New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Case Dismissed

Zam-Zam

Senator
Breaking...

Judge dismisses Trump documents case

(NewsNation) — Judge Aileen Cannon has dismissed the classified documents case against former President Donald Trump.

Cannon dismissed the case on the grounds that the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Appointments Clause of the Constitution.

The case was one of four against the former president. Trump was found guilty of 34 felonies in a business fraud case in New York and the two election cases against him, one in federal court and one in Georgia, remain in legal limbo.



Complete text: Trump documents case dismissed by judge (newsnationnow.com)



Swing and a miss.
 
Breaking...

Judge dismisses Trump documents case

(NewsNation) — Judge Aileen Cannon has dismissed the classified documents case against former President Donald Trump.

Cannon dismissed the case on the grounds that the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Appointments Clause of the Constitution.

The case was one of four against the former president. Trump was found guilty of 34 felonies in a business fraud case in New York and the two election cases against him, one in federal court and one in Georgia, remain in legal limbo.



Complete text: Trump documents case dismissed by judge (newsnationnow.com)



Swing and a miss.
She has overturned previous court rulings...Read Article II, section 2, clause 2.
"Congress may vest the appointment of inferior officers in the president alone".

That clause does not specifically mention special counsul.

In Edmond v. United States (1997) the Court stated that "‘inferior Officers' are officers whose work is directed and supervised at some level by others who were appointed by Presidential nomination with the advice and consent of the Senate."

Appointments Clause - Wikipedia
 
Breaking...

Judge dismisses Trump documents case

(NewsNation) — Judge Aileen Cannon has dismissed the classified documents case against former President Donald Trump.

Cannon dismissed the case on the grounds that the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Appointments Clause of the Constitution.

The case was one of four against the former president. Trump was found guilty of 34 felonies in a business fraud case in New York and the two election cases against him, one in federal court and one in Georgia, remain in legal limbo.



Complete text: Trump documents case dismissed by judge (newsnationnow.com)



Swing and a miss.

What a disgusting ruling by an obviously politically motivated hack Judge. This coming right on the heels of the unprecedented immunity ruling by obviously corrupt SCOTUS. Criminality by public officials is not only being normalized but encouraged by the highest court in the land. First the Alito opinion on cheating and gerrymandering in South Carolina, followed by making corrupt kickbacks legal in Indiana then Trumpy immunity for the insurrection. Just a big FVCK YOU right in the faces of the American Justice system which has served us well for 250 years. We are definitely in trouble. Heading towards a kleptocracy like Hungary, Russia and North Korea where corrupt dictators reign supreme. We are about to join these murderous mafia states…..Pretty sad indeed and those who are cheering these radical rulings are either delusional or evil.
 
What a disgusting ruling by an obviously politically motivated hack Judge. This coming right on the heels of the unprecedented immunity ruling by obviously corrupt SCOTUS. Criminality by public officials is not only being normalized but encouraged by the highest court in the land. First the Alito opinion on cheating and gerrymandering in South Carolina, followed by making corrupt kickbacks legal in Indiana then Trumpy immunity for the insurrection. Just a big FVCK YOU right in the faces of the American Justice system which has served us well for 250 years. We are definitely in trouble. Heading towards a kleptocracy like Hungary, Russia and North Korea where corrupt dictators reign supreme. We are about to join these murderous mafia states…..Pretty sad indeed and those who are cheering these radical rulings are either delusional or evil.

Some will say any ruling in favor of Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Some will say any ruling against Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Each side often contends that the other side is corrupt, outrageous, and dangerous to America. They also think themselves to be just, patriotic, and ever virtuous.

It never occurs to them how very similar they are to the other...The hate gets in the way.

And hate is not a just, patriotic, or of any virtue.

So, maybe, take a deep breath and tone down the rhetoric a tad.
 
What a disgusting ruling by an obviously politically motivated hack Judge. This coming right on the heels of the unprecedented immunity ruling by obviously corrupt SCOTUS. Criminality by public officials is not only being normalized but encouraged by the highest court in the land. First the Alito opinion on cheating and gerrymandering in South Carolina, followed by making corrupt kickbacks legal in Indiana then Trumpy immunity for the insurrection. Just a big FVCK YOU right in the faces of the American Justice system which has served us well for 250 years. We are definitely in trouble. Heading towards a kleptocracy like Hungary, Russia and North Korea where corrupt dictators reign supreme. We are about to join these murderous mafia states…..Pretty sad indeed and those who are cheering these radical rulings are either delusional or evil.
Have you already read the 93 pages with the Judge’s ruling?
 
