I'm sorry, but I doubt that "many" do this. Some do, undoubtedly. Most do not.
Even Robertson is a "born again" Christian, right? I don't know whether, as with Bush and McCain, that involved rejecting the faith he was raised in, in order to adopt a less rational (or more politically convenient) new faith, or whether it just involved reaffirming his allegiance to the faith imposed on him as a child, after some period of drifting away, but either way it suggests a conscious, adult choice to adhere to those beliefs. My whole point is that people are morally culpable for their choices, and there isn't a special category for religious beliefs that allows a person to shed that moral culpability.
Just how do we determine that one's religious beliefs are based on "a pack of lies?" I know of only one religion where I feel that is the case, and it was created by an obvious charlatan in 19th century America.
They all are. They were all created by charlatans. The only difference is that the more recently the charlatan lived, the more obvious the hokum is to a modern audience. Thus, most Americans would say David Koresh (very recent) was an obvious charlatan, with L. Ron Hubbard (somewhat recent) a little less obvious than that, but still a charlatan, and Joseph Smith (not quite so recent) a little less obvious still. When you go back farther to a charlatan like Jesus, the distance is such that the obviousness of his charlatanism is too muted for a lot of people to notice. But all religious leaders built up a following for themselves by pushing supernatural beliefs for which they lacked any evidence. If there had never been a Jesus in the ancient world, and one popped up today, telling people that he was the son of God, and insisting that he could raise the dead, walk on water, and turn bread and wine into flesh and blood (which he instructed his followers to devour in a mock cannibalistic feast), you'd spot him as a charlatan for sure. But with almost 2000 years of dust settled on that weirdness, it looks less weird.
The Catholics who use birth control know that via their "a la carte" decision to do so, the church in which they worship condemns them to hell.
The 80%+ of American Catholics, and likely even more European Catholics who use birth control don't do so with the assumption that a loving God will cause them to be roasted for all eternity for it. They do it with the assumption that they know better than their church leaders on this topic. The same is true for the many conservative Catholics who support the death penalty, which the Church opposes, or who supported the Iraq invasion, when the Pope opposed it. That kind of independent thought is present in every religious person. I've yet to meet a single person who adheres to all their church's teachings on every topic. And that's a good thing. The world would be much worse off if religious leaders truly had the power to get 100% adherence from their followers. But the point is that we don't hand over our moral responsibility to some religious leader, even when we join a church. We remain independent moral beings, and remain responsible for our choices, both the choice to join and stay in the religion, and the choice of which of the religion's views to adopt and which to reject.
Intellectually, there is no rigorous way to embrace a religion. Religion, any religion, is based on the faith in things that are not intellectually provable.
True. But there are degrees of intellectual sloppiness. It's kind of like "suspension of disbelief" in a movie. I can handle it when a filmmaker asks me to suspend my disbelief to the minimal extent required to set up the world he's made -- e.g.., believing that Jedi can use the Force to do all sorts of supernatural things. But where I get annoyed is when the created world then does not function consistently within its own rules -- when a bad writer keeps having things happen that don't make sense even after accepting his outlandish premises. That breaks my suspension of disbelief. In a similar way, even if I wanted to go down the religious path far enough to embrace certain supernatural elements as a matter of faith, I'd then want to apply reasoning consistently within that framework. It's from that perspective that I can't understand the Christian primacy of the letters of Paul over the direct sayings of Jesus in the Gospels. If I were to accept that Jesus was the Son of God, and that Paul was some evangelist who saw a vision of Jesus after his death, and the two disagreed on some point (e.g., whether some aspects of the Law had fallen away), then how could I justify assuming Paul's letter was right and Jesus himself was wrong?
Jesus did not say that his followers must abjure all wealth. He basically said they must give up greed, and he said it was difficult for wealthy people to get into heaven -- but not impossible.
What he said is that a rich person will hardly ever get into Heaven -- that it was like trying to pass a camel through the eye of a needle -- and so the rich should sell everything they own and give the money to charity. If Robertson, in fact, believed that Jesus was the infallible son of God, and that the Gospels accurately recount his word, then it would be reckless to the point of raving insanity for him NOT to give away all his wealth. It's akin to going to see the best doctors in the world and having them tell you that you have hardly any chance of surviving the year if you didn't get a certain operation, and yet you choose not to get that operation.... only it's much more reckless than that, for two reasons: (1) doctors are fallible, whereas the advice you're ignoring from Jesus comes from an infallible or at least nigh-infallible source; and (2) with the operation, you're only gambling with your life, whereas with the money, you're gambling with your immortal soul. The decision of Robertson to ignore Jesus' clear advice on this topic tells me that he doesn't really believe the Bible -- he just likes to pretend he does when it gives him a way to bash other people. Giving away his money would be inconvenient, whereas, as a heterosexual, giving up gay sex is not inconvenient. So he chooses to focus on Paul's letter while ignoring the direct words of Jesus from three separate gospels. That convenient morality is understandable, but nonetheless contemptible.
You would be a most unusual god. Which is immaterial. You are not the God of Abraham shared by the Christians, Muslims and Jews. That god doesn't portray the things you'd like him to, at least not according to the records about him/her/it.
And that's why moral people have either outgrown Christianity, Islam, and Judaism, or modified it, in their personal faith, to be more morally supportable. Everyone picks and chooses -- good people do so in a way that improves the faith morally, whereas bad people, like Robertson or bin Laden, do so in a way that brings the worst aspects of the faith to the top.
Well, you seem to "hate" Robertson (et al) on their innate qualities -- those qualities including the belief in evangelical Christianity.
There's nothing innate about evangelical Christianity. Nobody is born a Christian. If we took a child and raised him in a society where there was no Christianity to infect him, he would not grow up to be a Christian. Believing in the divinity of carpenter's son who died almost two thousand years ago is a learned thing, like believing that Allah wants you to hijack a plane and fly it into a tower. It's not innate. It involves choices, and choices involve moral culpability.