New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Birth Rates

Arkady

President
The US birth rate has fallen quite a bit in recent decades, to around 1.86 births per woman. This is below the "replacement rate," which means the US is on a path to have either a shrinking population, or to have to maintain population through immigration. That's not necessarily a problem, but I was curious what people here thought about it.

If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.

So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.

Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.

So, what do others think?

Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids. Most approaches to boosting birth rates go the other way -- they are too small to encourage the upper class to breed more, so they result in the lower class having even more kids, while upper-class fortunes get concentrated by way of inter-generational population shrinkage, which can cause social problems.
 
Last edited:
The US birth rate has fallen quite a bit in recent decades, to around 1.86 births per woman. This is below the "replacement rate," which means the US is on a path to have either a shrinking population, or to have to maintain population through immigration. That's not necessarily a problem, but I was curious what people here thought about it.

If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.

So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.

Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.

So, what do others think?

Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids.


I don't think an shrinking population is inherrently bad. Ultimately we need fewer people in the world. Other countries are trying to figure out how to get people to stop breeding. We know at some point the earth will stop being able to support people. We know that as automation continues we need fewer workers. I would by far prefer that we reduce population naturally by people choosing to limit their family size rather than arbitrarily telling people how many children they can have.

The problem is - that our entitlement spending is based on a continually growing population. Social security for example. So, what we need to do is figure out how to build controls into all our social spending, so that the people who get the benefits, get what they paid for, not what other people are chipping in for them necessitating more people to be chipping in. And, to reduce the benefits which are ultimately paid out, thus reducing the overall burden on other taxpayers.

The problem of course is trying to get this to line up So that by the time you have fewer jobs, you have fewer people who need jobs. To do that means we have to drastically curb immigration, and we have to make some drastic alterations in our social welfare spending to make the amount affordable by less people.

I am not a fan of Gov't either importing people to support the economy or encouraging people to breed. I would rather plan for the reduction in the economy and the relative spending.


connie
 
The US birth rate has fallen quite a bit in recent decades, to around 1.86 births per woman. This is below the "replacement rate," which means the US is on a path to have either a shrinking population, or to have to maintain population through immigration. That's not necessarily a problem, but I was curious what people here thought about it.

If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.

So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.

Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.

So, what do others think?

Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids. Most approaches to boosting birth rates go the other way -- they are too small to encourage the upper class to breed more, so they result in the lower class having even more kids, while upper-class fortunes get concentrated by way of inter-generational population shrinkage, which can cause social problems.

Government regulations telling people when to have kids and where to live? Yup, sounds right up your alley...
 
I don't think an shrinking population is inherrently bad. Ultimately we need fewer people in the world. Other countries are trying to figure out how to get people to stop breeding. We know at some point the earth will stop being able to support people. We know that as automation continues we need fewer workers. I would by far prefer that we reduce population naturally by people choosing to limit their family size rather than arbitrarily telling people how many children they can have.

The problem is - that our entitlement spending is based on a continually growing population. Social security for example. So, what we need to do is figure out how to build controls into all our social spending, so that the people who get the benefits, get what they paid for, not what other people are chipping in for them necessitating more people to be chipping in. And, to reduce the benefits which are ultimately paid out, thus reducing the overall burden on other taxpayers.

The problem of course is trying to get this to line up So that by the time you have fewer jobs, you have fewer people who need jobs. To do that means we have to drastically curb immigration, and we have to make some drastic alterations in our social welfare spending to make the amount affordable by less people.

I am not a fan of Gov't either importing people to support the economy or encouraging people to breed. I would rather plan for the reduction in the economy and the relative spending.


connie
Just imagine a responsible state order in which entitlements were not over promised and hard committed costs were actually budgeted and accrued like a real business...
 
So, what we need to do is figure out how to build controls into all our social spending, so that the people who get the benefits, get what they paid for, not what other people are chipping in for them necessitating more people to be chipping in.