Some will say any ruling in favor of Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Some will say any ruling against Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Each side often contends that the other side is corrupt, outrageous, and dangerous to America. They also think themselves to be just, patriotic, and ever virtuous.

It never occurs to them how very similar they are to the other...The hate gets in the way.

And hate is not a just, patriotic, or of any virtue.

So, maybe, take a deep breath and tone down the rhetoric a tad.
Well said
 
L
Some will say any ruling in favor of Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Some will say any ruling against Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Each side often contends that the other side is corrupt, outrageous, and dangerous to America. They also think themselves to be just, patriotic, and ever virtuous.

It never occurs to them how very similar they are to the other...The hate gets in the way.

And hate is not a just, patriotic, or of any virtue.

So, maybe, take a deep breath and tone down the rhetoric a tad.

It‘s not about hate, it’s about truth and Justice. Those rulings that I have cited are obviously corrupt, unjust and just dead wrong. Not to mention totally outrageous.
 
Did anyone honestly think this wasn't going to happen, seriously the double standard in our legal system is horrific. This right wing messiah will keep on sliding by won't he and his avid loving supporters will keep cheering the rule of law being broken for him. If he wins and turns the US into Hungary I hope you cultists will finally be happy when your kids and grandkids get jailed for speaking their mind against him ! whoot whoot

So say you cultists get yourself in trouble like this, you think you will get the SAME teatement, what a hoot !

We LUV U Sir ( you always know when he is lying when he says sir )
 
Have you already read the 93 pages with the Judge’s ruling?

Not yet but just like the Trump immunity ruling, it is about taking an idiotic petition written by Trumps lawyers, rubber stamping it and making it the law of the land. Both of these petitions have been shot down by previous courts. In effect Trump’s $500 million “legal” team paid by political operators and donors are writing the new criminal laws of the land. If you got enough money, you can buy your way out of anything and even buy the Presidency.
 
L


It‘s not about hate, it’s about truth and Justice. Those rulings that I have cited are obviously corrupt, unjust and just dead wrong. Not to mention totally outrageous.

I have not read, in its entirety, the court's ruling.

And I do not possess a law degree.

That being the case, I can hardly render an informed educated opinion on the legality or validity of the dismissal. And I would be wary of any kneejerk opinion based on politics.

That seems to be the best course for myself.

Others may choose a different path.


It's all good.
 
Not yet but just like the Trump immunity ruling, it is about taking an idiotic petition written by Trumps lawyers, rubber stamping it and making it the law of the land. Both of these petitions have been shot down by previous courts. In effect Trump’s $500 million “legal” team paid by political operators and donors are writing the new criminal laws of the land. If you got enough money, you can buy your way out of anything and even buy the Presidency.
Actually the ruling in this matter is fairly cut and dry. Jack Smith was never approved by the Senate. Which is part of the ruling by this Judge.
 
Actually the ruling in this matter is fairly cut and dry. Jack Smith was never approved by the Senate. Which is part of the ruling by this Judge.
"Inferior officers" do not require Senate confirmation.
Cannon has ruled contrary to previous court rulings...including the WhiteWater special counsel. She is about to be overruled....again.

In Edmond v. United States (1997) the Court stated that "‘inferior Officers' are officers whose work is directed and supervised at some level by others who were appointed by Presidential nomination with the advice and consent of the Senate."

Appointments Clause - Wikipedia
 
Breaking...

Judge dismisses Trump documents case

(NewsNation) — Judge Aileen Cannon has dismissed the classified documents case against former President Donald Trump.

Cannon dismissed the case on the grounds that the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Appointments Clause of the Constitution.

The case was one of four against the former president. Trump was found guilty of 34 felonies in a business fraud case in New York and the two election cases against him, one in federal court and one in Georgia, remain in legal limbo.



Complete text: Trump documents case dismissed by judge (newsnationnow.com)



Swing and a miss.

Trump is still accused and has not been found innocent...instead she threw a roadblock into either clearing his name or proving him guilty.
 
Actually the ruling in this matter is fairly cut and dry. Jack Smith was never approved by the Senate. Which is part of the ruling by this Judge.

Again, I have no law degree and make no claims of expertise...I did read this, however:

The Supreme Court of the United States capped off a blockbuster run of opinions by ultimately handing Donald Trump a win in his Jan. 6 prosecution, dragging out proceedings by forcing the Washington, D.C., trial court to analyze which alleged acts in his indictment were “official” and which were “unofficial,” only the latter of which would afford him “no immunity” from prosecution. Still, legal experts believe the ruling all but guarantees there will be no trial before the 2024 election, throwing a major wrench into special counsel Jack Smith’s case and clouding it with uncertainty.

