New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Changing history

Boltlady

Governor
Recently across came a good example of how it's done.

Since Israel is trying frantically to retain it's 'victim' status, there will, once again, be more stories about Anne Frank. In the following article, it is said that the Germans murdered her. Excerpt: "In 2015, it will have been 70 years since the Nazis murdered Anne Frank, and the anniversary coincides with renewed interest in the Jewish girl and her famed diary chronicling a life in hiding."

Rival Anne Frank Projects Spark War of Words in Europe


Well, they didn't murder her. Like so many of the prisoners, she did of typhus. Excerpt: " During World War II typhus struck the German army as it invaded Russia in 1941.[6] In 1942 and 1943 typhus hit French North Africa, Egypt and Iran particularly hard.[15] Typhus epidemics killed inmates in the Nazi Germany concentration camps; infamous pictures of typhus victims' mass graves can be seen in footage shot at Bergen-Belsen concentration camp.[6] Thousands of prisoners held in appalling conditions in Nazi concentration camps such Theresienstadt and Bergen-Belsen also died of typhus during World War II,[6] including Anne Frank at the age of 15 and her sister Margot. Even larger epidemics in the post-war chaos of Europe were only averted by the widespread use of the newly discovered DDT to kill the lice on millions of refugees and displaced persons."

Epidemic typhus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


While I don't know how the movie, the mini series, etc. will tell the story, just think of how many people reading the article will believe that the "Germans murdered her". Do you suppose that it will be mentioned that her father Otto was working for the Germans, or that her 'diary' was rewritten several times by ghost writers because the original was only a few pages and they needed to do a lot of filling in? The last version was written with a ball point pen that hadn't even been invented yet at the time.

That's the way 'history' is often done. A few pieces of actual information are tweaked, added to and embellished until it suits the writers.
 
That's the way 'history' is often done. A few pieces of actual information are tweaked, added to and embellished until it suits the writers.


Or, until it suits the preexisting bias of the readers. You should be an expert regarding revisionist histories. Seems that is the only history of which you are aware.
 
Or, until it suits the preexisting bias of the readers. You should be an expert regarding revisionist histories. Seems that is the only history of which you are aware.

Oh, I think my example is pretty clear as to how the 'facts' get conveniently changed.
 
one only needs to read "the southern strategy theory" to understand how far the revisionists are willing to go....
 
Recently across came a good example of how it's done.

Since Israel is trying frantically to retain it's 'victim' status, there will, once again, be more stories about Anne Frank. In the following article, it is said that the Germans murdered her. Excerpt: "In 2015, it will have been 70 years since the Nazis murdered Anne Frank, and the anniversary coincides with renewed interest in the Jewish girl and her famed diary chronicling a life in hiding."

Rival Anne Frank Projects Spark War of Words in Europe


Well, they didn't murder her. Like so many of the prisoners, she did of typhus. Excerpt: " During World War II typhus struck the German army as it invaded Russia in 1941.[6] In 1942 and 1943 typhus hit French North Africa, Egypt and Iran particularly hard.[15] Typhus epidemics killed inmates in the Nazi Germany concentration camps; infamous pictures of typhus victims' mass graves can be seen in footage shot at Bergen-Belsen concentration camp.[6] Thousands of prisoners held in appalling conditions in Nazi concentration camps such Theresienstadt and Bergen-Belsen also died of typhus during World War II,[6] including Anne Frank at the age of 15 and her sister Margot. Even larger epidemics in the post-war chaos of Europe were only averted by the widespread use of the newly discovered DDT to kill the lice on millions of refugees and displaced persons."

Epidemic typhus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


While I don't know how the movie, the mini series, etc. will tell the story, just think of how many people reading the article will believe that the "Germans murdered her". Do you suppose that it will be mentioned that her father Otto was working for the Germans, or that her 'diary' was rewritten several times by ghost writers because the original was only a few pages and they needed to do a lot of filling in? The last version was written with a ball point pen that hadn't even been invented yet at the time.

That's the way 'history' is often done. A few pieces of actual information are tweaked, added to and embellished until it suits the writers.


Well, the question for me is - would she have lived - if she had not been taken an placed in a camp? would those people have lived - had they not been in camps. If the German's created a situation where disease, lack of food, pestilence and other health risks put people lives at risk, then in my opinion they murdered them - surely as if they held a gun to their heads.

