Arkady
President
For thinking people, one of the most convincing things about the mainstream theories about global warming is the trend within the scientific community. This isn't some short-lived fad hypothesis with little testing and investigation behind it. If this were an idea --like the global cooling craze, thirty or forty years ago-- that grew up quickly based on some interesting speculation and some snippets of evidence, we might expect it could vanish just as suddenly. But, instead, this is a theory that has grown slowly and steadily over the course of half a century, on the basis of mountains of research and data collection by many thousands of experts from dozens of fields of science and several dozen countries.
It's important to note that as these mountains of data grow, so does the confidence of the expert community about the theory that human activities are responsible for most of the warming trend. You may not know that if you've sealed yourself up within the airtight sarcophagus of the conservative media. In that crypt, the only stories that are let in are those that cast doubt on the theory. And with many thousands of new findings every year, inevitably there will be a steady trickle of those raising doubts, amidst the flood of findings raising confidence. But when the findings are considered as a whole, their net effect has been to broaden and strengthen the consensus among the experts every few years. The trend has been for a larger and larger portion of the expert community to become convinced, and for their confidence about that conviction to rise with time.
You can watch this playing out by reading the IPCC reports that come out every few years. Those are conservative reports (in the traditional sense of the word), since they require unanimous national consent. And so they've been slow to express the magnitude of the confidence most experts have long felt about the idea that human activities are the majority cause for global warming. But each new report has shown the intensified language that even that conservative consensus is willing to use. Most recently, they'll be hiking the probability they attribute for the theory to 95%:
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/20/s...l=1&adxnnlx=1376996753-gU4inp5yAW/7Vn1MheQkJw
So, what will it take to get you on board for political action? If you're holding out for the experts to tell you it's 100%, it won't happen. That's not how scientists think. We will either need to act with something less than 100% certainty, or we will never act. Think of it in medical terms. If you visited many of the best nutritionists and endocrinologists in the world and their consensus was that there was a 95% chance that your high blood sugar was mostly due to diet and lifestyle, and you'd soon be debilitated by diabetes if you didn't start exercising and improve your diet, would you hold out for 96% before making a change? 97%?
It's important to note that as these mountains of data grow, so does the confidence of the expert community about the theory that human activities are responsible for most of the warming trend. You may not know that if you've sealed yourself up within the airtight sarcophagus of the conservative media. In that crypt, the only stories that are let in are those that cast doubt on the theory. And with many thousands of new findings every year, inevitably there will be a steady trickle of those raising doubts, amidst the flood of findings raising confidence. But when the findings are considered as a whole, their net effect has been to broaden and strengthen the consensus among the experts every few years. The trend has been for a larger and larger portion of the expert community to become convinced, and for their confidence about that conviction to rise with time.
You can watch this playing out by reading the IPCC reports that come out every few years. Those are conservative reports (in the traditional sense of the word), since they require unanimous national consent. And so they've been slow to express the magnitude of the confidence most experts have long felt about the idea that human activities are the majority cause for global warming. But each new report has shown the intensified language that even that conservative consensus is willing to use. Most recently, they'll be hiking the probability they attribute for the theory to 95%:
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/20/s...l=1&adxnnlx=1376996753-gU4inp5yAW/7Vn1MheQkJw
So, what will it take to get you on board for political action? If you're holding out for the experts to tell you it's 100%, it won't happen. That's not how scientists think. We will either need to act with something less than 100% certainty, or we will never act. Think of it in medical terms. If you visited many of the best nutritionists and endocrinologists in the world and their consensus was that there was a 95% chance that your high blood sugar was mostly due to diet and lifestyle, and you'd soon be debilitated by diabetes if you didn't start exercising and improve your diet, would you hold out for 96% before making a change? 97%?