New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone really believe?

888888

Council Member
That if you cut aid to those who need it, it will somehow make them not need it? Does anyone out there believe that most people who are getting help doesn't really need it? That those who receive help if cut off would somehow be better educated, have less debt, own a home and be able to get a good job?

Or is it as I believe, that most republicans could give a shit about need, they just don't want to provide it for hardly any reason. ]That it's not their fault that people suffer, it's their own, EOS.
 
You are talking about people who love war and killing and somehow equate victory with jesus. This is the mentality of idol worship... our gods will give us the victory over your army. It is a primitive mindset.

kill or be killed.

Now, do these same people care if other people are tortured or suffer abuse or starve to death? Of course not. But it is polite to pretend they are compassionate when in public; the great thing about the internet is here they are anonymous and they can let their hair down... except for political types who are so caught up in stumping for their party that they still try to pretend to be compassionate (to win votes). But while they are pretending to be compassionate, they still are not. So you get sentences like these, "I believe someone should feed the poor, just not my taxes". That way they still look compassionate while they starve the poor.

these are the fearful, the unbelieving, the religious hypocrites who go to church every Sunday but are never born again. We used to call them the 'majority" ... but nowadays they are roughly half the nation.
 
That if you cut aid to those who need it, it will somehow make them not need it? Does anyone out there believe that most people who are getting help doesn't really need it? That those who receive help if cut off would somehow be better educated, have less debt, own a home and be able to get a good job?

Or is it as I believe, that most republicans could give a shit about need, they just don't want to provide it for hardly any reason. ]That it's not their fault that people suffer, it's their own, EOS.

But at the same time they were really quick to pass TARP, weren't they? Billionaires are more deserving of welfare apparently.
 
That if you cut aid to those who need it, it will somehow make them not need it? Does anyone out there believe that most people who are getting help doesn't really need it? That those who receive help if cut off would somehow be better educated, have less debt, own a home and be able to get a good job?[/B]

Well Bill Clinton (at the urging if not direction of the republican party) signed into law a bill that cut off welfare to a large portion of those receiving it after 5 years of benefits. Was that wrong?

I am fully in favor of limiting unemployment benefits to something like nine or twelve months. After that, you may continue to receive your unemployment checks for another extended time, but you also must perform regular public service work to do so.

I am also in favor of “able bodied men” (and women without dependents) receiving welfare benefits for a very long time, except they need to perform some type of social service work to continue receiving it. If they have young children, then we pay for the care of their children while they work and/or go to school. Such “incentives” are not cruel or demeaning, they are a plus for most everyone involved.

To answer your question more directly, no, I do not believe there are too many who believe if you take away aid from someone in great need then that will somehow create a situation where they will no longer need it. Why do you ask? Was President Obama telling another one of his “truths” in the debate along those lines about the republican party?


Or is it as I believe, that most republicans could give a shit about need, they just don't want to provide it for hardly any reason. ]That it's not their fault that people suffer, it's their own, EOS.

Wow, what stark contrasts there must be between parties that I never realized. Republicans are selfish and greedy (by and large) and democrats are selfless saints (by and large) --- except these “saints” find God to be pretty much a nuisance.
 
Now, do these same people care if other people are tortured or suffer abuse or starve to death? Of course not.
Are we talking about abortion here? I came in late.

You are talking about people who love war and killing and somehow equate victory with jesus. This is the mentality of idol worship... our gods will give us the victory over your army. It is a primitive mindset.
No, I think you are talking about hyperbole, Days, or even, outright fabrication. Such talk makes you…. what’s the word?.... “undebatable.”

these are the fearful, the unbelieving, the religious hypocrites who go to church every Sunday but are never born again. We used to call them the 'majority" ... but nowadays they are roughly half the nation.

What a silly game you play, albeit hyper-dangerous, so that makes it quite a paradox in some ways. You can have the last word because I refuse to revisit this subject with you in detail --- but to put it simply ---- God is not a genie. It’s not as though the only ones who get into heaven are those who know the secret password “open sesame” and everyone else is left outside scratching their heads and shielding their faces from the flames.
 
I grew up in a Catholic Republican family... a pretty big one. My mother was always decrying the bleeding heart liberals. These were the attitudes and platitudes I saw prevailing over a couple of decades; until I became born again and then nobody wanted anything to do with me after that. Whether or not they are outdated or persist; I'll let you be the judge. It's just my dangerous opinion.

peace
 
Well Bill Clinton (at the urging if not direction of the republican party) signed into law a bill that cut off welfare to a large portion of those receiving it after 5 years of benefits. Was that wrong?

