Arkady
President
There are three ways that our creaky old Constitution can adapt over time, two official and one that has arisen as a de facto matter. First is the process of formal amendment. Second is a Constitutional Convention. And third is the process of federal judges interpreting existing language in the Constitution in new ways (e.g., deciding that "equal protection" forbids government from having racially segregated public schools). Historically, only the first and third options have been used, but the possibility for the second is expressly set forth in Article V of the Constitution.
The idea of a Constitutional Convention sometimes gains popularity among conservatives, either as a way of negating the role that "activists judges" have had (e.g., reimposing racial segregation), or as a way of imposing new ideas in a batch that would be difficult or impossible to get through the normal amendment process (e.g., term limits, a balanced budget requirement, etc.) Although this has usually been promoted by Republicans, and is currently being pushed by Marco Rubio, I actually like the idea of having occasional Constitutional Conventions. I'd like to see one where the Constitution as a whole is considered and reworked to make it more suitable for a modern nation.
In the business context, a similar concept comes up with certain kinds of complex "master agreements". Over time, the contracts can become unwieldy, as year after year an underlying agreement gets embellished with amendments, schedules, purchase orders, appendices, etc., and the core underlying document become increasingly out-of-line with the actual course of business dealings and practical needs of the parties. It's always easier just to hang the next exception off the agreement as an amendment, side letter, schedule, etc., but eventually the whole become so lousy that the parties bite the bullet and do an "Amended and Restated" agreement -- essentially a fresh agreement that supersedes the original, set up along the same lines but liberally revising and integrating everything so you get a single, harmonized, rationalized, and updated contract going forward. I'd like to see something similar with the Constitution.
Take the Second Amendment as an example. Regardless of what you think gun rights SHOULD BE, in this country, it should be clear that the Second Amendment is a clinic in how not to draft legal language. If you think that there should be an absolute individual right to own firearms, you're probably well aware of how the way the Second Amendment is drafted can be used to argue that it guarantees no such thing -- all that talk of a well-regulated militia and the defense of the state, plus the inconvenient fact the amendment refers to "arms" instead of firearms, all create angles for gun controllers to argue that the amendment doesn't protect what you think it should. And if, on the other hand, you're a gun controller, you're well aware of the fact that there's a reference to "the right of the people" and that an absolute-sounding "shall not be infringed" can be used by anti-gun-controllers against arguments that the amendment allows for certain regulations or that it's only applicable in certain contexts. As far as legal writing goes, it's a steaming pile of feces that fails on the basic test of setting forth its rule plainly enough that reasonable people can agree in even a very general way about what is and is not allowed. Whether you're pro-gun-control or anti-gun-control, surely you could easily craft a better way to get across the idea of what YOU think the rule should be than what is in the Second Amendment. Either way, we can do better.
A Constitutional Convention would open the door for a long-overdue major overhaul.... the kind that would never happen on a piecemeal basis if every item were brought up and debated as an individual amendment, allowing aggrieved minority states to shoot each down individually. Being able to take the changes as a whole, in a Constitutional Convention, you could potentially do what the Founders did the first time through, when they came up to something massively better than the Articles of Confederation, by dealing with it as a fresh package deal. Even when each individual change may have a sufficient minority against it to kill the hope of any amendment, those various minorities may still see the package deal as a net improvement, such that it can survive.
What would a new Constitution look like, as a product of that process? I don't know. Since the language of the Constitution would require 3/4 of the legislatures (or conventions) of the states to ratify, and since our system is wildly skewed in favor of over-representation of small states, such a process might be doomed to fail, since it couldn't address so many of the things needing improvement, as even if those things would be beneficial to the vast majority of Americans, people representing a fairly small minority living in small states could kill it. Possibly the only way to get fundamental change is by way of actual reorganization -- if the clusters of states realized, through the course of the convention, that they wanted to move in opposite directions, and that an amicable, negotiated split would allow each to get what it wanted.
What would be on your wish list in a new Constitution? Term limits? Elimination of the income tax. A line-item veto? A rule against flag burning? A referendum process? A method for presidential recalls?
I'd want to reorganize the states fundamentally, along natural population divisions, into roughly equally sized units -- and fewer of them -- with a mechanism for impartial (algorithm-driven) periodic redistricting. That would deal with the over- and under-representation problem. I'd stick with a bicameral legislature, but alter the way it works, so one chamber was a "winner take all" district-by-district representation system based on voting for the individual (like our current system), and the other chamber had proportional representation with party-based voting (such that minority interests could get some representation, even if they didn't happen to form the majority in any particular district). So, for example, you could have 10 districts, each of which elected 5 Senators, all at the same time, so that you'd see more libertarians, greens, and others who represent significant minorities go to Congress.
