program of voluntary collectivization on the basis of a worker-peasant alliance.

Engels of course warned in 1882 that if Russia were to have a working-class revolution, but that revolution did not quickly spread to a more advanced country (Germany or the UK), the result would be an "orgy of barbarism" due to the mismatch between the objective requirements for socialist construction and Russia's material and political backwardness.
 
Back
Top