I am fully in favor of limiting unemployment benefits to something like nine or twelve months. After that, you may continue to receive your unemployment checks for another extended time, but you also must perform regular public service work to do so.

I am also in favor of “able bodied men” (and women without dependents) receiving welfare benefits for a very long time, except they need to perform some type of social service work to continue receiving it. If they have young children, then we pay for the care of their children while they work and/or go to school. Such “incentives” are not cruel or demeaning, they are a plus for most everyone involved.

To answer your question more directly, no, I do not believe there are too many who believe if you take away aid from someone in great need then that will somehow create a situation where they will no longer need it. Why do you ask? Was President Obama telling another one of his “truths” in the debate along those lines about the republican party?




Wow, what stark contrasts there must be between parties that I never realized. Republicans are selfish and greedy (by and large) and democrats are selfless saints (by and large) --- except these “saints” find God to be pretty much a nuisance.


Well great sir, I agree with you. But you would think that after all the time Republicans have had to come up with an answer of how to do this. But the truth is as we know it, republicans will not go along with any program that helps people who are trying to improve themselves. That people who need help are cut off of programs that they use as they improve their situation in life. So what it does is make one worse off for trying to improve. A family who is in a place where the slightest problem in their life can throw them into a mess that they can't deal with. A sickness, a car breakdown, a refrigerator goes to hell, a furnace breaks down, or a layoff happens or maybe hrs are cut.

But if you got the answer why not run for office? But I can tell you that the answer isn't nearly as easy as you think it is. Life for people has so many different factors to it, and you are trying to put 25% of the population in a small sack thinking they are all the same, with one outcome from one set of policies.
 
Oh one more thing JV, taking help away from people is a lot more devastating to their liefs than it will be a benefit to yours.
Many on the right believe that if not for helping the poor people they would be better off in their own liefs. Not even close to being true. Your life will not improve by making other people's life worse.
 
Oh one more thing JV, taking help away from people is a lot more devastating to their liefs than it will be a benefit to yours.
Many on the right believe that if not for helping the poor people they would be better off in their own liefs. Not even close to being true. Your life will not improve by making other people's life worse.

We mustn't forget that when Clinton presided over the reform of welfare (for the poor), our nation was enjoying its lowest rate of unemployment in 50 years. It was "real", to tell people to "get a job". That's not the case right now.

To your point though...The Reagan/GOP shouted welfare (for the poor) as a "cost" to the non-poor. It was cost...but it was a remarkably pissant cost. Clinton reframed the argument from one of cost to the non-poor, to one of cost to the welfare recipients themselves. We forget that Clinton made it abundantly plain that reforming welfare would actually cost the non-poor MORE, not less. "Teaching a man to fish", costs money.

How quickly we forget. We're right back to that Reagan/GOP mindset of shouting that people should get off their duffs and go to work, in an especially weak employment climate. AND, we're considering the whole prospect, only within the frame of "saving the taxpayer's money".
 
We mustn't forget that when Clinton presided over the reform of welfare (for the poor), our nation was enjoying its lowest rate of unemployment in 50 years. It was "real", to tell people to "get a job". That's not the case right now.

To your point though...The Reagan/GOP shouted welfare (for the poor) as a "cost" to the non-poor. It was cost...but it was a remarkably pissant cost. Clinton reframed the argument from one of cost to the non-poor, to one of cost to the welfare recipients themselves. We forget that Clinton made it abundantly plain that reforming welfare would actually cost the non-poor MORE, not less. "Teaching a man to fish", costs money.

How quickly we forget. We're right back to that Reagan/GOP mindset of shouting that people should get off their duffs and go to work, in an especially weak employment climate. AND, we're considering the whole prospect, only within the frame of "saving the taxpayer's money".

No, I don’t agree. The greater objective here for society is to lift their fellow man up. Do you honestly think a man feels better of himself sitting at home, feeling useless, and just collecting money to sustain himself vs. accomplishing something of his own efforts? What gives you greater satisfaction and dignity? Neither republican nor democrat is uncaring towards the poor. Our objectives for assisting them differ, but really, only slightly.

The financial benefit for the community is greater if man is working, yes, but why should that too not be considered? Does that not free up resources to help others who need it? Teaching a man to fish is well worth the costs for many reasons, regardless if you say it is more costly.
 
Oh one more thing JV, taking help away from people is a lot more devastating to their liefs than it will be a benefit to yours.
Many on the right believe that if not for helping the poor people they would be better off in their own liefs. Not even close to being true. Your life will not improve by making other people's life worse.

I'm not arguing with that. And whether my life will be better off or not by not helping the poor is hardly the motivation.

This is not a black and white matter either. Some need more help, some need less, and some need a different kind of help.
 
Back
Top