Now, I do believe the diary - having read it a few times myself - was heavily filled in and much ghost writing occurred. However, even quite frankly, if the Germans didn't really "mean" to kill them - there is absolutely simply NO reason to have rounded people up, to have destroyed lives, and stolen personal items like they have been proven to have done. The idea that you rat on your neighbor, that you turn your neighbors in - that they created and exploited this environment ( and they are not alone with that - unfortunately the US has as disgraceful a history in the rounding up and "exterminating" people as the German's do.) disgusts me. I have friends whose German grandparents talked about that time, and my own Polish relatives have their own horror stories of the German occupation. I believe in the horridness of the Nazis.

HOWEVER - I have never and will never understand why we felt like - because they were so mistreted in Germany - we ( meaning the West) had to help them re-establish themselves in their Native country. The Arabs had by and large kicked them out and made them a whipping boy thousands of years ago. They have no more claim to their former homeland, than the Aboringinees do to all the lands they occupied in Australia, nor do the Native Americans do to all the land we stole from them. They were on the loosing end of the sword, and it is what it is. It is not our obligation because they were mistreated to continue to write some wrong. But, then I feel like that about racisim in this country, too. Its history- its over... find a new place to settle and move the freak on. I am tired of hearing about how bad you had it - how awful it was for your ancestors. It was for many of mine, too..... particularly the Native American ones... but life's a bitch... and then you die. No one owes you a damn thing in the interim.
 
Well, the question for me is - would she have lived - if she had not been taken an placed in a camp? would those people have lived - had they not been in camps. If the German's created a situation where disease, lack of food, pestilence and other health risks put people lives at risk, then in my opinion they murdered them - surely as if they held a gun to their heads.
Now, I do believe the diary - having read it a few times myself - was heavily filled in and much ghost writing occurred. However, even quite frankly, if the Germans didn't really "mean" to kill them - there is absolutely simply NO reason to have rounded people up, to have destroyed lives, and stolen personal items like they have been proven to have done. The idea that you rat on your neighbor, that you turn your neighbors in - that they created and exploited this environment ( and they are not alone with that - unfortunately the US has as disgraceful a history in the rounding up and "exterminating" people as the German's do.) disgusts me. I have friends whose German grandparents talked about that time, and my own Polish relatives have their own horror stories of the German occupation. I believe in the horridness of the Nazis.
HOWEVER - I have never and will never understand why we felt like - because they were so mistreted in Germany - we ( meaning the West) had to help them re-establish themselves in their Native country. The Arabs had by and large kicked them out and made them a whipping boy thousands of years ago. They have no more claim to their former homeland, than the Aboringinees do to all the lands they occupied in Australia, nor do the Native Americans do to all the land we stole from them. They were on the loosing end of the sword, and it is what it is. It is not our obligation because they were mistreated to continue to write some wrong. But, then I feel like that about racisim in this country, too. Its history- its over... find a new place to settle and move the freak on. I am tired of hearing about how bad you had it - how awful it was for your ancestors. It was for many of mine, too..... particularly the Native American ones... but life's a bitch... and then you die. No one owes you a damn thing in the interim.

This is a classic example of the appalling education our citizens receive in school. I cringed all the while I was reading this woman's post. Who can we blame for this plague of ignorance that has descended on the American people?

Anna Frank and her sister would never have ended up in a German work camp if Otto Frank had not defrauded the German Army by shorting the supplies of pectin he had promised them, according to contract. In fact, he had been getting away with his fraud for a couple of years before the Germans finally caught on to what he was doing. Otto Frank had been a thief all his life, and continued to defraud people until the day he died. His final, and ultimate, fraud was the 'Diaries'. He made millions out of the book, taking in naive, but well-meaning, people like connieb.
 
Last edited:
Or, until it suits the preexisting bias of the readers. You should be an expert regarding revisionist histories. Seems that is the only history of which you are aware.

Here is another example of the appalling ignorance I was talking about in my previous post. Sometimes I am convinced that we need 're-education camps' here in America, horrble as that sounds. Brings back memories of the 're-education camps' of the North Viet-Namese, doesn't it? But how in hell can we develop an advanced civilization with an ignorant populace, who don't know the most basic of things, and cannot critically think, even in their middle age? Those 're-education camps' may not be so far-fetched.
 
