New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

distorting Russia

and note , Ark, not even one ounce of blood was shed in Crimea....
Strictly peaceful operation protecting Russian population.
I think after Iraq, Kosovo Lybia etc, we have no room to blame Russia for protecting his own people....
The US is certainly far from the moral high ground, on which to take any stand. But I still don't like the idea of a foreign military power sending in troops to sovereign nation, without a formal invitation from the internationally recognized government of the nation, or a proper UN Security Council resolution authorizing that (or, at a bare minimum, if that's blocked by a veto, a majority vote in the UN General Assembly.) In the case of Ukraine, the parliement voted to oust the president. I don't know their Constitution and whether that's a legal way of ousting a head of state there or not, but it's at least enough for me to say that foreign powers should butt out and let Ukraine work it out.
 
http://www.thenation.com/article/178344/distorting-russia#
Sample:
Any doubts about the Obama administration’s real intentions in Ukraine should have been dispelled by the recently revealed taped conversation between a top State Department official, Victoria Nuland, and the US ambassador in Kiev. The media predictably focused on the source of the “leak” and on Nuland’s verbal “gaffe”—“**** the EU.” But the essential revelation was that high-level US officials were plotting to “midwife” a new, anti-Russian Ukrainian government by ousting or neutralizing its democratically elected president—that is, a coup.

Americans are left with a new edition of an old question. Has Washington’s twenty-year winner-take-all approach to post-Soviet Russia shaped this degraded news coverage, or is official policy shaped by the coverage? Did Senator John McCain stand in Kiev alongside the well-known leader of an extreme nationalist party because he was ill informed by the media, or have the media deleted this part of the story because of McCain’s folly?


Read the whole thing at the link

Yep.... I figured that this kind of turd would eventually come bobbing to the top. Now for the rest of the sub-turds like which corporations have their greedy little sights set on Ukraine mineral wealth and the Gas and Oil Port in Crimea.

I love this country but man I am not for one moment blind to the bullshit that sometimes masquerades as Freedom fignting. This is, just as I figured....just another banker's war and Putin is no fool.

JO
 
The US is certainly far from the moral high ground, on which to take any stand. But I still don't like the idea of a foreign military power sending in troops to sovereign nation, without a formal invitation from the internationally recognized government of the nation, or a proper UN Security Council resolution authorizing that (or, at a bare minimum, if that's blocked by a veto, a majority vote in the UN General Assembly.) In the case of Ukraine, the parliement voted to oust the president. I don't know their Constitution and whether that's a legal way of ousting a head of state there or not, but it's at least enough for me to say that foreign powers should butt out and let Ukraine work it out.

Look Ark...

The UN is a big financial farce that is now and forever will be FOR SALE.

Waiting for a UN persmssion is equal to buying a license from a bandit to be a bandit.

[Unwelcome language removed] the UN.....they are as useless as tits on a bull and as corrupt as Al Capone.

JO
 
U.S Corporate Media is also claiming Russia is invading the entire Ukraine which is false. Russia is occupying mosty the Crimea which is seceding from Ukraine's revolutionary govt and where the Russian fleet is docked.
 
I love this country but man I am not for one moment blind to the bullshit that sometimes masquerades as Freedom fignting. This is, just as I figured....just another banker's war and Putin is no fool.

JO

Exactly!

The more I look into the Ukraine mess, the more I see IMF/ECB fingerprints all over it.
 
Exactly!

The more I look into the Ukraine mess, the more I see IMF/ECB fingerprints all over it.

You Damn Betchya and Holder, Obama , Clinton.... they are all part of that momey bag cabal. Gotta piss em right off that Putiin won't just fold and let them have their way.

JO
 
U.S Corporate Media is also claiming Russia is invading the entire Ukraine which is false. Russia is occupying mosty the Crimea which is seceding from Ukraine's revolutionary govt and where the Russian fleet is docked.

Putin is protecting the pipelines and his access to the Black Sea for exports. He is right to do so. His pipelines are a source of huge irritation to his competing Gas and Oil fellows.


JO
 
Look Ark...

The UN is a big financial farce that is now and forever will be FOR SALE.

Waiting for a UN persmssion is equal to buying a license from a bandit to be a bandit.

[Unwelcome language removed] the UN.....they are as useless as tits on a bull and as corrupt as Al Capone.

JO
Before the UN, major superpowers got into open shooting wars with each other every twenty years or so. In the seventy years or so since the UN, it's never happened. There are a few major factors in that, including the rise of global trade and the spread of nukes, but the UN is one factor. It provides a decent forum for defusing most problems before they get too bad.

