New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Disincentivized Workers

its a fact that human nature is to splinter/disagree along ethnic and racial lines. throughout history there have been pogroms, genocides, wars, and forced relocations of "others". whether you simply come from a different tribe, speak a different dialect, worship a different graven image, etc.

go back and read "othello" if you were absent that day in school. then read "mein kampf" and "bury my heart at wounded knee"

No, it is human NURTURE to splint along ethnic and racial lines.
 
here you go - here's how norway deals with its ethnic challenges:

"Norway deports record number of muslims to reduce crime"

theres's your model society for you, arkady.

http://themuslimissue.wordpress.com...rts-record-number-of-muslims-to-reduce-crime/

From your link:

Nigerian citizens topped the list of those expelled for committing crimes, with 232 citizens expelled as a punishment in 2013, followed by Afghan citizens with 136 expelled as a punishment, and 76 Moroccans expelled as a punishment.
Afghan citizens topped the list of those expelled for violating the Immigration Act, with 380 expelled for this reason, followed by Iraqi citizens, 234 were expelled for violating the act.
 
American's had money working through WW2 but were severely limited in what they could buy because of austerity measures for the war effort and the fact that production was not geared to civilian consumption.

It wasn't until 1947 or there abouts that the depression ended and an economic boom began. That boom was due to the fact that the only significant intact industrial base was in America and it was now successfully converted to peace time production and had no effective competition from abroad. The competition was so disadvantaged in its complete destruction that America had great economic ability to produce for the entire world and collect those monies and/or loyalties.

Keynes had zero to do with it.
I don't know how much consumer spending was down but spending was being done by them and by the government paying wages and buying raw materials from the private sector. You seem to believe that austerity is how to end a depression yet you say that during WW2 the depression continued with what you say is austerity in the economy. How do you explain that contradiction? Do you have an example of a depression being ended by austerity?
 
I'll help you out here, because there's no way this will ever occur to you without assistance. It isn't the ethnicity or race of the people concerned, it's the homogeneity of the society that gives it a great advantage over ours. The Scandinavian nations don't have the racial strife, enmity and division, created and perpetuated by deviant politicians like Barack Obama, Eric Holder, Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden. That strife, enmity and division tears us down as a society, makes people belligerent and unproductive (for generations, in some cases), and is used by scum like those I identified above for their own personal profit and consolidation of power.

Note to you for personal reflection; you're part of the problem, as your deliberate misidentification of the issue in your post above illustrates. I wish you could be part of the solution instead, but I hold little hope...
I've heard the homogeneity argument many times, but the problem with it is that a lot of countries that don't have as many problems as us are actually more heterogeneous than us, overall.

Consider Canada, for example. They may be more "white" than the US, but in a lot of senses, they're more heterogeneous. For starters, they have a higher share of foreign-born population than the US. And they have two official languages, and two very distinct cultures. Why is it that such a heterogeneous population, in Canada, mostly gets along, while that isn't the case in the US?

It's even more striking when you look at individual Canadian cities. Take Toronto, for example. Demographically, it's about half "visible minority" (people who are visually identified as "non-white):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Toronto

That's almost exactly the same "white" percentage as Buffalo, New York, which is just an hour and a half away, by car. And it's considerably less "white" than Kansas City, or Oklahoma City. Yet look at the stats. Toronto has a murder rate of 2.0 per 100k.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_Toronto

OK City is 14.3, Buffalo is 18.3, and KC is 22.6. What's going on there? If diversity is supposedly such a burden, why is highly diverse Toronto doing so darned well, while relatively homogenous US areas have murder rates ten times as high?

Take London as another example. It's been argued that it's the most diverse city in the world. It doesn't quite earn that title racially, but in terms of foreign backgrounds, lingual diversity, and number of religions, it probably does. Yet, it has an even lower homicide rate than Toronto (1 per 100k in 2013). Again, you've got vast numbers of very diverse people living together, and yet they mostly get along. How is that possible, when we have cities that are remarkably non-diverse, that do so poorly. You're five times as likely to be murdered in Charleston, West Virginia, which is 78.4% white, only 2.6% foreign born, and 96.1% native-English-speaking (and likely vastly more homogeneous in terms of religion)? If diversity is such a burden and homogeneity such an advantage, why is Charleston doing so much worse than London?

