I watched the cartoon.
And as I watched it, I thought to myself, "Damn, the style of this seems awfully familiar." And then it hit me. "This looks and sounds like one of the old MGM cartoon shorts", I thought. So I did some digging and sure enough, it from the Hanna Barbera folks. The same studio that did the old Tom & Jerry cartoons, among many others. It even features the same voice talent, including the incomparable Daws Butler -- the voice of Yogi Bear, Huckleberry Hound, Cap'n Crunch, and countless others.
Everyone knows Tom & Jerry, I reckon. My favorite Hanna Barbera / MGM character from that era is and always was Barney Bear. Who remembers Barney? Here's one of his earliest and best appearances:
[video=youtube;8dor-dcTcUI]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dor-dcTcUI&feature=related[/video]
As I get older, Barney reminds me more and more... of me!
Anyway, as for "Make Mine Freedom", I have a few thoughts. First of all, isn't it interesting that a Podunk liberal arts college in Arkansas could hire such top-notch animation talent in 1948? Times sure have changed.
Second, I'd point out that the cartoon isn't all that particular with respect to the "isms" that are being cautioned against. Sure, the specific examples given in the cartoon relate to the totalitarianism current at the time. Collective agriculture, five-year plans, state-run unions and the like... Let's not forget that in 1948 those ideologies were genuine competitors to the regulated capitalism that has since swept them aside.
And those ideologies have been swept aside. Sure, there are people who want to compare Obama's policies to those of Mao and Stalin. Those people are idiots, quite frankly. Their braying only clouds the issues, slippery slope fever dreams to the contrary notwithstanding.
Another point: the cartoon does specifically mention religious intolerance, for example, as a divisive element to fear in our politics. I know that various right wingers have embraced this cartoon as a kind of prophecy and ever-relevant warning. Oddly enough, they seem to highlight the anti-collectivist message in the film while ignoring the anti-religionist message. By the way, it's worth noting that free and activist unions are more or less celebrated in the cartoon as being part and parcel of freedom's bulwarks. Funny how that never seems to get mentioned in these latter-day reinterpretations.
One final point. Did you notice how all the defenders of freedom in the cartoon -- the folks intended to represent a meaningful cross-section of the American body politic -- are white males? Time do change, don't you think?
Cheers.