I'm not saying it's perfect, of course. The existence of the vetoes makes the UN nearly worthless any time a particular piece of lawlessness is endorsed by any of those five countries. So, for example, Israel has spent decades in open breach of countless international laws, and repeatedly attacks its neighbors, and the UN is powerless to do anything about it, because the US is fine with Israel doing those things, and we'll veto any effort to rein in their rogue ways with sanctons. I'd be all for getting rid of those vetoes, to make the UN more effective.

While we were at it, it would make sense to reform the UN to make it more democratic. Currently, it's a one-nation, one-vote system in the General Assembly, which creates the absurdity of giving gigantic economies and populations like the US and China only the same voting power as places few have heard of, like Tonga. It would make more sense to have some kind of proportional voting power. For example, you could set it up so that there were 1000 total votes, apportioned such that every country gets one, with the remaining being apportionated half by GDP and half by population. So, based on current population and GDP, that would be roughly one extra vote for every $180 billion of GDP, plus one for every extra 18 million people.

If we had that method, the countries with the greatest power in the UN would be China, with about 120 votes, the US, with about 110, India 80, Japan 40, Brazil and Germany 25, Russia, Indonesia, and France 20; UK 18, Italy 15, Canada 13, Pakistan and Nigeria 12. That would be a much truer reflection of current global power distributions, and thus would render votes that more realistically reflected the will of those with the social, military, and economic might to back it up.

That could do something similar with the Security Council, just much more restrictively. If you wanted a Security Council with 10 members, for example, only the US and China would have enough combined GDP and population to get one automatically. Others would need to pool their clout to get one (e.g., the EU could easily get one, Japan could get one if it went in on it with someone like South Korea or Australia, etc.) That would foster greater cooperation, regionally.
 
your link DOESNT establish that anyone in the US government was "plotting to overthrow" the ukrainian government.

it does, however, correctly characterize Kremlin policies as "repugnant" and Putin as "a thug"

I think the events over the past 2 weeks certainly bear out those assessments
 
Before the UN, major superpowers got into open shooting wars with each other every twenty years or so. In the seventy years or so since the UN, it's never happened. There are a few major factors in that, including the rise of global trade and the spread of nukes, but the UN is one factor. It provides a decent forum for defusing most problems before they get too bad.

I'm not saying it's perfect, of course. The existence of the vetoes makes the UN nearly worthless any time a particular piece of lawlessness is endorsed by any of those five countries. So, for example, Israel has spent decades in open breach of countless international laws, and repeatedly attacks its neighbors, and the UN is powerless to do anything about it, because the US is fine with Israel doing those things, and we'll veto any effort to rein in their rogue ways with sanctons. I'd be all for getting rid of those vetoes, to make the UN more effective.

While we were at it, it would make sense to reform the UN to make it more democratic. Currently, it's a one-nation, one-vote system in the General Assembly, which creates the absurdity of giving gigantic economies and populations like the US and China only the same voting power as places few have heard of, like Tonga. It would make more sense to have some kind of proportional voting power. For example, you could set it up so that there were 1000 total votes, apportioned such that every country gets one, with the remaining being apportionated half by GDP and half by population. So, based on current population and GDP, that would be roughly one extra vote for every $180 billion of GDP, plus one for every extra 18 million people.

If we had that method, the countries with the greatest power in the UN would be China, with about 120 votes, the US, with about 110, India 80, Japan 40, Brazil and Germany 25, Russia, Indonesia, and France 20; UK 18, Italy 15, Canada 13, Pakistan and Nigeria 12. That would be a much truer reflection of current global power distributions, and thus would render votes that more realistically reflected the will of those with the social, military, and economic might to back it up.

That could do something similar with the Security Council, just much more restrictively. If you wanted a Security Council with 10 members, for example, only the US and China would have enough combined GDP and population to get one automatically. Others would need to pool their clout to get one (e.g., the EU could easily get one, Japan could get one if it went in on it with someone like South Korea or Australia, etc.) That would foster greater cooperation, regionally.

It provides a decent forum for defusing most problems before they get too bad.
To the extent that it does that I will admit that it has value. At least the diplomats have a place to bang it out with words before they give the order to fire.

Saying that it needs reform is a very polite way of putting it. More accurately it is a sewer that has been neglected for twenty years with the fecal matter flowing down the gutters and the smell of urea wafting for miles from the epicenter.

I do think it's worth the effort but man what an effort!