As for your desire to blame Obama, Clinton, Holder, and Biden, how do you explain the FACT that things have gotten better in recent years? Murder rates and violent crime rates are down. There haven't been any significant race riots, either. By comparison, look back at how horribly this country was deteriorating towards the end of the twelve disastrous Reagan/Bush years. LA burned, and the nation hit an ALL TIME high for violent crime rates.
 
Last edited:
I don't know how much consumer spending was down but spending was being done by them and by the government paying wages and buying raw materials from the private sector. You seem to believe that austerity is how to end a depression yet you say that during WW2 the depression continued with what you say is austerity in the economy. How do you explain that contradiction? Do you have an example of a depression being ended by austerity?
I have no idea how you read that so wrong. I was commenting that by necessity, and though having money, during the war American's could not buy consumer goods because they were not being manufactured or they were going to the war effort.

There is nothing in that that says or implies that austerity ended the Great Depression. It was a comment about material sacrifice for the sake of the ongoing conflict. A comment about the living standards.
 
its a fact that human nature is to splinter/disagree along ethnic and racial lines. throughout history there have been pogroms, genocides, wars, and forced relocations of "others". whether you simply come from a different tribe, speak a different dialect, worship a different graven image, etc.

go back and read "othello" if you were absent that day in school. then read "mein kampf" and "bury my heart at wounded knee"
I've read all three (Mein Kampf in the original German). What I find interesting about inter-group strife is that it doesn't really require what would externally be seen as big differences. Check out the 30 Years War, for example. There was factional fighting between Catholics and Protestants that regularly degenerated into local genocidal purges, all over utterly trivial fine points of theology. Or look at the enmity between the English and Irish. Or how about the Tutsis and Hutus: two groups that would get lumped together, generically, as "blacks" in this country, yet in Central Africa have such hatred that it has led to almost non-stop war for generations, and occasional attempted genocides. People can find enough cause to kill each other over even the pettiest of little group differences.

Yet, they can also largely put those things aside. To go back to Norway, we may lump Norwegians mostly together generically as "white," the same way we would Tutsis and Hutus in the black category. Yet, if they were in the mood for ethnic strife, there's ample cause. There are Sami people who are as ethnically different from the Norwegian majority as, say, Kurds are from the people of Turkey, Iraq, etc. In Switzerland, you have four very distinct groups: French, German, Italian, and Romansh. Yet, in many countries, these various groups get along well enough that we don't even tend to think of them as distinct, for purposes of conversations like this, while in other areas, groups with what seem like more trivial differences are constantly at each other's throats.
 
I've heard the homogeneity argument many times, but the problem with it is that a lot of countries that don't have as many problems as us are actually more heterogeneous than us, overall.

Consider Canada, for example. They may be more "white" than the US, but in a lot of senses, they're more heterogeneous. For starters, they have a higher share of foreign-born population than the US. And they have two official languages, and two very distinct cultures. Why is it that such a heterogeneous population, in Canada, mostly gets along, while that isn't the case in the US?

It's even more striking when you look at individual Canadian cities. Take Toronto, for example. Demographically, it's about half "visible minority" (people who are visually identified as "non-white):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Toronto

That's almost exactly the same "white" percentage as Buffalo, New York, which is just an hour and a half away, by car. And it's considerably less "white" than Kansas City, or Oklahoma City. Yet look at the stats. Toronto has a murder rate of 2.0 per 100k.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_Toronto

OK City is 14.3, Buffalo is 18.3, and KC is 22.6. What's going on there? If diversity is supposedly such a burden, why is highly diverse Toronto doing so darned well, while relatively homogenous US areas have murder rates ten times as high?

Take London as another example. It's been argued that it's the most diverse city in the world. It doesn't quite earn that title racially, but in terms of foreign backgrounds, lingual diversity, and number of religions, it probably does. Yet, it has an even lower homicide rate than Toronto (1 per 100k in 2013). Again, you've got vast numbers of very diverse people living together, and yet they mostly get along. How is that possible, when we have cities that are remarkably non-diverse, that do so poorly. You're five times as likely to be murdered in Charleston, West Virginia, which is 78.4% white, only 2.6% foreign born, and 96.1% native-English-speaking (and likely vastly more homogeneous in terms of religion)? If diversity is such a burden and homogeneity such an advantage, why is Charleston doing so much worse than London?

As for your desire to blame Obama, Clinton, Holder, and Biden, how do you explain the FACT that things have gotten better in recent years? Murder rates and violent crime rates are down. There haven't been any significant race riots, either. By comparison, look back at how horribly this country was deteriorating towards the end of the twelve disastrous Reagan/Bush years. LA burned, and the nation hit an ALL TIME high for violent crime rates.