In a concurrence, which no other justice joined, Justice Clarence Thomas went a step further by strongly suggesting it his view that Jack Smith was unlawfully appointed as special counsel, giving Trump legal ammunition in undoing his Mar-a-Lago prosecution, where U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon recently permitted pro-Trump amici curiae (Latin for friends of the court) to argue some of the very points Thomas made on Monday...

...For Thomas, the attempted prosecution of Trump for official acts “threaten our constitutional order,” but also of concern was the appointment of “private citizen” Smith to embark on that mission.

“If there is no law establishing the office that the Special Counsel occupies, then he cannot proceed with this prosecution. A private citizen cannot criminally prosecute anyone, let alone a former President,” Thomas wrote of the Jan. 6 case, before urging the “lower courts” to answer whether non-Senate-approved Smith was lawfully appointed at all.

“No former President has faced criminal prosecution for his acts while in office in the more than 200 years since the founding of our country. And, that is so despite numerous past Presidents taking actions that many would argue constitute crimes,” Thomas said. “If this unprecedented prosecution is to proceed, it must be conducted by someone duly authorized to do so by the American people. The lower courts should thus answer these essential questions concerning the Special Counsel’s appointment before proceeding.”...

...In other words, in Thomas’ view, Jack Smith’s appointment could very well crumble whether he is an “inferior” or a “principal” officer under the Constitution.


Complete text: Clarence Thomas thinks Jack Smith was unlawfully appointed (lawandcrime.com)



FWIW.
 
Some will say any ruling in favor of Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Some will say any ruling against Mr. Trump is politically motivated.

Each side often contends that the other side is corrupt, outrageous, and dangerous to America. They also think themselves to be just, patriotic, and ever virtuous.

It never occurs to them how very similar they are to the other...The hate gets in the way.

And hate is not a just, patriotic, or of any virtue.

So, maybe, take a deep breath and tone down the rhetoric a tad.
Bingo!
 
Again, I have no law degree and make no claims of expertise...I did read this, however:

The Supreme Court of the United States capped off a blockbuster run of opinions by ultimately handing Donald Trump a win in his Jan. 6 prosecution, dragging out proceedings by forcing the Washington, D.C., trial court to analyze which alleged acts in his indictment were “official” and which were “unofficial,” only the latter of which would afford him “no immunity” from prosecution. Still, legal experts believe the ruling all but guarantees there will be no trial before the 2024 election, throwing a major wrench into special counsel Jack Smith’s case and clouding it with uncertainty.

In a concurrence, which no other justice joined, Justice Clarence Thomas went a step further by strongly suggesting it his view that Jack Smith was unlawfully appointed as special counsel, giving Trump legal ammunition in undoing his Mar-a-Lago prosecution, where U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon recently permitted pro-Trump amici curiae (Latin for friends of the court) to argue some of the very points Thomas made on Monday...

...For Thomas, the attempted prosecution of Trump for official acts “threaten our constitutional order,” but also of concern was the appointment of “private citizen” Smith to embark on that mission.

“If there is no law establishing the office that the Special Counsel occupies, then he cannot proceed with this prosecution. A private citizen cannot criminally prosecute anyone, let alone a former President,” Thomas wrote of the Jan. 6 case, before urging the “lower courts” to answer whether non-Senate-approved Smith was lawfully appointed at all.

“No former President has faced criminal prosecution for his acts while in office in the more than 200 years since the founding of our country. And, that is so despite numerous past Presidents taking actions that many would argue constitute crimes,” Thomas said. “If this unprecedented prosecution is to proceed, it must be conducted by someone duly authorized to do so by the American people. The lower courts should thus answer these essential questions concerning the Special Counsel’s appointment before proceeding.”...

...In other words, in Thomas’ view, Jack Smith’s appointment could very well crumble whether he is an “inferior” or a “principal” officer under the Constitution.


Complete text: Clarence Thomas thinks Jack Smith was unlawfully appointed (lawandcrime.com)



FWIW.

In Edmond v. United States (1997) the Court stated that "‘inferior Officers' are officers whose work is directed and supervised at some level by others who were appointed by Presidential nomination with the advice and consent of the Senate."

Appointments Clause - Wikipedia


Cannon ruled contrary to the rulings in other courts...she is out on a limb here...
The Supreme court ruling on official vs unofficial is bizarre...just a way to delay the case. Nothing about January 6 was about an official act. It was about the act of a candidate for office who, upon losing, called a mob to make him the winner.

In fact Barrett stated that Trump's involvement in getting the fake electors to send in fraudulent documents was not an official act.
 
Back
Top