Then again big things usually begin small. In this case we have a giant catastrophe that needs to shrink in burecracy and grow in impartial influence.
 
Last edited:
your link DOESNT establish that anyone in the US government was "plotting to overthrow" the ukrainian government.

it does, however, correctly characterize Kremlin policies as "repugnant" and Putin as "a thug"

I think the events over the past 2 weeks certainly bear out those assessments

You are right he is a thug....however the real danger for the west and for western diplomacy herein is mischarecterizing what he is doing presently.

1.) He has vested interests in Crimea not the least of whcih are major gas and oil docks. ( pipelines, storage tanks, processing centers....exct )

2.) Crimea for better or worse is 60% ethnic Russian. How they got there is no longer relevant they have a right to a political voice. If they wish to join Russia at this point they should be allowed to go in that direction. This is a lesson for us with Mexico is it not? Let too many of them in and you will see state legislatures voting to leave the US and join Mexico....Like California and Texas for instance.

3.) There is no questoin about the shennigans being sponsored by Western Corporate greed using the US and EU as a front to put a grab on the Ukraine mineral wealth.

4.) Putin may be a thug.....but he's not the only thug involved in this process.

JO
 
It provides a decent forum for defusing most problems before they get too bad.
To the extent that it does that I will admit that it has value. At least the diplomats have a place to bang it out with words before they give the order to fire.

Saying that it needs reform is a very polite way of putting it. More accurately it is a sewer that has been neglected for twenty years with the fecal matter flowing down the gutters and the smell of urea wafting for miles from the epicenter.

I do think it's worth the effort but man what an effort!

Then again big things usually begin small. In this case we have a giant catastrophe that needs to shrink in burecracy and grow in impartial influence.
Those seem like fair comments to me.

Unfortunately, as much as I think reform is worth the effort, I can't even picture how it could be accomplished, because any attempt at reform can be unilaterally derailed by any of the five permanent security council members. The US is so jealous of its sovereigny that it will block any reform that might give the UN power over it, and it's such a partisan for Israel that it'll block anything that could result in the UN being able to enforce sanctions against Israel. China will block anything that could allow UN measures to be taken against it for its various crimes against humanity, commerce, and the environment. Russia will block anything that might threaten serious global retalation when they throw their weight around in Eastern Europe. And France and the UK will block anything that reshuffles the power structure to recognize their fading importance in the world (it's ridiculous that they're permanent council members and such nations as Japan, Germany, India, and Brazil are not).

When each of the five of them has a motivation for preventing reform, and any of the five of them can unilaterally block reform, I suspect serious reform just won't happen. The only way it'll probably come is if there's a great crisis that shows the failings of the structure so badly that people basically HAVE to revisit things, the way the US revisited the Articles of Confederation, or the world revisited the League of Nations.
 
You are right he is a thug....however the real danger for the west and for western diplomacy herein is mischarecterizing what he is doing presently.

1.) He has vested interests in Crimea not the least of whcih are major gas and oil docks. ( pipelines, storage tanks, processing centers....exct )

2.) Crimea for better or worse is 60% ethnic Russian. How they got there is no longer relevant they have a right to a political voice. If they wish to join Russia at this point they should be allowed to go in that direction. This is a lesson for us with Mexico is it not? Let too many of them in and you will see state legislatures voting to leave the US and join Mexico....Like California and Texas for instance.

3.) There is no questoin about the shennigans being sponsored by Western Corporate greed using the US and EU as a front to put a grab on the Ukraine mineral wealth.

4.) Putin may be a thug.....but he's not the only thug involved in this process.

JO
I defnitely can't see California and Texas voting to join Mexico. It would be like Massachusetts voting to join Ireland after the Irish-descended population became a majority. Irish-descended people in Massachusetts may wave the Irish Flag in their St. Patrick's Day Parades, and Mexico-descended people in California may wave the Mexican flag in Cinco De mayo celebrations, but as long as the US is a welcoming and prosperous place, they're going to identify, within a generation or less, with the new country much more than the old.
 
I defnitely can't see California and Texas voting to join Mexico. It would be like Massachusetts voting to join Ireland after the Irish-descended population became a majority. Irish-descended people in Massachusetts may wave the Irish Flag in their St. Patrick's Day Parades, and Mexico-descended people in California may wave the Mexican flag in Cinco De mayo celebrations, but as long as the US is a welcoming and prosperous place, they're going to identify, within a generation or less, with the new country much more than the old.

Yeah but the Kennedy's could have done it about thrity years ago!

Massachusetts that is.

JO
 
Back
Top