I'd want more power at the federal level and less at the states. For example, there should be more harmonized public education nationally, as well as consistent voting rules and balloting processes. I'd want to clean up examples of clearly lousy drafting, one way or the other, so we could have clarity on issues. I'd want to clear the boards of judge-made notions that money is speech and corporations are people for purposes of speech rights. I'd want clearer, tighter rules regarding the use of force abroad. Other ideas?
The idea of a Constitutional Convention sometimes gains popularity among conservatives, either as a way of negating the role that "activists judges" have had (e.g., reimposing racial segregation), or as a way of imposing new ideas in a batch that would be difficult or impossible to get through the normal amendment process (e.g., term limits, a balanced budget requirement, etc.) Although this has usually been promoted by Republicans, and is currently being pushed by Marco Rubio, I actually like the idea of having occasional Constitutional Conventions. I'd like to see one where the Constitution as a whole is considered and reworked to make it more suitable for a modern nation.
In the business context, a similar concept comes up with certain kinds of complex "master agreements". Over time, the contracts can become unwieldy, as year after year an underlying agreement gets embellished with amendments, schedules, purchase orders, appendices, etc., and the core underlying document become increasingly out-of-line with the actual course of business dealings and practical needs of the parties. It's always easier just to hang the next exception off the agreement as an amendment, side letter, schedule, etc., but eventually the whole become so lousy that the parties bite the bullet and do an "Amended and Restated" agreement -- essentially a fresh agreement that supersedes the original, set up along the same lines but liberally revising and integrating everything so you get a single, harmonized, rationalized, and updated contract going forward. I'd like to see something similar with the Constitution.
Take the Second Amendment as an example. Regardless of what you think gun rights SHOULD BE, in this country, it should be clear that the Second Amendment is a clinic in how not to draft legal language. If you think that there should be an absolute individual right to own firearms, you're probably well aware of how the way the Second Amendment is drafted can be used to argue that it guarantees no such thing -- all that talk of a well-regulated militia and the defense of the state, plus the inconvenient fact the amendment refers to "arms" instead of firearms, all create angles for gun controllers to argue that the amendment doesn't protect what you think it should. And if, on the other hand, you're a gun controller, you're well aware of the fact that there's a reference to "the right of the people" and that an absolute-sounding "shall not be infringed" can be used by anti-gun-controllers against arguments that the amendment allows for certain regulations or that it's only applicable in certain contexts. As far as legal writing goes, it's a steaming pile of feces that fails on the basic test of setting forth its rule plainly enough that reasonable people can agree in even a very general way about what is and is not allowed. Whether you're pro-gun-control or anti-gun-control, surely you could easily craft a better way to get across the idea of what YOU think the rule should be than what is in the Second Amendment. Either way, we can do better.
A Constitutional Convention would open the door for a long-overdue major overhaul.... the kind that would never happen on a piecemeal basis if every item were brought up and debated as an individual amendment, allowing aggrieved minority states to shoot each down individually. Being able to take the changes as a whole, in a Constitutional Convention, you could potentially do what the Founders did the first time through, when they came up to something massively better than the Articles of Confederation, by dealing with it as a fresh package deal. Even when each individual change may have a sufficient minority against it to kill the hope of any amendment, those various minorities may still see the package deal as a net improvement, such that it can survive.
What would a new Constitution look like, as a product of that process? I don't know. Since the language of the Constitution would require 3/4 of the legislatures (or conventions) of the states to ratify, and since our system is wildly skewed in favor of over-representation of small states, such a process might be doomed to fail, since it couldn't address so many of the things needing improvement, as even if those things would be beneficial to the vast majority of Americans, people representing a fairly small minority living in small states could kill it. Possibly the only way to get fundamental change is by way of actual reorganization -- if the clusters of states realized, through the course of the convention, that they wanted to move in opposite directions, and that an amicable, negotiated split would allow each to get what it wanted.
What would be on your wish list in a new Constitution? Term limits? Elimination of the income tax. A line-item veto? A rule against flag burning? A referendum process? A method for presidential recalls?
I'd want to reorganize the states fundamentally, along natural population divisions, into roughly equally sized units -- and fewer of them -- with a mechanism for impartial (algorithm-driven) periodic redistricting. That would deal with the over- and under-representation problem. I'd stick with a bicameral legislature, but alter the way it works, so one chamber was a "winner take all" district-by-district representation system based on voting for the individual (like our current system), and the other chamber had proportional representation with party-based voting (such that minority interests could get some representation, even if they didn't happen to form the majority in any particular district). So, for example, you could have 10 districts, each of which elected 5 Senators, all at the same time, so that you'd see more libertarians, greens, and others who represent significant minorities go to Congress.
I'd want more power at the federal level and less at the states. For example, there should be more harmonized public education nationally, as well as consistent voting rules and balloting processes. I'd want to clean up examples of clearly lousy drafting, one way or the other, so we could have clarity on issues. I'd want to clear the boards of judge-made notions that money is speech and corporations are people for purposes of speech rights. I'd want clearer, tighter rules regarding the use of force abroad. Other ideas?
Last edited: