New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ducks one

Marvin,

You've never exhibited the propensity to piece together an adequate collection of thoughts to generate so much as a complete paragraph. You've never taken a clear and concise position on any issue of significance. You are nothing more than a classic ankle biter, and yet you have the audacity to discredit the debating skills of your fellow posters? You are far more absurd than any actual cartoon character.

OMG..witness the superior education of a gawd damn progressive, I'm better than YOU.....sorry SOB...............☻ please!
 
OMG..witness the superior education of a gawd damn progressive, I'm better than YOU.....sorry SOB...............☻ please!


At least you state an opinion from time to time, Dawg. Marvin doesn't even have an opinion. He does nothing but whine about other posters.
 
Po-Po Boar..............I heat with WOOD..........cost=much manual labor...but FREE.......have a water-stove that heats my water........electric water heater suck....you're on a CORP made computer bitching at other's for doing what you do..........go suk another [Unwelcome language removed]........live your life and let us live ours......YOu don't have the power to make us live like YOU...........Boar☻

Oh touchy touchy. Must have hit some reality check with the image of these macho redneck right wingers sucking on a teat and being slaves. Which they are and so immediately they cry out " let us live the way we want", and please don't show us the truth anymore, we don't want to see it. We prefer thinking we are so free as we suck the teat! We can afford it. So we must be free.
 
Oh touchy touchy. Must have hit some reality check with the image of these macho redneck right wingers sucking on a teat and being slaves. Which they are and so immediately they cry out " let us live the way we want", and please don't show us the truth anymore, we don't want to see it. We prefer thinking we are so free as we suck the teat! We can afford it. So we must be free.

Get off the DRUGs..........my gawd Boar........they have fried ya brains cells to hell........p I t I f u l☻
 
No. That was gibberish. I'm saying every religious person picks and chooses which things to include in his personal faith, generally in part from some collection of beliefs in one or more religions. Some are good people, and select morally sound values for their personal faith. Some are evil, like Robertson, and instead select depraved values.

Or maybe some are just consistent with the teachings of their church, rather than being inconsistent with those teachings. Again, essentially all Christian faiths find homosexuality to be a sin, and sin to be the means to enter hell. Robertson is by no means alone in his faith in that regard, no matter how depraved you find such a faith.

Fine. Then we can just say that my religion requires me to hate people like Robertson and any who would defend him. Does that make my position more palatable to you?

Hatred is also something that condemns most Christians to hell. Your call, I guess. Does your statement make you guilty of "hate speech?" If not, why would Robertson's statements be any different?

Says me, obviously. And when you claim that is faulty you are, likewise, stacking your morality against mine and claiming superiority for yours. Only one of us is right. I don't think it's the one defending the guy who believes never-ending, unimaginable torment is the right fate for someone who chooses to indulge in unorthodox, consensual sexual practices. That is an sadistic belief, and is a sign of a deeply diseased soul.

When did you become the arbiter of morality for anyone? I'm unaware of the "First Church of Arkady" in which we all follow the 10 Arkady commandments.

And where we differ is that although I don't agree with Robertson, I feel he has every right to believe what he believes. Well, we also differ on another point. You say homosexuals "choose to indulge in unorthodox consensual sexual practices." I do not believe homosexuals have such a choice, or that the practices are unorthodox (to them).
 
I STILL can't figure out why otherwise semi-rational people, think the duck thing is a "free speech" issue. Something tells me we need a civics lesson.
This is one of those issues where hypcrisy is rampant on both sides. Each side is quick to bring up accusations of censorship when some corporate outlet or organized boycott reacts against speech they approve of, but is quick to point out that the first amendment only protects speech from government censorship when the speech is speech they disapprove of.
 
Or maybe some are just consistent with the teachings of their church, rather than being inconsistent with those teachings

There are two acts of choice going on. First, is the selection of a church. If a person selects a church that teaches horrible things, the selection of that church does not, somehow, immunize the person against criticisms about those horrible beliefs. For example, if some young jihadist chooses a church that says that all Middle Eastern Jews must be exterminated, it doesn't matter at all if his beliefs are 100% consistent with what his church is teaching, they're still evil beliefs and he should rightly be judged for them. He could have chosen a better church, or no church at all, like countless others have. In the same way, if Robertson chooses a church that believes people should be burned forever and ever if they have consensual homosexual sex, then he's evil, and it doesn't matter if that's 100% consistent with the evil that's taught by the church he chose.

