Arkady
President
The US birth rate has fallen quite a bit in recent decades, to around 1.86 births per woman. This is below the "replacement rate," which means the US is on a path to have either a shrinking population, or to have to maintain population through immigration. That's not necessarily a problem, but I was curious what people here thought about it.
If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.
So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.
Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.
So, what do others think?
Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids. Most approaches to boosting birth rates go the other way -- they are too small to encourage the upper class to breed more, so they result in the lower class having even more kids, while upper-class fortunes get concentrated by way of inter-generational population shrinkage, which can cause social problems.
If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.
So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.
Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.
So, what do others think?
Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids. Most approaches to boosting birth rates go the other way -- they are too small to encourage the upper class to breed more, so they result in the lower class having even more kids, while upper-class fortunes get concentrated by way of inter-generational population shrinkage, which can cause social problems.
Last edited: