New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Dangerous minorities

Arkady

President
We have a few racist posters here who troll the Internet looking for any isolated incidents of racial minorities behaving badly to share with the group. Sometimes it's petty misbehavior, sometimes serious. Past examples include a guy who punched a cashier and a woman who splashed her kid in a swimming pool. But, in the big picture, all of them pale in importance relative to the impact another dangerous minority is having on all of us. I speak of the Tea Party Republicans.

First, realize what a small minority they are. Republicans lost the presidency and the Senate, but took the House despite having fewer votes than Democrats, due to gerrymandering. But the present shutdown isn't even the work of all those House Republicans. If Boehner had allowed a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote it would have passed, with the help of a number of Republicans... which is the whole reason he blocked it from coming to a vote. It's only a subset of the Republicans who wanted to put their heel on the throat of America so they could start making demands, but Boehner empowered them. So, we're two degrees removed from our majoritarian principles: gerrymandering lets a corrupt Speaker of the House take power, and then he blocks majority rule even in that body, so a dangerous minority can make ransom demands.

There's a great Teaching Company lecture series about the history of Ancient Rome. It's 24 hours of lectures covering everything from the mythic foundation to the ultimate collapse. The lectures concerning the crises that precipitated the fall of the Republic focus largely on the concept that part of what went wrong is that politicians started ignoring traditions and instead using their powers to the maximum possible effect, heedless of the consequences. If someone had the theoretical power to block all the business of the state until he got his way, he'd do it, even if countless generations of Romans who held that power before him had refused to use that power in such a way. Those lectures keep coming back to me now, for obvious reasons. Politicians in this country ALWAYS had the theoretical power to do what the Tea Party minority is now doing. For example, progressives could have refused to allow a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote in the Bush years, shutting down government unless he agreed to raise taxes on the rich, or to pull troops from Iraq. But that's just not how things are done. Tradition dictates that even if minorities theoretically have the power to derail our whole government if their demands aren't met, they don't do so. If Republicans are willing to dispense with that tradition, things don't look good for our Republic. Fortunately, it looks like Reid and Obama are willing to stand up for principle this time. The dangerous Tea Party minority has to be taught a lesson before it's too late.
 
We have a few racist posters here who troll the Internet looking for any isolated incidents of racial minorities behaving badly to share with the group. Sometimes it's petty misbehavior, sometimes serious. Past examples include a guy who punched a cashier and a woman who splashed her kid in a swimming pool. But, in the big picture, all of them pale in importance relative to the impact another dangerous minority is having on all of us. I speak of the Tea Party Republicans.

First, realize what a small minority they are. Republicans lost the presidency and the Senate, but took the House despite having fewer votes than Democrats, due to gerrymandering. But the present shutdown isn't even the work of all those House Republicans. If Boehner had allowed a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote it would have passed, with the help of a number of Republicans... which is the whole reason he blocked it from coming to a vote. It's only a subset of the Republicans who wanted to put their heel on the throat of America so they could start making demands, but Boehner empowered them. So, we're two degrees removed from our majoritarian principles: gerrymandering lets a corrupt Speaker of the House take power, and then he blocks majority rule even in that body, so a dangerous minority can make ransom demands.

There's a great Teaching Company lecture series about the history of Ancient Rome. It's 24 hours of lectures covering everything from the mythic foundation to the ultimate collapse. The lectures concerning the crises that precipitated the fall of the Republic focus largely on the concept that part of what went wrong is that politicians started ignoring traditions and instead using their powers to the maximum possible effect, heedless of the consequences. If someone had the theoretical power to block all the business of the state until he got his way, he'd do it, even if countless generations of Romans who held that power before him had refused to use that power in such a way. Those lectures keep coming back to me now, for obvious reasons. Politicians in this country ALWAYS had the theoretical power to do what the Tea Party minority is now doing. For example, progressives could have refused to allow a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote in the Bush years, shutting down government unless he agreed to raise taxes on the rich, or to pull troops from Iraq. But that's just not how things are done. Tradition dictates that even if minorities theoretically have the power to derail our whole government if their demands aren't met, they don't do so. If Republicans are willing to dispense with that tradition, things don't look good for our Republic. Fortunately, it looks like Reid and Obama are willing to stand up for principle this time. The dangerous Tea Party minority has to be taught a lesson before it's too late.