The second act of choice is deciding which aspects of a church's dogma to take on, and which aspects to object to. Most religious people choose not to be 100% compliant with the orthodox rules of their church. Most Catholics use birth control, for example. I don't know the rules of his church, but I'd bet good money that he has chosen to be less than 100% compliant with its orthodoxies. I do know a lot about the Bible, and most of the Christians I know have a very sinful character as judged by a strict interpretation of the scriptures themselves. They have tattoos for example, or eat shrimp (each of which is labeled with the same "abomination" label as homosexuality, by the very same book of the Bible). I seriously doubt if Robertson keeps on the right side of the Bible when it comes to all of its rules, from keeping Saturday holy to observing all the holy feasts and preparing burnt offerings. I don't know, when he does depart from the Bible, whether he does so solo or with his entire Church, but in the end, it doesn't even matter. The point is, either way it's a choice, and he should be accountable for his choices. When those judgments he makes are neutral (whether or not to eat foods the Bible considers abominations), I don't care. But when the judgement are horrific, like believing eternal torture would be a righteous fate for someon who crosses one of his taboos, then I condemn him for it,

Again, essentially all Christian faiths find homosexuality to be a sin, and sin to be the means to enter hell.

I'm not sure if that's true. I have a friend who is a pastor for a Christian faith that not only doesn't condemn homosexuality, but performs gay weddings. But even if it were true, I don't think that would make any difference. I don't care, for example, whether a majority or a minority of Muslim faiths believe killing Jews is OK. If a Muslim believes that, it's morally reprehensible, and having one church or a thousand on his side doesn't change that a bit. The same is true for a Christian who sees homosexuality as a ticket to eternal, righteous torture. Whether he's in the Christian majority or the Christian minority, he is embracing an evil teaching, and should be condemned for doing so.

Robertson is by no means alone in his faith

Nor was Bin Laden. Doesn't make it right.

Your call, I guess. Does your statement make you guilty of "hate speech?" If not, why would Robertson's statements be any different?

It's all semantic. But, in my case, I'm attacking someone for his beliefs -- beliefs which regard as morally correct the torture of millions of people for acts of consensual sex.

When did you become the arbiter of morality for anyone?

We all make moral judgments of others. You're doing it right there, by judging my right to judge others. It's merely a question of who is right and who is wrong.

I feel he has every right to believe what he believes.

Do I? I believe that Robertson is a depraved person, and that those who would defend his comments are moral degenerates. Do I have a right to believe what I believe?

We all have that right. Nobody is trying to say Robertson can't believe what he believes. I'm just saying that in announcing those beliefs, he has identified himself as a monster, and people should treat him accordingly.

Well, we also differ on another point. You say homosexuals "choose to indulge in unorthodox consensual sexual practices." I do not believe homosexuals have such a choice, or that the practices are unorthodox (to them).

We all have a choice about whethe or not to act on our sexual desires.
 
There are two acts of choice going on. First, is the selection of a church. If a person selects a church that teaches horrible things, the selection of that church does not, somehow, immunize the person against criticisms about those horrible beliefs. For example, if some young jihadist chooses a church that says that all Middle Eastern Jews must be exterminated, it doesn't matter at all if his beliefs are 100% consistent with what his church is teaching, they're still evil beliefs and he should rightly be judged for them. He could have chosen a better church, or no church at all, like countless others have. In the same way, if Robertson chooses a church that believes people should be burned forever and ever if they have consensual homosexual sex, then he's evil, and it doesn't matter if that's 100% consistent with the evil that's taught by the church he chose.

Most people, for good or ill, do not "choose" churches. Most people are raised in certain churches as part of a family experience. Condemning them as adults for not abjuring teachings learned from the time they were old enough to speak is essentially directing them not to be human.

