New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

CNN iReports

Arkady

President
On several occasions here, I've encountered right-wing posters making dubious claims, backed by a link to what appears to be a CNN story, but, in fact, is something from CNN iReport. That's an outlet for anonymous people to publish un-vetted assertions. Essentially, it's like Political Jack, but co-branded with CNN, to give it a false appearance of having some credibility. That makes it a useful outlet for giving right-wing lies the veneer of truth. For example, if you want to assert that there was never a budget surplus in the Clinton years, when every reputable news source will confirm there was, just go onto iReport, create a story making your assertion, then link to that. It's a bit like inserting propaganda into Wikipedia, but without the ability of other users to fix misinformation, and without as much public awareness of the fact it's crowd-sourced.

In addition to the lie about there never being a surplus during the Clinton years, I've also encountered a lie --sourced to iReport-- claiming that the Bush recession started under Clinton. I've seen a number of other references to iReports here, generally by right-wingers, but occasionally by lefties. So, I thought that, in the interest of sparing ourselves some embarrassment, it would be worth publicizing the fact CNN iReport is not a credible news source, if some here still weren't aware of it after the recent asteroid hoax:

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/05/...ler-asteroid-will-hit-earth-on-march-35-2041/

Since that story dealt with a civilization-ending asteroid strike scheduled for March 35, from now on I'll refer to iReport stories, and similar links to "news" published in crowd-sourced outlets, as "March 35 stories."
 
Better people post their bullshit with no links at all, like yours?
As you know, my posts tend to be extensively sourced. The only time I don't bother with links is when the source of the data should be widely known. For example, if I'm going to say that the labor participation rate was X% in Y month, then obviously the source is the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
 
On several occasions here, I've encountered right-wing posters making dubious claims, backed by a link to what appears to be a CNN story, but, in fact, is something from CNN iReport. That's an outlet for anonymous people to publish un-vetted assertions. Essentially, it's like Political Jack, but co-branded with CNN, to give it a false appearance of having some credibility. That makes it a useful outlet for giving right-wing lies the veneer of truth. For example, if you want to assert that there was never a budget surplus in the Clinton years, when every reputable news source will confirm there was, just go onto iReport, create a story making your assertion, then link to that. It's a bit like inserting propaganda into Wikipedia, but without the ability of other users to fix misinformation, and without as much public awareness of the fact it's crowd-sourced.

In addition to the lie about there never being a surplus during the Clinton years, I've also encountered a lie --sourced to iReport-- claiming that the Bush recession started under Clinton. I've seen a number of other references to iReports here, generally by right-wingers, but occasionally by lefties. So, I thought that, in the interest of sparing ourselves some embarrassment, it would be worth publicizing the fact CNN iReport is not a credible news source, if some here still weren't aware of it after the recent asteroid hoax:

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/05/...ler-asteroid-will-hit-earth-on-march-35-2041/

Since that story dealt with a civilization-ending asteroid strike scheduled for March 35, from now on I'll refer to iReport stories, and similar links to "news" published in crowd-sourced outlets, as "March 35 stories."

Mr. Arkady,

Are you sure you want to go with that? If that's the case, it ruins your claims of the past 5 years of economic duldrums that "it's Bush's fault."
 
CNN has never suggested in any way that "i-reports" are official CNN content, vetted, or factual. they are very clear that this is "user submitted content" and principally for entertainment.

sorry you were confused about that, but apparently nobody else was.

when you go to youtube, do become agitated until realize its not cable tv?
 
Mr. Arkady,

Are you sure you want to go with that? If that's the case, it ruins your claims of the past 5 years of economic duldrums that "it's Bush's fault."
I have no idea what you mean. I don't recall making the case that the past five years of economic "duldrums" [sic] are Bush's fault, or even making the case that the past five years consist of economic doldrums. Regardless, if I had argued the economy of the past five years was Bush's fault, what about what I just posted would ruin that claim?
 
Better people post their bullshit with no links at all, like yours?

Arkady's missive is either true and valid, or it isn't, regardless if whether or not he offered a link. If you're convinced it isn't, you should offer up your own counter information.

