New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Diminishing Returns

MaryAnne

Governor
Those of us smart enough have been saying this for 30 years.Now,the lightbulb has come on for others.

awww.democraticunderground.com_avatars_opus.gif
Response to an article by Charles Krauthammer




Here is the article: "The Right-To-Work Dilemma"

Here is my response which I sent to him in an email:

Mr. Krauthammer,

In your first sentence you miss-state the over-all issue, an accommodation to reality. What happened in Michigan was a ham-handed execution of a lame-duck session of state government, to impart their will and not the will of the people. To do this, the legislature suspended rules, rammed through legislation without the normal processes and procedures normally put in place to allow input from all points of view. This speaks to a suspension of reality not an accommodation to it.

You speak of Globalization, however you did not include the fact that hordes of lobbyist worked to get tax breaks for American companies to essentially get paid for moving jobs out of America. Those same companies are now losing on their balance sheets because by under-cutting the American workforce, there are fewer Americans buying the company's foreign made goods. Globalization works when there is value placed on the worker and the worker is able to participate in the economic circle by having enough to buy the products. You cut that part out, as current corporate thinking goes, and you will destroy not only the American market, but the world market. The current corporate-think of cheap labor is a short-sighted one that even the staunch conservative Henry Ford didn't share. He believed you had to pay your workers enough to be able to buy the product. So much for cheap labor.

You stated "Angry protesters return" to a norm that doesn't exist today and hasn't existed for over twenty years, or more. What they were protesting about is being able to be at the negotiating table to see that the workers are a part of the decision-making process. Over the last twenty years, unions have given concessions in order to help keep businesses operating. There are many examples where management has taken advantage of this, Hostess comes to mind. They squandered the pension fund, money worker contributed, and even had the hubris to ask the bankruptcy court for payment on management bonuses.

When you compare the northern car companies to those of the south, you're comparing apples to oranges. The only reason there is a car manufacturing boon in the south is because foreign car manufacturers didn't want to pay the additional tax for vehicles not made in America. So, they researched where they could open the cheapest manufacturing here and the south won, oh not for it's level of intellect, but the amount of breaks the southern states gave these foreign manufacturers. These breaks, which the local people have to absorb by paying higher taxes to cover the taxes not being paid by these companies. The northern states, already having a manufacturing base felt they didn't need to lower their standards, and their tax base, in an attempt to lure these foreign companies. The right to work issue was just a bonus.

The reason Detroit went bankrupt was because of management deciding to not listen to market forces and stop building SUV's and gigantic gas-guzzlers when Americans were asking for higher fuel economy. Unions were not in the boardrooms, they were on the factory floors building whatever the company decided to put out for that year. Seems rather intriguing how management and republicans are afflicted with the same disease, an inability to listen to the people of America.

Next, you state "There is a principle at stake: A free country should allow its workers to choose whether or not to join a union. " Sir, I direct you to the Taft-Hartley Labor Act passed in 1947, yes you read that correctly, 1947. This act was passed and it outlawed the "closed shop". This means that joining a union was not a condition of employment. So, your assertion is false and is factually wrong, 65 years wrong. You can confirm this fact by reading up on it at this informational site: [URL]http://www.infoplease.com/encyclopedia/business/taft-hartley-labor-act.html[/URL] As the rest of your blather, since it's based on a false premise, the rest of your statement carries the same validity.

You speak of right to work states having lower unemployment, there may be some validity to that, but they also have higher usage of food stamps and higher welfare numbers as well. In an article about which states use more federal money than they contribute, Mother Jones took a look at 2010 census data and found states that voted republican tended to get more federal dollars than they provide ("Most Red States Take More Money From Washington Than They Put In" Feb 16, 2012). It would seem to me if you have lower unemployment, you would have a higher influx of money going from the state to federal government. However, since the wages are markedly lower, they are not contributing more. Lower wages means less money to put back into the local economy, which means less of a tax base for the state to operate.

