New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Dollar cost averaging.

Arkady

President
Just some advice for fellow investors. So far for 2015, the stock market's been bouncing up and down. Whether it's up or down YTD changes from day to day or even hour to hour (as of this moment, the S&P 500 is down 0.07% for 2015, which is essentially unchanged). One way to take advantage of this is dollar-cost averaging. If stocks keep going up and down by about the same amount, and you buy the same dollar amount of stocks every month, then you'll tend to get a positive return on your own investment, even as the overall market shows none. For example, if in consecutive months the stock went $10, $11, $10, $9, then repeated the pattern, bouncing up and down around a $10 average, you could average an annualized return of around half a percentage point per year, even if the stock never progressed upwards, if you simply bought the same dollar amount of it every month.... and that's not even counting dividends. When you buy that way, you naturally tend to buy more of the stock when it's cheaper and less when it's more expensive, which is how you can average a return even when the market isn't going up on average.

Obviously, that's no substitute for the gigantic gains we enjoyed every other year since Obama took office, but it's a way to keep getting a small return when the market is stuck in neutral, at a time when there aren't a lot of good options other than stocks for a decent return.
 
Indeed. Constant war is always good for the economy.

We had constant war during all but the very first few months of the unlamented George W. Bush Presidency, and it was NOT 'good for the economy'. In fact, as you apparently don't remember, he left office with the entire world economy on the verge of a resounding collapse, with U.S. GDP falling at an annualized rate of ~9%, a more rapid rate of decline than anything seen even during the Great Depression.

But you do remind us that many if not most Republicans DO subscribe to the economic fallacy that 'War is good for the economy'.

The best reason of ALL to keep them out of the White House.
 
Just some advice for fellow investors. So far for 2015, the stock market's been bouncing up and down. Whether it's up or down YTD changes from day to day or even hour to hour (as of this moment, the S&P 500 is down 0.07% for 2015, which is essentially unchanged). One way to take advantage of this is dollar-cost averaging. If stocks keep going up and down by about the same amount, and you buy the same dollar amount of stocks every month, then you'll tend to get a positive return on your own investment, even as the overall market shows none. For example, if in consecutive months the stock went $10, $11, $10, $9, then repeated the pattern, bouncing up and down around a $10 average, you could average an annualized return of around half a percentage point per year, even if the stock never progressed upwards, if you simply bought the same dollar amount of it every month.... and that's not even counting dividends. When you buy that way, you naturally tend to buy more of the stock when it's cheaper and less when it's more expensive, which is how you can average a return even when the market isn't going up on average.

Obviously, that's no substitute for the gigantic gains we enjoyed every other year since Obama took office, but it's a way to keep getting a small return when the market is stuck in neutral, at a time when there aren't a lot of good options other than stocks for a decent return.

I have put money in my 401k since 1996 and my total is about equal to the amount I put in and my company matched. No actual gain. I balance the portfolio over each choice in the plan equally 8% each.

I also bought my house in 1999 and it recently appraised at just under the 1999 purchase price.

Yes, I know I have bad luck when it comes to investments.

Last April my wife and I decided to start putting $600 a month in a college fund for the kids. 8 months $4,800. It is now at $3,600...

In laws bought the grand kids all an insurance policy for $3,600 each back in 2001. They said it would pay for their college. We said thank you knowing it might pay for a semester if we are lucky. The kids were all newborns to 2 years old. Today the statement says $3,720. It is invested in stocks and gained $120 in 15 years... Incidentally State Farm sends a statement every quarter, so 4 times a year for .40 cent stamp (avg) for 15 years...$24.00 worth of postage.

In laws bought my step son a mutual fund when he was born in 1991. They put like $50 in it every birthday or special event. Total put in was around $1,500. The fund was an international fund. Around 2008 we got a letter from the mutual fund company saying the fund was closing and the funds in my step sons account was under $100 so they cashed it out.

ouch.

I have no stories of a successful investment except for my websites...sigh
 
I have put money in my 401k since 1996 and my total is about equal to the amount I put in and my company matched. No actual gain. I balance the portfolio over each choice in the plan equally 8% each.

I also bought my house in 1999 and it recently appraised at just under the 1999 purchase price.

