New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Charter Schools

Arkady

President
I'm agnostic about charter schools, since I can see strong arguments in both directions. On the one hand, educational experimentation at the school level allows for a survival-of-the-fittest approach that could select for more successful strategies, and ultimately help us evolve better educational systems. On the other hand, at any given dollar level, charter schools are typically going to have a disadvantage in having smaller economies of scale, and many will have the double disadvantage of having some of those dollars siphoned off for ownership's profits, as well as for marketing. That means fewer dollars available for actually teaching kids. Which of these will tend to be the more dominant effect is an interesting question, but the results from Sweden sure don't look great for the charter school initiative:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings

I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:

"It’s easy to imagine teachers going easy on their own students... a study co-authored by my colleague, Jonah Rockoff, found exactly this result in an analysis of New York Regents Exam grading. In Sweden, according to the study by Hinnerich and Vlachos, the scores issued by external evaluators were indeed harsher than those assigned by internal graders. And... it turned out that the external evaluators had downgraded the scores for students at voucher schools much more than for students at government ones. In fact, a sizable portion of the much-vaunted outperformance of voucher school students could be chalked up to nothing more than easy grading. More surprising still, the voucher school grade inflation is almost as high for math and science (where you’d think an answer is either right or wrong) as it is for Swedish...."
​
I'm still trying to figure out what I believe when it comes to education reform. I used to be a huge proponent of high-stakes testing (driven, most likely, in part by the fact I do well on standardized tests). But now I've seen evidence that some high-performing systems (like Finland) don't go that way, so it no longer seems critical.

I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.
 
I'm agnostic about charter schools, since I can see strong arguments in both directions. On the one hand, educational experimentation at the school level allows for a survival-of-the-fittest approach that could select for more successful strategies, and ultimately help us evolve better educational systems. On the other hand, at any given dollar level, charter schools are typically going to have a disadvantage in having smaller economies of scale, and many will have the double disadvantage of having some of those dollars siphoned off for ownership's profits, as well as for marketing. That means fewer dollars available for actually teaching kids. Which of these will tend to be the more dominant effect is an interesting question, but the results from Sweden sure don't look great for the charter school initiative:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings

I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:

"It’s easy to imagine teachers going easy on their own students... a study co-authored by my colleague, Jonah Rockoff, found exactly this result in an analysis of New York Regents Exam grading. In Sweden, according to the study by Hinnerich and Vlachos, the scores issued by external evaluators were indeed harsher than those assigned by internal graders. And... it turned out that the external evaluators had downgraded the scores for students at voucher schools much more than for students at government ones. In fact, a sizable portion of the much-vaunted outperformance of voucher school students could be chalked up to nothing more than easy grading. More surprising still, the voucher school grade inflation is almost as high for math and science (where you’d think an answer is either right or wrong) as it is for Swedish...."
​
I'm still trying to figure out what I believe when it comes to education reform. I used to be a huge proponent of high-stakes testing (driven, most likely, in part by the fact I do well on standardized tests). But now I've seen evidence that some high-performing systems (like Finland) don't go that way, so it no longer seems critical.

I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.

The number one determining factor of a child's success is their parents economic wealth and educational attainment.

That being said, charters schools, to the evidence I have read, perform worse then public schools in every metric. It seems to me charter schools are just a way to undermine any type of publically subsidized benefit.

In any case, I admire you reven handed approach. But until the aforementioned factors are settled no matter what type of school wont make much of a difference.
 
I don't like charter schools much. I live in an area with a very large school district and many charter schools. I haven't seen any statistics for our school district for several years but the ones I did tended to show that charter schools under performed against the standard public schools. The schools tended to do much better or much worse than the average for public schools. I think (my opinion only) that the results are due to the fact that most charter schools have less oversight. Motivated administrators use that to the advantage of the students and less-motivated administrators hide behind it.

And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.

You can't really control parental involvement. In Freakonomics, it was shown that the goodness or badness of a school had less of an impact than did family. If I remember correctly, whether it is genetics, family support, or both; can't really be distinguished in the stats.

I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. .

You aren't the typical student. My limited experience is that rote homework helps some students in the middle to understand and retain the material. It frustrates those in the upper portion and the bottom portion isn't motivated to do it.
 