Free trade is the straw man of your argument. Trade by its very nature is not free. The word itself belies your argument. From Merriam-Webster.com, "The business of buying or selling or bartering commodities." You go to any business person and say "I want to Trade for Free" and you'll be laughed out of the room. There is no such animal, nothing is for free, period. There is an exchange of value, there is a price, there is an agreed contract, period. What you are talking about is devaluing labor until it is almost free. That is the process we are the victims of here in America and it most certainly is a head-long tumble to the bottom. Fair trade is the mantra we must spread across the globe.

The recalibration you speak of is one of devaluation of the one thing this country was founded on and that is the might of the American worker, We The People, that is the value we put into the products we generate, that the world prizes when they see the label "Made In America" because it stands for quality and strength. No lame ducks will destroy that, no matter how hard and how craftily they try. We must work towards Fair Trade, a fair day's pay for a fair day's work.
12




4 replies, 329
 
Actually that article originally appeared in the publication named The Communist Workers' Daily.

Tell me something How much is the interest on 25 trillion dollars? And how will workers, either union or not union be able to afford the taxes to pay it. Because it will be impossible to pay for no matter who and how much you tax.

Because Dumbo, your president, has admitted that under his plan, that's what the debt will be in 10 short years. Of course, Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Obamacare, Food Stamps, SCHIP, Unemployment payments, Housing subsidies for the poor, Free Cell Phones, Free Cell phone service, Free School Lunches, and the whole rest of the damn mess of your dear fearless leader's vote buying programs will have gone bye, bye by then.

And he will have also taxed the rich and the jobs out of existence by then.

Whatcya gonna do then? HMMMMMM? Since Mathematics doesn't seem to be the Democrats forte, how are you gonna pay for all that HMMMMMM? Just the The interest on the debt will consume more than two thirdds of all tax revenues, even if taxes are raised on EVERY damn person who pays taxes

And by then there won't be many who do pay taxes; tax rates will have to be so high it won't be worth working, no matter how much money you make.

Oh well; I'm 66 years wise. Glad I got to live in America when we were still a free country with a limited government.

Guess I'll enjoy what's left of it while I still can.

You really screwed your kids when you elected this guy. It least I can tell mine I tried to prevent it.

>>>Obama budget report: $25 trillion debt by 2022<<<

The Obama administration quietly released a new budget report Friday afternoon at a time calculated to make sure it received minimal attention.

As reported over the weekend, the new Obama budget document lowers growth estimates for the current year to a (still) high 2.6 percent and estimates this years' deficit at $1.2 trillion. That will bring our national debt to $16.2 trillion by the end of the fiscal year.

The more worrisome number in the new report is the estimated national debt at the end of the current 10-year budget widow. Senator Sessions, ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee posted this chart of the anticipated growth of our debt. As you can see, we'll be looking at over $25 trillion in debt by 2022:

Read more: http://times247.com/articles/obama-s-legacy-25-trillion-in-debt-by-2022#ixzz2FEtMriXj
 
You speak of right to work states having lower unemployment, there may be some validity to that, but they also have higher usage of food stamps and higher welfare numbers as well.

Right to work state have lower unemployment AND faster NET wage growth, due to lower state taxes, of 11% vs. 3% for non right to work states.

California has about 13% of the Nations population and consumes 20% of the nation's welfare spending.

The Reason that SOME Blue states send more to the Federal Government than Red States is a perfect example of Liberal's hoisting themselves on their own petards, because it results from the progressive income tax.

Since Blue states have more liberal spending programs, have public sector unionization pensions and health care payments, state costs are higher so state taxes are higher. Therefore, in order to live in a Blue State, you must, necessarily earn more income.

Under Our progressive tax system that you so love, the more income you earn, the higher your rate of taxation, meaning more money leaves Blue States and goes to the federal government, than if you lived in a Red State, enjoyed the same standard of living, even though earning less money,

I mean, you just have to LOVE Liberal stupidity. they even Voted for a guy who is going to make the situation even worse, raising taxes on the so called rich (People earning over 200K, most of whom live in Blue States) and taking it out of their states and giving it to DC.

