Interesting. Are your gains being eaten up by fees? That's a huge issue with a lot of 401k plans. I'm lucky enough to have Vanguard as my plan manager, and a big enough company that could negotiate especially good terms for the 401k. With about an 0.17% expense ratio, you get to keep nearly all your gains that way, but if you're in one of those funds where 2% gets taken to keep the fat-cats on Wall Street well fed, you can wind up with few real gains.
My approach is pretty simple. I go for very low fees and very simple investments, but I don't shy away from risk. Consider, say, the ETF VTI or Vanguard's FVINX -- low costs, solid returns. Since 2005, you'd have gotten about 6.7% per year, on average, which is enough that your initial investment should have roughly doubled over the course of the decade ($1000 would be worth around $1900 today).
My timing on my home purchase was also bad. I bought in around 2002, which was right around the peak of the local market, since Massachusetts was ahead of the curve with the bubble and the crash. So, it took me years before we appraised for more than the purchase price, but at this point, we're up around 15%... which isn't any kind of real return, after accounting for inflation, but at least we haven't lost any money.
Are you doing a 529? I've got mixed emotions about those. On the plus side, there are tax advantages, but on the minus side the plans themselves aren't great, in terms of costs. We've been doing a 529 since my wife got pregnant, which we put in our daughter's name once she was born, five and a half years ago. It's going well. At the present pace, we'll be able to stop putting money away in five years and she'll be able to cover the full cost of a four-year private college education, assuming the market averages returns equal to the education inflation rate. But you got really unlucky starting in April -- you missed years of run-up and came out right before the market took a hit. Ride it out, though, and you should be good. Down markets mean you get to buy more with less.
Paying for college without debt is CRAZY difficult. Right now you have to budget about $60,000 per year for a top private university. That's almost a quarter of a million dollars you have to put away for four years, and if your kids are young it'll be a whole lot more by the time you get there. If you start the month a child is born, you need to put away about $1000 per month until they graduate high school, based on various assumptions about returns. If you start later, you have to put away far more.
That's nuts! I'd love to know which mutual fund it was. Even with the Bush stock collapse, just about any portfolio should have been up. At the start of 1991, the S&P 500 had an adjusted close of 322. By the end of 2008, it was at 903. So, even that first $50 they put in should have been worth about $140 by 2008, just based on a generic large-cap US portfolio. The S&P 500 averaged about 5.9% return per year during that time. So, if they put in about $100 per year (one birthday, one special event), it should have been worth a bit over $3,340 in 2008, if it had matched the pace of the overall market. Even accounting for expenses, it should have easily been over $3,000. It sounds like whatever investment firm they used really hosed them if somehow it was under $100. I don't have the data for international funds going back that far, but given the fact international stocks outperformed US stocks for most of the Bush era, there were returns to be had there, too. I wonder if maybe it was heavy into the Nikkei or something.