I'm agnostic about charter schools, since I can see strong arguments in both directions. On the one hand, educational experimentation at the school level allows for a survival-of-the-fittest approach that could select for more successful strategies, and ultimately help us evolve better educational systems. On the other hand, at any given dollar level, charter schools are typically going to have a disadvantage in having smaller economies of scale, and many will have the double disadvantage of having some of those dollars siphoned off for ownership's profits, as well as for marketing. That means fewer dollars available for actually teaching kids. Which of these will tend to be the more dominant effect is an interesting question, but the results from Sweden sure don't look great for the charter school initiative:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings

I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:

"It’s easy to imagine teachers going easy on their own students... a study co-authored by my colleague, Jonah Rockoff, found exactly this result in an analysis of New York Regents Exam grading. In Sweden, according to the study by Hinnerich and Vlachos, the scores issued by external evaluators were indeed harsher than those assigned by internal graders. And... it turned out that the external evaluators had downgraded the scores for students at voucher schools much more than for students at government ones. In fact, a sizable portion of the much-vaunted outperformance of voucher school students could be chalked up to nothing more than easy grading. More surprising still, the voucher school grade inflation is almost as high for math and science (where you’d think an answer is either right or wrong) as it is for Swedish...."
​
I'm still trying to figure out what I believe when it comes to education reform. I used to be a huge proponent of high-stakes testing (driven, most likely, in part by the fact I do well on standardized tests). But now I've seen evidence that some high-performing systems (like Finland) don't go that way, so it no longer seems critical.

I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.
Do you realize how large a revenue center public education would be for private industry? I mean we spend hundreds of billions on public education and it is all just sitting there waiting for someone to stick their hands in and take it. I mean in my state they don't have too meet public education standards for teachers or curriculum. In fact the private schools are pushing the GOP who control our state to keep them from state testing and how their schools are doing, even from their students parents. Just think of the profits that could be made with no oversite.
 
I don't like charter schools much. I live in an area with a very large school district and many charter schools. I haven't seen any statistics for our school district for several years but the ones I did tended to show that charter schools under performed against the standard public schools. The schools tended to do much better or much worse than the average for public schools. I think (my opinion only) that the results are due to the fact that most charter schools have less oversight. Motivated administrators use that to the advantage of the students and less-motivated administrators hide behind it.



You can't really control parental involvement. In Freakonomics, it was shown that the goodness or badness of a school had less of an impact than did family. If I remember correctly, whether it is genetics, family support, or both; can't really be distinguished in the stats.



You aren't the typical student. My limited experience is that rote homework helps some students in the middle to understand and retain the material. It frustrates those in the upper portion and the bottom portion isn't motivated to do it.


I agree with your interpretation of schools vs family and homework. I think for some the rote memorization is an important component of learning. And, seeing many of my tween nieces and nephews who can't do math in their head and who can't recall what I think are some of the basic building blocks of grammar, etc, have convinced me that - doing some of that rote memorization is important for some kids to be to able to really have that skill and build on it. I know for instance, that using flash cards has really helped my kids with their reading by increasing the number of sight words they recognize, and once they have gotten to the point where those sight words are no longer something they have to try to recall but are automatic, they make much much better use of being able to sound out other words they don't know and being able to learn and master new words. Same with spelling words. Repetition there is very helpful.

connie
 
One would assume that for lefty the current "unionized keep 'em stupid and voting democratic" method or C.O.R.E. would be preferable...anything that allows students to excel academically based on knowledge rather than skin tone is not preferable to lefty.
 
"survival of the fittest" is part of the vernacular teachers unions parrot to scare parents into thinking that their neighborhood school might be closed.

in reality, progressive approaches to education are intended to help schools - as a class - evolve and do better. the practices in charter schools, schools that accept vouchers, "theme schools" (NYC has arts, math and science themed schools) should be rigorously tested, and adopted in schools which have poorer performance. nobody wants to see neighborhood schools close - we want to see them evolve and improve.

one area where both the federal government and teachers have colluded to frustrate progress is the evaluation of "single gender" schools. testing in several urban school districts has demonstrated that boys are at MUCH LESS RISK of dropping out if they (the most troubled) are diverted to all male middle schools, and taught by male teacherss.

there is considerable evidence that female teachers spend more time interacting with female students - they call on them more, praise them more, and are more likely to offer advice. in contrast - female teachers are far more likely to hold back a boy, or refer him to IQ/behavioral/disability testing if he doesn't meet their expectations.

a lot of this is based on girls being more intellectually advanced in grade school (on average - not all kids conform to gender standards). boys have more difficulty sitting still and completing the same lesson plans at the earlier grades. the negative feedback they experience at this stage may have lifelong implications for some boys - especially if they come from fatherlessless households, and the women teachers and administrators denigrate and devalue the efforts of boys when they fail to immediately attain the same level of achievment as girls.

there is no data which demonstrates that ensuring numerical equality of gender, race, religion, or IQ in a classroom improves the overall performance of that group of students.

in fact, the opposite is often the case.

an analogy - would you want to drive a car where all the engineers were from a pool of diverse skills and intelligence?

actually, i think that's how GM assigns the engineers who make its ignitions switches.

never mind . ..
 