This could be done fairly easily by just having a law where the payout for each age cohort would have to be whatever that cohort paid in, adjusted up by the applicable treasury rate for each year they contributed. That would beat private accounts, in that it would retain the "insurance" aspect of the system, so it wouldn't merely be repeating the function of private retirement savings accounts. But it would prevent inter-generational transfers of money. So, for example, all people born in 1950, put together, would, in total, take out the present value of all contributions that people born in 1950 put in.

The only problem with this is that prior generations already took out more than they put in, so you need to find a way to cover that, or you're screwing whichever generation gets the change imposed on them.

What makes me angry is that the solutions most commonly proposed for SS, like switching to chained CPI, go the exact opposite direction as what makes sense from a fairness perspective. Moving to a lower inflation adjustor means minor reductions for the oldest people, who are most likely to have already benefited from taking out more value than they put in, and major reductions for the youngest people, none of whom have taken out more than they put in. That's a solution that only makes sense from a strictly political perspective, because the old have more money and higher voter turnout, so politicians fear them more. It would be fairer to go the other way -- cut off retirees when their cohort reaches the point where they've taken out more present value than they put in.
To do that means we have to drastically curb immigration

If we do that, who does the work? The need for the labor will remain, whether it's done by government or the private sector. All those retired Baby Boomers, for example, who increasingly depend on others, need to have someone doing the work. If subsequent generations are very small, that drives up the price of that work through supply and demand (e.g., making nursing care very expensive for frail Boomers), to levels where it isn't affordable for many. Then either government lets those people suffer and die, or it steps up and helps out with Medicare and Medicaid covering more stuff, resulting in larger and larger portions of our GDP flowing through the government to those services. More immigration, by comparison, lowers the cost of those services, resulting in a smaller share of GDP going to them.

we have to make some drastic alterations in our social welfare spending to make the amount affordable by less people.

It's certainly possible to approach the problem by depressing the quality of life of more Americans, so that reduced production is enough to cover reduced consumption. But I'm not convinced that's superior to just boosting immigration so that production can continue to grow, allowing quality of life to continue to grow, with the new Americans providing the expanding production.
 
Government regulations telling people when to have kids and where to live? Yup, sounds right up your alley...
I know it's fun to just launch mindless personal attacks, rather than to engage with issues, but how about trying to step up your game, if only for a day? What would your approach be to the falling birth rate? Just ignore it?
 
This could be done fairly easily by just having a law where the payout for each age cohort would have to be whatever that cohort paid in, adjusted up by the applicable treasury rate for each year they contributed. That would beat private accounts, in that it would retain the "insurance" aspect of the system, so it wouldn't merely be repeating the function of private retirement savings accounts. But it would prevent inter-generational transfers of money. So, for example, all people born in 1950, put together, would, in total, take out the present value of all contributions that people born in 1950 put in.

The only problem with this is that prior generations already took out more than they put in, so you need to find a way to cover that, or you're screwing whichever generation gets the change imposed on them.

What makes me angry is that the solutions most commonly proposed for SS, like switching to chained CPI, go the exact opposite direction as what makes sense from a fairness perspective. Moving to a lower inflation adjustor means minor reductions for the oldest people, who are most likely to have already benefited from taking out more value than they put in, and major reductions for the youngest people, none of whom have taken out more than they put in. That's a solution that only makes sense from a strictly political perspective, because the old have more money and higher voter turnout, so politicians fear them more. It would be fairer to go the other way -- cut off retirees when their cohort reaches the point where they've taken out more present value than they put in.


If we do that, who does the work? The need for the labor will remain, whether it's done by government or the private sector. All those retired Baby Boomers, for example, who increasingly depend on others, need to have someone doing the work. If subsequent generations are very small, that drives up the price of that work through supply and demand (e.g., making nursing care very expensive for frail Boomers), to levels where it isn't affordable for many. Then either government lets those people suffer and die, or it steps up and helps out with Medicare and Medicaid covering more stuff, resulting in larger and larger portions of our GDP flowing through the government to those services. More immigration, by comparison, lowers the cost of those services, resulting in a smaller share of GDP going to them.



