New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Censorship

Arkady

President
I don't know if it's auto-censorship by keyword or something moderators are doing, but substantive political points are being edited out of posts here -- they're being characterized as "unwelcome language." I'm talking about words that aren't vulgar, and which are not being used in ways that insult fellow posters. In particular, a post of mine attacking a political figure's intellect was subject to censorship. That kind of thing renders this a poor forum for trying to have a political discussion.
 
I don't know if it's auto-censorship by keyword or something moderators are doing, but substantive political points are being edited out of posts here -- they're being characterized as "unwelcome language." I'm talking about words that aren't vulgar, and which are not being used in ways that insult fellow posters. In particular, a post of mine attacking a political figure's intellect was subject to censorship. That kind of thing renders this a poor forum for trying to have a political discussion.

Agreed.

I-d-i-o-t (idiot)has been tossed out, removed from the board as a word. That's too far. Others have commented on this overly sensitive matter.
 
I don't know if it's auto-censorship by keyword or something moderators are doing, but substantive political points are being edited out of posts here -- they're being characterized as "unwelcome language." I'm talking about words that aren't vulgar, and which are not being used in ways that insult fellow posters. In particular, a post of mine attacking a political figure's intellect was subject to censorship. That kind of thing renders this a poor forum for trying to have a political discussion.

So calling an elected official an i-diot is ok and adds to the political discussion?

What word in particular would you like to see uncensored?

It is an ongoing process to pick and choose words we don't want to see.
 
So calling an elected official an i-diot is ok and adds to the political discussion?

What word in particular would you like to see uncensored?

It is an ongoing process to pick and choose words we don't want to see.
Yes, I think calling an idiotic public figure an idiot adds to the political discussion.

Just as importantly, I think that censoring the word is pointless. I can say the guy has the reasoning abilities of a slime mold. I can say he is deeply mentally deficient. I can say he's ferociously illiterate. I can say it's a shock he can even figure out how to tie his own shoes in the morning. I can say he'd have to be spotted 20 IQ points just to come up to average. I can call him a gibbering coxcomb and an addle-pated Dummkopf. I can call him a harebrain and a dullard and even an "i-diot". But if I call him an idiot, it gets censored. What does that accomplish?

I don't want to see any word censored. But, if the management is made so uncomfortable by words that they disagree, that's their call to make, and I suppose I have plenty of forums to choose from that aren't strait-jacketed by the language police.
 
So calling an elected official an i-diot is ok and adds to the political discussion?

What word in particular would you like to see uncensored?

It is an ongoing process to pick and choose words we don't want to see.


All of them.

The headline cleanup is fine. Leave the body alone.

If someone is offended by language, let them report the offense.
 
Yes, I think calling an idiotic public figure an [Unwelcome language removed] adds to the political discussion.

Just as importantly, I think that censoring the word is pointless. I can say the guy has the reasoning abilities of a slime mold. I can say he is deeply mentally deficient. I can say he's ferociously illiterate. I can say it's a shock he can even figure out how to tie his own shoes in the morning. I can say he'd have to be spotted 20 IQ points just to come up to average. I can call him a gibbering coxcomb and an addle-pated Dummkopf. I can call him a harebrain and a dullard and even an "i-diot". But if I call him an [Unwelcome language removed], it gets censored. What does that accomplish?

I don't want to see any word censored. But, if the management is made so uncomfortable by words that they disagree, that's their call to make, and I suppose I have plenty of forums to choose from that aren't strait-jacketed by the language police.

Or you could say he was a blockhead or a nincompoop or a cad too if you wished - but never call an i'diot an id'iot by gad!
 
So calling an elected official an i-diot is ok and adds to the political discussion?

What word in particular would you like to see uncensored?

It is an ongoing process to pick and choose words we don't want to see.

Who put you up to this SW? You were so cool to begin with.

What has happened? You've even zapped my play mate - you are getting mean :(
 
Yes, I think calling an idiotic public figure an [Unwelcome language removed] adds to the political discussion.

Just as importantly, I think that censoring the word is pointless. I can say the guy has the reasoning abilities of a slime mold. I can say he is deeply mentally deficient. I can say he's ferociously illiterate. I can say it's a shock he can even figure out how to tie his own shoes in the morning. I can say he'd have to be spotted 20 IQ points just to come up to average. I can call him a gibbering coxcomb and an addle-pated Dummkopf. I can call him a harebrain and a dullard and even an "i-diot". But if I call him an [Unwelcome language removed], it gets censored. What does that accomplish?

I don't want to see any word censored. But, if the management is made so uncomfortable by words that they disagree, that's their call to make, and I suppose I have plenty of forums to choose from that aren't strait-jacketed by the language police.

Not sure what kind of lawyer you are, Ark.. but have to wonder if you use foul, name calling language in your court briefs or when defending cases in court, I am just curious> :)
 
i've noticed the same thing. "idiot" was edited out of my top post last week. go figure. (the edited word is i-d-i-o-t)

at one point (under the old regime) i was banned for a week for using the term "oreo". i guess that's no longer forbidden, lol
 
Not sure what kind of lawyer you are, Ark.. but have to wonder if you use foul, name calling language in your court briefs or when defending cases in court, I am just curious> :)
What would make you think I might? Obviously, I write differently for legal purposes. You'll notice I never use proper Bluebook citation here, either.
 
What would make you think I might? Obviously, I write differently for legal purposes. You'll notice I never use proper Bluebook citation here, either.
I wanted to thank you for helping me finish fleshing out the argument in favor of the 2nd Amendment. I got the major mind blocks between the two sides and feel confident that in other venues gun grabbers are going to be midly shocked at the idea that American citizens have a right to form militias and that it is the militias that are well regulated. It goes contrary to the feel they've had for the 2nd Amendment that has been allowed to flourish. Anyways, thanks.
 
Agreed.

I-d-i-o-t ([Unwelcome language removed])has been tossed out, removed from the board as a word. That's too far. Others have commented on this overly sensitive matter.

It's not overly sensitive...it's just the same 12 Democrats and 8 Republicans. I would say that when you listen ot the wingers here tell you that if yu ivest 1 million dollars to start a business it's unearned income...or if you invest in a corporation that already exists so the corporation can grow and that new jobs are created...that unearned income...so it is simpler to use the shorter version of unwelcome language removed...but it makes a good point which is that you can use your brain and come up with better languaging to say what you need to say.
 
So calling an elected official an i-diot is ok and adds to the political discussion?

What word in particular would you like to see uncensored?

It is an ongoing process to pick and choose words we don't want to see.
But "liar" and "coward"....righty favorites and obviously inflammatory to the point of qualifying as actual fighting words, let alone "flame-baiting", are no problem.

Censoring adult conversations doesn't work. That's why we have an ignore button. I use mine on flamers and baiters with nothing else to offer....because you don't censor them or give them warnings or infractions as they use inflammatory language with impunity. You're more focused on "idiots" and "poopy head".

It's subjective. No one is a perfect judge when it comes to rewriting the First Amendment to conform to their own sensibilities just because they can.
 
OK...now that seems a pretty reasonable list of mostly provocative but otherwise useless insult.

P-ug and d-im are good words that can be used as light insults, but serve more as shorthand than any painful cut.
P-ug is out, but "liberals" lives on because it is almost always used in the plural.
 
Back
Top