Yes, I know I have bad luck when it comes to investments.

Last April my wife and I decided to start putting $600 a month in a college fund for the kids. 8 months $4,800. It is now at $3,600...

In laws bought the grand kids all an insurance policy for $3,600 each back in 2001. They said it would pay for their college. We said thank you knowing it might pay for a semester if we are lucky. The kids were all newborns to 2 years old. Today the statement says $3,720. It is invested in stocks and gained $120 in 15 years... Incidentally State Farm sends a statement every quarter, so 4 times a year for .40 cent stamp (avg) for 15 years...$24.00 worth of postage.

In laws bought my step son a mutual fund when he was born in 1991. They put like $50 in it every birthday or special event. Total put in was around $1,500. The fund was an international fund. Around 2008 we got a letter from the mutual fund company saying the fund was closing and the funds in my step sons account was under $100 so they cashed it out.

ouch.

I have no stories of a successful investment except for my websites...sigh

Arkady will tell you that's because you've been thinking conservative thoughts. Bad boy!
 
Indeed. Constant war is always good for the economy.
Nope. As you'll recall, we were at war, on Bush's watch, from September 2001 through January 2009, yet stock values plunged horribly during that time and the overall economy performed terribly.
 
I have put money in my 401k since 1996 and my total is about equal to the amount I put in and my company matched. No actual gain. I balance the portfolio over each choice in the plan equally 8% each.

Interesting. Are your gains being eaten up by fees? That's a huge issue with a lot of 401k plans. I'm lucky enough to have Vanguard as my plan manager, and a big enough company that could negotiate especially good terms for the 401k. With about an 0.17% expense ratio, you get to keep nearly all your gains that way, but if you're in one of those funds where 2% gets taken to keep the fat-cats on Wall Street well fed, you can wind up with few real gains.

My approach is pretty simple. I go for very low fees and very simple investments, but I don't shy away from risk. Consider, say, the ETF VTI or Vanguard's FVINX -- low costs, solid returns. Since 2005, you'd have gotten about 6.7% per year, on average, which is enough that your initial investment should have roughly doubled over the course of the decade ($1000 would be worth around $1900 today).

My timing on my home purchase was also bad. I bought in around 2002, which was right around the peak of the local market, since Massachusetts was ahead of the curve with the bubble and the crash. So, it took me years before we appraised for more than the purchase price, but at this point, we're up around 15%... which isn't any kind of real return, after accounting for inflation, but at least we haven't lost any money.

Last April my wife and I decided to start putting $600 a month in a college fund for the kids. 8 months $4,800. It is now at $3,600...

Are you doing a 529? I've got mixed emotions about those. On the plus side, there are tax advantages, but on the minus side the plans themselves aren't great, in terms of costs. We've been doing a 529 since my wife got pregnant, which we put in our daughter's name once she was born, five and a half years ago. It's going well. At the present pace, we'll be able to stop putting money away in five years and she'll be able to cover the full cost of a four-year private college education, assuming the market averages returns equal to the education inflation rate. But you got really unlucky starting in April -- you missed years of run-up and came out right before the market took a hit. Ride it out, though, and you should be good. Down markets mean you get to buy more with less.

Paying for college without debt is CRAZY difficult. Right now you have to budget about $60,000 per year for a top private university. That's almost a quarter of a million dollars you have to put away for four years, and if your kids are young it'll be a whole lot more by the time you get there. If you start the month a child is born, you need to put away about $1000 per month until they graduate high school, based on various assumptions about returns. If you start later, you have to put away far more.

In laws bought my step son a mutual fund when he was born in 1991. They put like $50 in it every birthday or special event. Total put in was around $1,500. The fund was an international fund. Around 2008 we got a letter from the mutual fund company saying the fund was closing and the funds in my step sons account was under $100 so they cashed it out.