It's certainly possible to approach the problem by depressing the quality of life of more Americans, so that reduced production is enough to cover reduced consumption. But I'm not convinced that's superior to just boosting immigration so that production can continue to grow, allowing quality of life to continue to grow, with the new Americans providing the expanding production.

I agree - the limiting the payouts is problematic and it would have to be phased in. Someone is going to ahve to bite the bullet though and Its probably going to start with our generation. But, at this point I have paid in enough SS to draw the max when I retire. So, I am already getting screwed as it is. I would rather get the situation in line instead of continually kicking it down the road. It is an abomination that the previous generations got back more than they put in ( plus obviously some sort of investment rate) but it is what is , doesn't mean we continue that problem.

In regards to who will do the work - the answer is we already have unemployment. We already hav emore workers than we have work, - so the answer will bepeople who would otherwise be unemployed. You have argued many times of the increase in productivity was never passed onto the worker and he didn't get the gains, so clearly we need fewer employees. I do not agree this will come with any corresponding increase in labor costs. Labor cost will remain stagnant since there is only so much a person is willing to spend. What else there is will be made up in automation and outsourcing where labor costs will be lower. But, ultimately in a generation or two we will need far fewer people to work, so it would better to just have way less people.

I do not advocate continuing to just increase population and production -because we are doing it all on credit. EVENTUALLY the growth will stop. At some point - there will be no more growth, then there will be total collapse. I would rather rein that in, reduce immigration, and ultimately reduce the GDP made up by labor dollars. But, which will be made up instead by automated productivity. I do not see how there will be any significant decrese in the quality of life.Infact, I think we will once again be the envy because everyone will be employed and instead of living like a bunch of ants on top of each other - we will still have wide open spaces, natural resources, and freedom of movement and oppressive gov't policies.

connie
 
illegals are making sure that birth rates remain high...........while other Americans realized they couldn't afford making more babies........of course when you produce and others pay.....having 6 is no problem.........
 
Last edited:
I would rather get the situation in line instead of continually kicking it down the road. It is an abomination that the previous generations got back more than they put in ( plus obviously some sort of investment rate) but it is what is , doesn't mean we continue that problem.

I'm fine with a phased-in transition if it is done right. For example, just pulling a number out of the air, say current people age 90+, as a group, are on track to take out 200% of the interest-adjusted value of what they paid in. You could drop their payments enough that they're only now on likely to take out 197.5%. Then, for those age 89, let's say that under the current system they're projected to take out 198% of the value of what they paid in. Drop their payments so they they have twice the proportional reduction in the unfunded excess (a 5 percentage point drop, rather than 2.5). And then do the same to those age 88 (a 7.5 percentage point). And so on. Every younger year cohort would have more options for dealing with the unexpected decrease, and so could be expected to handle a bigger decrease. Thus, by the time you get to those currently age 40, you have matched the value paid in and the value paid out.... which is less than they would have expected under the prior system, but they've got many years to adjust their retirement plans accordingly. That way no age cohort is thrown in a lurch and no age cohort pays in more value than it gets out. What I worry about systems like a lower COLA adjustment is that the young may end up paying more into the system than they get out.

That seems like a fair way to transition this system gradually to a fully-funded system that doesn't rely on population growth, over the course of the next forty years. But, in the meantime, you still need to figure out where to get the extra money to fund all those people who take more out than they put in.

Alternately, you could do the transition more quickly (30 years, 20, 10, 5?), but the faster you do it, the more people are going to be hit by having SS incomes well below what they'd been planning on, without time to adjust. Picture, for example, someone who "semi-retires" at 55, into some sort of low-paying public interest job, with the idea that he's put away just enough for a comfortable, albeit modest retirement already. If you spring on him the fact his SS payments are going to drop considerably, he may have limited ability to ramp his career back up again to make up the difference, so you will have screwed him.

In regards to who will do the work - the answer is we already have unemployment.