"survival of the fittest" is part of the vernacular teachers unions parrot to scare parents into thinking that their neighborhood school might be closed.

in reality, progressive approaches to education are intended to help schools - as a class - evolve and do better. the practices in charter schools, schools that accept vouchers, "theme schools" (NYC has arts, math and science themed schools) should be rigorously tested, and adopted in schools which have poorer performance. nobody wants to see neighborhood schools close - we want to see them evolve and improve.

one area where both the federal government and teachers have colluded to frustrate progress is the evaluation of "single gender" schools. testing in several urban school districts has demonstrated that boys are at MUCH LESS RISK of dropping out if they (the most troubled) are diverted to all male middle schools, and taught by male teacherss.

there is considerable evidence that female teachers spend more time interacting with female students - they call on them more, praise them more, and are more likely to offer advice. in contrast - female teachers are far more likely to hold back a boy, or refer him to IQ/behavioral/disability testing if he doesn't meet their expectations.

a lot of this is based on girls being more intellectually advanced in grade school (on average - not all kids conform to gender standards). boys have more difficulty sitting still and completing the same lesson plans at the earlier grades. the negative feedback they experience at this stage may have lifelong implications for some boys - especially if they come from fatherlessless households, and the women teachers and administrators denigrate and devalue the efforts of boys when they fail to immediately attain the same level of achievment as girls.

there is no data which demonstrates that ensuring numerical equality of gender, race, religion, or IQ in a classroom improves the overall performance of that group of students.

in fact, the opposite is often the case.

an analogy - would you want to drive a car where all the engineers were from a pool of diverse skills and intelligence?

actually, i think that's how GM assigns the engineers who make its ignitions switches.

never mind . ..

Some really interesting points but this is all within limits.

Parents education and income are the number one factors that determine a child's success.

In my town there is a rich majority white part and a small poor black projects. Year in and year out the white kids are doing better then the black kids. Same teachers. Same school. My school was considered a blue-ribbon school, which in NYS is some sort of unique classification.

However, as I said, same education but statistics year in year out show the black kids are ,mostly not graduating and the white kids are virtually all going to college.

The only difference is the parental upbringing and the poverty. This has been done in peer-reviewed studies all the way back to the Coleman report in the 60s. In fact, when you control for income, etc, black kids do better then white kids slightly.

The point is that teachers are generally doing a wonderful job. But when the income of a family poor, the surrounding neighborhood high in crime and the parents educational background low, there is only so much unique strategies can do. The real solution is as much as possible ending poverty, etc.
 
I'm agnostic about charter schools, since I can see strong arguments in both directions. On the one hand, educational experimentation at the school level allows for a survival-of-the-fittest approach that could select for more successful strategies, and ultimately help us evolve better educational systems. On the other hand, at any given dollar level, charter schools are typically going to have a disadvantage in having smaller economies of scale, and many will have the double disadvantage of having some of those dollars siphoned off for ownership's profits, as well as for marketing. That means fewer dollars available for actually teaching kids. Which of these will tend to be the more dominant effect is an interesting question, but the results from Sweden sure don't look great for the charter school initiative:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...sastrous_experiment_with_milton_friedman.html
http://www.thelocal.se/20140401/sweden-takes-another-tumble-in-pisa-school-rankings

I was particularly interested in this bit, about the Regents Exam in New York and similar evaluations in Sweden, where teachers grade their own students:

"It’s easy to imagine teachers going easy on their own students... a study co-authored by my colleague, Jonah Rockoff, found exactly this result in an analysis of New York Regents Exam grading. In Sweden, according to the study by Hinnerich and Vlachos, the scores issued by external evaluators were indeed harsher than those assigned by internal graders. And... it turned out that the external evaluators had downgraded the scores for students at voucher schools much more than for students at government ones. In fact, a sizable portion of the much-vaunted outperformance of voucher school students could be chalked up to nothing more than easy grading. More surprising still, the voucher school grade inflation is almost as high for math and science (where you’d think an answer is either right or wrong) as it is for Swedish...."
​
I'm still trying to figure out what I believe when it comes to education reform. I used to be a huge proponent of high-stakes testing (driven, most likely, in part by the fact I do well on standardized tests). But now I've seen evidence that some high-performing systems (like Finland) don't go that way, so it no longer seems critical.