That's nuts! I'd love to know which mutual fund it was. Even with the Bush stock collapse, just about any portfolio should have been up. At the start of 1991, the S&P 500 had an adjusted close of 322. By the end of 2008, it was at 903. So, even that first $50 they put in should have been worth about $140 by 2008, just based on a generic large-cap US portfolio. The S&P 500 averaged about 5.9% return per year during that time. So, if they put in about $100 per year (one birthday, one special event), it should have been worth a bit over $3,340 in 2008, if it had matched the pace of the overall market. Even accounting for expenses, it should have easily been over $3,000. It sounds like whatever investment firm they used really hosed them if somehow it was under $100. I don't have the data for international funds going back that far, but given the fact international stocks outperformed US stocks for most of the Bush era, there were returns to be had there, too. I wonder if maybe it was heavy into the Nikkei or something.
 
a rare case where ASOT and Arkady completely agree (ASOT looks over her shoulder in fear, at possible impending asteroid strike ... )

the "sanest" way to invest is through your 401K, each paycheck, automatic deduction. Pick a mutual fund indexed to a the broad market (S&P works better than the DOW). Don't buy or sell a company just because they roused Warren Buffet from his coma to give an opinion on it.

That said, we ARE likely to see "volatility" the moment Janet is finally forced to increase the fed funds rate. Expect people with margin loans to lighten their positions. how long, how severe? Who knows.

errata: the "green stock of the year" (solar city - scty) lost 50% of its value a few months ago when it had an earnings miss. This is an Elon Musk company. It has since recovered half of its loss, but it is extremely volatile, and has minimal to negative earnings - just like Tesla itself.
 
529 yes
Interesting. Are your gains being eaten up by fees? That's a huge issue with a lot of 401k plans. I'm lucky enough to have Vanguard as my plan manager, and a big enough company that could negotiate especially good terms for the 401k. With about an 0.17% expense ratio, you get to keep nearly all your gains that way, but if you're in one of those funds where 2% gets taken to keep the fat-cats on Wall Street well fed, you can wind up with few real gains.

My approach is pretty simple. I go for very low fees and very simple investments, but I don't shy away from risk. Consider, say, the ETF VTI or Vanguard's FVINX -- low costs, solid returns. Since 2005, you'd have gotten about 6.7% per year, on average, which is enough that your initial investment should have roughly doubled over the course of the decade ($1000 would be worth around $1900 today).

My timing on my home purchase was also bad. I bought in around 2002, which was right around the peak of the local market, since Massachusetts was ahead of the curve with the bubble and the crash. So, it took me years before we appraised for more than the purchase price, but at this point, we're up around 15%... which isn't any kind of real return, after accounting for inflation, but at least we haven't lost any money.



Are you doing a 529? I've got mixed emotions about those. On the plus side, there are tax advantages, but on the minus side the plans themselves aren't great, in terms of costs. We've been doing a 529 since my wife got pregnant, which we put in our daughter's name once she was born, five and a half years ago. It's going well. At the present pace, we'll be able to stop putting money away in five years and she'll be able to cover the full cost of a four-year private college education, assuming the market averages returns equal to the education inflation rate. But you got really unlucky starting in April -- you missed years of run-up and came out right before the market took a hit. Ride it out, though, and you should be good. Down markets mean you get to buy more with less.

Paying for college without debt is CRAZY difficult. Right now you have to budget about $60,000 per year for a top private university. That's almost a quarter of a million dollars you have to put away for four years, and if your kids are young it'll be a whole lot more by the time you get there. If you start the month a child is born, you need to put away about $1000 per month until they graduate high school, based on various assumptions about returns. If you start later, you have to put away far more.



That's nuts! I'd love to know which mutual fund it was. Even with the Bush stock collapse, just about any portfolio should have been up. At the start of 1991, the S&P 500 had an adjusted close of 322. By the end of 2008, it was at 903. So, even that first $50 they put in should have been worth about $140 by 2008, just based on a generic large-cap US portfolio. The S&P 500 averaged about 5.9% return per year during that time. So, if they put in about $100 per year (one birthday, one special event), it should have been worth a bit over $3,340 in 2008, if it had matched the pace of the overall market. Even accounting for expenses, it should have easily been over $3,000. It sounds like whatever investment firm they used really hosed them if somehow it was under $100. I don't have the data for international funds going back that far, but given the fact international stocks outperformed US stocks for most of the Bush era, there were returns to be had there, too. I wonder if maybe it was heavy into the Nikkei or something.

