Dino...that's like a Cherokee or Apache in 1491 saying "There are no other people but red men like us."
@RC #54: Wait, someone asked what is truth once, before . . . if only I could remember . . . .
I suggest it is the parents' job, initially, to teach what they understand the truth to be to the child.
@gabriel: I am trying to see what you mean. I do not see how a parent teaching a child what the parent believes to be true could be brainwashing, as I understand it. Feel free to ignore, of course; no obligation.
@ red cloud and gabriel: See, I think we actually all substantially agree. I do not think the parent is ever going to convince a child of the truth of a religious belief (into adulthood) unless the parent really lives the faith. Gabriel (and RedCloud too), I think we agree that the parent should teach the truth as the parent understands it, but we disagree as to what that truth is (would our hypothetical agnostic parent be "brainwashing" as to agnoticism from a christian perspective?).
GG, you are right. I'm afraid that another intelligent alien civilization will discover "us," and we will go the way of the red man.
Not sure about that....any advanced civilization doesn't "need Earth" for "breathing room". Nano-technology would provide them a Utopia of endless resources and Space itself all the "room for colonization" they'd ever want.
More likely they would AVOID us...fearful of their technology (if some form of interstellar drive) falling into our hands....but with a similar analogy to American Indians in that, if the Spanish had considered the true strategic advantages of allowing the HORSE to fall into the hands of the Indians....they would have slaughtered them (the horses) upon setting foot in North America, given it was a key advantage in technology that prolonged the Indians' attempt at repulsing white settlers.
Way off topic now...but a good one for another thread. As for Dino's assertion....it would only work if we had a good, EXTENSIVE capacity for detailed examination of dozens, if not hundreds of stellar bodies and potential "Earth-like" planets.
To claim Earth as "special"...just because we have "found no other like it"....is like a guy born on an isolated island with no boat claiming "There are no other islands but mine!"
well rather than risk YOUR TRUTH as YOU believe it i wont send pictures of MY grandkids!! lol
20+ light years away, and it's the only one with the POSSIBILITY of sustaining life in any type of animal form. Of course your definitive "BULLSHIT" response is purely theoretical. Human life may very well be exceptional to this planet alone in the universe, and if that doesn't stop to give you pause you're more closed-minded than you even realize.
youre trying to convince a child that your beliefs are truth rather than letting the child be made aware of all of the beliefs and someday make its own decisions. a child will always expect that the parent will know what is true and will accept whatever it is told as gospel. thats brainwashing