The second act of choice is deciding which aspects of a church's dogma to take on, and which aspects to object to. Most religious people choose not to be 100% compliant with the orthodox rules of their church. Most Catholics use birth control, for example.

You have data? Thought not. I think the statement is probably true for most Catholics in the U.S., but certainly not "most Catholics."

I don't know the rules of his church, but I'd bet good money that he has chosen to be less than 100% compliant with its orthodoxies. I do know a lot about the Bible, and most of the Christians I know have a very sinful character as judged by a strict interpretation of the scriptures themselves. They have tattoos for example, or eat shrimp (each of which is labeled with the same "abomination" label as homosexuality, by the very same book of the Bible).

Phil didn't take his text from Leviticus, which condemns people for tattoos, shell fish, etc., while giving advice on slave sales and other things anathema to modern people, but from 1 Corinthians in the New Testament which makes no such judgements.
I seriously doubt if Robertson keeps on the right side of the Bible when it comes to all of its rules, from keeping Saturday holy to observing all the holy feasts and preparing burnt offerings.

Perhaps he doesn't keep Saturday holy -- the Saturday sabbath is a matter of some debate outside the Jewish faith. Most Christians favor a Sunday sabbath.

But when the judgement are horrific, like believing eternal torture would be a righteous fate for someon who crosses one of his taboos, then I condemn him for it,

What if he said the same thing about the unbaptized and virtuous pagans; the lustful (carnal malefactors); the avaricious or miserly; the wrathful; heretics; the violent; the fraudulent; and the treacherous? (The more literate among us will recognize the ur-document from which these categories are taken). Is there ANY sin you find worthy of the Christian's belief in Christian hell?

I'm not sure if that's true. I have a friend who is a pastor for a Christian faith that not only doesn't condemn homosexuality, but performs gay weddings. But even if it were true, I don't think that would make any difference. I don't care, for example, whether a majority or a minority of Muslim faiths believe killing Jews is OK. If a Muslim believes that, it's morally reprehensible, and having one church or a thousand on his side doesn't change that a bit. The same is true for a Christian who sees homosexuality as a ticket to eternal, righteous torture. Whether he's in the Christian majority or the Christian minority, he is embracing an evil teaching, and should be condemned for doing so.

I'm a fair student of the culture in which we live, and I'm fairly confident that one or another condemnation of homosexuality is a common Christian belief. Perhaps its the beliefs of those Christians that you would find sinful enough to send them to hell? I don't think most of the Christians I know are evil or worthy of this sort of wrathful condemnation.



It's all semantic. But, in my case, I'm attacking someone for his beliefs -- beliefs which regard as morally correct the torture of millions of people for acts of consensual sex.

No, it's more than semantic. You said you "hated" those beliefs. Does that make your statement hate speech? If it does not so qualify, why does Robertson's statement qualify?

We all make moral judgments of others. You're doing it right there, by judging my right to judge others. It's merely a question of who is right and who is wrong.

I made no such judgement. I asked a question.
 
Most people, for good or ill, do not "choose" churches. Most people are raised in certain churches as part of a family experience. Condemning them as adults for not abjuring teachings learned from the time they were old enough to speak is essentially directing them not to be human.



You have data? Thought not. I think the statement is probably true for most Catholics in the U.S., but certainly not "most Catholics."



Phil didn't take his text from Leviticus, which condemns people for tattoos, shell fish, etc., while giving advice on slave sales and other things anathema to modern people, but from 1 Corinthians in the New Testament which makes no such judgements.


Perhaps he doesn't keep Saturday holy -- the Saturday sabbath is a matter of some debate outside the Jewish faith. Most Christians favor a Sunday sabbath.



What if he said the same thing about the unbaptized and virtuous pagans; the lustful (carnal malefactors); the avaricious or miserly; the wrathful; heretics; the violent; the fraudulent; and the treacherous? (The more literate among us will recognize the ur-document from which these categories are taken). Is there ANY sin you find worthy of the Christian's belief in Christian hell?



I'm a fair student of the culture in which we live, and I'm fairly confident that one or another condemnation of homosexuality is a common Christian belief. Perhaps its the beliefs of those Christians that you would find sinful enough to send them to hell? I don't think most of the Christians I know are evil or worthy of this sort of wrathful condemnation.





