New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Demonizing Vladimir Putin

Funny how your slant on the events in Afghanistan make it seem like the Soviets were just reluctant participants in the whole 10 years of warfare....What is different between Afghanistan and the Soviets vs South Vietnam and the US?

There was a military coup in 1973 which deposed the king. There were massive demonstrations against the Daoud regime and in the end there was another military coup in 1978. A rebellion started against that regime with an attack on the military garrision in Nuristan. Amin seized power in September of 1979 after a shootout killed the President.

The Soviet invasion was not in support of a popular elected government....

To be clear, I think the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was unprincipled, thuggish, and reactionary ... although the specific motives differed, it was comparable in brutality, folly, and great-power arrogance to the American war in Vietnam.
 
The country didn't have a recognized government and the Taliban was not willing to turn over the suspects....
Actually, the Taliban offered to turn them over if the U.S. provided evidence of their involvement. The U.S. refused to do so. Contrast that to the case of Luis Posada Carriles:

luis carriles was tried in court and acquitted in 2011.
He was acquitted of lying to immigration agents. He was convicted, however, of attempting to assassinate Fidel Castro (for which he received a pardon from the president of Panama), and of various terrorist acts including the bombing of Cubana Airlines Flight 455. The U.S. has refused to allow him to be tried overseas, and as an agent of the CIA he is protected in the U.S.
 
The problem with the American public is they never get a chance to see what is unfolding on the other side of the fence. They are held in a tight propaganda cocoon, causing them to support the most heinous of deeds by their Jewish-run government, and incurring the wrath of the world's nations. It is inconceivable to them, for example, that Vladimir Putin could be the good guy in this Ukraine scenario, and that our banker rulers, led by the First Family of
Evil (the Rothschilds), are after his hide because of what he has done to them in Russia and elsewhere.

Click here: Putin’s Purge Of The Rothschild Money Changers From Russia: Another Rothschild Goon Found Dead & Another Flees To

It is because of posts like this that we think your accusations of anti-Semitism against the new Ukrainian government smack of cynical opportunism.
 
you either believe in democracy or you dont. many of those guys suspended elections

I don't make a fetish of democracy, and particularly of bourgeois constitutional forms (which Yanukovich, btw, suspended when, using physical threats, he pressured the high court into suspending the 2004 constitutional amendments). The truest kind of democracy is socioeconomic democracy, which in the process of asserting itself often looks like mob rule to the unsympathetic eye.
 
it was a coup. am election was coming. bourgeois legality?? lol


Did parliament not have every right to remove him from office, under the 2004 constitution, whether an election was coming in several months or not? Was there not a history of rigged elections to contend with?
 
You are a strange mixture of both :) So am I I am not criticizing it is just funny sometimes never knowing from which angle you will come at anything.

Though I am beginning to understand you ;-)

Let me take the guesswork away. Hey, I'm not going to hide where I'm coming from. Theoretically, my positions can be deduced from the basic principle Marx and Engels laid out in the "Communist Manifesto":

The Communists are distinguished from the other working-class parties by this only: 1. In the national struggles of the proletarians of the different countries, they point out and bring to the front the common interests of the entire proletariat, independently of all nationality. 2. In the various stages of development which the struggle of the working class against the bourgeoisie has to pass through, they always and everywhere represent the interests of the movement as a whole.

Practically speaking, part of this means following the party line in my public agitation/propaganda, both in the majority of cases when I am in full agreement with my party, and in the occasional case where I think my party is wrong, because it is only by marching together in strict Bolshevik discipline under the leadership of a vanguard party that the working class can achieve success. I still have the responsibility to privately communicate my doubts to the party in cases of disagreement, to choose the right party (a party that is communist in the sense described in the quote above), to recognize if this party has gone over to the side of reaction and abandon it in such a case, and to maintain an independent political attitude in the absence of any such party.

I do believe that there is a revolutionary vanguard party in the U.S., which has demonstrated its mettle for over 75 years in a variety of critical political situations. This party is the Socialist Workers' Party, which preserved the best traditions of the Communist Party as that party itself took the first steps down the road to reaction. This party is united by a common political trajectory, if not formally, with other parties around the world including the Communist League in the UK. And as long as the SWP remains a revolutionary party in my eyes, the political opinion you see me express on these forums will be the SWP line.
 
Putin is Stalin's GPU/KGB without the Communist Party. His Russia is the USSR without egalitarianism.

He has murdered 100 million too has he? I hate communism with all my being - it cannot work, the ideal is a spiritual one and can only work on that basis, politics ain't spiritual but that aside - how does one bring such a large country out of such a place as Russia found herself in when 'the wall came down'?
I was there when it came down with all my idealism about peoples freedoms and so on, what did most want? Things, they only wanted things -

What an impossibility for such a huge amount of peoples and in a country burdened down with debt - Putin paid off that debt in 6 years - For all Russians to throw out their old furniture and buy new from the West - new western cars, cloths electrical equipment - and so on - It seems to me to be rather a practical problem -

Putin is not Stalin, though they do say there are more gulags now than before so it seems does the US have more prisons than before -
 
safe_image.php
 


A copy of the 16 March ballot paper - released by the Crimean parliament - appears to give voters two choices: to join Russia immediately or become independent and, possibly, join Russia later.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-26514797

Has America ever had a referendum? Lol, they are always like this -

They are at the moment a part of the Ukraine, no? The referendum asks if they want to become independent or join Russia -
 
No he hasn't, Putin said in 2005 that the break up of the old USSR was a regret - he voiced nostalgia - I don't remember the whole of what he said so don't remember even in what context he said it.

I don't even begin to understand the mind set of a Russian head of State but since the KGB was the keeper of the only system they had one cannot put a man down for that alone - in fact who better than one from the workings of said KGB to understand Russia and how it works and how to bring her forward? Did you want it disbanded all together? Look what happened to Iraq when all authorities were disbanded, the whole place fell into chaos, is that what you think should have happened to Russia? The mind boggles!
He is not a dictator he has to ask and answer to others, he is Head of State - But I thought the same until recently but watching him recently I begin to see how he was probably right and has given a continuity which is only good for Russia domestically and internationally - Many countries have a Prez and a PM -

Russia has come out of a 'darkness; according to our way of thinking - shall we forever judge it on its past and darkest hour? OK then let us judge Cameron by Henry the VIII shall we? You will hear many from the ex USSR saying that things were better before, and will ask you 'what was wrong with communism?' if you are critical of it.

As for the last 50 years though America has been no bloody angel - and you know which link I would post to prove that - 'Killing Hope'

I've pointed out why Putin's motives are suspect. You turn that around to ask me if I want chaos in Russia....incredible logic there Queenie....

I've reminded you that Russia has invaded sovereign nations on a number of occasions. You say "America has been no bloody angel". So that makes the invasion of Afghanistan, Georgia, Chechnya and now Ukraine ok....

So far you've excused dictators like Hitler, Stalin, Milosevic, the leaders of North Korea and the terrorists attacking the US....all in search of something negative to say about the US. You are obviously incapable of honestly evaluating actions and motives.....
 
We don't really know what is in Poland - the open proposal was to have a 'missile defence shield' against Iran lol yes, that is what they said -Iran! But what is actually there we do not know - The US is sending war machines there now though.

But you turned that into "the US has nuclear missiles pointed at Russia"....and you don't see that as having been dishonest. You're laughable.
 
Back
Top