529 yes.

The 401k I moved to EJ a year and half ago when I started my own business.

The step son fund was Franklin Templeton International Growth Fund I believe.
 
Interesting. Are your gains being eaten up by fees? That's a huge issue with a lot of 401k plans. I'm lucky enough to have Vanguard as my plan manager, and a big enough company that could negotiate especially good terms for the 401k. With about an 0.17% expense ratio, you get to keep nearly all your gains that way, but if you're in one of those funds where 2% gets taken to keep the fat-cats on Wall Street well fed, you can wind up with few real gains.

My approach is pretty simple. I go for very low fees and very simple investments, but I don't shy away from risk. Consider, say, the ETF VTI or Vanguard's FVINX -- low costs, solid returns. Since 2005, you'd have gotten about 6.7% per year, on average, which is enough that your initial investment should have roughly doubled over the course of the decade ($1000 would be worth around $1900 today).

My timing on my home purchase was also bad. I bought in around 2002, which was right around the peak of the local market, since Massachusetts was ahead of the curve with the bubble and the crash. So, it took me years before we appraised for more than the purchase price, but at this point, we're up around 15%... which isn't any kind of real return, after accounting for inflation, but at least we haven't lost any money.



Are you doing a 529? I've got mixed emotions about those. On the plus side, there are tax advantages, but on the minus side the plans themselves aren't great, in terms of costs. We've been doing a 529 since my wife got pregnant, which we put in our daughter's name once she was born, five and a half years ago. It's going well. At the present pace, we'll be able to stop putting money away in five years and she'll be able to cover the full cost of a four-year private college education, assuming the market averages returns equal to the education inflation rate. But you got really unlucky starting in April -- you missed years of run-up and came out right before the market took a hit. Ride it out, though, and you should be good. Down markets mean you get to buy more with less.

Paying for college without debt is CRAZY difficult. Right now you have to budget about $60,000 per year for a top private university. That's almost a quarter of a million dollars you have to put away for four years, and if your kids are young it'll be a whole lot more by the time you get there. If you start the month a child is born, you need to put away about $1000 per month until they graduate high school, based on various assumptions about returns. If you start later, you have to put away far more.



That's nuts! I'd love to know which mutual fund it was. Even with the Bush stock collapse, just about any portfolio should have been up. At the start of 1991, the S&P 500 had an adjusted close of 322. By the end of 2008, it was at 903. So, even that first $50 they put in should have been worth about $140 by 2008, just based on a generic large-cap US portfolio. The S&P 500 averaged about 5.9% return per year during that time. So, if they put in about $100 per year (one birthday, one special event), it should have been worth a bit over $3,340 in 2008, if it had matched the pace of the overall market. Even accounting for expenses, it should have easily been over $3,000. It sounds like whatever investment firm they used really hosed them if somehow it was under $100. I don't have the data for international funds going back that far, but given the fact international stocks outperformed US stocks for most of the Bush era, there were returns to be had there, too. I wonder if maybe it was heavy into the Nikkei or something.

And I won't have a million of anything or be paying 60k a year for anyones college. I have 4 kids. 3 will go to college at the same time. May be community college then 2 years of a state university not sure.
 
a rare case where ASOT and Arkady completely agree (ASOT looks over her shoulder in fear, at possible impending asteroid strike ... )

the "sanest" way to invest is through your 401K, each paycheck, automatic deduction. Pick a mutual fund indexed to a the broad market (S&P works better than the DOW). Don't buy or sell a company just because they roused Warren Buffet from his coma to give an opinion on it.

That said, we ARE likely to see "volatility" the moment Janet is finally forced to increase the fed funds rate. Expect people with margin loans to lighten their positions. how long, how severe? Who knows.