No, it's more than semantic. You said you "hated" those beliefs. Does that make your statement hate speech? If it does not so qualify, why does Robertson's statement qualify?



I made no such judgement. I asked a question.

Ankle biting or absurdities. Holy Sabbath or Sunday. Big effing deal. Does Robertson strictly abide by a day of friggin rest??? Of course not!

And as far as using the word hate (as in I hate something) and you asserting it is then the exact same thing as the bigotry and racism speech of Phil is just plain over the top ludicrous and you are either pretending you are ignorant or you authentically are ignorant. But to say they are the same is ignorant.
 
Ankle biting or absurdities. Holy Sabbath or Sunday. Big effing deal. Does Robertson strictly abide by a day of friggin rest??? Of course not!

You know this how? My grandparents most definitely did abide by a full day of rest on Sunday, and took the matter quite seriously. I don't know what Phil Robertson does.

And as far as using the word hate (as in I hate something) and you asserting it is then the exact same thing as the bigotry and racism speech of Phil is just plain over the top ludicrous and you are either pretending you are ignorant or you authentically are ignorant. But to say they are the same is ignorant.

I'm doing no such thing. I ASKED (not stated) Arkady if his stated hatred of the common Christian stance against homosexuality amounted to hate speech.
 
Oh touchy touchy. Must have hit some reality check with the image of these macho redneck right wingers sucking on a teat and being slaves. Which they are and so immediately they cry out " let us live the way we want", and please don't show us the truth anymore, we don't want to see it. We prefer thinking we are so free as we suck the teat! We can afford it. So we must be free.

leftwing racist
http://tv.msn.com/tv/article.aspx?news=845297

it's all good making fun of black baby☻
 
Most people, for good or ill, do not "choose" churches. Most people are raised in certain churches as part of a family experience.

The choice to remain within a church, as an adult, is a choice of that church. Many of us were raised within a church and then chose to leave it. Others never grow up. Now, I'll admit that we need to judge people a bit more gently when they're essentially victims of brain-washing. When the people that a child trusts most take that child, at a highly impressionable age, and teach them a pack of lies by way of time-tested methods of subliminal influence (forced repetitions of dogma, peer pressure, rituals, etc.), it's understandable that many will be dug into a mental rut so deeply that they will not be able to pull themselves out of it when they get older. But I still won't give people a free pass for hate they learned when they were children. If someone was told that murdering Jews was the will of Allah, when he was still an impressionable child, that doesn't mean he gets a free pass for clinging to that hate when he's an adult. And it's the same for those who were taught to hate gays when they were children.


You have data? Thought not. I think the statement is probably true for most Catholics in the U.S., but certainly not "most Catholics."

The data show a huge majority of US Catholics (over 80%) think birth control is morally acceptable, which is directly contrary to the Church's teaching. Given the very low birth rates in Europe, I'd expect the percentages are even higher there. However, with many Catholics living in places without modern polling, I doubt we have data to back up the idea that the majority internationally think so. But it's largely irrelevant for my point. My point is just that it's common practice (in the US, at least), for people to pick and choose from the teachings of the church to which they give nominal fealty. If Robertson chooses not to reject the evil aspects of his church's teachings, he's morally culpable for that.

Phil didn't take his text from Leviticus, which condemns people for tattoos, shell fish, etc., while giving advice on slave sales and other things anathema to modern people, but from 1 Corinthians in the New Testament which makes no such judgements.

Sort of on a tangent here, but I've never much understood the Christian obsession with those epistles. Think about it -- they were written by a guy who admits he never so much as met the living Jesus, yet, for some reason, usurped control of the early church from Jesus' actual disciples (including his brother James). This man, going under the pseudonym Paul, was Saul of Tarsus -- a persecutor of early Christians, who once took part in a mob that murdered one of Jesus' followers. He spent his time directly contradicting the teachings of Jesus (Jesus, who had said that not one jot of the Law would fall away, was contradicted by the writings of Paul, who spent his time listing Laws that had fallen away.... when he wasn't instructing slaves to submit to their masters). I just can't see an intellectually rigorous way to embrace the writings of Paul, when they so directly contradict the express views of Jesus, as recorded in the gospels. I mean, I get why early pagans would have been drawn to the epistles -- you don't have to give up bacon or observe the Sabbath on an inconvenient day or cut off your foreskin, or anything else that would require a real sacrifice for you supposed faith, but intellectually it doesn't make much sense to take as primary authority something so removed from the actual teachings of Jesus, if you treat yourself as a follower of Jesus.

