It’s not that I “blame Trump” for withdrawing. We should have withdrawn. After 20 years it was clear that only the Taliban had the will to control the country. Our attempt to enable others was futile. But Trump should not have switched sides and aided the Taliban, creating the inevitable chaos we saw. That’s all I’m saying.
I disagree with you on ever count. Your pov, as many people's sadly are, is an ignorant and a purely selfish one. That be as it may ..... how exactly did Trump cause Biden's chaos? - pray tell.
What specifics of trump's withdrawal plan? He lost...therefore no.plan ensued.As you know, I don’t ignore it. I have asked for specifics - things that Biden could have done differently to provide for an “orderly, informed exit.” Things that would have avoided the consequences of Trump’s withdrawal plan. I have heard no such things. And for the reasons I have laid out, the chaos was inevitable. There’s no “orderly” way to flee a country upon ending a war that is lost.
It’s JUST LIKE this early-generation gas powered toy airplane I had as a kid. It had individual punch cards that you insert into a slot. That punch card contained a pattern that commanded the plane to “Loop de Loop” or “20-yard Circle”. The plane would execute the precise, to-the-letter hardwired flight pattern and that is all. It could do nothing more, nothing less.A worthy point.
How many times have we heard insurrection "dutifully parroted" in this forum?
Not coup attempt....No revolt or mutiny or uprising or even sedition, or any one of another handful of terms they could have used...Just that one singular term for their collective one singular mind. It's as if the mother ship sends out the marching orders and the zombies just fall in line in total compliance.
Now, after Biden's Afghanistan debacle, the phrase du jour is "Trump Surrender", with not a single syllable altered. Regurgitated verbatim, and then insisted upon, as if the poor chap in the White House is but a helpless babe, powerless against the might of a departed administration.
The dearth of independent thought is truly astounding.
What specifics of trump's withdrawal plan? He lost...therefore no.plan ensued.
It’s JUST LIKE this early-generation gas powered toy airplane I had as a kid. It had individual punch cards that you insert into a slot. That punch card contained a pattern that commanded the plane to “Loop de Loop” or “20-yard Circle”. The plane would execute the precise, to-the-letter hardwired flight pattern and that is all. It could do nothing more, nothing less.
…Although at least if a strong gust of wind blew there would be some modest variation as to trajectory. There is no such “gust” for the dutiful lefty automaton.
I have explained this many times, chapter and verse. The short version…
When Trump switched sides and agreed with the Taliban (only the Taliban) to unilaterally reduce our troops and release 5,000 Taliban fighters, the die was cast - the deal guaranteed that the Taliban would take over the country. The only issue was how quickly that would happen. As we saw during the closing weeks, the Afghanistan government and army were totally demoralized and they threw down their weapons. Not at all surprising when you think about it - they knew that Trump switched sides and cut a deal with the Taliban to cede the nation to them. Why die resisting the inevitable? The Afghans just collapsed. And when they collapsed, the chaos ensued. All inevitable.
That’s how. Rather than making more noise, refute what I said, if you can.
I didn’t ask for the specifics of Trump’s surrender plan. I provided them.
Good morning, you do realize that your attempting rational conversation with bat crap crazy.No, no you did not.
Good morning, you do realize that your attempting rational conversation with bat crap crazy.![]()
Good morning, you do realize that your attempting rational conversation with bat crap crazy.![]()
I am not the only one to have 'refuted' your above twisted version of events, more than once. I am not doing it again, it is to tedious, but to comment on your use of language!
You just accused Trump of being a turn coat and committing treason, in broad day light! when he was your Commander in Chief. You are like a mad person on a bicycle with no brakes wizzing down a hill. Get a hold of yourself man!
The usual winger response - all rant, no substance.
Let me know if you can actually confront or refute what I said. Your inability to do so speaks volumes, as does your mindless dittoing with other wingers who can only rant.
Do you believe that it was right to leave Afghanistan? I think that you'd say yes to that as do many on here, left and right leaning. I do not, so accusing me of dittoing those whom I disagree with is a mindless accusation, on your part - some of us can be civil toward each other, even when we do disagree.
You accused Trump of treason, of changing sides as in becoming a Taliban .... he did not become Taliban. He talked to them, in preperation of a US departure, with the veiw of leaving a stable inclusive Gov behind. The prisoner swap was a good will gesture between the two main Afghan factions before they sat down to talk.
That was it - end of Trump's input.
The US was going - Bush, Obama, Trump, Biden, what difference did it make to Afghans? They believed that you were leaving.
In May when the Taliban come out of hibernation what did Biden do to help the Afghan army?
Perhaps President Biden is contemplating a more dangerous situation unfolding- among others.That is another worry - the USofA was set up so as not to have any despotic, cranky, old 'Kings' inflicted upon you. What happened? You have ended up with a truly wicked and utterly stupid old man who, with the click of his fingers, has just inflicted a needless and idiotic devastation on the world. One which will reverberate for centuries to come.
1. You ask me if I thought withdrawal from Afghanistan was appropriate although I just said above that it was. Again, you should read what is written instead of ranting.
2. I did not use the word treason - I described what Trump did. Facts.
3. I did not say Trump “became Taliban.” Your need to tell such bizarre lies should tell you that your argument is baseless.
4. It’s absurd to claim Trump sought to leave a stable government behind through a totally one-sided deal that paved the way for the Taliban to take control of the country. Or is the Taliban the “stable government” to which you refer?
Perhaps President Biden is contemplating a more dangerous situation unfolding- among others.
![]()
China Air Force Warns Away Suspected U.S. Aircraft on Patrol Near Taiwan
Flight-tracking software showed a U.S. Navy patrol aircraft conducting a routine operation in the Bashi Channel, south of Taiwan, on Monday.www.newsweek.com
1. Just making absolutely certain that you were happy with Trump, on that point.
2. 3. That is exactly what you described Trump as. Did you exaggerate yourself into a lie?
3. At any and every point, in the last 20 yrs, that 'peace talks' were mentioned, the Taliban, as a part of the Afghan gov, were always in the equasion. You haven't been watching, have you?