New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Demonizing Vladimir Putin

This is why although some may assume it as pissy/snarky to describe Putin as a czar, but we HAVE to consider Putin within the context of a "czar", rather than of a democratically elected president the way we understand one to be.

We learn about our current presidents by comparing and contrasting them with prior presidents. We'd be foolish to think we'd learn anything by comparing Putin with our prior presidents - and vice versa.
Exactly right. Russia has no history of democracy. And even more profoundly, no history of exposure to the Enlightenment. Russia in 1917 was a feudal, agrarian, Russian Orthodox based country that had more in common with France of 1700 than it did with France of 1917. And after 80 years of Communist serfdom, it was somewhat technologically advanced, but shares way less of a worldview with us than our totalitarian leftwing universalists would like.
 
Exactly right. Russia has no history of democracy. And even more profoundly, no history of exposure to the Enlightenment. Russia in 1917 was a feudal, agrarian, Russian Orthodox based country that had more in common with France of 1700 than it did with France of 1917. And after 80 years of Communist serfdom, it was somewhat technoligically advanced, but shares way less of a worldview with us than our totalitarian leftwing universalists would like.

I read an interesting piece about why even as Russia is SO corrupt and "f"-ed up, the Russian people don't seem to hold Putin accountable. Evidently, that's somewhat the Russian norm. They don't blame Putin (the czar). They take it for granted that he only wants the best for him. They blame everbody in guvmint, BUT the czar.
 
I read an interesting piece about why even as Russia is SO corrupt and "f"-ed up, the Russian people don't seem to hold Putin accountable. Evidently, that's somewhat the Russian norm. They don't blame Putin (the czar). They take it for granted that he only wants the best for him. They blame everbody in guvmint, BUT the czar.
Correct again..........Russia has a secular czar in Putin. This is the psychological archetype Russian civilization has worked off of since Kievan Rus.
The fact that our modern yuppies at the White House have no info whatsoever on this guarantees that they will have a shallow and superficial perspective which ultimately endangers all US citizens.
And that's where we're at.
 
Correct again..........Russia has a secular czar in Putin. This is the psychological archetype Russian civilization has worked off of since Kievan Rus.
The fact that our modern yuppies at the White House have no info whatsoever on this guarantees that they will have a shallow and superficial perspective which ultimately endangers all US citizens.
And that's where we're at.

I'll actually argue that the Obamans are putting Putin in BETTER perspective than did most prior American presidents - GOP or Dem, as regards prior Russian leaders.
 
I'll actually argue that the Obamans are putting Putin in BETTER perspective than did most prior American presidents - GOP or Dem, as regards prior Russian leaders.
Could be a reasonable assertion. But I think Europe long ago should have invited Russia into the EU as a member in progress kind of thing.
 
I'll actually argue that the Obamans are putting Putin in BETTER perspective than did most prior American presidents - GOP or Dem, as regards prior Russian leaders.
You got a lot of things right on this thread.....but this isn't one of them.
The way to deal with Russia is to do business with them where you can.....but don't preach or moralize to them. If Russia wants a law against homosexuality........let them have it. They're gonna do it anyway.
Bush fucked up on this as well....bigtime. In 2004 one of the worst atrocities in modern times occured. The Beslan School Massacre. Roughly 370 school kids slaughtered by Chechen Muslim terrorists. Most of these kids were only children so their families had not a single child after their death.
Bush lectured Putin on not being overly harsh in exacting justice from the Chechen Muslims after all the retribution we were exacting on the Taliban in Afghanistan(which was completely justified).
We should have told Vlad behind closed doors.........kill all the Muslims you need to kill to make things right. Vlad would be our friend today.
 
You got a lot of things right on this thread.....but this isn't one of them.
The way to deal with Russia is to do business with them where you can.....but don't preach or moralize to them. If Russia wants a law against homosexuality........let them have it. They're gonna do it anyway.
Bush fucked up on this as well....bigtime. In 2004 one of the worst atrocities in modern times occured. The Beslan School Massacre. Roughly 370 school kids slaughtered by Chechen Muslim terrorists. Most of these kids were only children so their families had not a single child after their death.
Bush lectured Putin on not being overly harsh in exacting justice from the Chechen Muslims after all the retribution we were exacting on the Taliban in Afghanistan(which was completely justified).
We should have told Vlad behind closed doors.........kill all the Muslims you need to kill to make things right. Vlad would be our friend today.
they were killin chechnens , not muslims
 
You got a lot of things right on this thread.....but this isn't one of them.
The way to deal with Russia is to do business with them where you can.....but don't preach or moralize to them. If Russia wants a law against homosexuality........let them have it. They're gonna do it anyway.
Bush fucked up on this as well....bigtime. In 2004 one of the worst atrocities in modern times occured. The Beslan School Massacre. Roughly 370 school kids slaughtered by Chechen Muslim terrorists. Most of these kids were only children so their families had not a single child after their death.
Bush lectured Putin on not being overly harsh in exacting justice from the Chechen Muslims after all the retribution we were exacting on the Taliban in Afghanistan(which was completely justified).
We should have told Vlad behind closed doors.........kill all the Muslims you need to kill to make things right. Vlad would be our friend today.

I see what you're saying, but it's all relative (as they say). For instance from a historical perspective, the Obamans have been most restrained as to Ukraine/Crimea. He's in the position of having to do and say at least something, and what he's said and done is about the least he could've said and done.

Similar is true as to Putin's gay pogroms. Obama does not have the option of just outright ignoring the issue. But in terms of how he's actually responded? It's kind of hard to imagine how he could've done less, without actually doing nothing.

I doubt that if we had a Republican president, Putin would've chosen homophobia as is cause celebre. He would've chosen something else. He did what he did, as much as anything, to see how far he could goad Obama and the west. He didn't goad 'em very far.
 
I see what you're saying, but it's all relative (as they say). For instance from a historical perspective, the Obamans have been most restrained as to Ukraine/Crimea. He's in the position of having to do and say at least something, and what he's said and done is about the least he could've said and done.

Similar is true as to Putin's gay pogroms. Obama does not have the option of just outright ignoring the issue. But in terms of how he's actually responded? It's kind of hard to imagine how he could've done less, without actually doing nothing.

I doubt that if we had a Republican president, Putin would've chosen homophobia as is cause celebre. He would've chosen something else. He did what he did, as much as anything, to see how far he could goad Obama and the west. He didn't goad 'em very far.
In a sense you're right. Practically speaking, Obama has done very little vis a vis Russia. And that's the right approach. The grandstanding over gay rights displayed Obama's lack of understanding about how to approach Russia. Bush was even worse because the issues he miscalculated on were bigger and he blew a genuine opportunity to build a beneficial long term relationship with Russia.
The real moral of the story is, in my opinion, we may see things our way and they may see things theirs, but why do we always have to try to build a Tower of Babel where we integrate everyone into some universal framework for the glorification of Nimrod?
 
In a sense you're right. Practically speaking, Obama has done very little vis a vis Russia. And that's the right approach. The grandstanding over gay rights displayed Obama's lack of understanding about how to approach Russia. Bush was even worse because the issues he miscalculated on were bigger and he blew a genuine opportunity to build a beneficial long term relationship with Russia.
The real moral of the story is, in my opinion, we may see things our way and they may see things theirs, but why do we always have to try to build a Tower of Babel where we integrate everyone into some universal framework for the glorification of Nimrod?
because youre the "essential nation" lol!!
 
What a strange day it is.
It only took 7 years..........but in one day.....I've agreed with Bo and now gabe.
besides, almost everything you said to fairsheet about russians, their mindset, their preferences and their leader are spot on
 
Back
Top