New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Cut Egypt off.

Jen

Senator
I am not a huge McCain fan. I have been disagreeing with him a lot lately. But on this issue I am in agreement with him.

We need to cut off aid to Egypt. Now.

LINK

McCain, a member of the Senate’s Foreign Relations Committee, on Friday called for the United States to suspend its $1.5 billion in annual aid, based on long-standing federal law that prohibits the U.S. from giving aid to countries in which a military coup overthrows a democratically elected government.

I agree with McCain that Morsi hasn't exactly been a stellar leader for Egypt, but we need to wait and see if they hold elections or if something else takes place.
 
I suppose that I can imagine why some would argue that throwing little tantrums in response to world events amounts to smart diplomacy.

I can imagine it, but I can't understand the logic that would lead one to maintain such a position.
 
I am not a huge McCain fan. I have been disagreeing with him a lot lately. But on this issue I am in agreement with him.

We need to cut off aid to Egypt. Now.

LINK

I agree with McCain that Morsi hasn't exactly been a stellar leader for Egypt, but we need to wait and see if they hold elections or if something else takes place.

I'm confused by the top post. Should we cut ties with Egypt now or should we wait in case they hold elections?

For what it's worth, I'll agree that the removal of Morsi was a coup. Since that's the case, then the law is clear regarding aid to Egypt.

The problem is that cutting off aid to Egypt because the military overthrew the elected government isn't what the foreign policy establishment wants, and it goes against decades of US policy.

Their policy has been to ally the US with the Egyptian military as the ultimate power broker in Egypt. This was true under Sadat, Mubarak, Morsi and now Mansour -- the extent to which these regimes were or weren't democratic not being the operative point to the policy of allying US interests with the Egyptian military.

Since 1978, the US policy has been to provide military assistance to Egypt in return for Egypt's guarantee of the Camp David Accords.
 
Reading the article would have dispelled your confusion.
We need to cut ties now and resume them if and when a legal election is held and the new legally elected president is installed.

Our policy of supporting Egypt clearly stated that if their military overthrew the government we no longer had to send that support so we would be within the guidelines of that support.

Our withdrawal of funds should encourage them to get their next leader the right way instead of just allowing whatever group holds the power to install their guy and that is why I support the withdrawal of our money.


I'm confused by the top post. Should we cut ties with Egypt now or should we wait in case they hold elections?

For what it's worth, I'll agree that the removal of Morsi was a coup. Since that's the case, then the law is clear regarding aid to Egypt.

The problem is that cutting off aid to Egypt because the military overthrew the elected government isn't what the foreign policy establishment wants, and it goes against decades of US policy.

Their policy has been to ally the US with the Egyptian military as the ultimate power broker in Egypt. This was true under Sadat, Mubarak, Morsi and now Mansour -- the extent to which these regimes were or weren't democratic not being the operative point to the policy of allying US interests with the Egyptian military.

Since 1978, the US policy has been to provide military assistance to Egypt in return for Egypt's guarantee of the Camp David Accords.
 
I am not a huge McCain fan. I have been disagreeing with him a lot lately. But on this issue I am in agreement with him.

We need to cut off aid to Egypt. Now.

LINK



I agree with McCain that Morsi hasn't exactly been a stellar leader for Egypt, but we need to wait and see if they hold elections or if something else takes place.




First off, the law:

SEC. 508. None of the funds appropriated or otherwise made available pursuant to this Act shall be obligated or expended to finance directly any assistance to any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup or decree: Provided, That assistance may be resumed to such country if the President determines and reports to the Committees on Appropriations that subsequent to the termination of assistance a democratically elected government has taken office.

Source: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/cpque...r_n=hr825.105&db_id=105&item=&sel=TOC_564277&




I confess, part of me likes that. I also realize, however, that no money means no influence, and if Egypt is not getting money from us, they'll shop elsewhere. Given that they control access to the Suez Canal, I would think nations such as China or Russia would happily fill the void.

Just something to think about.
 
First off, the law:

SEC. 508. None of the funds appropriated or otherwise made available pursuant to this Act shall be obligated or expended to finance directly any assistance to any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup or decree: Provided, That assistance may be resumed to such country if the President determines and reports to the Committees on Appropriations that subsequent to the termination of assistance a democratically elected government has taken office.

Source: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/cpque...r_n=hr825.105&db_id=105&item=&sel=TOC_564277&




I confess, part of me likes that. I also realize, however, that no money means no influence, and if Egypt is not getting money from us, they'll shop elsewhere. Given that they control access to the Suez Canal, I would think nations such as China or Russia would happily fill the void.

Just something to think about.

ZZ, you seem to be an adherent of the old adage, "Look before you leap." A lot of armchair Generals have an immediate solution for any problem. We went through eight years of that and are still paying the price.
 
ZZ, you seem to be an adherent of the old adage, "Look before you leap." A lot of armchair Generals have an immediate solution for any problem. We went through eight years of that and are still paying the price.

Good point, ZamZam. Looks like our hands are tied and we have no leverage. We bribe them, they blackmail us.o_O
 
Good point, ZamZam. Looks like our hands are tied and we have no leverage. We bribe them, they blackmail us.o_O
The old adage on Wall Street is "Buy low, sell high." This may be an opportunity to buy - influence, that is - in Egypt. They need the money:

Egypt can ill afford to lose foreign aid. The country appears headed for a looming funding crunch unless it can quickly access money from overseas. The local currency has lost 11 percent of its value since late last year.

The governor of Egypt's central bank, Hisham Ramez, flew to Abu Dhabi on Sunday, officials at Cairo airport said, following Egyptian media reports Cairo was seeking financial aid from Gulf states after Mursi's removal.

Egypt's foreign reserves fell $1.12 billion in June to $14.92 billion, representing less than three months of imports.

Only about half are in the form of cash or in securities that can easily be spent, and the IMF considers three months to be the minimum safe cushion for reserves.



http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/07/08/us-egypt-protests-idUSBRE95Q0NO20130708



The trick, of course, is to back the right pony. Historically, we haven't always been too good at that.
 
Back
Top