This is a classic example of the appalling education our citizens receive in school. I cringed all the while I was reading this woman's post. Who can we blame for this plague of ignorance that has descended on the American people?

Anna Frank and her sister would never have ended up in a German work camp if Otto Frank had not defrauded the German Army by shorting the supplies of pectin he had promised them, according to contract. In fact, he had been getting away with his fraud for a couple of years before the Germans finally caught on to what he was doing. Otto Frank had been a thief all his life, and continued to defraud people until the day he died. His final, and ultimate, fraud was the 'Diaries'. He made millions out of the book, taking in naive, but well-meaning, people like connieb.

I have heard her dad defauded the government. I do not care. I didn't find the book particularly appealing or interesting - but it was assigned reading in two different grades in school.

EVEN if her father was a thief - you do not lock up an entire family. Period. The "truth" of the story - is that she was sent to a work camp and she died there. And, the Germans are entirely responsible for sending her and thousands of others there - which ultimately lead to their deaths. I know from my relatives who lived under German occupation - how disgusting and horrible and awful the treatment of non Germans was - so excuse me if I think that is the likes of you who have bought into the ingnorance that is holocaust denialism. I don't really care how many Jews or others were killed or how they were killed. I am certainly not sympathetic to the Jewish people as a whole because of it.

However, it is never ever ever acceptable to round up people for whatever purpose and put them into camps. The Germans did that. It is not disputed. I saw the camp in Dachau myself. Period. And for that and that alone - regardless of why they did it - I hope there are thousands of Nazi's burning in hell.
 
Well, the question for me is - would she have lived - if she had not been taken an placed in a camp? would those people have lived - had they not been in camps. If the German's created a situation where disease, lack of food, pestilence and other health risks put people lives at risk, then in my opinion they murdered them - surely as if they held a gun to their heads.

Now, I do believe the diary - having read it a few times myself - was heavily filled in and much ghost writing occurred. However, even quite frankly, if the Germans didn't really "mean" to kill them - there is absolutely simply NO reason to have rounded people up, to have destroyed lives, and stolen personal items like they have been proven to have done. The idea that you rat on your neighbor, that you turn your neighbors in - that they created and exploited this environment ( and they are not alone with that - unfortunately the US has as disgraceful a history in the rounding up and "exterminating" people as the German's do.) disgusts me. I have friends whose German grandparents talked about that time, and my own Polish relatives have their own horror stories of the German occupation. I believe in the horridness of the Nazis.



The Arabs had by and large kicked them out and made them a whipping boy thousands of years ago. They have no more claim to their former homeland, than the Aboringinees do to all the lands they occupied in Australia, nor do the Native Americans do to all the land we stole from them. They were on the loosing end of the sword, and it is what it is. It is not our obligation because they were mistreated to continue to write some wrong. But, then I feel like that about racisim in this country, too. Its history- its over... find a new place to settle and move the freak on. I am tired of hearing about how bad you had it - how awful it was for your ancestors. It was for many of mine, too..... particularly the Native American ones... but life's a bitch... and then you die. No one owes you a damn thing in the interim.

You write:

"""HOWEVER - I have never and will never understand why we felt like - because they were so mistreted in Germany - we ( meaning the West) had to help them re-establish themselves in their Native country."""

This is one of those instances where we should probably clarify that "we" didn't affect this one. Our parents and grandparents did. Having discussed this one with my late mother, I think I have an idea as to why THEY felt as they did. Had the western world intervened earlier, 6 million wouldn't have died. There are all manner of reasons and explanations for the west not intervening. But the fact remains that it didn't.
 
I have heard her dad defauded the government. I do not care. I didn't find the book particularly appealing or interesting - but it was assigned reading in two different grades in school.
EVEN if her father was a thief - you do not lock up an entire family. Period. The "truth" of the story - is that she was sent to a work camp and she died there. And, the Germans are entirely responsible for sending her and thousands of others there - which ultimately lead to their deaths. I know from my relatives who lived under German occupation - how disgusting and horrible and awful the treatment of non Germans was - so excuse me if I think that is the likes of you who have bought into the ingnorance that is holocaust denialism. I don't really care how many Jews or others were killed or how they were killed. I am certainly not sympathetic to the Jewish people as a whole because of it.
However, it is never ever ever acceptable to round up people for whatever purpose and put them into camps. The Germans did that. It is not disputed. I saw the camp in Dachau myself. Period. And for that and that alone - regardless of why they did it - I hope there are thousands of Nazi's burning in hell.