errata: the "green stock of the year" (solar city - scty) lost 50% of its value a few months ago when it had an earnings miss. This is an Elon Musk company. It has since recovered half of its loss, but it is extremely volatile, and has minimal to negative earnings - just like Tesla itself.
I used to day trade, a long time ago. I was OK at it -- doubling overall market returns on average. But it was killing me. Miss a peak or guess a trough wrong even by a couple minutes and you can go from a big gain to a big loss. Play with derivatives and it's even scarier. I would go from way up to way down from day to day, and I was obsessing over the market -- listening for every bit of news and trying to guess if the insiders had already figured out the implications and traded before I could make a move, or whether there was a shot to make a quick buck. If it's not your full-time job, that kind of trading can become impossible, given competing priorities that could make you miss a trade. So, I gave up and went about as plain vanilla as you can: a "buy and hold," "dollar cost averaging," broad-based-index portfolio, which tries to put the overall market to work for me, with as much tax and cost efficiency as possible. I still play an occasional market-timing game.... for example, holding a bonus for a couple weeks and then buying on a fall. So, I've been able to beat the S&P 500 slightly, on average, over the last several years (e.g., buying in the midst of Euro zone panics, so I can ride the inevitable bounce back). But it's not the kind of investment plan that'll ever make me very rich. still, since I'm consistent about my contributions, it builds up nicely with time, and I ought to be able to retire fairly young, and send my daughter through college without debt.
 
And I won't have a million of anything or be paying 60k a year for anyones college. I have 4 kids. 3 will go to college at the same time. May be community college then 2 years of a state university not sure.
The community college-to-state-school strategy makes great sense, financially. Once someone graduates, all they list is where their degree is from, so you get the full credit for the better school, at a lower cost. Another option to consider is study-abroad. I did a year at Ludwig Maximilians Universitaet, in Germany, and that year was practically free for me, because of how the German system works, and yet I got full credit towards graduating from a very expensive US school. It cut my overall college bill by around 15-20%, even after considering the costs of travel. Also, if your kids test well, look into whether schools have deals for National Merit Scholars. Back when I was applying, there were dozens of schools that would waive application fees for National Merit Scholars, so you could send out a ton of applications at no cost and see who comes up with the most financial aid.... at the time, George Washington was providing free tuition to any National Merit Scholar, so room and board would be the only costs.

Having three kids makes it tough. One of my best friends is in the same boat. I wanted two kids but ended up with only one. That does have some huge financial consolation, though, obviously. When it comes to everything from vacation to education, I can be extravagant in a way that wouldn't be possible if I multiplied her costs.
 
I have put money in my 401k since 1996 and my total is about equal to the amount I put in and my company matched. No actual gain. I balance the portfolio over each choice in the plan equally 8% each.

I also bought my house in 1999 and it recently appraised at just under the 1999 purchase price.

Yes, I know I have bad luck when it comes to investments.

Last April my wife and I decided to start putting $600 a month in a college fund for the kids. 8 months $4,800. It is now at $3,600...

In laws bought the grand kids all an insurance policy for $3,600 each back in 2001. They said it would pay for their college. We said thank you knowing it might pay for a semester if we are lucky. The kids were all newborns to 2 years old. Today the statement says $3,720. It is invested in stocks and gained $120 in 15 years... Incidentally State Farm sends a statement every quarter, so 4 times a year for .40 cent stamp (avg) for 15 years...$24.00 worth of postage.

In laws bought my step son a mutual fund when he was born in 1991. They put like $50 in it every birthday or special event. Total put in was around $1,500. The fund was an international fund. Around 2008 we got a letter from the mutual fund company saying the fund was closing and the funds in my step sons account was under $100 so they cashed it out.

ouch.

I have no stories of a successful investment except for my websites...sigh

You aren't alone. Guys like the poster here tout stocks because stock index levels is one of the few economic measures they can use to spin the (failed) Obama economic agenda as a success. But the fact is that the gains are not that great for the buy and hold crowd:

Screen Shot 2015-12-11 at 8.36.16 AM.png
And, unless you are in an index fund, your "gains" are probably negative:

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-12-09/almost-70-us-stocks-are-below-their-200-day-moving-average

And the future doesn't look very promising:

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/st...000-and-2007-peaks-2015-12-11?dist=beforebell

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/a137f388-7f26-11e5-ae43-f6d4a22c5a1a.html

So one would be wise to take this poster's "investment" advice with a grain of salt...
 