OR...you can request a link. But in that case, the polite thing to do would be to suggest that IF he proffered the requisite links, you'll proudly accept his missive.
 
CNN has never suggested in any way that "i-reports" are official CNN content, vetted, or factual. they are very clear that this is "user submitted content" and principally for entertainment.

sorry you were confused about that, but apparently nobody else was.

when you go to youtube, do become agitated until realize its not cable tv?
Who, exactly, are you gibbering at? Are you under the impression I'm saying I believed CNN vetted that material? If so, you should work on your reading comprehension skills. I suggested nothing of the sort. I've never been confused about iReport. If you do a keyword search for "iReport," with me as the author, you'll see that all three times a reference to iReport has appeared in a post by me, it was to inform other posters that it's just user-submitted content and not a credible news source.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...ada-ranch-standoff.68416/page-12#post-1043374

OK.... so your source is some anonymous right-wing kook who posts on CNN's un-vetted iReport pages? Take a look at other work from your nutter: http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-844064
You'll recognize the grammar problems, random capitalization, misspellings, and outlandish calls for the abolition of our government, as the same kind of unhinged ravings you'll see from the right-wingers here. He has no more credibility than if you were just linking to a fellow politicaljack conservative. It should tell you something that you can't find any more credible source for the claim there was no surplus under Clinton.
​

Also:

https://www.politicaljack.com/threa...-on-another-vacation.66133/page-4#post-990143

Also, note that ireport is essentially just a forum comment, not a news report.
​
There are posters here who were confused about what iReport is, but I wasn't one of them.
 
CNN has never suggested in any way that "i-reports" are official CNN content, vetted, or factual. they are very clear that this is "user submitted content" and principally for entertainment.

sorry you were confused about that, but apparently nobody else was.

when you go to youtube, do become agitated until realize its not cable tv?

If nobody but Arkady thinks "i-reports" are a valid source, why do people suggest them as their source? Are you saying that whenever people do so, their intent is satirical?
 
Arkady's missive is either true and valid, or it isn't, regardless if whether or not he offered a link. If you're convinced it isn't, you should offer up your own counter information.

OR...you can request a link. But in that case, the polite thing to do would be to suggest that IF he proffered the requisite links, you'll proudly accept his missive.
Occasionally people do challenge me for a link and when they do I provide them. However, for most of the numbers-based stuff I post, the data is widely available exactly where people would expect to find it.

Crime stats can be found in the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports.

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/ucr

Budget stats can be found in the White House or CBO historical budget tables:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/historicals

Population, income, and poverty stats can be found at the Census:

http://www.census.gov/data/data-tools.html

Unemployment, jobs, inflation, and healthcare insurance stats can be found at the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

http://www.bls.gov/data/

GDP stats can be found at the Bureau of Economic Analysis:

http://www.bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp

Business Cycle dates and recession calls can be found at the National Bureau of Economic Research:

http://www.nber.org/cycles/cyclesmain.html

International stats can be found at the OECD (detailed stats for developed nations):

http://www.oecd.org/

Or the CIA World Factbook (less detailed stats for all nations):

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/

Historical stock price numbers can be found through any decent financial website:

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=^dji historical prices

When I'm posting something of that sort (e.g., saying that the the unemployment rate was 3.9% in December 2000), I often don't bother to post the link because I figure people already know how to find that data, and since I often am getting it from memory, I don't have the link in front of me. When, on the other hand, I'm posting something where I wouldn't expect a reasonably well informed person to know where to look to find the data (e.g., climate data, state-specific data, etc.), I try to remember to provide the link.
 
Arkady's missive is either true and valid, or it isn't, regardless if whether or not he offered a link. If you're convinced it isn't, you should offer up your own counter information.

OR...you can request a link. But in that case, the polite thing to do would be to suggest that IF he proffered the requisite links, you'll proudly accept his missive.

Arkady makes the claim...If Arkady doesn't want to back up....fine ..but know this it is of no value what he has to say and you backing up Arkady has an even less valid point.
 
Occasionally people do challenge me for a link and when they do I provide them. However, for most of the numbers-based stuff I post, the data is widely available exactly where people would expect to find it. .