I don't believe in assigning a lot of homework. I think rote performance of problem sets is a huge waste of time. I always hated slaving away for hours on BS busy-work when I'd already mastered the concept or skill before even starting the homework. And I strongly believe in the value of parental and peer reinforcement of the importance of academics. Even in a horrible school, if you have parents who emphasize academics and peers who strive for educational greatness, you're going to find a way to learn. But, aside from that, I don't have any strong convictions about the topic.

I have been away from formal education long enough not to want to comment on the goodness or badness of Charter schools. But education needs to become less hands on by a teacher, more student-driven as that student gains skills. Just as in parenting, when a child is very young, there must be lots of hands- on parenting. The early stages of schooling is necessarily hands-on by teachers.

With our technology now, students should be able to take off on their own with directional steering by teachers fairly quickly(I am thinking early teens). The teacher needs to be competent enough in the subjects to offer explanation if the child hits a wall on something, so a teacher is more than a babysitter or an IT expert. The growing person that a child is needs to gain independence in learning when it is age-appropriate to make an adult person who continues to learn and appreciate the learning process for his whole life.

Teaching, imo, is more like teaching someone how to learn and how to live than it is teaching them the tiny details. Those details in early years are the basis for later learning, and they must be there, but real education is teaching someone how to access information and giving them tools for retaining and using that information.

I never believed in homework and when I taught high school I always incorporated time for that necessary practice work to be done as part of class. Kids have lots going on in their lives and homework is really not appropriate. Sometimes long-term assignments either reading or written need to be given; you can't write a research paper in class. But just general homework in lower grades.......... not good. And I just didn't do it.
 
I don't like charter schools much. I live in an area with a very large school district and many charter schools. I haven't seen any statistics for our school district for several years but the ones I did tended to show that charter schools under performed against the standard public schools. The schools tended to do much better or much worse than the average for public schools. I think (my opinion only) that the results are due to the fact that most charter schools have less oversight. Motivated administrators use that to the advantage of the students and less-motivated administrators hide behind it.



You can't really control parental involvement. In Freakonomics, it was shown that the goodness or badness of a school had less of an impact than did family. If I remember correctly, whether it is genetics, family support, or both; can't really be distinguished in the stats.



You aren't the typical student. My limited experience is that rote homework helps some students in the middle to understand and retain the material. It frustrates those in the upper portion and the bottom portion isn't motivated to do it.
I despised excessive homework so much that I ended up with awful grades, because I simply wouldn't bother to do it. I can specifically remember one monster problem set, in Algebra, back in seventh grade, where there must have been 50 problems that were all the same damned thing, over and over,just with different numbers plugged in (and sometimes word problems that you knew relied on the same concept).

I doubt that the quantity did much to help it stick for anyone, because after the first couple problems, they were on auto-pilot anyway. Certainly there were no genuine problem-solving skills being developed, since you knew all the problems were there to test the same math concept you'd just learned, so you knew they could all be solved using the same damned procedure you'd just been given, so there was no need to think about it at all. If you know, for example, that they're trying to drive home the skill of factoring quadratic equations, then you know every word problem implies a quadratic equation, which can be solved by factoring the equation. The more problems of that sort you give a student, the more you lull him into simply mechanically marching through the steps. Then educators wonder why nearly all the students completely forget the skill after the test. You're systematically deadening their minds with repetition, then wondering why they can no longer think well. There's got to be a better way.
 
One would assume that for lefty the current "unionized keep 'em stupid and voting democratic" method or C.O.R.E. would be preferable...anything that allows students to excel academically based on knowledge rather than skin tone is not preferable to lefty.
As you should know, "keep 'em stupid" would be a terrible way to assure that people vote Democrat, since the correlations run the opposite way. The most highly educated people tend to vote Democrat -- finding PhDs who vote Republican takes some real effort. And on a state-wide basis, the most highly educated states tend to vote Democrat, while the least educated vote Republican.

For example, see the 8th-grade reading scores here:

http://www.kansasopengov.org/School...adeReadingProficiency/tabid/2171/Default.aspx

These are the ten highest-performing states, in order:

MA, NJ, CT, VT, MT, NH, CO, MD, ME, MN

Montana is the only one among them that's a red state. Within that list is the second-most Democratic-leaning state in the union (Maryland, according to Gallup), and the fifth-most (MA), and the sixth (CT), and seventh (VT).
If you want to get people to vote Democrat, clearly "keeping 'em stupid" would be a horrible, horrible strategy, since making them smart seems to work so much better.