When the economy has been going strong, we already get to "full employment levels" -- like the sub-4% unemployment we had in the late Clinton era. At that level, it's not really possible to go much lower, because of the number of people who are in transition at any given time, and already it's low enough that it creates inflationary pressure. If low population growth puts us near those levels for extended periods of time, won't that screw over older people, who won't have the money to pay for the services they need? Basically, you'd have a bunch of older folks with money they'd love to use to hire assistance in their elder years (nursing, help around the house, etc.), and you'd have a bunch of people across the border who'd love to provide that assistance for relatively modest pay, and yet you're keeping the two apart, causing both to suffer. Whom does that benefit?

You have argued many times of the increase in productivity was never passed onto the worker and he didn't get the gains, so clearly we need fewer employees

That's not clear. You could accomplish it with the same number of employees but fewer hours worked. Or you could simply require the owners of capital to share the value of the productivity gains with displaced workers, so that we'd have fewer multi-billionaires tooling around in the 200-foot yachts and lear jets, but more widespread prosperity. There are lots of options here, aside from trying to reduce the workforce to create more bargaining power for the workers.

EVENTUALLY the growth will stop.

Why?

I do not see how there will be any significant decrese in the quality of life.

Look at it historically. Living standards have risen over time, with population growth. Most is due to technological advances and accumulated physical and human infrastructure improvements, but some is due to the economies of scale that bigger societies get. If you roll back population size, you can lose those. We can see a pretty dramatic example during the Middle Ages, when the collapse of Rome resulted in rapid population decline throughout Europe. In theory, people should have been getting richer, with more land and resources theoretically being available per person, but in fact people got poorer. People living in small, far-flung communities couldn't maintain the same quality of life as people in a big, interconnected, denser empire. Obviously, with US population decline, we're not talking about the same kind of collapse as post-Rome, but there is the same risk, on a smaller scale, that population decline could drive down quality of life. And that's compounded by the decline that could come through an increasing dependency ratio, if we allow our demographics to get top-heavy with the elderly. If we're a nation mostly of non-productive, expensive elderly people, with only a fairly small number of workers, how could we expect quality of life not to decline?
 
illegals are making sure that birth rates remain high...........while other Americans realized they couldn't afford making more babies........of course when you produce and others pay.....having 6 is no problem.........
Globally and historically, poorer people have more children. It's probably an evolutionarily imposed impulse, based on an expectation of high infant mortality that comes when people suffer privation. If you're stressed and unsure that you're going to have a roof over your head and food on the table, your subconscious perceives that as a higher probability that your children will die, and encourages you to have more children, to hedge against those losses, whereas if you feel pretty confident that your basic needs will be met, you invest in maximizing the prospects of your existing children, rather than maximizing the number of children.

For example, the fertility rates in sub-Saharan Africa are in the 5-8 range (5-8 births per woman), and they're also quite high in war-torn areas like Iraq and Afghanistan, while at the other end of the spectrum, in Europe and the richer countries of Southeast Asia, the rate is between about 1 and 2.

So, if the birth rates among those who come here illegally concern you, the way we'd be more likely to bring them down is to improve social services for such people, so that they're not as poor and not, subconsciously, hedging against the risk of high rates of mortality among their children.
 
The US birth rate has fallen quite a bit in recent decades, to around 1.86 births per woman. This is below the "replacement rate," which means the US is on a path to have either a shrinking population, or to have to maintain population through immigration. That's not necessarily a problem, but I was curious what people here thought about it.

If you want to make a case that it's a problem, it's mostly about demographics. There's something called a dependency ratio, which measures the ratio of dependents to workers. Dependents can be children, the disabled, or the elderly. In the third-world, dependency ratios get thrown out of whack by high mortality rates and high birth rates, which results in lots of kids per adult, and thus require the average worker to support a whole bunch of others. In wealthy nations, the risk is in the other direction -- years of low birth rates and low mortality result in relatively few people of working age having to support a lot of retirees. Europe is well along that path and the US is headed that way rapidly. Already Gen X, known as the "birth dearth," is poorly positioned to fill roles being vacated by retiring Baby Boomers, since the Boomers were a bigger generation. This is somewhat mitigated by the Millennials having been a large generation, and by a lot of immigration. But if this next generation ends up being small and we cut back on immigration, Gen X and the Millennials will have trouble footing the bill for the Baby Boomer and the Silents, in their golden years. Moreover, the debt run up during the last couple decades of sky-high military spending and rock-bottom taxes may be sustainable if the GDP grows robustly, thanks to an expanding population base, but it could become unmanageable if the country's population is shrinking.