I have to apologize for being a little hard on you there, Connieb. War always brings on horrible conditions for some people, no question, but Jews had suffered no more than other prisoners at the camps. Jews just make more of a big deal of it, and won't let it go. It has become a lucrative scam for them, worth billions every year. The criminal State of Israel thrives on it, bleeding the German people, year after year. Bleeding us too. Russians, Poles, and Serbs suffered just as much, and lost more people than the Jews, but you don't hear them screaming holocaust. The Serbs lost 700,000 people, for example, the Poles a couple of million. The other thing Jews won't tell you is that their leadership (the Zionist leadership) had declared economic war on Germany in 1933, and the German economy suffered because of it. So, when war was declared in 1939, the Germans felt they could not trust their own Jewish citizens to be loyal, so the majority were sent to work camps, where they could be watched. We did something similar to our Japanese citizens here. Our Japanese prisoners were lucky in that no invasion of the American mainland had occurred, and we were not fighting Japanese forces on our own soil. If Japan had invaded, I doubt we would have been so kind to our Japanese prisoners, or let them off so easily. We need to get real about these things, not live in a fantasy world. This is where critical thinking comes into play.

The Jews and other prisoners were actually treated decently until the end of the war, when the Allies cut off (bombed) all the supply lines to the camps, so food and other essential supplies could not be delivered. So people at the camps began to starve and get sick from the unsanitary conditions which developed. The German army was under siege from both East and West, so could not relieve the camps, and so the camps went from bad to worse. Everybody starved, including the Germans themselves. Don't believe the propaganda the it was only Jews who were singled out, or that there was a deliberate campaign to exterminate the Jews. All lies. There were no gas chambers, period. Nobody died from gassng. And certainly no 6 million were killed. I have already explained the origin of the phantom 6 million figure, where it came from. [There are holocaust apologists on these forums, who will keep bringing the 6 million up, and will keep hammering it into your brain, so you never forget. Heaven forbid that you should uncover the truth about WW2, or wake up to the scam that has been going on for over 60 years].

Of course, when the American and Russian armies arrived to liberate the camps, they saw dead bodies piled up that had died of starvation and typhus. That was it.
The people who suffered a real holocaust were the German people, who lost millions to fire-bombing of their cities, and starvation and neglect at Eisenhower's detention camps in 1945. Approximately 2 million Germans died at those camps alone. So, stop coddling these Jews. They are making out like bandits; they own just about everything we possess--and then some.
 
You write:

"""HOWEVER - I have never and will never understand why we felt like - because they were so mistreted in Germany - we ( meaning the West) had to help them re-establish themselves in their Native country."""

This is one of those instances where we should probably clarify that "we" didn't affect this one. Our parents and grandparents did. Having discussed this one with my late mother, I think I have an idea as to why THEY felt as they did. Had the western world intervened earlier, 6 million wouldn't have died. There are all manner of reasons and explanations for the west not intervening. But the fact remains that it didn't.

And, I am not saying there shouldn't be some sort of guilt over that. And hey - you want to offer asylum or some sort of reparations in that regard, no problem. THAT would have been understandable. But, to take the stance that you will help them essentially steal back land they had by and large lost on the battlfield... was very wrong-headed. It was sort of like sticking a needle in the eye of the middle east - because the West had a lot of guilt and in reality is a large reason for much of the unrest. Not just the creating Israel, but the nation making and chopping up and reboardering that happened in conjunction with that. The Jews had been kicked out of the ME for all intents and purposes long before WWII and helping them create establish the Israel we know today was not going to bring back 6 million people. And, has maybe cost the lives of thousands if not millions, since.

Besides - millions died at the hands of the Germans. But, it wasn't just Jews. It was also anyone else the determined was an undesireable. And, I think the approach was we will make it up to the Jews - sort of left out the very real impact it had on many, many others.
 
