New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ducks one

I've often thought Christianity should be renamed Paulianism. So much of what comprises Christianity is the writings attributed to Paul, some zealot who never met Jesus and who put his spin on the religion and unfortunately most Christians assert his word too is the word of God... So, how many goddam Gods do the Christians have?? If Paul is the word of God isn't Paul God? And just what is the purpose of that Holy Ghost anyway?? Seems pretty useless. Isn't God the father and God the son and of course Mary the perpetual Virgin given almost Godlike abilities, and then all these humans who wrote the word of God.... Aren't these more than enough Gods? Who the hell needs some Holy Ghost that does nothing.
 
Even Robertson is a "born again" Christian, right? I don't know whether, as with Bush and McCain, that involved rejecting the faith he was raised in, in order to adopt a less rational (or more politically convenient) new faith, or whether it just involved reaffirming his allegiance to the faith imposed on him as a child, after some period of drifting away, but either way it suggests a conscious, adult choice to adhere to those beliefs. My whole point is that people are morally culpable for their choices, and there isn't a special category for religious beliefs that allows a person to shed that moral culpability.

Frankly, I don't know more about Robertson than I could glean from his wikipedia entry. I detest Duck Dynasty and don't watch the show. My assumption, based on wikipedia, is that he was raised into the Church of Christ he still attends. And again, most Christianity holds that Christians as individuals are not truly morally culpable. God has forgiven Christians of their sins (it's not a universally belief, but it is at the core of most Christian teaching).


They all are. They were all created by charlatans. The only difference is that the more recently the charlatan lived, the more obvious the hokum is to a modern audience. Thus, most Americans would say David Koresh (very recent) was an obvious charlatan, with L. Ron Hubbard (somewhat recent) a little less obvious than that, but still a charlatan, and Joseph Smith (not quite so recent) a little less obvious still.

A side comment, I'd neglected to include Scientology in my mental list of "religions." It is so obviously a con job that it fits into a different category in my mind.
Having said that, are you really saying Christ was a charlatan?


The 80%+ of American Catholics, and likely even more European Catholics who use birth control don't do so with the assumption that a loving God will cause them to be roasted for all eternity for it.

Where are your numbers being generated? I know that my devoutly Catholic first "serious" girlfriend used no birth control (we were either fortunate or unfortunate, depending on your perspective, that we didn't make a baby). And I think if you talk, one on one, to Catholics using birth control, the feel bad about it, know that it's a sin, and know that if they go to their graves having committed the sin without having been absolved of it via the offices of the church, they will "roast for all eternity."

To quote the British humorist Terry Pratchett, "But... but you can't treat religion as a sort of buffet, can you? I mean, you can't say yes, please, I'll have some of the Celestial Paradise and a helping of the Divine Plan, but go easy on the kneeling and none of the prohibition of images, they give me wind. It's table d'hote or nothing, otherwise...well, it would be silly."


They do it with the assumption that they know better than their church leaders on this topic. The same is true for the many conservative Catholics who support the death penalty, which the Church opposes, or who supported the Iraq invasion, when the Pope opposed it. That kind of independent thought is present in every religious person. I've yet to meet a single person who adheres to all their church's teachings on every topic. And that's a good thing. The world would be much worse off if religious leaders truly had the power to get 100% adherence from their followers. But the point is that we don't hand over our moral responsibility to some religious leader, even when we join a church. We remain independent moral beings, and remain responsible for our choices, both the choice to join and stay in the religion, and the choice of which of the religion's views to adopt and which to reject.



True. But there are degrees of intellectual sloppiness. It's kind of like "suspension of disbelief" in a movie. I can handle it when a filmmaker asks me to suspend my disbelief to the minimal extent required to set up the world he's made -- e.g.., believing that Jedi can use the Force to do all sorts of supernatural things. But where I get annoyed is when the created world then does not function consistently within its own rules -- when a bad writer keeps having things happen that don't make sense even after accepting his outlandish premises.

I agree on this, when it comes to sci-fi. Such a universe has to be internally consistent -- if Star Trek TNG figures out how to use a transporter and DNA sample to "youthen" someone, then in future episodes no one should age. Religion is another thing, but I'll get to that in a minute.

t's from that perspective that I can't understand the Christian primacy of the letters of Paul over the direct sayings of Jesus in the Gospels. If I were to accept that Jesus was the Son of God, and that Paul was some evangelist who saw a vision of Jesus after his death, and the two disagreed on some point (e.g., whether some aspects of the Law had fallen away), then how could I justify assuming Paul's letter was right and Jesus himself was wrong?