Tangent ended. Anyway, the point here is that Robertson is making a choice. He has chosen to fixate on some scriptures and not others. He is not, for example, saying that rich people like him who disobey Jesus by not giving away all their wealth will not get into Heaven, even though there is far, far stronger scriptural backing for that (direct quotations of Jesus in three separate gospels, as opposed to a letter by some dude who never even met Jesus, which Robertson chose to quote). These are choices, and people are morally culpable for their choices.

Perhaps he doesn't keep Saturday holy -- the Saturday sabbath is a matter of some debate outside the Jewish faith. Most Christians favor a Sunday sabbath.

Yes. Early evangelists had a choice: insist on keeping the Sabbath day holy, as instructed by the Bible, and have an uphill climb recruiting new members among the Roman pagans, or create a new rule that says the pagans were right and Jesus was wrong: the first day, not the seventh is the holy day. Since evangelists live off the money of converts, they understandably preferred to throw out the Sabbath and make the pagan holy day the new standard for Christianity.

Is there ANY sin you find worthy of the Christian's belief in Christian hell?

No. If I were a god, setting up a cosmos, I would be too merciful to want anyone to be tortured for all eternity. It's hard to picture a perfect deity who isn't even as merciful as me, which is part of why the Christian conception of God strikes me as such a flawed one.

No, it's more than semantic. You said you "hated" those beliefs. Does that make your statement hate speech? If it does not so qualify, why does Robertson's statement qualify?

Yes, it's obviously semantic. You're asking if a belief fits the definition of a label. That depends entirely on how you define the label. If hate speech is any speech indicating hatred, then yes, it's hate speech. If you define hate speech differently -- such as speech that indicates hatred of a group based on their supposed innate qualities (as opposed to their choices), then it isn't hate speech. If hate speech can include just hating ugly beliefs, then it's hate speech, whereas if it's more (like wanting to see people torture eternally for sexual peccadilloes), then what I've said isn't hate speech. It's all semantic. Define it as you will. In the case of Robertson, you can call it hate speech or not, but what I call it is morally depraved, since he is positing a cosmic scheme, which he approves of, which results in eternal torture for people who have done no harm to anyone.
 
The choice to remain within a church, as an adult, is a choice of that church. Many of us were raised within a church and then chose to leave it.

I'm sorry, but I doubt that "many" do this. Some do, undoubtedly. Most do not.

Others never grow up. Now, I'll admit that we need to judge people a bit more gently when they're essentially victims of brain-washing. When the people that a child trusts most take that child, at a highly impressionable age, and teach them a pack of lies by way of time-tested methods of subliminal influence (forced repetitions of dogma, peer pressure, rituals, etc.), it's understandable that many will be dug into a mental rut so deeply that they will not be able to pull themselves out of it when they get older.

Just how do we determine that one's religious beliefs are based on "a pack of lies?" I know of only one religion where I feel that is the case, and it was created by an obvious charlatan in 19th century America.


The data show a huge majority of US Catholics (over 80%) think birth control is morally acceptable, which is directly contrary to the Church's teaching.

American Catholics are by no means all Catholics.


My point is just that it's common practice (in the US, at least), for people to pick and choose from the teachings of the church to which they give nominal fealty. If Robertson chooses not to reject the evil aspects of his church's teachings, he's morally culpable for that.

And your point is utterly moot. You're still saying that churchgoers don't believe what they claim they believe. It's specious. The Catholics who use birth control know that via their "a la carte" decision to do so, the church in which they worship condemns them to hell.


