New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Blogging Piketty

Arkady

President
I've just started reading Thomas Piketty's blockbuster economics tome "Capital in the 21st Century." It's 700 pages, and I'm only about 50 pages in, but so far it's been great.

His theses aren't terribly revolutionary. They're things I tumbled to, without any formal macroeconomic education, years ago. And I'm sure many here already understood them instinctively. Among those:

(1) Wealth tends to "trickle up" over time, other than in extraordinary periods that disrupt the normal flow (such as the period encompassing WWI, the Great Depression, and WWII).

(2) If the rate of return on capital exceeds the growth rate of the economy, national wealth will tend to collect in the hands of the few.

(3) The value of labor, relative to capital, tends to decline in periods of low economic growth (which also emphasizes the relative importance of inheritance rather than personal production).

(4) These are not automatic features of the market, but rather respond to various policy choices that countries make (some of which are responsible for the reversal in the rise of income inequality we see in the extraordinary periods like 1914-1945).

Although none of those should be very striking, it sounds like what Piketty has set his sites on is incredibly ambitious: rather than using raw theoretical constructs and math (and naked political ideology) to establish these things, he's going to use massive amounts of historical data, spanning dozens of countries and going back centuries... some of which had to be generated fresh from sources like old tax assessments, from eras when nations didn't track national stats, but did collect data that would be useful for discovering them.

One other point he made (in justifying how much he focuses on France rather than the US in some of his assessments) is a good one to keep in mind. When projecting forward how capital and wealth are likely to play out in the 21s century, the history of the US is probably a poor example. After all, over the course of 230 years, the US expanded its physical territory to nine times its original size, and expanded its population to over ten times the original size. That kind of population growth rate is unlikely for the world, as a whole, in coming centuries, and such physical growth rate is impossible. So, France, which in the same era only doubled in population and kept roughly the same land area winds up being a better model for long-term changes in wealth distribution. The kinds of things the US used to do that promoted wealth equality in the past, like giving away huge tracts of arable farmland to landless citizens, is not something that can happen on a global scale going forward. If you're worried about excessive inequality, you'll need to look to other policy options to address it.
 
did you get to the part yet where he admits that government mandated wealth redistribution schemes haven't worked in the past, and that today's "inequality" (wealth in the hands of the few) is driven primarily by progressive leaning entrepreneurs? Soros; Jobs; Gates; Jeff Bezos; Sergey Brin; Mark Zuckerberg; Steve Ballmer; Phil Knight (adidas) . . . etc.
 
did you get to the part yet where he admits that government mandated wealth redistribution schemes haven't worked in the past, and that today's "inequality" (wealth in the hands of the few) is driven primarily by progressive leaning entrepreneurs? Soros; Jobs; Gates; Jeff Bezos; Sergey Brin; Mark Zuckerberg; Steve Ballmer; Phil Knight (adidas) . . . etc.

Spoiler alert!
 
did you get to the part yet where he admits that government mandated wealth redistribution schemes haven't worked in the past, and that today's "inequality" (wealth in the hands of the few) is driven primarily by progressive leaning entrepreneurs? Soros; Jobs; Gates; Jeff Bezos; Sergey Brin; Mark Zuckerberg; Steve Ballmer; Phil Knight (adidas) . . . etc.
No. That sounds inconsistent with the facts he's shared so far, though.

On a side note, Knight founded Nike. Adidas is German and --curiously-- was founded by the brother of the guy who founded Puma.
 
I've just started reading Thomas Piketty's blockbuster economics tome "Capital in the 21st Century." It's 700 pages, and I'm only about 50 pages in, but so far it's been great.

His theses aren't terribly revolutionary. They're things I tumbled to, without any formal macroeconomic education, years ago. And I'm sure many here already understood them instinctively. Among those:

(1) Wealth tends to "trickle up" over time, other than in extraordinary periods that disrupt the normal flow (such as the period encompassing WWI, the Great Depression, and WWII).