Perfect example of "approved lefty target acquisition". Aside from the silly rhetoric here, I would also suggest that any "racists" who post of "minorities behaving badly" are - at least - assuring that there is bad behavior to report. When such a time arrives that these folks post about these particular minorities doing good things and suggest that they are bad, I'll take issue with them. However, a criminal is a criminal is a criminal. No sacred cows here. Lefties need to learn that no one gets hands-off treatment. Clearly, based on your posts, minority races and homosexuals are extraordinarily dear to you - while Christians and rural folks are backward savages. That's some of your selective tolerance at work. Everyone believes that their target selection is the optimum blend. Christians are superstitious and the character of their God as revealed in their very Bible itself betrays an unjust, jealous, evil character. Right? I've seen you pen such thoughts and paint an entire group of billions with no regard to care and respect. So it goes with the unsophisticated porch-sitters sipping from a mason jar in rural areas...why can't they be more like Bay State highbrows?

Every day this board is littered with bigoted posts versus one group or another. We selectively tolerate and even trade in bigotry regarding certain groups based on ideological alignment. YOU do this Arkady. Nearly everyone here does this. Your particular sensibility is not the standard. Minorities of all kinds are great. Liberals and conservatives are great. Rural folks and faithful people are great.

Painful eh? :)

Now, about those congressional "terrorists".

I agree they need to observe process. This is true. Up or down votes always. Let's remember this irrespective of who or what is on the chopping block - policy-wise, appointees, etc. Let us be consistent rather than selective. I'm with you here.
 
Perfect example of "approved lefty target acquisition". Aside from the silly rhetoric here, I would also suggest that any "racists" who post of "minorities behaving badly" are - at least - assuring that there is bad behavior to report. When such a time arrives that these folks post about these particular minorities doing good things and suggest that they are bad, I'll take issue with them. However, a criminal is a criminal is a criminal. No sacred cows here. Lefties need to learn that no one gets hands-off treatment. Clearly, based on your posts, minority races and homosexuals are extraordinarily dear to you - while Christians and rural folks are backward savages. That's some of your selective tolerance at work. Everyone believes that their target selection is the optimum blend. Christians are superstitious and the character of their God as revealed in their very Bible itself betrays an unjust, jealous, evil character. Right? I've seen you pen such thoughts and paint an entire group of billions with no regard to care and respect. So it goes with the unsophisticated porch-sitters sipping from a mason jar in rural areas...why can't they be more like Bay State highbrows?

Every day this board is littered with bigoted posts versus one group or another. We selectively tolerate and even trade in bigotry regarding certain groups based on ideological alignment. YOU do this Arkady. Nearly everyone here does this. Your particular sensibility is not the standard. Minorities of all kinds are great. Liberals and conservatives are great. Rural folks and faithful people are great.

Painful eh? :)

Now, about those congressional "terrorists".

I agree they need to observe process. This is true. Up or down votes always. Let's remember this irrespective of who or what is on the chopping block - policy-wise, appointees, etc. Let us be consistent rather than selective. I'm with you here.

Our high tech, multi-tasking society has created a lot of insecurities in people. Perhaps that's why there is so much intolerance and bigotry that goes on these days. So many people have to feel that they're above somebody else.
 
You need to 'teach a lesson' to those who disagree with you politically? Care to tell us what that 'lesson' would include?
Sure. The lesson would be that these tactics will not produce concessions. Once they learn that lesson, they'll stop using the tactic. Unfortunately, Obama spent years teaching them the opposite lesson, by giving them countless concessions during prior stand offs of this type. So, it will be hard for them to unlearn that expectation.
 
Our high tech, multi-tasking society has created a lot of insecurities in people. Perhaps that's why there is so much intolerance and bigotry that goes on these days. So many people have to feel that they're above somebody else.
Yep. I think part of it is human nature and insecurity, but it's also nurtured culturally (we want people to be like us) and politically (our miserable pols have us right where they want us - at each other's throats...keeps the focus off of them and enables a basic divide and conquer electoral strategy).

