New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does anyone rember ?

What I was referring to was your saying something to the effect that the Filipinos welcomed American troops with open arms, and from what you said I took it as unanimously. What I am saying is that was not true in all areas. I was also in the Navy, in the 60's as part of MRFV, and we used to reload at Subic until the facilities in CamRahn Bay were finished. I knew a lot of Filipinos, not only in Subic but also in Navotas Rizal. At night you could hear the Huks singing on the beach, and they still carried a strong dislike for Americans. And I knew a number of the older generation, and heard stories from them. I also had two uncles that were in Bataan before the fall, so i do have a good understanding of the history of the country. And in the early 60's animosity toward Americans was one of the major reasons for some areas to be off limits. I used to go into some of these areas, but that was because I had friends, and having brown skin didn't hurt either. But I had a lot of people tell me that I was welcome because I didn't treat them like other Americans did, and they actually told me stories that would make your hair curl.

And it was more than just Clark and Subic, it was also how they felt Americans were still stealing their natural resources. Their independence came with strings attached, and requirements.

Yes I know there's a lot of 'anti-American' sentiments, and that is brought on by the government and it's ties to big business. You don't have to go far to see certain sentiments, you can find them right here, on any reservation. But it's not against the American people, unless they continue to allow the government to do the kinds of things it regularly does. You know this 'my country right or wrong' is a ridiculous statement. We want our country to be right, and the only way that can happen is to fess up to those things in it's past, and not allow them to happen again. It never ceases to amaze me how many people think Iraq was a justified war, or those who disagreed with the war but still felt the country must be right anyway.

Let me give you an example. During WWII Minh was promised the U.S. would aid Vietnam in their bid for independence from France if they would assist us in fighting the Japanese in Indochina. They agreed, and they fought with us. When the war was over the U.S. allowed France to just walk right in and take over again, inspite of Vietnam asking where was their help. We refused to aid them, and infact aided the French.

Secondly, in the 1950's when France was beaten, a Col Lansdale was sent by the CIA to Vietnam to begin operations against the north. You can read a lot about the Nasty boat operations simply by searching Nasty Boats or Operation 34A. By the way Lansdale was loaned to Magasaysay in the 1950's. And I can tell you that in any operation, just like 'Clean Sweep' in Vietnam, innocent civilians die. All too often at too great a cost. To tell a population that you must leave your ancestral lands or be considered the enemy and face death is not a recipe for winning the hearts and minds of people. It didn't work here, why would they think it would work anywhere else.

Anyway that's my sentiments on it.
 
No, I was referring to stories told to me by people who were around during WWII.

The Huk rebellion was against the Magasaysay government, but the U.S. interdicted in it. The CIA sent Lansdale to the Philippines to assist Magasaysay, because Magasaysay was the U.S. puppet in the Philippines. Whatever the U.S. wanted, Magasaysay gave it, no matter how the Filipinos felt about it. I'm not really sure where you were going with the 'ruling class' collaborating with the Japanese part, but I do know the Huks felt like the Philippines was 'liberated' but not really. American owned plantations, as well as other American owned companies was still the norm. Many of those I talked to felt the American presence was the 'ruling class'.
 
en.wikipedia.org/Wiki/Post-World_war_two_demobilization_strikes

I don't see what disqualifies Marxist sources, especially when other sources just refuse to report the information.

The capitalist class that ended slavery in the U.S. was a progressive class whose political strength was connected with increasing economic production. The capitalist class that rules the U.S. tosay is a parasitical class whose political strength comes at the cost of production; thus it can no lomger play that sort of progressive role.

What other country fought to end slavery? Certainly, France under the Convention.
Leaving aside the question of how much the Marshall Plan helped any but the elites of Europe, Cuba is the obvious example of a very poor country that yet sends volunteer teachers and doctors to dozens of other countries to help them, continues to treat Chernobyl victims (unlike the U.S. which treated victims for two months), andspends a greater proportion of GDP on foreign aid than any other country.
If the Filipino resistance to the U.S. came from privileged capitalists who'd collaborated with Japan, that doesn't change the fact that it affected the U.S.'s political calculations. No, I don't know what was in the U.S. leaderss' heart, but I can contrast their behavior in the Philippines with that in Indo-China (which was also promised independence), Greece, Puerto Rico, Korea, etc., and draw the obvious conclusions.
 
And as far as 'hating America', how does one hate a country? A country is land, trees, rivers, lakes, or whatever that particular regions environment is. So those who say 'if you don't like America get the hell out' are just being ludicrous. It's the decision makers, the button pushers that are the problem.
 
Back
Top