(2) If the rate of return on capital exceeds the growth rate of the economy, national wealth will tend to collect in the hands of the few.

(3) The value of labor, relative to capital, tends to decline in periods of low economic growth (which also emphasizes the relative importance of inheritance rather than personal production).

(4) These are not automatic features of the market, but rather respond to various policy choices that countries make (some of which are responsible for the reversal in the rise of income inequality we see in the extraordinary periods like 1914-1945).

Although none of those should be very striking, it sounds like what Piketty has set his sites on is incredibly ambitious: rather than using raw theoretical constructs and math (and naked political ideology) to establish these things, he's going to use massive amounts of historical data, spanning dozens of countries and going back centuries... some of which had to be generated fresh from sources like old tax assessments, from eras when nations didn't track national stats, but did collect data that would be useful for discovering them.

One other point he made (in justifying how much he focuses on France rather than the US in some of his assessments) is a good one to keep in mind. When projecting forward how capital and wealth are likely to play out in the 21s century, the history of the US is probably a poor example. After all, over the course of 230 years, the US expanded its physical territory to nine times its original size, and expanded its population to over ten times the original size. That kind of population growth rate is unlikely for the world, as a whole, in coming centuries, and such physical growth rate is impossible. So, France, which in the same era only doubled in population and kept roughly the same land area winds up being a better model for long-term changes in wealth distribution. The kinds of things the US used to do that promoted wealth equality in the past, like giving away huge tracts of arable farmland to landless citizens, is not something that can happen on a global scale going forward. If you're worried about excessive inequality, you'll need to look to other policy options to address it.

We all see what we want to see. Me I'm tired of liberal data.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/31/u...omas-piketty-vs-the-financial-times.html?_r=0

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/24/upshot/did-piketty-get-his-math-wrong.html

http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2014/05/inequality-0

https://www.google.com/search?q=dat...microsoft:en-US:IE-Address&ie=&oe=&gws_rd=ssl
 
I'm well aware of the controversy and have followed it closely. In fact, I held off starting to read the book until I was satisfied by the various reviews that it was a good faith data analysis by a top flight economist, rather than just some partisan number gaming, since I had no interest in investing the time needed to read 700 pages of challenging material only to find it was based on skewed data. After reading a few rounds of critics and defenders going back and forth on it, including defenses by some of the most respected economists in the world, I concluded that whatever errors were in his data were the kind one could expect even from very conscientious work of this sort, and unlikely to be systematic enough to foul the whole data set, given how massive and diverse it was, and how many eminent researchers were involved in pulling it together.

So far, what I've read is consistent with the idea that this is not the work of some partisan hack. He's been very open about the limits of his data, he's been very careful to point out the problems with trying to predict events based on past data, and he's had both praise and criticism for predecessors of various political leanings (i.e., both praising and condemning those who thought inequality would tend to expand and those who thought it would tend to contract, based on their contributions to the data and analytical tools, rather than their conclusions).

It doesn't read like policy propaganda. It reads more like an academic piece trying to convince fellow economists that they need to move beyond abstract models and get back to working with historical data, now that new technologies make it more possible to crunch the numbers on vast troves of data like old tax records. He also is very interested in getting economists to work cross functionally with other social scientists,which he thinks has been neglected. It all reads like someone who has a vision for how his profession should be moving forward, but who is otherwise going where the data leads him, rather than someone who starts from a partisan political mindset.
 
I'm well aware of the controversy and have followed it closely. In fact, I held off starting to read the book until I was satisfied by the various reviews that it was a good faith data analysis by a top flight economist, rather than just some partisan number gaming, since I had no interest in investing the time needed to read 700 pages of challenging material only to find it was based on skewed data. After reading a few rounds of critics and defenders going back and forth on it, including defenses by some of the most respected economists in the world, I concluded that whatever errors were in his data were the kind one could expect even from very conscientious work of this sort, and unlikely to be systematic enough to foul the whole data set, given how massive and diverse it was, and how many eminent researchers were involved in pulling it together.