Meanwhile, here are the ten lowest-performing states when it comes to 8th-grade reading, in order:

MS, NM, LA, WV, CA, NV, AL, HI, OK, TX

Six out of ten are red states. So, keeping 'em stupid seems like a decent way to push people towards the GOP.
 
"survival of the fittest" is part of the vernacular teachers unions parrot to scare parents into thinking that their neighborhood school might be closed.

in reality, progressive approaches to education are intended to help schools - as a class - evolve and do better. the practices in charter schools, schools that accept vouchers, "theme schools" (NYC has arts, math and science themed schools) should be rigorously tested, and adopted in schools which have poorer performance. nobody wants to see neighborhood schools close - we want to see them evolve and improve.

one area where both the federal government and teachers have colluded to frustrate progress is the evaluation of "single gender" schools. testing in several urban school districts has demonstrated that boys are at MUCH LESS RISK of dropping out if they (the most troubled) are diverted to all male middle schools, and taught by male teacherss.

there is considerable evidence that female teachers spend more time interacting with female students - they call on them more, praise them more, and are more likely to offer advice. in contrast - female teachers are far more likely to hold back a boy, or refer him to IQ/behavioral/disability testing if he doesn't meet their expectations.

a lot of this is based on girls being more intellectually advanced in grade school (on average - not all kids conform to gender standards). boys have more difficulty sitting still and completing the same lesson plans at the earlier grades. the negative feedback they experience at this stage may have lifelong implications for some boys - especially if they come from fatherlessless households, and the women teachers and administrators denigrate and devalue the efforts of boys when they fail to immediately attain the same level of achievment as girls.

there is no data which demonstrates that ensuring numerical equality of gender, race, religion, or IQ in a classroom improves the overall performance of that group of students.

in fact, the opposite is often the case.

an analogy - would you want to drive a car where all the engineers were from a pool of diverse skills and intelligence?

actually, i think that's how GM assigns the engineers who make its ignitions switches.

never mind . ..
I would expect boys to do better in all-boy classrooms just due to the lack of feminine distraction, if nothing else. I know I'd have paid more attention if I weren't devoting 97% of my mental faculties to the pretty young thing in the tight sweater. But school sure would have been duller, and I wouldn't have been able to develop my sexual experiences as precociously.
 
Some really interesting points but this is all within limits.

Parents education and income are the number one factors that determine a child's success.

In my town there is a rich majority white part and a small poor black projects. Year in and year out the white kids are doing better then the black kids. Same teachers. Same school. My school was considered a blue-ribbon school, which in NYS is some sort of unique classification.

However, as I said, same education but statistics year in year out show the black kids are ,mostly not graduating and the white kids are virtually all going to college.

The only difference is the parental upbringing and the poverty. This has been done in peer-reviewed studies all the way back to the Coleman report in the 60s. In fact, when you control for income, etc, black kids do better then white kids slightly.

The point is that teachers are generally doing a wonderful job. But when the income of a family poor, the surrounding neighborhood high in crime and the parents educational background low, there is only so much unique strategies can do. The real solution is as much as possible ending poverty, etc.
Yes. Much of the difference between average US schools and average schools of top-performing nations is attributable simply to our greater neglect of the poor here. If we addressed that better, we'd already have solved the lion's share of the problem. And I think you can see that in the way our wealthier states and districts perform, which is already roughly up to the standards of the most elite national systems.

Massachusetts, for example, if it were a nation, would rank third in the world for reading (fourth if you count Shanghai separately), and sixth for science (seventh if you count Shanghai) and ninth for math (tenth with Shanghai). Taken altogether, Massachusetts would be the best-performing non-Asian nation, if it were a nation.

It's worth noting that it's not ALL about poverty. While Massachusetts has a low poverty rate for the US, thirteen states have lower rates, some of which have lousy educational systems. It's a combination of high income, reasonably low poverty, and strong social spending. But it's also about culture. Take Alaska as an example. It has higher median income than Massachusetts and lower poverty, and thanks to all that oil wealth the state has, and federal subsidization, it also has better per capita spending than Massachusetts. Yet its educational system is a bit of a wreck. It's a state of proud, know-nothing redneck imbeciles like Sarah Palin, and emphasizing a good education is simply not part of the culture there.
 
Back
Top