I used to day trade, a long time ago. I was OK at it -- doubling overall market returns on average. But it was killing me. Miss a peak or guess a trough wrong even by a couple minutes and you can go from a big gain to a big loss. Play with derivatives and it's even scarier. I would go from way up to way down from day to day, and I was obsessing over the market -- listening for every bit of news and trying to guess if the insiders had already figured out the implications and traded before I could make a move, or whether there was a shot to make a quick buck. If it's not your full-time job, that kind of trading can become impossible, given competing priorities that could make you miss a trade. So, I gave up and went about as plain vanilla as you can: a "buy and hold," "dollar cost averaging," broad-based-index portfolio, which tries to put the overall market to work for me, with as much tax and cost efficiency as possible. I still play an occasional market-timing game.... for example, holding a bonus for a couple weeks and then buying on a fall. So, I've been able to beat the S&P 500 slightly, on average, over the last several years (e.g., buying in the midst of Euro zone panics, so I can ride the inevitable bounce back). But it's not the kind of investment plan that'll ever make me very rich. still, since I'm consistent about my contributions, it builds up nicely with time, and I ought to be able to retire fairly young, and send my daughter through college without debt.

I tried day trading too.Derivatives? I traded the mini Nasdaq, you can make some good money but you can get your clock cleaned too. I made decent profits but quite frankly it wasn't worth the work. I also found it was far too easy to go from technically analyzing the market action to simply gambling. I think day traders who are successful long term are able to keep a pretty much completely objective mindset- something extremely difficult to do when you're watching streaming charts with your money at play. Was your experience with it similar?

Market timing: this bull market cannot go on forever. While I do generally dollar cost average, I've stayed out all of 2015. I know I've missed out on some modest gains. And who knows, I may miss out on more. But in times like these, I always remember what one of the investment gurus (can't remember his name, but I know it was epic like Jim Rogers, Warren Buffet and George Soros level) once said about the key to his success: he always sold too soon.
 
The community college-to-state-school strategy makes great sense, financially. Once someone graduates, all they list is where their degree is from, so you get the full credit for the better school, at a lower cost. Another option to consider is study-abroad. I did a year at Ludwig Maximilians Universitaet, in Germany, and that year was practically free for me, because of how the German system works, and yet I got full credit towards graduating from a very expensive US school. It cut my overall college bill by around 15-20%, even after considering the costs of travel. Also, if your kids test well, look into whether schools have deals for National Merit Scholars. Back when I was applying, there were dozens of schools that would waive application fees for National Merit Scholars, so you could send out a ton of applications at no cost and see who comes up with the most financial aid.... at the time, George Washington was providing free tuition to any National Merit Scholar, so room and board would be the only costs.

Having three kids makes it tough. One of my best friends is in the same boat. I wanted two kids but ended up with only one. That does have some huge financial consolation, though, obviously. When it comes to everything from vacation to education, I can be extravagant in a way that wouldn't be possible if I multiplied her costs.

Thanks.

My twins just started High School and got a 4.07 grade average first semester. My other is a Soph he gets a 3.3. So not sure on the scholarships but worth a try for the 4 pointers.
 
I used to day trade, a long time ago. I was OK at it -- doubling overall market returns on average. But it was killing me. Miss a peak or guess a trough wrong even by a couple minutes and you can go from a big gain to a big loss. Play with derivatives and it's even scarier. I would go from way up to way down from day to day, and I was obsessing over the market -- listening for every bit of news and trying to guess if the insiders had already figured out the implications and traded before I could make a move, or whether there was a shot to make a quick buck. If it's not your full-time job, that kind of trading can become impossible, given competing priorities that could make you miss a trade. So, I gave up and went about as plain vanilla as you can: a "buy and hold," "dollar cost averaging," broad-based-index portfolio, which tries to put the overall market to work for me, with as much tax and cost efficiency as possible. I still play an occasional market-timing game.... for example, holding a bonus for a couple weeks and then buying on a fall. So, I've been able to beat the S&P 500 slightly, on average, over the last several years (e.g., buying in the midst of Euro zone panics, so I can ride the inevitable bounce back). But it's not the kind of investment plan that'll ever make me very rich. still, since I'm consistent about my contributions, it builds up nicely with time, and I ought to be able to retire fairly young, and send my daughter through college without debt.