To be fully honest, though, the prospect of uber-unity is somewhat scary. I'm not arguing that bigotries are good - but to an extent they dilute our excesses and our abilities to over-indulge passions.
 
Perfect example of "approved lefty target acquisition". Aside from the silly rhetoric here, I would also suggest that any "racists" who post of "minorities behaving badly" are - at least - assuring that there is bad behavior to report. When such a time arrives that these folks post about these particular minorities doing good things and suggest that they are bad, I'll take issue with them. However, a criminal is a criminal is a criminal. No sacred cows here. Lefties need to learn that no one gets hands-off treatment. Clearly, based on your posts, minority races and homosexuals are extraordinarily dear to you - while Christians and rural folks are backward savages. That's some of your selective tolerance at work. Everyone believes that their target selection is the optimum blend. Christians are superstitious and the character of their God as revealed in their very Bible itself betrays an unjust, jealous, evil character. Right? I've seen you pen such thoughts and paint an entire group of billions with no regard to care and respect. So it goes with the unsophisticated porch-sitters sipping from a mason jar in rural areas...why can't they be more like Bay State highbrows?

Every day this board is littered with bigoted posts versus one group or another. We selectively tolerate and even trade in bigotry regarding certain groups based on ideological alignment. YOU do this Arkady. Nearly everyone here does this. Your particular sensibility is not the standard. Minorities of all kinds are great. Liberals and conservatives are great. Rural folks and faithful people are great.

Painful eh? :)

Now, about those congressional "terrorists".

I agree they need to observe process. This is true. Up or down votes always. Let's remember this irrespective of who or what is on the chopping block - policy-wise, appointees, etc. Let us be consistent rather than selective. I'm with you here.

With a nation this large, there will always be examples for the bigots to choose from. I could, of course, do the same thing, if I had that mentality. Every time some jackass who happened to be Christian threw a sucker punch or committed some fraud, I could first-tier post a "Christians Behaving Badly" item. And given the number of Christians in this country, and the universal fallibility of human nature, I'd never lack for material. But, as you know, I don't do that. When someone who happens to be Christian does something bad, with no reference to his Christianity and no obvious link to it, I'd find it absurd to highlight his Christianity in order to smear all his co-religionists. The same with rural people. Every day rural people, like urban people, commit all manner of horrible acts. I can't think of a single time that I dug one of these items out of some obscure crime blotter and first-tier posted it with a reference to the perpetrator being a rural person. But that's just what we see here with the "blacks behaving badly" racists, when it comes to digging up instances of bad behavior by people who happen to be black and first-tier posting it while calling attention to their race.
 
With a nation this large, there will always be examples for the bigots to choose from. I could, of course, do the same thing, if I had that mentality. Every time some jackass who happened to be Christian threw a sucker punch or committed some fraud, I could first-tier post a "Christians Behaving Badly" item. And given the number of Christians in this country, and the universal fallibility of human nature, I'd never lack for material. But, as you know, I don't do that. When someone who happens to be Christian does something bad, with no reference to his Christianity and no obvious link to it, I'd find it absurd to highlight his Christianity in order to smear all his co-religionists. The same with rural people. Every day rural people, like urban people, commit all manner of horrible acts. I can't think of a single time that I dug one of these items out of some obscure crime blotter and first-tier posted it with a reference to the perpetrator being a rural person. But that's just what we see here with the "blacks behaving badly" racists, when it comes to digging up instances of bad behavior by people who happen to be black and first-tier posting it while calling attention to their race.
Ok, so if these "racists" were to cease the incremental "behaving badly posts" and instead spool it up to a larger group indictment platform that lumps the entirety together as you do - then it's swell.

10-4.

:-/
 
Ok, so if these "racists" were to cease the incremental "behaving badly posts" and instead spool it up to a larger group indictment platform that lumps the entirety together as you do - then it's swell.

10-4.

:-/
If they want to make an indictment of people based on the ideological content of the choices the people make (e.g., people who choose to join Al Qaeda, the Nazi Party, or the Christian faith), that's perfectly legitimate. If we can't criticize people based on their choices, that would be very strange indeed.
 