So far, what I've read is consistent with the idea that this is not the work of some partisan hack. He's been very open about the limits of his data, he's been very careful to point out the problems with trying to predict events based on past data, and he's had both praise and criticism for predecessors of various political leanings (i.e., both praising and condemning those who thought inequality would tend to expand and those who thought it would tend to contract, based on their contributions to the data and analytical tools, rather than their conclusions).

It doesn't read like policy propaganda. It reads more like an academic piece trying to convince fellow economists that they need to move beyond abstract models and get back to working with historical data, now that new technologies make it more possible to crunch the numbers on vast troves of data like old tax records. He also is very interested in getting economists to work cross functionally with other social scientists,which he thinks has been neglected. It all reads like someone who has a vision for how his profession should be moving forward, but who is otherwise going where the data leads him, rather than someone who starts from a partisan political mindset.

Is his raw unadulterated dataset online. Are his calculations too? I heard he used Excel.

edit: Of course academics can and have to write to standards that don't seem partisan and yet are. He speaks to you and so you hear him.
 
I'm well aware of the controversy and have followed it closely. In fact, I held off starting to read the book until I was satisfied by the various reviews that it was a good faith data analysis by a top flight economist, rather than just some partisan number gaming, since I had no interest in investing the time needed to read 700 pages of challenging material only to find it was based on skewed data. After reading a few rounds of critics and defenders going back and forth on it, including defenses by some of the most respected economists in the world, I concluded that whatever errors were in his data were the kind one could expect even from very conscientious work of this sort, and unlikely to be systematic enough to foul the whole data set, given how massive and diverse it was, and how many eminent researchers were involved in pulling it together.

So far, what I've read is consistent with the idea that this is not the work of some partisan hack. He's been very open about the limits of his data, he's been very careful to point out the problems with trying to predict events based on past data, and he's had both praise and criticism for predecessors of various political leanings (i.e., both praising and condemning those who thought inequality would tend to expand and those who thought it would tend to contract, based on their contributions to the data and analytical tools, rather than their conclusions).

It doesn't read like policy propaganda. It reads more like an academic piece trying to convince fellow economists that they need to move beyond abstract models and get back to working with historical data, now that new technologies make it more possible to crunch the numbers on vast troves of data like old tax records. He also is very interested in getting economists to work cross functionally with other social scientists,which he thinks has been neglected. It all reads like someone who has a vision for how his profession should be moving forward, but who is otherwise going where the data leads him, rather than someone who starts from a partisan political mindset.
Interestingly in you initial post you made no mention of the very real conflict over his work (since it has been rather newsworthy). Even I heard of it a few days ago.
 
Interestingly in you initial post you made no mention of the very real conflict over his work (since it has been rather newsworthy). Even I heard of it a few days ago.
I had no insights to offer about that, yet, since I haven't reached the part of the book pulling from the controversial data sources.
 
Is his raw unadulterated dataset online. Are his calculations too? I heard he used Excel.

edit: Of course academics can and have to write to standards that don't seem partisan and yet are. He speaks to you and so you hear him.
http://www.quandl.com/PIKETTY?keyword=*&page=1
http://topincomes.g-mond.parisschoolofeconomics.eu

I haven't reviewed his data myself, but I find it important to note that the criticisms of the book are based on his critics being able to dive into the data, suggesting he's being very transparent.

http://www.theguardian.com/business...dishonest-criticism-economics-book-inequality

To quote conservative think-tanker Scott Winship, a critic of Piketty's conclusions:

"It’s hard to think Piketty did something unethical when he put it up there for people like me to delve into his figures and find something that looks sketchy. Piketty has been as good or better than anyone at both making all his data available and documenting what he does generally.”

Based on comments like that even from his critics, I conclude he's been working in good faith. His conclusions and prescriptions may be right or wrong, but it sounds like pretty much everyone sees this as serious scholarship that has to be reckoned with, not just number-gaming partisanship.
 
Back
Top