And the stock Christian answer is "via faith," an answer I'll abjure. Instead, I'll cite something I read somewhere, attributed I think to Mark Twain, "Of course truth is stranger than fiction -- fiction has to make sense."


What he said is that a rich person will hardly ever get into Heaven -- that it was like trying to pass a camel through the eye of a needle -- and so the rich should sell everything they own and give the money to charity.

Greater minds than mine used to debate whether or not God could restore a virgin, and how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. I make no defense of the reality of Robertson's beliefs -- they are his own and the tenet's of his church. I merely don't think it is within you or me to make a moral judgement about those beliefs -- we lack the perspective.

And that's why moral people have either outgrown Christianity, Islam, and Judaism, or modified it, in their personal faith, to be more morally supportable. Everyone picks and chooses -- good people do so in a way that improves the faith morally, whereas bad people, like Robertson or bin Laden, do so in a way that brings the worst aspects of the faith to the top.

See Terry Pratchett, above. Although I do think it interesting that you define the practitioners of the three major western faiths, all, as being immoral.
 
I've often thought Christianity should be renamed Paulianism. So much of what comprises Christianity is the writings attributed to Paul, some zealot who never met Jesus and who put his spin on the religion and unfortunately most Christians assert his word too is the word of God... So, how many goddam Gods do the Christians have?? If Paul is the word of God isn't Paul God? And just what is the purpose of that Holy Ghost anyway?? Seems pretty useless. Isn't God the father and God the son and of course Mary the perpetual Virgin given almost Godlike abilities, and then all these humans who wrote the word of God.... Aren't these more than enough Gods? Who the hell needs some Holy Ghost that does nothing.

I suspect the multiplication of godlike entities within Christianity is a product of the disparity between monotheism and what we see in life around us. On the one hand, monotheism is useful for would-be dictators, since it conditions people to think in terms of one absolute authority, which means there will always be a strong political desire among the powerful to push monotheism. But, at the same time, it creates problems in terms of resolving the questions of evil, multiplicity, and change. Polytheistic faiths don't really have those issues, because all those things can be explained through the differences between many different gods, each with different personalities and aims, often in conflict with each other. A polytheistic religion can address the different aspects of man more easily, since they're not forced to regard their avenger-god, who drowns the whole world, as identical with their god who is the font of perfect mercy, and they're not stuck praying to a god of peace for success in war, etc.

Because monotheism is such an awkward instrument in the real world (other than when it comes to conditioning people to submit to dictators), monotheistic religions tend to develop polytheistic aspects with time. Christianity has the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, for example, but also a Virgin Mother to accommodate the feminine divine in a way polytheistic cultures do with female gods. And it has a multitude of patron saints to handle special functions, the way minor gods once did (e.g., the patron saint of weavers or of children). It also has a devil/satan/lucifer to explain evil, and demons, Seraphim, Cherubim, Aeons, Hosts, Powers, Authorities, Principalities, Thrones, Archangels, Angels, and Dominions, etc. That way you build a flexibile pseudo-polytheistic faith atop something that is nominally a monotheistic system.
 
God has forgiven Christians of their sins (it's not a universally belief, but it is at the core of most Christian teaching).

I can't speak for Christianity in general, but in Catholicism the idea is that God's decision to have his Son/Self murdered wiped the slate clean of the torture he otherwise was going to inflict on all of us for our distant ancestors having eaten the wrong fruit, but otherwise we remain culpable for our sins (most of which can be forgiven through confession).

Having said that, are you really saying Christ was a charlatan?

I'm saying Jesus of Nazareth was a charlatan. "Christ" is a name for a fictional construct erected around the historical Jesus during subsequent centuries, by way of things like the "visions" of Paul, another charlatan.

Where are your numbers being generated?
http://www.gallup.com/poll/154799/americans-including-catholics-say-birth-control-morally.aspx

82%, plus another 3% with no opinion (which is likewise a rejection of church teaching). So, total, only about 15% of American Catholics agree with their church on this topic.

I know that my devoutly Catholic first "serious" girlfriend used no birth control (we were either fortunate or unfortunate, depending on your perspective, that we didn't make a baby)

The fact you'd say you were lucky not to have made a baby suggests you had sex, which, assuming it wasn't rape, is another example of a "devout" Catholic diverging from the teachings of her faith, since unmarried Catholics are not supposed to engage in any sexual activity, yet most do. Divorce is another example. A large minority of Catholics get divorced. My mother came from a "devout" Catholic family. Of the six siblings in the family, three got divorced, and at least four had extramarital sex (three were pregnant or had already had a baby at the time of their wedding).