Talk about DUMB. So, let me summarize: Since you love the progressive income tax, and you love increasing taxes on the rich, sending more money out of your state to the federal government that we do in my state, the least you could do is
QUIT WHINING ABOUT IT.

A flat rate income tax with zero deductions would alleviate the problem. Under a flat income tax, if you make 10 times a much, you pay 10 times as much, unlike our current system where in some cases, if you make 10 times as much you pay as much as 60 or 70 times a much
 
I think Krauthammer nails it. Yes, there may have been politics involved in Michigan going 'pro choice' regarding the joining of unions. But union demands are calling for paying out money to its people that just isn't there. Union demands will ultimately (and that time is very near) break our financial backs.

Yes. Right to work state people have lower pay checks. But they have jobs. And just as the stock market occasionally has to find a new "normal" level, pay has to find that too and it needs to find it sooner than later.
 
I think Krauthammer nails it. Yes, there may have been politics involved in Michigan going 'pro choice' regarding the joining of unions. But union demands are calling for paying out money to its people that just isn't there. Union demands will ultimately (and that time is very near) break our financial backs.

Yes. Right to work state people have lower pay checks. But they have jobs. And just as the stock market occasionally has to find a new "normal" level, pay has to find that too and it needs to find it sooner than later.

Which begs the question. Would people prefer more employment/lower wages or the reverse? If state voters have the option to vote in Right To Work status.
 
I haven't researched,but I think that the Michigan case is an anomaly of sorts..... where the governor did something a little tricky. And Krauthammer seems to think that people would prefer some employment rather than living on government dole. But to me, if I were a person supporting my family on $30k a year at a dead end job where I could sit at home and make $50k a year from the government, I would choose to stay home. Easy choice.

And I also understand that the "right to choice" makes it so a person can choose not to be in a union and pay union dues and still get all of the benefits that the union gets for its members. That isn't fair to those who paid out for those benefits.

It's a multi-faceted problem .......nothing simple. And I don't have an answer.

Which begs the question. Would people prefer more employment/lower wages or the reverse? If state voters have the option to vote in Right To Work status.
 
the best way to depress an economy that is 70+% based on consumption is to keep wages low.

yet that's exactly what the Corporatists and GOP want.
 
But to me, if I were a person supporting my family on $30k a year at a dead end job where I could sit at home and make $50k a year from the government, I would choose to stay home. Easy choice.

what $50,000 govt job would that be?
 
And I also understand that the "right to choice" makes it so a person can choose not to be in a union and pay union dues and still get all of the benefits that the union gets for its members. That isn't fair to those who paid out for those benefits.

It's completely fair, as the Union worker now has the choice to not pay dues, just as the non union worker does. That's the whole point, to get rid of the Unions.

Unions are obsolete. They destroyed Hostess, costing 18,000 jobs, they bankrupted the car companies requiring multi tens of billions in bailouts that, unlike the evil wall street, will never be paid back, they've destroyed Detroit, and ruined our education system by protecting inferior teachers.

AND if you care to check, Non union auto workers are now making more than there union counterparts, because they pay on performance, and don't pay people who used to build cars, only the people who actually do build cars.

It's up to the individual to save for their own retirement, it isn't the companies responsibility to pay for non-work.

But to me, if I were a person supporting my family on $30k a year at a dead end job where I could sit at home and make $50k a year from the government, I would choose to stay home. Easy choice.

The fix to that is easy. Cut off the 50K from the government
 
Corey Booker is living on the welfare dole of his state. He is trying to see how hard it is to just exist.He gets 1.30 for each meal.Where that 50,000 came from is beyond me. People are fat because they have to live on starches with that little money.

And,the jobs that are available pay so little people cannot survive. Such obtuse people you are.
 
Both numbers were just numbers to work with......... not actual numbers. My point was that right to work states are known to have lower wages and anyone supporting a family is going to opt for the higher money level between working and taking welfare. If working wages are so low that welfare is more........... something is wrong. My numbers were fictional, but I was addressing the issue that although I believe in "right to work" (meaning the right to choose whether or not to join a union) I understand that the answer isn't just that simple.

