New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Does Yanukovych = Morsi?

fairsheet

Senator
This is where democracy can get really messy. Morsi was presumably the democratically elected president of Egypt. But, he was deposed by extra-democratic means. The same of course, is true of Ukraine's ex-President Yanukovych. This sort of thing makes we western (d)emocrats uncomfortable. But as someone much wiser than I asked in the Morsi case, "Is democracy served if it elects a non-democrat?"
 
This is where democracy can get really messy. Morsi was presumably the democratically elected president of Egypt. But, he was deposed by extra-democratic means. The same of course, is true of Ukraine's ex-President Yanukovych. This sort of thing makes we western (d)emocrats uncomfortable. But as someone much wiser than I asked in the Morsi case, "Is democracy served if it elects a non-democrat?"


Democracy is never a panacea when the majority of the citizens living in the prospective new democracy doesn't share the values of the outsiders promoting their newfound democracy.

Same thing happened in Palestine. The people elected the wrong guys.
 
Democracy is never a panacea when the majority of the citizens living in the prospective new democracy doesn't share the values of the outsiders promoting their newfound democracy.

Same thing happened in Palestine. The people elected the wrong guys.

I'm not sure if this is where you're going or not but....I'm not talking about their electing people WE don't like. I think it goes more to their having a completely different understanding of what democracy IS, from ours. (maybe you said that?)

Since I've spent a lot of time in Latin America over the last several decades, it's become plain that even they have a different perception of democracy, from ours. Basically (probably from experience!) they don't really expect their guvmint to do anything good for them. All they demand and expect is that their leaders won't do things that are overtly bad.
 
I'm not sure if this is where you're going or not but....I'm not talking about their electing people WE don't like. I think it goes more to their having a completely different understanding of what democracy IS, from ours. (maybe you said that?)


"We", as in the US, aren't always the outside observers hoping to promote better governance within a dysfunctional nation by promoting the institution of democracy.

I'm merely stating the obvious fact that having such a nation vote for a government, in an of itself, isn't likely to be as effective as one might have hoped upon going into the election.
 
Back
Top