So, if you think it's a problem, should government be doing anything to combat it? One solution is simply to open the gates to more immigration. Lots of immigration can create its own problems, in the creation of ethnic underclasses, etc., but this could be managed by taking a more active "recruiting" role to immigration. We would specifically manage immigration to bring in the right mix of skills, the desired distribution of ages, a diverse set of national backgrounds, and perhaps even start with residence permits that encouraged people to live in a more distributed fashion around the country, so as not to unduly burden border states.

Another solution would be policies to encourage higher birth rates, like allowances for those with underage children, subsidized daycare, longer paid vacation mandates, mandates for paid maternity and paternity pay, tighter control on work hours, etc. I like those ideas for other social reasons (I think we could bring down crime and obesity, while boosting academic achievement, if parent's had more time and money for parenting), but I'm not convinced they'd boost birth rates, just based on how low birth rates are in Europe, where they have those things.

So, what do others think?

Just a quick, counter-intuitive thought here. There's a case to be made for providing bigger incentives for the upper-class to breed more. This would, long term, work counter to growing wealth inequality in this country, by dividing larger fortunes up more ways. As a liberal, the idea of intentionally flowing extra resources to those who already have them sticks in my craw, but I've got to admit you're likely to end up in a better position, in a generation, if you can find a way to get the top of the economic ladder having big broods, while the bottom portion focuses their limited resources on doing better raising a smaller number of kids. Most approaches to boosting birth rates go the other way -- they are too small to encourage the upper class to breed more, so they result in the lower class having even more kids, while upper-class fortunes get concentrated by way of inter-generational population shrinkage, which can cause social problems.

You won't believe me but you're starting to see the numbers.

excerpt:

"According to Voice of Russia, scientists from the National Association for Gene Security and the Institute of Ecological and Evolutional Problems discovered that animals fed GMOs as part of their normal diet eventually develop the inability to reproduce.

A shocking revelation; the study is one of several that has identified a link between GMO consumption and infertility in recent years. And because it was conducted independently of the biotechnology industry, it came to far different conclusions than have most of the studies offered up for mainstream consumption in defense of GMOs."

I'm giving you this link, but there are a lot more. Farmers are starting to lose their farms because they've started to feed their animals and the animals are no longer reproducing enough to keep things going. Of course your usual news sources don't tell you these things. Too much money involved.

GMOs cause animals to lose their ability to reproduce, Russian scientists discover - NaturalNews.com
 
I'm fine with a phased-in transition if it is done right. For example, just pulling a number out of the air, say current people age 90+, as a group, are on track to take out 200% of the interest-adjusted value of what they paid in. You could drop their payments enough that they're only now on likely to take out 197.5%. Then, for those age 89, let's say that under the current system they're projected to take out 198% of the value of what they paid in. Drop their payments so they they have twice the proportional reduction in the unfunded excess (a 5 percentage point drop, rather than 2.5). And then do the same to those age 88 (a 7.5 percentage point). And so on. Every younger year cohort would have more options for dealing with the unexpected decrease, and so could be expected to handle a bigger decrease. Thus, by the time you get to those currently age 40, you have matched the value paid in and the value paid out.... which is less than they would have expected under the prior system, but they've got many years to adjust their retirement plans accordingly. That way no age cohort is thrown in a lurch and no age cohort pays in more value than it gets out. What I worry about systems like a lower COLA adjustment is that the young may end up paying more into the system than they get out.

That seems like a fair way to transition this system gradually to a fully-funded system that doesn't rely on population growth, over the course of the next forty years. But, in the meantime, you still need to figure out where to get the extra money to fund all those people who take more out than they put in.