If they want to make an indictment of people based on the ideological content of the choices the people make (e.g., people who choose to join Al Qaeda, the Nazi Party, or the Christian faith), that's perfectly legitimate. If we can't criticize people based on their choices, that would be very strange indeed.
So, since many Christians believe differently than others about even baseline material (heaven, hell, purgatory, singular or multiple paths to God, Sabbath day) they can nonetheless be telescoped and indicted as a grouping. However, if large segments of a minority conduct criminal acts as a comparative percentage - this cannot be properly ratcheted to the larger group. Selective indeed. It is always different where a lefty's sensibilities and conduct are concerned.

For the record, I oppose grouping traits and criticizing/generalizing in both cases.
 
We have a few racist posters here who troll the Internet looking for any isolated incidents of racial minorities behaving badly to share with the group. Sometimes it's petty misbehavior, sometimes serious. Past examples include a guy who punched a cashier and a woman who splashed her kid in a swimming pool. But, in the big picture, all of them pale in importance relative to the impact another dangerous minority is having on all of us. I speak of the Tea Party Republicans.

First, realize what a small minority they are. Republicans lost the presidency and the Senate, but took the House despite having fewer votes than Democrats, due to gerrymandering. But the present shutdown isn't even the work of all those House Republicans. If Boehner had allowed a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote it would have passed, with the help of a number of Republicans... which is the whole reason he blocked it from coming to a vote. It's only a subset of the Republicans who wanted to put their heel on the throat of America so they could start making demands, but Boehner empowered them. So, we're two degrees removed from our majoritarian principles: gerrymandering lets a corrupt Speaker of the House take power, and then he blocks majority rule even in that body, so a dangerous minority can make ransom demands.

There's a great Teaching Company lecture series about the history of Ancient Rome. It's 24 hours of lectures covering everything from the mythic foundation to the ultimate collapse. The lectures concerning the crises that precipitated the fall of the Republic focus largely on the concept that part of what went wrong is that politicians started ignoring traditions and instead using their powers to the maximum possible effect, heedless of the consequences. If someone had the theoretical power to block all the business of the state until he got his way, he'd do it, even if countless generations of Romans who held that power before him had refused to use that power in such a way. Those lectures keep coming back to me now, for obvious reasons. Politicians in this country ALWAYS had the theoretical power to do what the Tea Party minority is now doing. For example, progressives could have refused to allow a clean continuing resolution to come to a vote in the Bush years, shutting down government unless he agreed to raise taxes on the rich, or to pull troops from Iraq. But that's just not how things are done. Tradition dictates that even if minorities theoretically have the power to derail our whole government if their demands aren't met, they don't do so. If Republicans are willing to dispense with that tradition, things don't look good for our Republic. Fortunately, it looks like Reid and Obama are willing to stand up for principle this time. The dangerous Tea Party minority has to be taught a lesson before it's too late.

Seems to me it flies both ways. I recall recently an instance of a man shooting an unarmed kid. (appropriately, it was described, quite thoroughly and incessantly, as a white man shooting a black kid).

That one person is white, and another black, or vice versa, or yellow, etc/..is irrelevant. Other than to push an agenda (racism, bigotry..)...and to state the obvious.

That a subfaction of the republican party is pushing an agenda (no clean resolution)...is a subject for rationed people to debate and discuss. The parties have made a mess of it, for sure, but that meme (rationed discussion) is not without merit.
 
What's funny is how they have to even oppress their OWN side.

The Sane Republicans (like Pete King, etc) want a vote on a "clean CR"....but the Tea Partyers won't allow it because they know it'll pass with a good number of GOP votes.

Apparently voting and representative government?...are BAD for the Tea Party agenda.
 
So, since many Christians believe differently than others about even baseline material (heaven, hell, purgatory, singular or multiple paths to God, Sabbath day) they can nonetheless be telescoped and indicted as a grouping. However, if large segments of a minority conduct criminal acts as a comparative percentage - this cannot be properly ratcheted to the larger group. Selective indeed. It is always different where a lefty's sensibilities and conduct are concerned.

For the record, I oppose grouping traits and criticizing/generalizing in both cases.
No. Christians can all, of course, be indicted for the absurdity in believing in certain key supernatural things without any significant evidence, since those beliefs are the definition of Christianity. But as far the variations beyond that core, the indictments only apply to those who believe such things. For example, a Christian who doesn't believe in Hell could not, obviously, be faulted for the horrific belief that a perfect God would create such a system of eternal torture.

