New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Climate record

Yes but lefty was claiming global warming before 2007. See Al "I just make money off da sh#t" Gore

And it has become much more pronounced since then, to the point that human-driven forcings overwhelm natural cycles of variability creating a positive feedback loop with no real end in sight.
 
Mostly advocating political change ... the only really effective thing an individual can do. But I also don't drive a car, rarely consume meat, put on a sweater rather than turning the heat up, etc.
I'm with you. My lifestyle is fairly modest when it comes to long-term carbon impact (only one kid, small energy-efficient home, Prius, recycling, no red meat and little meat of any kind, etc.) but there's little an individual can realistically do other than influence political change. Absent political change, anything I do to shrink my footprint just takes pressure off others to do the same, so they mostly just end up filling the part of the footprint I would have been in. It's going to take more than that.
 
Geothermal, wind, and hydro are cheaper and nuclear is nearly as cheap.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source

Solar can be pursued anywhere, and wind and nuclear in many places.

Nuclear is less vulnerable to supply interruptions.

Solar is the most efficient in that it is a direct use of the sun which is the ultimate source of fossil fuel resources anyway.
One, Germany leads the EU in its demand for fossil fuel. Two, China is predicting an all time high in demand for fossil fuel in 2017. Third, and by no means least, does the word Fukushima ring any bells? Are we to replace fossil fuel in America with nuclear death traps? Not to mention hazardous waste? No I'm afraid that there is no adequate solution at the moment. Wind, Solar, hydroelectric, and nuclear combined barely make a dent in the demand for fossil fuels.
To even dream that we were to reduce this consumption is foolishness.
 
For something to be a viable alternative it doesn't need to be at least as good in every way. It just needs to be good enough to make adoption realistic. For example, unleaded gas wasn't as good in every way as leaded gas. There's a reason industry fought tooth and nail against the deleading regulations. But it was good enough to make adoption realistic.

There are lots of viable alternatives to fossil fuels. Solar and wind plus battery technology is a viable alternative for most applications. It'll be a bit more expensive than the cheapest fossil fuels, but not hugely so. Right now the levelized system cost for the cheapest fossil fuel generation is 5.8 cents per Kwh, for combined cycle natural gas. That compares to 6.5 for land-based wind and 8.47 for solar PV. So, you pay about 12% to 46% more than for the cheapest of the fossil fuels. But you actually pay less than for coal. And costs for the greener options have been falling fast. We can move towards those alternatives fairly quickly without any serious fallout for our economy.


Unleaded gas is STILL gas. It's still a refined petroleum product. It's portable. It's efficient. It's cheap. None of your so-called 'alternatives' can match 2 out of 3.

We are stuck with fossil fuels for a long time to come.

As to the economy..are you serious? Did you not see what happens to the coal miners in the past decade or two? No serious impact? Tell that to them. Now extrapolate those job losses to the ENTIRE petroleum industry.

No serious fallout?

GTFO.
 
I'm with you. My lifestyle is fairly modest when it comes to long-term carbon impact (only one kid, small energy-efficient home, Prius, recycling, no red meat and little meat of any kind, etc.) but there's little an individual can realistically do other than influence political change. Absent political change, anything I do to shrink my footprint just takes pressure off others to do the same, so they mostly just end up filling the part of the footprint I would have been in. It's going to take more than that.

I own 2 cars and an RV, I live in a 25000 sq ft home, and I do so love a medium-rare center cut rib-eye. Oh, and when it gets cold..I turn up the heat.

You see it takes JOBS to make the cars, refine the gas and oil, and manufacture spare parts. It takes JOBS to build houses, furniture, appliances and carpets/drapes. It takes JOBS to ranch fine cattle to produce a juicy steak. Those folks working at the gas company? They need jobs too.

And I'll take jobs and a thriving economy over living like Ebeneezer Scrooge trying vainly to save a planet that doesn't need saving at all.
 
Unleaded gas is STILL gas. It's still a refined petroleum product. It's portable. It's efficient. It's cheap. None of your so-called 'alternatives' can match 2 out of 3.

Batteries charged with solar energy are portable, efficient, and cheap. They're not AS portable, efficient, and cheap as gas. But, again, being as good in those terms is not the test for viability.

We are stuck with fossil fuels for a long time to come.

We are if we want to be... which clearly you do. Similarly, we could have been stuck with CFCs until we waited around for an alternative that was just as cheap and efficient. And we could have been stuck with sulfur-dioxide-spouting power plants if we didn't start moving away from them until someone figured out how to make a plant that was equally efficient without spouting sulfur dioxide. But, fortunately, in the past we've been willing to take a reasonably small hit when it comes to things like price and efficiency, in order to gain some large improvements in other areas. That's what we can do with green energies as well.

As to the economy..are you serious? Did you not see what happens to the coal miners in the past decade or two? No serious impact?

Any economic change is going to have localized impacts. If we came up with dirt-cheap cold fusion tomorrow, it would have serious localized negative impacts in the oil and gas fields, for example. But what I mean is that looking at it from the perspective of the economy as a whole, we can move to green energy, at this point, without taking a big hit. The costs differentials are already narrow enough that it wouldn't be the severe shock we'd have seen if we tried to do it in the 90s, for example.
 
I own 2 cars and an RV, I live in a 25000 sq ft home, and I do so love a medium-rare center cut rib-eye. Oh, and when it gets cold..I turn up the heat.

You see it takes JOBS to make the cars, refine the gas and oil, and manufacture spare parts. It takes JOBS to build houses, furniture, appliances and carpets/drapes. It takes JOBS to ranch fine cattle to produce a juicy steak. Those folks working at the gas company? They need jobs too.

And I'll take jobs and a thriving economy over living like Ebeneezer Scrooge trying vainly to save a planet that doesn't need saving at all.
There will always be horrible people who don't care what harm they do to the rest of us by way of the externalized costs of their conspicuous consumption. That's why it's so important that we act through policy changes, rather than just relying on voluntary individual action. If all you have are individual actions, then the guy who does the right thing by keeping his consumption reasonable just lowers commodity prices so some immoral prick can come along and indulge in a 25,000 sq ft home.
 
Batteries charged with solar energy are portable, efficient, and cheap. They're not AS portable, efficient, and cheap as gas. But, again, being as good in those terms is not the test for viability.



We are if we want to be... which clearly you do. Similarly, we could have been stuck with CFCs until we waited around for an alternative that was just as cheap and efficient. And we could have been stuck with sulfur-dioxide-spouting power plants if we didn't start moving away from them until someone figured out how to make a plant that was equally efficient without spouting sulfur dioxide. But, fortunately, in the past we've been willing to take a reasonably small hit when it comes to things like price and efficiency, in order to gain some large improvements in other areas. That's what we can do with green energies as well.



Any economic change is going to have localized impacts. If we came up with dirt-cheap cold fusion tomorrow, it would have serious localized negative impacts in the oil and gas fields, for example. But what I mean is that looking at it from the perspective of the economy as a whole, we can move to green energy, at this point, without taking a big hit. The costs differentials are already narrow enough that it wouldn't be the severe shock we'd have seen if we tried to do it in the 90s, for example.

Batteries produce hazardous waste that as bad, if not worse than carbon. We crate 13 tones of HW on this planet every SECOND.
http://www.theworldcounts.com/counters/waste_pollution_facts/hazardous_waste_statistics

You want to create more. Quick question....where are you going to put the hazmat from these wonder batteries? Which, still, are not even close to being able to compete with Fossil Fuel.
 
There will always be horrible people who don't care what harm they do to the rest of us by way of the externalized costs of their conspicuous consumption. That's why it's so important that we act through policy changes, rather than just relying on voluntary individual action. If all you have are individual actions, then the guy who does the right thing by keeping his consumption reasonable just lowers commodity prices so some immoral prick can come along and indulge in a 25,000 sq ft home.

And there will always be horrible people who are willing to impoverish the working man and wreck the world's economy in order to regulate what size house, which type of car or what type of food others should consume. All of that to make a minuscule impact on a process that you still can't prove is even the 'problem' you claim it to be.

Because you and your 'oh so caring' ilk know better? You've assigned yourselves as the paragons of virtue and the rest of us better fall in line?

Not on my watch, tree-hugger.
 