Alternately, you could do the transition more quickly (30 years, 20, 10, 5?), but the faster you do it, the more people are going to be hit by having SS incomes well below what they'd been planning on, without time to adjust. Picture, for example, someone who "semi-retires" at 55, into some sort of low-paying public interest job, with the idea that he's put away just enough for a comfortable, albeit modest retirement already. If you spring on him the fact his SS payments are going to drop considerably, he may have limited ability to ramp his career back up again to make up the difference, so you will have screwed him.



When the economy has been going strong, we already get to "full employment levels" -- like the sub-4% unemployment we had in the late Clinton era. At that level, it's not really possible to go much lower, because of the number of people who are in transition at any given time, and already it's low enough that it creates inflationary pressure. If low population growth puts us near those levels for extended periods of time, won't that screw over older people, who won't have the money to pay for the services they need? Basically, you'd have a bunch of older folks with money they'd love to use to hire assistance in their elder years (nursing, help around the house, etc.), and you'd have a bunch of people across the border who'd love to provide that assistance for relatively modest pay, and yet you're keeping the two apart, causing both to suffer. Whom does that benefit?



That's not clear. You could accomplish it with the same number of employees but fewer hours worked. Or you could simply require the owners of capital to share the value of the productivity gains with displaced workers, so that we'd have fewer multi-billionaires tooling around in the 200-foot yachts and lear jets, but more widespread prosperity. There are lots of options here, aside from trying to reduce the workforce to create more bargaining power for the workers.



Why?



Look at it historically. Living standards have risen over time, with population growth. Most is due to technological advances and accumulated physical and human infrastructure improvements, but some is due to the economies of scale that bigger societies get. If you roll back population size, you can lose those. We can see a pretty dramatic example during the Middle Ages, when the collapse of Rome resulted in rapid population decline throughout Europe. In theory, people should have been getting richer, with more land and resources theoretically being available per person, but in fact people got poorer. People living in small, far-flung communities couldn't maintain the same quality of life as people in a big, interconnected, denser empire. Obviously, with US population decline, we're not talking about the same kind of collapse as post-Rome, but there is the same risk, on a smaller scale, that population decline could drive down quality of life. And that's compounded by the decline that could come through an increasing dependency ratio, if we allow our demographics to get top-heavy with the elderly. If we're a nation mostly of non-productive, expensive elderly people, with only a fairly small number of workers, how could we expect quality of life not to decline?


I am not "rolling back" population, I am allowing population to naturally decrease due to natural atrition. We have got to get over this last hurdle of all the old babyboomers tieing us down where the ration of old to worker will still be out of balance. But, since many people of my genration plan on working until long past wha t our parents consider retirement - I think it is feesible that the time of non-productive living for most people will be 5- 10 years max. Unlike the 30 plus years of non productive lving that many of my Gparents enjoyed and the 20 - 25 years plus of non productive living that my parents will enjoy. So, some of the jobs will be that older people still work and still have an incentive to work. Since I think work is not a bad thing, but actually an inherrently postivie thing I do not think this is a decrease in the quality of life.

Near term with all the aging boomers we do have a shortfall of needed support services. For that I would support a guest worker program - come work -leave before you cost us anything. Once they are gone they will not be part of the system we have to support, but yet, we had the temporary labor when we needed it.

The decline in population will only cause a decline in quality of life, IF - it is not met by a corresponding increase in technology. For instance, most processed food is prepped and packaged entirely without it ever touching the hand of a human. At some point a McDonald's can operate the same way. No humans except maybe a supervisor or trouble shooter. That frees up labor. You would rather reduce work hours commensute with additional technology, I beleive the better route is to stop adding people.

connie
 
You won't believe me but you're starting to see the numbers.

excerpt:

"According to Voice of Russia, scientists from the National Association for Gene Security and the Institute of Ecological and Evolutional Problems discovered that animals fed GMOs as part of their normal diet eventually develop the inability to reproduce.