It is about cultural difference and not racial for one.

For two you always compare apples and oranges.

Canadian Immigration Requirements
Share on facebookShare on twitterShare on emailShare on printShare on gmailShare on stumbleuponShare on favoritesShare on tumblrMore Sharing Services

Applicants must satisfy the following points requirements to qualify for the Federal Skilled Worker program.
Work Experience
To satisfy the point requirements you must have at least one year of full-time paid work experience in fields that satisfy Canadian immigration standards such as managerial jobs, professional occupations, or technical / skilled trades.

For more information about the jobs and occupations that Canadian immigration considers valid, visit the National Occupational Classification website: www23.hrdc-drhc.gc.ca/2001/e/generic/welcome.shtml.

Education
The main applicant will likely need at least some completed post-secondary education. Of course, up to a point, the more education an applicant has the better that person’s chances become. Education is a very important aspect of the evaluation process .

Language Abilities

Language is also very important. English and French are the two languages that count for points in the Canadian immigration requirements. Of course, to be fluent in both provides more points to any applicant, but fluency in one of these two languages will increase any applicant’s chances significantly.

Age10 points are awarded to applicants between 21 and 49 years of age. 2 points are removed for every year older or younger (to a maximum of 10 points).

Arranged EmploymentWith a permanent job offer from a Canadian employer, applicants may be awarded an additional 10 points.

Adaptability
The Canadian government also takes adaptability into account when evaluating any applicant. The adaptability category addresses a potential applicant’s perceived ability to adapt quickly to life in Canada. The Canadian Government will award any applicant who has relatives in Canada or has spent time in Canada working or studying.

Point Structure
This is the point breakdown for the Canadian Immigration Requirements for Federal Skilled Worker.

  • Work Experience: Maximum 21 Points
  • Education: Maximum 25 Points
  • Language: Maximum 24 Points
  • Arranged Employment: Maximum 10 Points
  • Age: Maximum 10 Points
  • Adaptability: Maximum 10 Points

TOTAL POINTS: Maximum 100 Points
POINTS REQUIRED TO PASS: 67 Points
 
I have no idea how you read that so wrong. I was commenting that by necessity, and though having money, during the war American's could not buy consumer goods because they were not being manufactured or they were going to the war effort.

There is nothing in that that says or implies that austerity ended the Great Depression. It was a comment about material sacrifice for the sake of the ongoing conflict. A comment about the living standards.
You are saying Keynesian doesn't work to end a depression so the other way would be austerity. The stock market crashed fall 1929 and Roosevelt didn't take office for over 3 years. In the meantime Hoover did next to nothing assuming charity and state and local governments should handle the depression which they couldn't because they were hanging on with their fingernails themselves. That was your austerity, government not doing any Keynesian to stimulate the economy and it just kept getting worse. Roosevelt started the new deal (Keynesian) and economy was improving but after 1936 election he pulled back and economy slumped again until WW2 government spending ended the depression. It ended during the war because of the government spending not in 1947. Just because a couple of conservative economists say what you are saying about Keynesian doesn't make it fact.
 
It is about cultural difference and not racial for one.

For two you always compare apples and oranges.

Canadian Immigration Requirements

I'd be fine with raising the bar on immigration standards, but I'm not convinced that's a meaningful factor here. First, foreign-born citizens in this country out-perform US-born citizens:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/25/opinion/sunday/the-immigrant-advantage.html?_r=0

So, even without particularly tough rules for gaining US citizenship, they're helping our stats, not hurting them.

Moreover, there's no apparent correlation between the percent of foreign-born residents in a state, and how that state is doing, socioeconomically. If there is any correlation, it appears to be the opposite of what you might expect. Most of the Deep South and Bible Belt has a low percentage of foreign-born citizens (e.g., 1.2% in West Virginia, 2.1% in Mississippi, 3.5% in Alabama, 3.2% Kentucky, 3.8% Louisiana, etc.), and those places are open sewers. Meanwhile, Massachusetts is 15.0% foreign-born, New York is 22.2%, New Jersey is 21.0%, Hawaii is 18.2%, etc. Those are some of the wealthiest and best-educated states, each has a murder rate below the national average, etc.

