Arkady
President
I'm agnostic about charter schools, since I can see strong arguments in both directions. On the one hand, educational experimentation at the school level allows for a survival-of-the-fittest approach that could select for more successful strategies, and ultimately help us evolve better educational systems. On the other hand, at any given dollar level, charter schools are typically going to have a disadvantage in having smaller economies of scale, and many will have the double disadvantage of having some of those dollars siphoned off for ownership's profits, as well as for marketing. That means fewer dollars available for actually teaching kids. Which of these will tend to be the more dominant effect is an interesting question, but the results from Sweden sure don't look great for the charter school initiative:
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings
I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:
I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings
I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:
"It’s easy to imagine teachers going easy on their own students... a study co-authored by my colleague, Jonah Rockoff, found exactly this result in an analysis of New York Regents Exam grading. In Sweden, according to the study by Hinnerich and Vlachos, the scores issued by external evaluators were indeed harsher than those assigned by internal graders. And... it turned out that the external evaluators had downgraded the scores for students at voucher schools much more than for students at government ones. In fact, a sizable portion of the much-vaunted outperformance of voucher school students could be chalked up to nothing more than easy grading. More surprising still, the voucher school grade inflation is almost as high for math and science (where you’d think an answer is either right or wrong) as it is for Swedish...."
I'm still trying to figure out what I believe when it comes to education reform. I used to be a huge proponent of high-stakes testing (driven, most likely, in part by the fact I do well on standardized tests). But now I've seen evidence that some high-performing systems (like Finland) don't go that way, so it no longer seems critical.
I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.