And, I am not saying there shouldn't be some sort of guilt over that. And hey - you want to offer asylum or some sort of reparations in that regard, no problem. THAT would have been understandable. But, to take the stance that you will help them essentially steal back land they had by and large lost on the battlfield... was very wrong-headed. It was sort of like sticking a needle in the eye of the middle east - because the West had a lot of guilt and in reality is a large reason for much of the unrest. Not just the creating Israel, but the nation making and chopping up and reboardering that happened in conjunction with that. The Jews had been kicked out of the ME for all intents and purposes long before WWII and helping them create establish the Israel we know today was not going to bring back 6 million people. And, has maybe cost the lives of thousands if not millions, since.

Besides - millions died at the hands of the Germans. But, it wasn't just Jews. It was also anyone else the determined was an undesireable. And, I think the approach was we will make it up to the Jews - sort of left out the very real impact it had on many, many others.

You asked why they did what they did back then. I told you. If you don't like it, take it up with your grandparents. But...remember that your grandparents didn't have benefit of the extensive "library" of Israeli hate angles, that we do now.
 
Or, until it suits the preexisting bias of the readers. You should be an expert regarding revisionist histories. Seems that is the only history of which you are aware.

It was what Historians always did in the past- now they just copy each other lies - round and round and round and round in circles til every one is giddy and the truth is so tangled up and unrecognizable that people have forgotten what it was. Truth that is.

Whilst real Historians languish in jails - for telling or searching for that precious thing - the truth.
 
Well, the question for me is - would she have lived - if she had not been taken an placed in a camp? would those people have lived - had they not been in camps. If the German's created a situation where disease, lack of food, pestilence and other health risks put people lives at risk, then in my opinion they murdered them - surely as if they held a gun to their heads.

Now, I do believe the diary - having read it a few times myself - was heavily filled in and much ghost writing occurred. However, even quite frankly, if the Germans didn't really "mean" to kill them - there is absolutely simply NO reason to have rounded people up, to have destroyed lives, and stolen personal items like they have been proven to have done. The idea that you rat on your neighbor, that you turn your neighbors in - that they created and exploited this environment ( and they are not alone with that - unfortunately the US has as disgraceful a history in the rounding up and "exterminating" people as the German's do.) disgusts me. I have friends whose German grandparents talked about that time, and my own Polish relatives have their own horror stories of the German occupation. I believe in the horridness of the Nazis.

HOWEVER - I have never and will never understand why we felt like - because they were so mistreted in Germany - we ( meaning the West) had to help them re-establish themselves in their Native country. The Arabs had by and large kicked them out and made them a whipping boy thousands of years ago. They have no more claim to their former homeland, than the Aboringinees do to all the lands they occupied in Australia, nor do the Native Americans do to all the land we stole from them. They were on the loosing end of the sword, and it is what it is. It is not our obligation because they were mistreated to continue to write some wrong. But, then I feel like that about racisim in this country, too. Its history- its over... find a new place to settle and move the freak on. I am tired of hearing about how bad you had it - how awful it was for your ancestors. It was for many of mine, too..... particularly the Native American ones... but life's a bitch... and then you die. No one owes you a damn thing in the interim.


If France and Britain had not declared War on Germany no one would have been in Camps, if Britain had not halted the Jews leaving Germany no one would have been in Camps.



The people who call themselves Jews today are Khazars - Their 'Home Land' is no where near Israel.
 
However, it is never ever ever acceptable to round up people for whatever purpose and put them into camps. The Germans did that. It is not disputed. I saw the camp in Dachau myself. Period. And for that and that alone - regardless of why they did it - I hope there are thousands of Nazi's burning in hell.

What about the war criminals here in the States; those who are responsible for the mass murder of millions in West Asia? Why are they treated like heroes, and given cushy retirements? Why are they not languishing in prison? How about the Jews who quietly engineer the wars we get into, and hold the ultimate responsiblity for the millions of innocents murdered, so they can profit? Should these people spend time in Hell also? How about the Israelite mass murderers, who kill their Gentile neighbors with relish, using 2000-lb. cluster bombs and White Phosphorous; and using the money and arms we give them to do so. Should these bastards be spending some time in Hell? Give that some thought.

We make too much of WW2 and the Nazis. And guess who keeps us focused on that bygone era, bringing us back to it again and again? Would you call that manipulation? And if so, to what end, pray? Could it be profit---again?
 
Back
Top