Any attempt to draw parallels between that and people who try to indict all minorities on the basis of having similar physical characteristics as some people who did terrible things isn't going to hold together well. You're struggling to create a false equivalence here. There is not, so far as I'm aware, a lefty equivalent here of the right-wingers who post their "blacks behaving badly" material. I'm not even sure there's an equivalent of the "Muslims behaving badly" posts .
 
What's funny is how they have to even oppress their OWN side.

The Sane Republicans (like Pete King, etc) want a vote on a "clean CR"....but the Tea Partyers won't allow it because they know it'll pass with a good number of GOP votes.

Apparently voting and representative government?...are BAD for the Tea Party agenda.
The sane Republicans should make a deal with the Democrats to elect one of the sane Republicans to the Speakership. With Democratic help, they'd have the numbers. Boehner's fear of the Tea Party is a huge part of the problem here.
 
No. Christians can all, of course, be indicted for the absurdity in believing in certain key supernatural things without any significant evidence, since those beliefs are the definition of Christianity. But as far the variations beyond that core, the indictments only apply to those who believe such things. For example, a Christian who doesn't believe in Hell could not, obviously, be faulted for the horrific belief that a perfect God would create such a system of eternal torture.

Any attempt to draw parallels between that and people who try to indict all minorities on the basis of having similar physical characteristics as some people who did terrible things isn't going to hold together well. You're struggling to create a false equivalence here. There is not, so far as I'm aware, a lefty equivalent here of the right-wingers who post their "blacks behaving badly" material. I'm not even sure there's an equivalent of the "Muslims behaving badly" posts .


a majority of the world population believes in such supernatural things...absent evidence. such is the nature of faith. and the resulting indictments..far reaching.
 
No. Christians can all, of course, be indicted for the absurdity in believing in certain key supernatural things without any significant evidence, since those beliefs are the definition of Christianity. But as far the variations beyond that core, the indictments only apply to those who believe such things. For example, a Christian who doesn't believe in Hell could not, obviously, be faulted for the horrific belief that a perfect God would create such a system of eternal torture.

Any attempt to draw parallels between that and people who try to indict all minorities on the basis of having similar physical characteristics as some people who did terrible things isn't going to hold together well. You're struggling to create a false equivalence here. There is not, so far as I'm aware, a lefty equivalent here of the right-wingers who post their "blacks behaving badly" material. I'm not even sure there's an equivalent of the "Muslims behaving badly" posts .
Really? Not even among the lefties who top post about TEA Party atrocities every time there's a mass shooting?
 
No. Christians can all, of course, be indicted for the absurdity in believing in certain key supernatural things without any significant evidence, since those beliefs are the definition of Christianity. But as far the variations beyond that core, the indictments only apply to those who believe such things. For example, a Christian who doesn't believe in Hell could not, obviously, be faulted for the horrific belief that a perfect God would create such a system of eternal torture.

Any attempt to draw parallels between that and people who try to indict all minorities on the basis of having similar physical characteristics as some people who did terrible things isn't going to hold together well. You're struggling to create a false equivalence here. There is not, so far as I'm aware, a lefty equivalent here of the right-wingers who post their "blacks behaving badly" material. I'm not even sure there's an equivalent of the "Muslims behaving badly" posts .
Not really. Tell me, how are homosexuals defined? Appearance? Physical traits? Or is it, perhaps, a set of common behaviors and with whom they choose to identify, interact, and associate?

I...errr...uhhh...it's ok because my targets are sophisticated lefty approved.

Can you get a U-L logo on that?
 
There is demonstrable blindness here.


Christians are an easy mark. by proxy, I assume Buddists, Taoists, Lutherans, dare I say Muslims, Orthox, and many, many other denominations of faith are fair game, too.
 
Christians are an easy mark. by proxy, I assume Buddists, Taoists, Lutherans, dare I say Muslims, Orthox, and many, many other denominations of faith are fair game, too.
Good times.

And, in truth, I don't object. I just wish that those who do this would simply admit that they, too, have and assert bigotries...enthusiastically in fact.

Some just can't do it. They excuse it on the grounds that their targets are good ones.
 
Back
Top