Arkady
President
Right-wingers often worry that the "safety net will become a hammock" -- that things will be so easy on those who aren't working that there won't be any incentive to work. This was the reasoning behind ending long-term unemployment benefits, even at a time when standard economic theory would suggest we should have continued those benefits as a form of stimulus. The hope was that by pushing non-working people into greater hardship, malingerers would be sent back to work.
This never made much sense if you thought about wages. If the delay in job creation had been caused by a shortage of workers rather than a shortage of job openings, then wages should have risen, by simple supply and demand. With employers competing for fewer available workers, they would have had to pay more to fill positions. Instead, wages stagnated, as workers competed with each other for fewer available jobs, driving pay down.
Aside from that, though, it just doesn't line up with historical data. What we've seen is that unemployment rates can get extremely low, even when there's a fairly generous welfare state. The "hammock" just isn't that inviting when there are jobs to be had. In the US, we have a recent example from the Clinton years. Monthly unemployment rates got down as low as 3.8% -- and that was at a time when the five-year limit on federal welfare benefits had not yet run out on anybody, so it was under a more generous welfare system than we have today. During the legendary "Great Society" economy of Johnson --the high point of American welfare-state expansion-- unemployment rates got as low as 3.4%. That's well below what many people would call "full employment," and is pretty close to the lowest you can get given the "frictional unemployment" of some people being briefly between jobs at any given moment. Unless our society has changed dramatically since the late Clinton era, there just aren't a whole lot of the kind of people who can't be bothered to work even when jobs are available.
The US is not the only example of this, either. Take Norway. As of May, their unemployment rate is 3.3%. We haven't seen anything that low in the US since the early 1950s, and then only because of massive Korean War employment (by 1954, unemployment had risen over 6%). Is this because Norway has made sure there are no safety net "hammocks" to lie around on? Of course not. The OECD says total public social expenditure in Norway is 22.9% of GDP, versus 20.0% in the US. But there are jobs available, and the vast majority of people would rather work than collect benefits that, even in a relatively generous country like Norway, don't exact buy a luxurious lifestyle. Germany is another example -- they have 5.2% unemployment, which isn't spectacularly good, but is significantly better than the US. To put it in perspective, unemployment never once got that low in the entirety of the Reagan years. Yet Germany has a famously generous welfare state, with social spending of 26.2% of GDP.
I'll admit that it's probably true that having a decent welfare state makes ultra-low unemployment impossible, since people who can't find work don't have greatly increased mortality rates from illness and starvation, in nations with decent welfare states, and so they don't exit the unemployment rate by way of death the way they do in some poor countries. A nation with a generous welfare state is probably never going to have extended periods with unemployment rates lower than the mid-3s. Between the tiny number of malingerers, and unemployable folks who stubbornly refuse to die and so keep getting counted as unemployed, there will always be a little unemployment in a welfare nation. But so what? Unemployment rates don't have to be that low to make a country generally prosperous and to drive up pay and benefits for the vast majority. If we can get unemployment to average under 5%, that's good enough.
If one does think in terms of incentivizing workers, focus on making work more attractive, rather than making unemployment more painful. If there are available jobs that pay a living wage and treat workers decently, that will be enough to lure nearly all people away from the safety net.
This never made much sense if you thought about wages. If the delay in job creation had been caused by a shortage of workers rather than a shortage of job openings, then wages should have risen, by simple supply and demand. With employers competing for fewer available workers, they would have had to pay more to fill positions. Instead, wages stagnated, as workers competed with each other for fewer available jobs, driving pay down.
Aside from that, though, it just doesn't line up with historical data. What we've seen is that unemployment rates can get extremely low, even when there's a fairly generous welfare state. The "hammock" just isn't that inviting when there are jobs to be had. In the US, we have a recent example from the Clinton years. Monthly unemployment rates got down as low as 3.8% -- and that was at a time when the five-year limit on federal welfare benefits had not yet run out on anybody, so it was under a more generous welfare system than we have today. During the legendary "Great Society" economy of Johnson --the high point of American welfare-state expansion-- unemployment rates got as low as 3.4%. That's well below what many people would call "full employment," and is pretty close to the lowest you can get given the "frictional unemployment" of some people being briefly between jobs at any given moment. Unless our society has changed dramatically since the late Clinton era, there just aren't a whole lot of the kind of people who can't be bothered to work even when jobs are available.
The US is not the only example of this, either. Take Norway. As of May, their unemployment rate is 3.3%. We haven't seen anything that low in the US since the early 1950s, and then only because of massive Korean War employment (by 1954, unemployment had risen over 6%). Is this because Norway has made sure there are no safety net "hammocks" to lie around on? Of course not. The OECD says total public social expenditure in Norway is 22.9% of GDP, versus 20.0% in the US. But there are jobs available, and the vast majority of people would rather work than collect benefits that, even in a relatively generous country like Norway, don't exact buy a luxurious lifestyle. Germany is another example -- they have 5.2% unemployment, which isn't spectacularly good, but is significantly better than the US. To put it in perspective, unemployment never once got that low in the entirety of the Reagan years. Yet Germany has a famously generous welfare state, with social spending of 26.2% of GDP.
I'll admit that it's probably true that having a decent welfare state makes ultra-low unemployment impossible, since people who can't find work don't have greatly increased mortality rates from illness and starvation, in nations with decent welfare states, and so they don't exit the unemployment rate by way of death the way they do in some poor countries. A nation with a generous welfare state is probably never going to have extended periods with unemployment rates lower than the mid-3s. Between the tiny number of malingerers, and unemployable folks who stubbornly refuse to die and so keep getting counted as unemployed, there will always be a little unemployment in a welfare nation. But so what? Unemployment rates don't have to be that low to make a country generally prosperous and to drive up pay and benefits for the vast majority. If we can get unemployment to average under 5%, that's good enough.
If one does think in terms of incentivizing workers, focus on making work more attractive, rather than making unemployment more painful. If there are available jobs that pay a living wage and treat workers decently, that will be enough to lure nearly all people away from the safety net.