New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Creationism

@gabriel: I am trying to see what you mean. I do not see how a parent teaching a child what the parent believes to be true could be brainwashing, as I understand it. Feel free to ignore, of course; no obligation.
 
youre trying to convince a child that your beliefs are truth rather than letting the child be made aware of all of the beliefs and someday make its own decisions. a child will always expect that the parent will know what is true and will accept whatever it is told as gospel. thats brainwashing
 
@gabriel: then all parenting is brainwashing. Are you a parent? Is the parent also "brainwashing" the child into eating vegetables, going to bed, using manners, etc., or is that just "training"?

In your theory of parenting, would the parent acknowledge a belief in a particular system, i.e., "well, son, I am agnostic, but here are several other types of beliefs" or would the parent never let on directly what the parent believes so as not to 'prejudice' the child's choice?
 
the training of a child to take care of its physical health and to understand the expectations of the society in which it will live is a duty. as to the agnostic, if the child asks, tell him and explain why you think like you do but explain that many do not agree with you and why that is and what they believe. simple stuff.
 
@RC #54: Wait, someone asked what is truth once, before . . . if only I could remember . . . .

I suggest it is the parents' job, initially, to teach what they understand the truth to be to the child.

Nfp, it is the parent's job to search for the truth and teach the results of that search to their children. Not to sit on their haunches and pass on something they learned by rote. The "Cargo Cults" of the south Pacific are good examples.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult
 
@ red cloud and gabriel: See, I think we actually all substantially agree. I do not think the parent is ever going to convince a child of the truth of a religious belief (into adulthood) unless the parent really lives the faith. Gabriel (and RedCloud too), I think we agree that the parent should teach the truth as the parent understands it, but we disagree as to what that truth is (would our hypothetical agnostic parent be "brainwashing" as to agnoticism from a christian perspective?).
 
What would be worse if aliens did discover us would be that they are the exact same as us - bang goes earths' humanity
 
@gabriel: I am trying to see what you mean. I do not see how a parent teaching a child what the parent believes to be true could be brainwashing, as I understand it. Feel free to ignore, of course; no obligation.

Nfp, as is my wont, I'm sticking my nose into someone else's business. I think a parent has an obligation to pass on only proven scientific facts. It reminds me of the story of the young bride who was preparing to roast a ham. She told her helper to cut off the hock of the ham before putting it into the pan. The helper asked why. The bride said, "because my mother always did that." "Lets ask your mother why," said the helper. They did, and the mother said, "My mother always did that, so lets ask her." They did, and the grandmother said, "Why, child, it was because I didn't have a pan large enough to cook the whole ham."
 
nope. the parent shud explain that it is the parents BELIEF period. to try and tell him it is your TRUTH as you believe it is telling him that you have discovered truth without hard proof. i dont want my kid believing he can see truth thru faith alone.
 
@ red cloud and gabriel: See, I think we actually all substantially agree. I do not think the parent is ever going to convince a child of the truth of a religious belief (into adulthood) unless the parent really lives the faith. Gabriel (and RedCloud too), I think we agree that the parent should teach the truth as the parent understands it, but we disagree as to what that truth is (would our hypothetical agnostic parent be "brainwashing" as to agnoticism from a christian perspective?).

Nfp, "...the truth as the parent understands it..." should be based on scientific evidence and not fables passed down from antiquity. I believe most Agnostics would tell their children that they don't know that these religious claims are not true, but that the claims cannot be proven scientifically.
 
GG, you are right. I'm afraid that another intelligent alien civilization will discover "us," and we will go the way of the red man.

Not sure about that....any advanced civilization doesn't "need Earth" for "breathing room". Nano-technology would provide them a Utopia of endless resources and Space itself all the "room for colonization" they'd ever want.

More likely they would AVOID us...fearful of their technology (if some form of interstellar drive) falling into our hands....but with a similar analogy to American Indians in that, if the Spanish had considered the true strategic advantages of allowing the HORSE to fall into the hands of the Indians....they would have slaughtered them (the horses) upon setting foot in North America, given it was a key advantage in technology that prolonged the Indians' attempt at repulsing white settlers.

Way off topic now...but a good one for another thread. As for Dino's assertion....it would only work if we had a good, EXTENSIVE capacity for detailed examination of dozens, if not hundreds of stellar bodies and potential "Earth-like" planets.

To claim Earth as "special"...just because we have "found no other like it"....is like a guy born on an isolated island with no boat claiming "There are no other islands but mine!"
 
Not sure about that....any advanced civilization doesn't "need Earth" for "breathing room". Nano-technology would provide them a Utopia of endless resources and Space itself all the "room for colonization" they'd ever want.

More likely they would AVOID us...fearful of their technology (if some form of interstellar drive) falling into our hands....but with a similar analogy to American Indians in that, if the Spanish had considered the true strategic advantages of allowing the HORSE to fall into the hands of the Indians....they would have slaughtered them (the horses) upon setting foot in North America, given it was a key advantage in technology that prolonged the Indians' attempt at repulsing white settlers.

Way off topic now...but a good one for another thread. As for Dino's assertion....it would only work if we had a good, EXTENSIVE capacity for detailed examination of dozens, if not hundreds of stellar bodies and potential "Earth-like" planets.

To claim Earth as "special"...just because we have "found no other like it"....is like a guy born on an isolated island with no boat claiming "There are no other islands but mine!"

Gabe, I think it is human nature to think that everything about us is special and unique. I don't ascribe to that theory. However, my grandkids are prettier and smarter than any other kids. Some other grandparents don't think so, but I just try to humor them.
 
20+ light years away, and it's the only one with the POSSIBILITY of sustaining life in any type of animal form. Of course your definitive "BULLSHIT" response is purely theoretical. Human life may very well be exceptional to this planet alone in the universe, and if that doesn't stop to give you pause you're more closed-minded than you even realize.

I agree that human life may well be the exception. Neither of us knows, because neither of us has observed human life from another planet. What may or may not give me pause is not germane to any argument supporting ID. My "bullshit" call was merely a response to your statement of absolute esoteric theological knowledge that surpasses scientific observation.

We, as humans, have observed nothing beyond illusions to indicate the presence of an anthropomorphic deity among us, nor do we require the presence of one to explain our existence. That doesn't imply that God does not exist, only that God might not have any resemblance to our mythological archetypal image of God.

Insisting upon a prime mover to initiate creation is a losing argument, because it leads you down the path to an infinity. If the Universe required a Creator, then why wouldn't the Creator require a Creator as well? If the Creator has a way out of that one, then so does the Universe. The only solution is eternity. The Universe has always existed and always will. There was no Alpha and there will be no Omega. Those concepts are merely illusions created by our temporal nature as humans. Everything is infinite, and Nothing doesn't exist.
 
youre trying to convince a child that your beliefs are truth rather than letting the child be made aware of all of the beliefs and someday make its own decisions. a child will always expect that the parent will know what is true and will accept whatever it is told as gospel. thats brainwashing


Honestly, gabriel, children would not thrive in this world without being brainwashed by their parents. The kids just have to hope that the ones brainwashing them love them as well and brainwash them wisely.
 
Back
Top