How about a link for what you are talking about...a CNNi link?
 
...you are talking to who about what?

..."...you thought so"? LMAO, r-i-g-h-t...

th


swing and a miss once again
 
As you know, my posts tend to be extensively sourced. The only time I don't bother with links is when the source of the data should be widely known. For example, if I'm going to say that the labor participation rate was X% in Y month, then obviously the source is the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
You are an obama support that speaks volumes about your post being extensively sourced. You discredit yourself when you defend the liar in chief liar of the yesr 2013.
 
Occasionally people do challenge me for a link and when they do I provide them. However, for most of the numbers-based stuff I post, the data is widely available exactly where people would expect to find it.

Crime stats can be found in the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports.

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/ucr

Budget stats can be found in the White House or CBO historical budget tables:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/historicals

Population, income, and poverty stats can be found at the Census:

http://www.census.gov/data/data-tools.html

Unemployment, jobs, inflation, and healthcare insurance stats can be found at the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

http://www.bls.gov/data/

GDP stats can be found at the Bureau of Economic Analysis:

http://www.bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp

Business Cycle dates and recession calls can be found at the National Bureau of Economic Research:

http://www.nber.org/cycles/cyclesmain.html

International stats can be found at the OECD (detailed stats for developed nations):

http://www.oecd.org/

Or the CIA World Factbook (less detailed stats for all nations):

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/

Historical stock price numbers can be found through any decent financial website:

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=^dji historical prices

When I'm posting something of that sort (e.g., saying that the the unemployment rate was 3.9% in December 2000), I often don't bother to post the link because I figure people already know how to find that data, and since I often am getting it from memory, I don't have the link in front of me. When, on the other hand, I'm posting something where I wouldn't expect a reasonably well informed person to know where to look to find the data (e.g., climate data, state-specific data, etc.), I try to remember to provide the link.
Being you are an obama support and defender of liar of the year anything you say becomes irrelevant. any link you use becomes irrelevant.
 
Occasionally people do challenge me for a link and when they do I provide them. However, for most of the numbers-based stuff I post, the data is widely available exactly where people would expect to find it.

Crime stats can be found in the FBI's Uniform Crime Reports.

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/ucr

Budget stats can be found in the White House or CBO historical budget tables:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/historicals

Population, income, and poverty stats can be found at the Census:

http://www.census.gov/data/data-tools.html

Unemployment, jobs, inflation, and healthcare insurance stats can be found at the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

http://www.bls.gov/data/

GDP stats can be found at the Bureau of Economic Analysis:

http://www.bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp

International stats can be found at the OECD (detailed stats for developed nations):

http://www.oecd.org/

Or the CIA World Factbook (less detailed stats for all nations):

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/

Historical stock price numbers can be found through any decent financial website:

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=^dji historical prices

When I'm posting something of that sort (e.g., saying that the the unemployment rate was 3.9% in December 2000), I often don't bother to post the link because I figure people already know how to find that data, and since I often am getting it from memory, I don't have the link in front of me. When, on the other hand, I'm posting something where I wouldn't expect a reasonably well informed person to know where to look to find the data (e.g., climate data, state-specific data, etc.), I try to remember to provide the link.

I see it perhaps slightly differently. We're not exactly doing scholarly work here. So, let's say I post my conclusion that "Obamacare will save money over the next decade, as compared with the alternative". Then let's say...someone comes back with a "Prove it!" But then...why the hell SHOULD I prove it? Does anybody seriously believe that IF I prove it to the "prove it" shouter, that they're going to accept my conclusion? Of course they aren't.

What he could do on the other hand - if he could - is provide ME with alternate conclusion along with HIS cite. And in that case, I might feel challenged to play "dueling sources" with him.

The difference here - as opposed to academia - is that academia isn't 100% committed to disputing WHATEVER I say. So, if my conclusion is based on say...the official unemployment rate in 1990, I'll want to cite that so anyone considering my work can either be assured that I didn't just pull the number out my ass, OR they can double-check my work. And then.......they can accept my factoid as valid and move on from there.
 
Back
Top