Cotey Booker is living on the welfare dole of his state. He is trying to see how hard it is to just exist.He gets 1.30 for each meal.Where that 50,000 came from is beyond me. People are fat because they have to live on starches with that little money.

And,the jobs that are available pay so little people cannot survive. Such obtuse people you are.
 
Actually that article originally appeared in the publication named The Communist Workers' Daily.

Tell me something How much is the interest on 25 trillion dollars? And how will workers, either union or not union be able to afford the taxes to pay it. Because it will be impossible to pay for no matter who and how much you tax.

Because Dumbo, your president, has admitted that under his plan, that's what the debt will be in 10 short years. Of course, Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Obamacare, Food Stamps, SCHIP, Unemployment payments, Housing subsidies for the poor, Free Cell Phones, Free Cell phone service, Free School Lunches, and the whole rest of the damn mess of your dear fearless leader's vote buying programs will have gone bye, bye by then.

And he will have also taxed the rich and the jobs out of existence by then.

Whatcya gonna do then? HMMMMMM? Since Mathematics doesn't seem to be the Democrats forte, how are you gonna pay for all that HMMMMMM? Just the The interest on the debt will consume more than two thirdds of all tax revenues, even if taxes are raised on EVERY damn person who pays taxes

And by then there won't be many who do pay taxes; tax rates will have to be so high it won't be worth working, no matter how much money you make.

Oh well; I'm 66 years wise. Glad I got to live in America when we were still a free country with a limited government.

Guess I'll enjoy what's left of it while I still can.

You really screwed your kids when you elected this guy. It least I can tell mine I tried to prevent it.

>>>Obama budget report: $25 trillion debt by 2022<<<

The Obama administration quietly released a new budget report Friday afternoon at a time calculated to make sure it received minimal attention.

As reported over the weekend, the new Obama budget document lowers growth estimates for the current year to a (still) high 2.6 percent and estimates this years' deficit at $1.2 trillion. That will bring our national debt to $16.2 trillion by the end of the fiscal year.

The more worrisome number in the new report is the estimated national debt at the end of the current 10-year budget widow. Senator Sessions, ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee posted this chart of the anticipated growth of our debt. As you can see, we'll be looking at over $25 trillion in debt by 2022:

Read more: http://times247.com/articles/obama-s-legacy-25-trillion-in-debt-by-2022#ixzz2FEtMriXj

Sarge, since you are 66 years old, you can show just how serious you are in eliminating the "welfare state" by refusing to accept Social Security or Medicare.
 
the best way to depress an economy that is 70+% based on consumption is to keep wages low.

You really don't understand economics do you. You can't take money from the supply side and give it to the demand side and increase demand. It is mathematically impossible to do so.

Think of the private sector economy as water in a swimming pool, and you want to raise the level of the water in the pool. You can't take water from the supply side and pump it into the demand side and raise the water level. Jobs are only worth the dollar amount a person is willing to purchase labor for, and that purchase price has to be lower than the amount of 'creation' (water added to the pool) done by the worker. Profit is what increases wealth which increases economic growth.

So then the question is: How do you increase the water level in the pool when demand drops off. Answer: you add more money to it by REDUCING taxes on both supply and demand, and eliminating overhead (regulatory and energy costs). You then get more water, and the taxes on that increased amount of water more than make up for the tax reduction.

It has worked every time its been done. It wasn't tax rates or wars or prescription drug benefits that caused the massive debt or the economic collapse, because we had all of those in 2006 and the unemployment rate was 4.8% and the deficit was less than 200 billion.

What caused the collapse was the sub prime mortgage which was created by Democrats at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac which caused hyper inflation in the housing market ( the so called Housing bubble.) This sub prime market was created for two reasons. To loan more money in low income areas, and to increase the amount of money that went to the mortgage market to insure big fat bonuses for Freddie and Fannie executives.

Now if you want me to tell you why the economy isn't recovering and why it will never recover unless economic policy and the welfare state aren't reformed and why, if Obama's and the Feds policies are continued we are facing a massive collapse I'll be glad to do so.

