New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Can a conservative explain

degsme

Council Member
Can a Conservative please explain how repeating a lie that someone else said is ethical?

I'm asking because we have had numerous conservative posters repeat Limbaugh's lie about what Fluke testified to as though it were true.

How is repeating a lie different than say knowingly selling stolen merchandise?
 
Knowingly repeating a lie is unethical. It is actually lying in and of itself. What's the lie, BTW? (I was more caught up in how appalling it is to refer to ladies so disrespectfully...).
 
Can a Conservative please explain how repeating a lie that someone else said is ethical?

Sure, I'll be happy to explain. Let's start with the lie I'm going to repeat:

"I can make a firm pledge. Under my plan, no family making less than $250,000 a year will see any form of tax increase. Not your income tax, not your payroll tax, not your capital gains taxes, not any of your taxes."

--- Barack Obama

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...ily-making-less-250000-will-see-any-form-tax/

It's certainly ethical for me to point out he lied, and his lie resulted in the implementation of various forms of tax increases on the people he promised not to raise taxes on.

Glad I could help.
 
For a definitive answer, ask the person who repeated your "anchor baby" lie in another thread as if it was true.
 
Knowingly repeating a lie is unethical. It is actually lying in and of itself. What's the lie, BTW? (I was more caught up in how appalling it is to refer to ladies so disrespectfully...).

FLuke never testified about Birthcontrol for sex, much less sex for herself.

In fact her primary testimony was about a friend of hers who had to have surgery to REMOVE an Ovary - simply becuase the surgery was covered by health insurnace and the hormone therapy that was the preferred treatment was not - because that hormone treatment was The Pill.
 
Interestingly, some of them are still calling her basically a "sl*t"....

when RUSH HIMSELF said he calling her that was wrong.

So either Rush was lying about his apology...or his fans are doing something that their Mentor says is wrong to do.

Which is it??? :)
 
For a definitive answer, ask the person who repeated your "anchor baby" lie in another thread as if it was true.

And who would that be Jen? I know it wasn't me. Perhaps it was the person who accuesed me of lying when I engaged in no such statement...
 
FLuke never testified about Birthcontrol for sex, much less sex for herself.

In fact her primary testimony was about a friend of hers who had to have surgery to REMOVE an Ovary - simply becuase the surgery was covered by health insurnace and the hormone therapy that was the preferred treatment was not - because that hormone treatment was The Pill.

Did anyone ever check that for accuracy? My understanding is that contraceptives to treat medical conditions are allowed.
 
Interestingly, some of them are still calling her basically a "sl*t"....

when RUSH HIMSELF said he calling her that was wrong.

No that's not what Limbaugh said. Limbaugh said his choice of words was unfortunate. Which means he stands by his claim of what Fluke had testified to. And THAT is the lie.
 
Did anyone ever check that for accuracy? My understanding is that contraceptives to treat medical conditions are allowed.

The are ALLOWEd but often not covered because its one of the meds listed as "not covered".
 
It's not ethical...it's just as unethical, in my opinion, as making excuses for another's lie or failure to keep a promise in order to justify continued support of that person.
 
It's not ethical...it's just as unethical, in my opinion, as making excuses for another's lie or failure to keep a promise in order to justify continued support of that person.

So those who support Limbaugh's right to keep lying about what Fluke said, and who keep repeating it as equal to the non-lies about Palin are... ethically challenged?
 
And who would that be Jen? I know it wasn't me. Perhaps it was the person who accuesed me of lying when I engaged in no such statement...

Posted by you (and everyone knows that a question can be asked such that others take it as "truth" - as did politicy. And with his/her answer, your lie is launched.

So he was an anchor baby?

Posted by politicynicnh

Lol! No just getting to reach her... My interest is purely political. Saving Cons from eternal damnation in a Newt Gingrich history class! Plus if you didn't ask- I would have never learned about 'anchor baby'! Quite interesting.

So you see, you have the answer to your question at your fingertips. Just ask politicynicnh. You can thank me later. Glad I could help.
 
Can a Conservative please explain how repeating a lie that someone else said is ethical?

I'm asking because we have had numerous conservative posters repeat Limbaugh's lie about what Fluke testified to as though it were true.

How is repeating a lie different than say knowingly selling stolen merchandise?

From my little experiment below, I expect the better part of the conservatives here can't explain. I expect they can't read. I expect the few who can actually read, don't care to because they may find out something they don't like, which would lead to them having to explain...a little knowledge IS a dangerous thing, don't you know.

So, do you reckon I get points for starting and ending a post? Can a person just wrack up points asking themselves a question and answering it? Hmm...that may be an easier, less stressful way to make money in this place...
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by degsme
And who would that be Jen? I know it wasn't me. Perhaps it was the person who accuesed me of lying when I engaged in no such statement...
Posted by you (and everyone knows that a question can be asked such that others take it as "truth" - as did politicy. And with his/her answer, your lie is launched.

So if everyone knows a "question is taken as the truth"... why then have you used that technique yourself and claimed NOT to be calling people names?

Why then have you claimed to be abiding by the rules?

I asked a legitimate question - after all how would someone need to be applying for BOTH US and Israeli dual citizenship if their parents weren't non-citizens in some manner.

And PolitiCynicNY's response was simply about the Anchor Baby concept itself.....


See that's the issue here Jen.. You are so quick to accept the echo-chamber claims and dish them out - yet you seem completely unwilling to tolerate it when the same is dished at you.
 
From my little experiment below, I expect the better part of the conservatives here can't explain. I expect they can't read. I expect the few who can actually read, don't care to because they may find out something they don't like, which would lead to them having to explain...a little knowledge IS a dangerous thing, don't you know.

So, do you reckon I get points for starting and ending a post? Can a person just wrack up points asking themselves a question and answering it? Hmm...that may be an easier, less stressful way to make money in this place...

Well lukey seems to think that's the way to do it- he keeps asking if Obama is a commie and then answering it with his one nonsense.
 
While you, as you have stated numerous times, see it as different...I don't. I don't check my ethics at the door to only go back and pick them up if I agree politically with the speaker. I have already said degs, I find Limbaugh and Bill Maher to be equally disgusting and vile...but obviously, some on here are okay with disgusting and vile, not to mention unethical, as long as they can justify those actions and comments by pretending there's a difference because of the person being attacked.
 
Back
Top