A shocking revelation; the study is one of several that has identified a link between GMO consumption and infertility in recent years. And because it was conducted independently of the biotechnology industry, it came to far different conclusions than have most of the studies offered up for mainstream consumption in defense of GMOs.

"
I'm giving you this link, but there are a lot more. Farmers are starting to lose their farms because they've started to feed their animals and the animals are no longer reproducing enough to keep things going. Of course your usual news sources don't tell you these things. Too much money involved.

GMOs cause animals to lose their ability to reproduce, Russian scientists discover - NaturalNews.com

This is the first time I've ever heard of the "national Association for Gene Security" and the "Institute of Ecological and Evolutional Problems". In fact, this is the first time I've ever even heard the word "Evolutional." Are these real scientific institutes, or just add-hoc associations of GMO paranoids who have
given themselves institutional names? Was the study published in any peer-reviewed journal?

I'm open to the idea, here, but I'm strongly skeptical. There's no plausible mechanism for GMO crops to lead to infertility, unless the genes added to them are ones that cause them to generate lots of hormones or chemicals that triggered hormone receptors. No doubt it would be possible, for example, to create some GMO crop that churned out high levels of progesterone, and thereby interfered with fertility. But, in the same sense, it would be possible to breed a strain of crop, through normal artificial selection, that could do the same kind of thing (e.g., a breed of Soy selected for high levels of phytoestrogens).
 
Last edited:
I think it is feesible that the time of non-productive living for most people will be 5- 10 years max. Unlike the 30 plus years of non productive lving that many of my Gparents enjoyed and the 20 - 25 years plus of non productive living that my parents will enjoy

It could be feasible, but it sounds like a really crappy deal. Basically, generations'-worth of soaring productivity would be going entirely to stacking ever-greater luxury at the feet of the super-rich, while the actual laborers saw the benefits, in terms of years of liberation from the rat-race, decreasing generation after generation. We'd be looking at a world of ever-longer wage slavery, to benefit ever-fewer people. I'd prefer another course. In fact, I'd prefer for retirements to be growing longer and longer, so that people can capture a greater share of the benefit of their own enhanced productivity, relative to earlier generations.

For that I would support a guest worker program - come work -leave before you cost us anything.

I'm up for that. But, in light of the Constitution, you have the problem that their kids born here would be citizens, and the question is how to deal with that.

The decline in population will only cause a decline in quality of life, IF - it is not met by a corresponding increase in technology

To avoid a decline in quality of life, you'd need the combined impact of declining economies of scale and increasing dependency ratios to be offset by increasing productivity due to technological advance. It's entirely possible that will happen. But, it's also possible that it won't. And even if it does happen, it's possible it will be a break-even proposition (just barely keeping up quality of life), which would mean the first generations in our nation's history not to have it better than their parents. Part of the American Dream has been to give your kids a better life than you had, and I don't see a compelling reason to move away from that dream if we have the means to sustain it through increased immigration.
 
This is the first time I've ever heard of the "national Association for Gene Security" and the "Institute of Ecological and Evolutional Problems". In fact, this is the first time I've ever even heard the word "Evolutional." Are these real scientific institutes, or just add-hoc associations of GMO paranoids who have
given themselves institutional names? Was the study published in any peer-reviewed journal?

I'm open to the idea, here, but I'm strongly skeptical. There's no plausible mechanism for GMO crops to lead to infertility, unless the genes added to them are ones that cause them to generate lots of hormones or chemicals that triggered hormone receptors. No doubt it would be possible, for example, to create some GMO crop that churned out high levels of progesterone, and thereby interfered with fertility. But, in the same sense, it would be possible to breed a strain of crop, through normal artificial selection, that could do the same kind of thing (e.g., a breed of Soy selected for high levels of phytoestrogens).

GMOs add foreign DNA to foods and change hormonal balances.

GMO's Genetically Modified Foods, Pregnancy, Fertility and Children | NATURAL PREGNANCY OVER 40 - HAVING A BABY AFTER 40 Sandy Robertson
 
Back
Top