Right now the miniscule growth we do have is totally being propped up with borrowed and printed money, meaning there is ZERO private sector wealth creation.
 
Sarge, since you are 66 years old, you can show just how serious you are in eliminating the "welfare state" by refusing to accept Social Security or Medicare.

Actually, I want them to cut Social Security and Medicare about 20%, but only after they limit food stamps and unemployment to 13 weeks, increase co-pays and raise income limits on Medicaid, kill obamacare dead, tighten up on disability qualifications, and increase or eliminate free school lunches.

Then I'll gladly take a cut. Because if reforms aren't made, all of those programs Including SS and Medicare, are going away on their own.
 
Corey Booker is living on the welfare dole of his state. He is trying to see how hard it is to just exist.He gets 1.30 for each meal.Where that 50,000 came from is beyond me. People are fat because they have to live on starches with that little money.

And,the jobs that are available pay so little people cannot survive. Such obtuse people you are.

Jen made up that $50,000.

But to me, if I were a person supporting my family on $30k a year at a dead end job where I could sit at home and make $50k a year from the government, I would choose to stay home. Easy choice.

with her con-imagination, she thinks folks on welfare get $50,000 a year. that's nuts, but then you knew that, too.
 
I am so sorry that you don't understand hypothetical use of various things to make a point that is just as easily demonstrable with hypothetical as it is with exact numbers. I didn't mean to confuse you, Judy.

Jen made up that $50,000.



with her con-imagination, she thinks folks on welfare get $50,000 a year. that's nuts, but then you knew that, too.
 
I am so sorry that you don't understand hypothetical use of various things to make a point that is just as easily demonstrable with hypothetical as it is with exact numbers. I didn't mean to confuse you, Judy.

Your point didn't work because of the 50k figure. Where can one sit at home and make more than they make working? That was your point, wasn't it? That welfare paid better than work? That it was more lucrative to sit home and make 20K more...or some other such number that you really didn't mean...than you would by working?

The hypothetical has to have some basis in reality to be usable.
 
Jen made up that $50,000.



with her con-imagination, she thinks folks on welfare get $50,000 a year. that's nuts, but then you knew that, too.

Actually, it depends on which state you live in. This study was done in 1995, and, adjusting for inflation, welfare can pay, to a family of four, as much as a head of household who works and whose before tax earnings are as high as $46,000

Welfare benefits are especially generous in large cities. Welfare provides the equivalent of an hourly pretax wage of $14.75 in New York City, $12.45 in Philadelphia, $11.35 in Baltimore, and $10.90 in Detroit. For the hard-core welfare recipient, the value of the full range of welfare benefits substantially exceeds the amount the recipient could earn in an entry-level job. As a result, recipients are likely to choose welfare over work, thus increasing long-term dependence.

In nine states welfare pays more than the average first-year salary for a teacher. In 29 states it pays more than the average starting salary for a secretary. And in the six most generous states it pays more than the entry-level salary for a computer programmer.

http://www.cato.org/publications/po...e-analysis-total-level-welfare-benefits-state
 
Actually, it depends on which state you live in. This study was done in 1995, and, adjusting for inflation, welfare can pay, to a family of four, as much as a head of household who works and whose before tax earnings are as high as $46,000

Welfare benefits are especially generous in large cities. Welfare provides the equivalent of an hourly pretax wage of $14.75 in New York City, $12.45 in Philadelphia, $11.35 in Baltimore, and $10.90 in Detroit. For the hard-core welfare recipient, the value of the full range of welfare benefits substantially exceeds the amount the recipient could earn in an entry-level job. As a result, recipients are likely to choose welfare over work, thus increasing long-term dependence.

In nine states welfare pays more than the average first-year salary for a teacher. In 29 states it pays more than the average starting salary for a secretary. And in the six most generous states it pays more than the entry-level salary for a computer programmer.

http://www.cato.org/publications/po...e-analysis-total-level-welfare-benefits-state


your post refers to a 1995 study on welfare benefits.

Pres Clinton signed welfare reform in 1996.
 
Back
Top