Quick question....where are you going to put the hazmat from these wonder batteries?
Why would that be a "quick question"? It's a question that would require a great deal of information to answer.

https://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/what-happens-to-ev-and-hybrid-batteries.html

This is one of the reasons that sound environmental policy is built around cost internalization. That way a person doesn't have to try to be an expert in the whole life cycle of everything he uses in order to make responsible choices. The impact on the environment should already be priced into the product, so that he can just take the best option for himself, automatically factoring in those "externalities." So, for example, is the carbon footprint greater for locally-sourced beef or chicken trucked in from a great distance? It would be very tough to figure that out for the individual consumer. But if the carbon impact is already priced in (by way, for example, of carbon taxes on the fuel involved in raising and transporting those things), then the individual consumer can just look at the price tag and decide what he wants.
 
And there will always be horrible people who are willing to impoverish the working man and wreck the world's economy in order to regulate what size house, which type of car or what type of food others should consume.

I've never called for any of that.
 
Why would that be a "quick question"? It's a question that would require a great deal of information to answer.

https://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/what-happens-to-ev-and-hybrid-batteries.html

This is one of the reasons that sound environmental policy is built around cost internalization. That way a person doesn't have to try to be an expert in the whole life cycle of everything he uses in order to make responsible choices. The impact on the environment should already be priced into the product, so that he can just take the best option for himself, automatically factoring in those "externalities." So, for example, is the carbon footprint greater for locally-sourced beef or chicken trucked in from a great distance? It would be very tough to figure that out for the individual consumer. But if the carbon impact is already priced in (by way, for example, of carbon taxes on the fuel involved in raising and transporting those things), then the individual consumer can just look at the price tag and decide what he wants.

The question was quick, The answer is even quicker. Using current battery technology in lieu of fossil fuel is trading one demon for another. But as long as it fits your political agenda of regulating "excessive consumption" because life isn't fair (darn it!), you good with it.
 
The question was quick, The answer is even quicker. Using current battery technology in lieu of fossil fuel is trading one demon for another.

Absolutely every economic choice trades one demon for another. That choice trades a big demon for a little one. If we make a habit of swaps like that, we end up much better off.
 
I've never called for any of that.

Sure you have. Just not in so many words. When you label people who don't fall in line with your doom-saying 'horrible' and call their lifestyle 'excessive' then you practically SCREAMING for regulation and rampant government intervention.

You try so carefully to hide it behind verbosity and double-speak but we all know that you'd have us all living in hovels and eating quinoa from hand-thrown pottery the rest of our miserable lives.
 
Absolutely every economic choice trades one demon for another. That choice trades a big demon for a little one. If we make a habit of swaps like that, we end up much better off.

You have no idea just how big either demon actually is. Batteries are created with toxic chemicals, they consume a shit-ton of rare earth minerals, AND they're hazardous waste.

But all of that is irrelevant when it's Capitalism that you despise, not Climate Change.
 
One, Germany leads the EU in its demand for fossil fuel. Two, China is predicting an all time high in demand for fossil fuel in 2017. Third, and by no means least, does the word Fukushima ring any bells? Are we to replace fossil fuel in America with nuclear death traps? Not to mention hazardous waste? No I'm afraid that there is no adequate solution at the moment. Wind, Solar, hydroelectric, and nuclear combined barely make a dent in the demand for fossil fuels.
To even dream that we were to reduce this consumption is foolishness.

"An all time high" as in a peak. If U.S. carbon emissions were also to peak in 2017, we'd be getting somewhere.

Fukushima was bad, but there's no source without costs. Putting safety ahead of profits by nationalizing the energy industry under union control would help prevent disasters like that. The Deepwater Horizon spill - - one of many fossil-fuel-related accidents - - will probably cause more deaths, and that's not even taking the nightmare scenario of accelerated climate change into account.

High-level nuclear waste is truly dangerous for a matter of decades, during which it can be contained within secure lead barriers in remote areas, or (increasingly) recycled into the power-generating process with no need for disposal. It's true that the waste can remain radioactive for tens of thousands of years, but also highly misleading. After 200 years or so, direct long-term exposure to a large nuclear waste dump would only raise a person's risk of cancer by an infinitesimal fraction of a percent.
 
Back
Top