New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Demonizing Vladimir Putin

You're not very nice.

Am I not? Ah huh - I do all, in my own small amount of power, and shall do more in the years to come to help to leave others to find their own way and not cheer and whoopy as the bombs rain down on other people who have not done any harm to anyone other than be in the path of the US Corporates insatiable hunger.
 
well, the vote commit and we shall see what the people wish for in Crimea, appears they are being persecuted in Ukraine and here I thought compassionate liberals were against such happenings, of course, liberals talk out both sides of their mouths.

The UN doesn't recognize votes held under the military authority of an occupying nation, because they are too subject to manipulation by the occupying forces.
 
So Ukraine is in the hands of an unbridled dictator, pointing American supplied nukes at Russia and threatening to use them? Pretty sure we removed them by agreement 20 years ago. Talk of putting them back is now coming only from Ukraine just since the occupation.

Even the UK, who granted Grenada independence in 1974, criticized Reagan for invading. I won't defend him for breathing air good people could have been breathing. But they did end up having an elected government instead of one installed by a coup....or an occupying army.

How was their 'elected government' not installed by an occupying army, and how were the elections legitimate given the persecution of the New Jewel Movement's leaders?
 
Not really. We circled the USSR. Did we have to forcibly occupy any of the countries who wanted us to do so? Or were they enthusiastically grateful to have secure and finite borders after WW2? How about you Canucks? Did you resent NORAD flying armed bombers over your territory every day for 60 years? Seems like that would have been in the news somewhere.

The encirclement of Russia has intensified since the fall of the USSR. And of course the U.S. has had to forcibly occupy many countries (Afghanistan, Iraq, etc.), and in many others it was welcomed by the (corrupt, oppressive) government and not by the countries' people.
 
Actually we tried to help the Cubans invade...it was a bad idea for us and it is a bad idea for Putin.

The October Crisis came after the failure of the Bay of Pigs invasion ... at this point the U.S. attempted a direct invasion ... it was these plans for an invasion, culminating in the naval blockade that continues to this day, that convinced Castro to allow the Soviets to store missiles in Cuba ... then the Soviets double-crossed him by agreeing to pull the missiles out in exchange for the U.S. pulling its missiles out of Turkey and easing up on the blockade as it affected trade between Cuba and the Warsaw Pact countries.
 
Exactly right. Russia has no history of democracy. And even more profoundly, no history of exposure to the Enlightenment. Russia in 1917 was a feudal, agrarian, Russian Orthodox based country that had more in common with France of 1700 than it did with France of 1917. And after 80 years of Communist serfdom, it was somewhat technologically advanced, but shares way less of a worldview with us than our totalitarian leftwing universalists would like.

Russia, of course, does have a history of democracy ... the fight for democracy and the first constitution under the czars, the flowering of proletarian democracy in Lenin's time (and not only Lenin but also the liberal czars, e.g., Catherine the Great, did their best to introduce some of the positive elements of the Enlightenment to Russia), and the fight to maintain democracy in the face of the Stalinist and capitalist counterrevolutions.
 
Correct again..........Russia has a secular czar in Putin. This is the psychological archetype Russian civilization has worked off of since Kievan Rus.
The fact that our modern yuppies at the White House have no info whatsoever on this guarantees that they will have a shallow and superficial perspective which ultimately endangers all US citizens.
And that's where we're at.

To some extent, the rise of leaders like Stalin, Putin, etc., is a function of modern capitalism, the bureaucratic regime it spawns, and the modern class struggle that allows this regime to take on an independent political character by "mediating" between the opposing classes--a phenomenon similar to de Gaulle's rise to power in France, and sought after by some capitalist groups in the U.S. as well (e.g., the Perot vote in 1992 and 1996, or Giuliani's attempt to postpone elections in 2002). Now the rise of the czarist autocracy under, e.g., Ivan the Terrible went hand in hand with the political advance of the capitalist class as well, but that's kind of my point ... personal rule in Russia isn't some Asiaticism imported by 'Slavophiles' ... it is the response of a weak capitalist class everywhere, including in Europe, whereas liberal democracy is the luxury of a strong capitalist class.
 
You got a lot of things right on this thread.....but this isn't one of them.
The way to deal with Russia is to do business with them where you can.....but don't preach or moralize to them. If Russia wants a law against homosexuality........let them have it. They're gonna do it anyway.
Bush fucked up on this as well....bigtime. In 2004 one of the worst atrocities in modern times occured. The Beslan School Massacre. Roughly 370 school kids slaughtered by Chechen Muslim terrorists. Most of these kids were only children so their families had not a single child after their death.
Bush lectured Putin on not being overly harsh in exacting justice from the Chechen Muslims after all the retribution we were exacting on the Taliban in Afghanistan(which was completely justified).
We should have told Vlad behind closed doors.........kill all the Muslims you need to kill to make things right. Vlad would be our friend today.