The other thing about the market is it has say a 9% historic return (not sure on the actual number), but what percentage of the 9% was made by insiders, professionals, and CEO and employees? What is the real historic return of the stock market for a 401k investor or individual investor?

I contend that a chunk of the historic gain was made by insiders and professionals that spend their full time on it.
 
I tried day trading too.Derivatives? I traded the mini Nasdaq, you can make some good money but you can get your clock cleaned too. I made decent profits but quite frankly it wasn't worth the work. I also found it was far too easy to go from technically analyzing the market action to simply gambling. I think day traders who are successful long term are able to keep a pretty much completely objective mindset- something extremely difficult to do when you're watching streaming charts with your money at play. Was your experience with it similar?

Yes. I found I actually got worse at it after I'd made some real money, when the opposite should have been true (since costs are proportionally lower the more you're investing). Emotionally, it was easier to stay objective about a small dollar figure than a big one, so I got a little less rational with time. I could justify to myself losing $10,000 I was playing with, but not $50,000, and growing risk aversion hurt my analysis.

Market timing: this bull market cannot go on forever. While I do generally dollar cost average, I've stayed out all of 2015. I know I've missed out on some modest gains. And who knows, I may miss out on more. But in times like these, I always remember what one of the investment gurus (can't remember his name, but I know it was epic like Jim Rogers, Warren Buffet and George Soros level) once said about the key to his success: he always sold too soon.

I agree that there's probably more downside than upside, at this point. My approach has been to stay in, but to reduce risk based on how I do the investing. I keep my 401K invested the way it always has been (mostly linked to the overall S&P 500, maxing out my tax-deductible contributions every month), and also the 529, but for my investing beyond that, I've gotten quite conservative.... a whole lot more sitting in an "emergency fund" (FDIC insured, low-interest), and the rest going into buying a company stock where I get a 15% discount. It's a safe, dividend-paying company, unlikely to fall by much more than 20% even in a really bad market, so I figure there's not huge risk there for me.
 
The other thing about the market is it has say a 9% historic return (not sure on the actual number), but what percentage of the 9% was made by insiders, professionals, and CEO and employees? What is the real historic return of the stock market for a 401k investor or individual investor?

I contend that a chunk of the historic gain was made by insiders and professionals that spend their full time on it.
Well, the 9% is average, and the insiders do much better than that, while most people do worse. But that's part of why I go with such a generic approach these days. If you do a buy-and-hold strategy on a very low-cost fund based on a broad index like the S&P 500, and the market averages 9%, you'll average just slightly less than that (say 8.94%, if you have a 0.06% expense). The only thing that will push it lower than that is if you try to market-time or play games with allocations, and thus get pulled into jumping onto bandwagons just as the wheels are about to come off. The generic approach is annoying, in that it pretty much guarantees that you'll do worse than the market, and you lose any chance of any "get rich quick result." You'll hear lots of stories about people who made a bundle on investments you knew would do well but didn't get into, and you'll feel like you're throwing away golden opportunities. But it's a sure-fire way to put the market to work for you. A long-term return of, say, 6% over inflation, is more than enough to make you comfortable if you stick with it. If you can put $1000 per month away that way, after 30 years you'll have about a million bucks, even after adjusting for inflation.
 
Yes. I found I actually got worse at it after I'd made some real money, when the opposite should have been true (since costs are proportionally lower the more you're investing). Emotionally, it was easier to stay objective about a small dollar figure than a big one, so I got a little less rational with time. I could justify to myself losing $10,000 I was playing with, but not $50,000, and growing risk aversion hurt my analysis.

BAM! Very well-said. Prior to trying day trading, I read at least ten books on it. I'm convinced it comes down to using the analytical part of our brain versus the greed part (for lack of a better term). I did some "paper trading" initially and it went well. My first few trades were great. I got 40% returns in a day on the mini Nasdaq on several occasions. At any rate, we had pretty much identical experiences.

I agree that there's probably more downside than upside, at this point. My approach has been to stay in, but to reduce risk based on how I do the investing. I keep my 401K invested the way it always has been (mostly linked to the overall S&P 500, maxing out my tax-deductible contributions every month), and also the 529, but for my investing beyond that, I've gotten quite conservative.... a whole lot more sitting in an "emergency fund" (FDIC insured, low-interest), and the rest going into buying a company stock where I get a 15% discount. It's a safe, dividend-paying company, unlikely to fall by much more than 20% even in a really bad market, so I figure there's not huge risk there for me.