I just can't see an intellectually rigorous way to embrace the writings of Paul, when they so directly contradict the express views of Jesus, as recorded in the gospels. I mean, I get why early pagans would have been drawn to the epistles -- you don't have to give up bacon or observe the Sabbath on an inconvenient day or cut off your foreskin, or anything else that would require a real sacrifice for you supposed faith, but intellectually it doesn't make much sense to take as primary authority something so removed from the actual teachings of Jesus, if you treat yourself as a follower of Jesus.

Intellectually, there is no rigorous way to embrace a religion. Religion, any religion, is based on the faith in things that are not intellectually provable.

Tangent ended. Anyway, the point here is that Robertson is making a choice. He has chosen to fixate on some scriptures and not others. He is not, for example, saying that rich people like him who disobey Jesus by not giving away all their wealth will not get into Heaven, even

Jesus did not say that his followers must abjure all wealth. He basically said they must give up greed, and he said it was difficult for wealthy people to get into heaven -- but not impossible.


No. If I were a god, setting up a cosmos, I would be too merciful to want anyone to be tortured for all eternity. It's hard to picture a perfect deity who isn't even as merciful as me, which is part of why the Christian conception of God strikes me as such a flawed one.

You would be a most unusual god. Which is immaterial. You are not the God of Abraham shared by the Christians, Muslims and Jews. That god doesn't portray the things you'd like him to, at least not according to the records about him/her/it.


Yes, it's obviously semantic. You're asking if a belief fits the definition of a label. That depends entirely on how you define the label. If hate speech is any speech indicating hatred, then yes, it's hate speech. If you define hate speech differently -- such as speech that indicates hatred of a group based on their supposed innate qualities (as opposed to their choices), then it isn't hate speech.

Well, you seem to "hate" Robertson (et al) on their innate qualities -- those qualities including the belief in evangelical Christianity. That isn't a choice for them.[/quote]
 
It would be easier for a camel to pass through an eye of a needle than for a rich man to get into heaven, so said Jesus. That sounds impossible to me, you lying justifying weasel word studded dummass.
 
I'm sorry, but I doubt that "many" do this. Some do, undoubtedly. Most do not.

Even Robertson is a "born again" Christian, right? I don't know whether, as with Bush and McCain, that involved rejecting the faith he was raised in, in order to adopt a less rational (or more politically convenient) new faith, or whether it just involved reaffirming his allegiance to the faith imposed on him as a child, after some period of drifting away, but either way it suggests a conscious, adult choice to adhere to those beliefs. My whole point is that people are morally culpable for their choices, and there isn't a special category for religious beliefs that allows a person to shed that moral culpability.

Just how do we determine that one's religious beliefs are based on "a pack of lies?" I know of only one religion where I feel that is the case, and it was created by an obvious charlatan in 19th century America.

They all are. They were all created by charlatans. The only difference is that the more recently the charlatan lived, the more obvious the hokum is to a modern audience. Thus, most Americans would say David Koresh (very recent) was an obvious charlatan, with L. Ron Hubbard (somewhat recent) a little less obvious than that, but still a charlatan, and Joseph Smith (not quite so recent) a little less obvious still. When you go back farther to a charlatan like Jesus, the distance is such that the obviousness of his charlatanism is too muted for a lot of people to notice. But all religious leaders built up a following for themselves by pushing supernatural beliefs for which they lacked any evidence. If there had never been a Jesus in the ancient world, and one popped up today, telling people that he was the son of God, and insisting that he could raise the dead, walk on water, and turn bread and wine into flesh and blood (which he instructed his followers to devour in a mock cannibalistic feast), you'd spot him as a charlatan for sure. But with almost 2000 years of dust settled on that weirdness, it looks less weird.

The Catholics who use birth control know that via their "a la carte" decision to do so, the church in which they worship condemns them to hell.

The 80%+ of American Catholics, and likely even more European Catholics who use birth control don't do so with the assumption that a loving God will cause them to be roasted for all eternity for it. They do it with the assumption that they know better than their church leaders on this topic. The same is true for the many conservative Catholics who support the death penalty, which the Church opposes, or who supported the Iraq invasion, when the Pope opposed it. That kind of independent thought is present in every religious person. I've yet to meet a single person who adheres to all their church's teachings on every topic. And that's a good thing. The world would be much worse off if religious leaders truly had the power to get 100% adherence from their followers. But the point is that we don't hand over our moral responsibility to some religious leader, even when we join a church. We remain independent moral beings, and remain responsible for our choices, both the choice to join and stay in the religion, and the choice of which of the religion's views to adopt and which to reject.