Overall, the functional/dysfunctional breakdown, by state, is mostly along blue-state/red-state lines, not along native-born/foreign-born lines. It appears to be very bad for a state to be polluted with too many conservatives, but having foreigners doesn't appear to be particularly problematic.
 
You are saying Keynesian doesn't work to end a depression so the other way would be austerity. The stock market crashed fall 1929 and Roosevelt didn't take office for over 3 years. In the meantime Hoover did next to nothing assuming charity and state and local governments should handle the depression which they couldn't because they were hanging on with their fingernails themselves. That was your austerity, government not doing any Keynesian to stimulate the economy and it just kept getting worse. Roosevelt started the new deal (Keynesian) and economy was improving but after 1936 election he pulled back and economy slumped again until WW2 government spending ended the depression. It ended during the war because of the government spending not in 1947. Just because a couple of conservative economists say what you are saying about Keynesian doesn't make it fact.
Yep. If they're interested, the data is widely available online. Compare the federal budget deficit by year with the GDP growth rate by year, in the Hoover, FDR, and Truman years. As you suggest, they'll see that GDP fell dramatically in the Hoover years, then rose dramatically under FDR, until the '37 recession when they tried premature deficit-fighting, and then grew again when the war gave them an excuse to ignore the deficit for a while, then fell again when there was demobilization and the resulting falling deficit.
 
I don't know how much consumer spending was down but spending was being done by them and by the government paying wages and buying raw materials from the private sector. You seem to believe that austerity is how to end a depression yet you say that during WW2 the depression continued with what you say is austerity in the economy. How do you explain that contradiction? Do you have an example of a depression being ended by austerity?

Hoover took national debt from 20% of GNP to 40%. He spent money. Additionally, he had Keynesian like programs in the pipeline that Roosevelt ended up implementing. Hoover was a great man sickenly maligned by liberal malingerers. Lol

Roosevelt was able to spend money because national debt was relatively low. When Roosevelt tried to cut back on the increasing debt level there was a recession because so many of those jobs were busy work jobs. Paper tiger jobs. Jobs need to be rooted in real consumer markets was clearly the lesson. Basically the war saved Roosevelt's and Keynes' reputations.

The German economy post WW1 is in fact what an economy with a huge debt looks like. It is what we will most likely look like soon enogh.

LaGuarde warned of English austerity ruining the economy. She's had to apologize.
 
here's the problem - norway doesn't have a 50% inner city dropout rate, or rampant narcotics addiction, a "gang related" crime spree based roughly along ethnic/racial divisions.

they have a homogenous, 99% white/nordic population that stays in school, doesn't shoot up heroin or use meth, and would feel shamed by their relatives if they became parasites on society.

Hard to say what would rectify the multicultural problem here in the states.

What do you suggest? I guess we could send all the blacks back to Africa, and all the Hispanics to their original countries. Then we could send all the Italians back to Italy, Germans to Germany, English to England and so on until Native Americans ran the whole show.

You advocate something like that?
 
here you go - here's how norway deals with its ethnic challenges:

"Norway deports record number of muslims to reduce crime"

theres's your model society for you, arkady.

http://themuslimissue.wordpress.com...rts-record-number-of-muslims-to-reduce-crime/

I went to that rather suspect site, followed one of the links and found this:

Nigerians and Romanians top the list of foreign criminals who break expulsion orders, he said.​

sadly, no Muslims were mentioned.
 
Basically the war saved Roosevelt's and Keynes' reputations.

Keynes's predictions played out correctly worldwide, and have done so repeatedly. As for FDR, his reputation didn't need saving. He was already insanely popular before we were ever pulled into WWII, and the economy had already grown at an epic pace between 1933 and November 1941. Find me any other president in history who presided over average annual GDP growth as high as we had in those years.

LaGuarde warned of English austerity ruining the economy. She's had to apologize.

The UK somewhat eased their counter-productive austerity policy, and the economy somewhat improved. That's exactly what we'd expect.
 
Keynes's predictions played out correctly worldwide, and have done so repeatedly. As for FDR, his reputation didn't need saving. He was already insanely popular before we were ever pulled into WWII, and the economy had already grown at an epic pace between 1933 and November 1941. Find me any other president in history who presided over average annual GDP growth as high as we had in those years.



The UK somewhat eased their counter-productive austerity policy, and the economy somewhat improved. That's exactly what we'd expect.

List all the countries where Keynes predictions worked wildly (especially those starting out with a large debt load).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top