The people killed by Chechen separatists numbered in the dozens, none of them schoolchildren. Nearly all those killed were killed by Russian security forces. Bush's most important statement in the wake of the attacks was that he stood "shoulder to shoulder" with Putin's government in the fight against "terrorism."
 
As usual, your knowledge of key historical events leaves much to be desired, ETR, and I have to put on my teacher's hat to educate you..again. Have you heard of Operation Northwoods? What was it about, and--who put a stop to it?

It was a plan for the CIA to stage terrorist attacks on the U.S. and blame it on Cuba as a pretext to invade that country. Kennedy stopped this particular program, while his administration carried out a number of other operations aimed at the eventual invasion of Cuba.
 
Last edited:
I grasp more than you know, old bean, and am much more rooted in reality. You, on the other hand, live in a dream world. Truth is, Ukraine is a buffer state, whether Ukranians like it or not; a buffer between Russia and the West. Putin or no Putin, Russia is not going to stand for the EU taking over the Ukraine in any shape or form. They have seen first-hand what NATO has done in Poland and the Czech Republic, and they are determined not to let it happen in Ukraine, right next door. It doesn't matter to them what the Ukranians want, or what the Ukranians think of Russia; it is a question of survival in Russian eyes. That is the reality.

In my view, the Ukranians have miscalculated badly in not following the recommendations of the EU ministers and wait for proper elections in December. They would have gotten rid of Yanukovych and had a new regime in place by January, 2015---without all this hassle. By forcing the issue on Yanukovych, without proper thought for the consequences, they gave Russia a pretext to do what it did. They don't even realize the precarious position they have put themselves in, with Russian troops on their border. They should have seen themselves for what they are, pawns in a Chess game. The EU doesn't give a damn for the Ukranians themselves; they simply want to expand their influence and complete their encirclement of Russia. If their present gambit does not work, they are certainly not going to go to war with Russia, so Ukranians can join the West and tell Russia to go F--k itself.

Perhaps the Ukrainians think they can fight a successful guerrilla war against Russia on their own, or convince the anti-Putin majority in Russia to come over to their side. Note that Russia was--for the military resources it had--most secure from attack under the leadership of Lenin, who rejected all great-power chauvinism and respected in theory and practice the right of minority nations to self-determination.
 
Funny thing....not one American on the beach captured by the Castro military. But you insist the leaders were not Cubans, but Americans.

Financed? Yes. Planned? Yes, the CIA did have a hand in it. So? How many revolutions had help from either Russia or China? How much help did the North Koreans get from Russia in starting the Korean War.

So supporting the poor and oppressed rising up against the rich and powerful is morally equivalent to supporting the rich trying to take back their privilege from the poor?
 
Is the Russian occupation of the Crimea a case of aggressive expansionism by Moscow, or aimed at at blocking a scheme by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) to roll right up to the Russia’s western border?

Russia's invasion of Ukraine makes it easier for NATO to assimilate Ukraine than anything else I can think of that Russia could possibly do.
 
Putin is not the Czar. There is no Czar, why do you always have to do that?

He did the best thing for Russia by staying, he gives continuity both to Russia and all those who deal with Russia politically.

'Order' has always been the watchword of reactionaries who used it to cover up their repression.
 
How so? There is not a Russian invasion of Crimea, journalists and foreign students there have searched for but have seen no more Russian troops then are always there with the Russian fleet, the Armed men are Crimean ex Police and ex Military recruited especially for and only for the referendum to keep the peace - There is going to be a referendum in the Crimea as to whether the people of Crimea want to split away from The Ukraine or not. The EU ( OSCE) have been invited to watch over said referendum. The Crimean Parliament has already written and passed an allowance for the Tartar minority to be given proportional representation and an assured amount of seats in the Parliament, the Tartars are happy with this.

Anything else?

There are 16,000 additional Russian regulars in Ukraine. There have been numerous fights between Tatars and pro-Russia ethnic Russians.
 
but canada was also stolen and yet they managed to avoid the worst failings of america. i once read it was because canada got the mainland scots and america got the ulster scots. a more curmudgeonly race never drew a breath!!

A lot of it's because the U.S. won the scramble to be the top dog worldwide.
 
There are 16,000 additional Russian regulars in Ukraine. There have been numerous fights between Tatars and pro-Russia ethnic Russians.

Prove the 16, ooo.

There had been fisty cuffs and argy bargys, what would you expect in such a time? The bill was rushed through a few days ago - The News about it is probably still in the RT, I linked it on here somewhere.
You really should read the 'other side' too to keep up a bit.
 
Back
Top