Intellectually, there is no rigorous way to embrace a religion. Religion, any religion, is based on the faith in things that are not intellectually provable.

True. But there are degrees of intellectual sloppiness. It's kind of like "suspension of disbelief" in a movie. I can handle it when a filmmaker asks me to suspend my disbelief to the minimal extent required to set up the world he's made -- e.g.., believing that Jedi can use the Force to do all sorts of supernatural things. But where I get annoyed is when the created world then does not function consistently within its own rules -- when a bad writer keeps having things happen that don't make sense even after accepting his outlandish premises. That breaks my suspension of disbelief. In a similar way, even if I wanted to go down the religious path far enough to embrace certain supernatural elements as a matter of faith, I'd then want to apply reasoning consistently within that framework. It's from that perspective that I can't understand the Christian primacy of the letters of Paul over the direct sayings of Jesus in the Gospels. If I were to accept that Jesus was the Son of God, and that Paul was some evangelist who saw a vision of Jesus after his death, and the two disagreed on some point (e.g., whether some aspects of the Law had fallen away), then how could I justify assuming Paul's letter was right and Jesus himself was wrong?

Jesus did not say that his followers must abjure all wealth. He basically said they must give up greed, and he said it was difficult for wealthy people to get into heaven -- but not impossible.

What he said is that a rich person will hardly ever get into Heaven -- that it was like trying to pass a camel through the eye of a needle -- and so the rich should sell everything they own and give the money to charity. If Robertson, in fact, believed that Jesus was the infallible son of God, and that the Gospels accurately recount his word, then it would be reckless to the point of raving insanity for him NOT to give away all his wealth. It's akin to going to see the best doctors in the world and having them tell you that you have hardly any chance of surviving the year if you didn't get a certain operation, and yet you choose not to get that operation.... only it's much more reckless than that, for two reasons: (1) doctors are fallible, whereas the advice you're ignoring from Jesus comes from an infallible or at least nigh-infallible source; and (2) with the operation, you're only gambling with your life, whereas with the money, you're gambling with your immortal soul. The decision of Robertson to ignore Jesus' clear advice on this topic tells me that he doesn't really believe the Bible -- he just likes to pretend he does when it gives him a way to bash other people. Giving away his money would be inconvenient, whereas, as a heterosexual, giving up gay sex is not inconvenient. So he chooses to focus on Paul's letter while ignoring the direct words of Jesus from three separate gospels. That convenient morality is understandable, but nonetheless contemptible.

You would be a most unusual god. Which is immaterial. You are not the God of Abraham shared by the Christians, Muslims and Jews. That god doesn't portray the things you'd like him to, at least not according to the records about him/her/it.

And that's why moral people have either outgrown Christianity, Islam, and Judaism, or modified it, in their personal faith, to be more morally supportable. Everyone picks and chooses -- good people do so in a way that improves the faith morally, whereas bad people, like Robertson or bin Laden, do so in a way that brings the worst aspects of the faith to the top.

Well, you seem to "hate" Robertson (et al) on their innate qualities -- those qualities including the belief in evangelical Christianity.

There's nothing innate about evangelical Christianity. Nobody is born a Christian. If we took a child and raised him in a society where there was no Christianity to infect him, he would not grow up to be a Christian. Believing in the divinity of carpenter's son who died almost two thousand years ago is a learned thing, like believing that Allah wants you to hijack a plane and fly it into a tower. It's not innate. It involves choices, and choices involve moral culpability.
 
A born again frequently breaks from whatever religion or non religion they were raised with (yes George WMD Bush broke from how he was raised to become a Borned Again)... and they make the choice to join this Jesus Is My Personal Savior dogma. And if you don't say it in precisely the same way every time they denounce you as not a "real" Christian!
 
1525385_723121684372312_860341204_n.jpg
 
Back
Top