I'm a big fan of index funds. As you noted, the expense ratios are nice and low. You clearly did the math as I did, comparing returns and expense fees. People don't realize how much that 1+% eats away over time. We do the same thing with our "emergency fund", keeping around 4 months' expenses we can get to quickly if needed.

Ben Stein has a great book on investing. And the fact is, almost everyone should do what we are doing- keeping the bulk, if not all of in some sort of index fund. Vanguard is my personal favorite, and for the reasons you mentioned.

The company discount sounds great, with the fact they pay dividends making it more attractive. I can't recall where specifically I read this, but companies who pay dividends tend to be more stable. With that in mind, you gotta take the 15% discount. I'm a freelancer, but my wife takes the free money in the form of matching funds. She also makes a pretty good living, and she's been there long enough to get a 125% match up to 6%. The company match is well into five figures yearly.When I was young and employed by a company, a wise man told me to put the 7% into my 401(k), that I'd never miss it. I was skeptical at first, but after the first two weeks I never looked back.

I would love to see our education system give focus on money management. I was fortunate to have wise parents, though still had to learn the credit card lesson early on. Many people aren't as fortunate and never really learn how to handle finances well.
 
I did some "paper trading" initially and it went well.

Funny you should say that. That's what got me into it in the first place. There was a website that let you play with fake money and I was ridiculously good at it. When there were no consequences, I could be completely dispassionate and just go where the numbers lead. So, I figured if I could do it with fake money I could do it with real money, too. But, although I did OK, I wasn't nearly as good once there were real consequences. Mostly it was growing risk aversion, but there was also an element of greed. Sometime I'd jump into something for no damned reason than I'd heard an analyst hyping the hell out of something and I didn't want to miss the boat -- I'd trade fast, with the fear that the analyst's report had just come out and if I didn't move fast everyone else will have already seen it and the buying opportunity would be gone. Dumb. In my wiser moments, I would always try to think more indirectly -- what are some consequences that the analyst DIDN'T think through... things that may not yet have occurred to other traders. Then move on that. But that takes patience and an ability to suppress wishful thinking.

People don't realize how much that 1+% eats away over time.

Frontline did a brilliant show on this a while back, showing how a 1% expense can eat up a huge portion of your portfolio. It seems like a particular problem in a low-return climate, where the proportional impact of fees isn't being washed out by the sheer size of the return.

We do the same thing with our "emergency fund", keeping around 4 months' expenses we can get to quickly if needed.

I should revisit it and figure out how much I should have there. I suspect I'm not being conservative enough. I could get by for a long time if, say, I lost my job. But it would require some pretty dramatic changes from day one to do so, which isn't really ideal. I've got about two months of my after-tax, after-401k salary sitting in the emergency fund, and three seems more reasonable.

she's been there long enough to get a 125% match up to 6%.

That's outstanding. Ours is done by a complicated formula, but if you max out it works out to a contribution equal to 4% of your annual income, which I think is standard these days. However, I also get a traditional defined-benefit pension, which is unusual, and it's a nice insurance policy against risk. I'm already vested for quite a bit, so it's comforting to think that between that and Social Security, I'm going to be virtually guaranteed a basic minimum income to live on.... nothing fancy, but I'm never going to be living out of a cardboard box.

I would love to see our education system give focus on money management.

Same. In my case, I learned through sheer terror, in the face of college loans that were absolutely crushing. I needed to learn to live VERY frugally for the first several years, and by then I was disciplined enough that as my income rose and my debt disappeared, I prevented myself from letting my expenses keep pace with my means. I still live in my run-down little "starter home," worth about $300k, even though those affordability calculators say I could easily afford around $1.5 million. I drive a ten-year-old car, too, and we don't have a third car or a boat or a vacation home or any extravagances like that, which most of my work peers have. We live solidly middle-class and put lots of money away. The only big extravagance is my daughter's school.
 
Back
Top