And I think if you talk, one on one, to Catholics using birth control

I come from a Catholic family and went to a Catholic university, and have had lots of sexual activity with lots of Catholic girls, and none of them ever indicated any such guilt.

To quote the British humorist Terry Pratchett, "But... but you can't treat religion as a sort of buffet, can you? I mean, you can't say yes, please, I'll have some of the Celestial Paradise and a helping of the Divine Plan, but go easy on the kneeling and none of the prohibition of images, they give me wind. It's table d'hote or nothing, otherwise...well, it would be silly."

I agree, entirely, that it's silly, which I suspect was his real meaning. Anyway, Pratchett's course on religion is remarkably similar to mine. Both of us were turned off to Christianity by having actualy read the Bible cover to cover:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/video/2009/dec/19/terry-pratchett-religion

"I was inoculated against the Christian religion by reading the whole of the Old Testament in one go (apart from the begats). And I thought if this were true, we were in the hands of a maniac."

I recommend that kind of reading of the Bible to my Christian friends, almost none of whom (bizarrely) have ever read the Bible. I've had devout friends who brag about having read the whole Lord of the Rings trilogy multiple times, but admit, when pressed, that they've never read the whole Bible even once. That is just plain insane. I mean, if I believed a book held the Word of God and guidance for acheiving infinite reward and avoiding eternal torture, you better believe I'd read it over and over until I knew it by heart. Yet most self-described believers claim to believe that, yet can't be bothered to give it a single cover-to-cover reading. It makes no sense... unless they feel, deep down, that they'd be like Pratchett and me, and that actually reading the book they claim to believe in would alienate them from the faith they claim to have, and so they shelter themselves from that disillusioning revelation under the guise of mere laziness.
if Star Trek TNG figures out how to use a transporter and DNA sample to "youthen" someone, then in future episodes no one should age.

Yeah. I like Star Trek (especially TNG), but they're an egregious offender on that front. Things regularly happen that just don't make sense if you take seriously things that happened earlier. There's a funny series of YouTube videos called "how it should have ended" that plays with some of these plot holes in sci-fi and fantasy films. For example, it shows you Lord of the Rings the way it would have actually played out in a universe filled with the powers we see through the course of the films: Gandalf would have summoned the giant eagles, who would have flown the ringbearer right to the volcano to destroy the ring: the end -- no fuss, not muss. But, instead, we have those eagles only popping up as a deus ex machina at points in the Hobbit and Lord of the Ring where a character needs to be saved from certain death, but remaining conspicuously absent when their abilities would spare a lot of pointless traveling by foot and bypass a lot of unnecessary battles.

I merely don't think it is within you or me to make a moral judgement about those beliefs -- we lack the perspective.

If that's a principle you apply consistently, I guess I can't strike it down. In a sense, nobody can pass moral judgment on anyone else's beliefs, period, because we all lack that perspective. What I object to, though, is the double standard, whereby people feel free to attack the vast majority of beliefs, but the moment someone says "but that's my religion," we're supposed to refrain from such attacks, no matter how silly the belief. I treat it all equally. Whether a person believes something dumb or cruel because of his politics, or his personality quirks, or his religion is all the same to me. It is the beliefs, not the source, that is important.
 
I can't speak for Christianity in general, but in Catholicism the idea is that God's decision to have his Son/Self murdered wiped the slate clean of the torture he otherwise was going to inflict on all of us for our distant ancestors having eaten the wrong fruit, but otherwise we remain culpable for our sins (most of which can be forgiven through confession).

I'd call that an accurate description of Catholicism.



I'm saying Jesus of Nazareth was a charlatan. "Christ" is a name for a fictional construct erected around the historical Jesus during subsequent centuries, by way of things like the "visions" of Paul, another charlatan.

Interesting. At worst, I'd pick the historical Jesus as a pretty good philosopher, at least as he's described in the gospels. Now, you may hold that all philosophers are in some way charlatans and con artists -- I don't know.


http://www.gallup.com/poll/154799/americans-including-catholics-say-birth-control-morally.aspx

82%, plus another 3% with no opinion (which is likewise a rejection of church teaching). So, total, only about 15% of American Catholics agree with their church on this topic.

And yet, they do believe that they'll "roast eternally" if they haven't been forgiven, by the church, for the sin of using birth control.



The fact you'd say you were lucky not to have made a baby suggests you had sex, which, assuming it wasn't rape, is another example of a "devout" Catholic diverging from the teachings of her faith, since unmarried Catholics are not supposed to engage in any sexual activity, yet most do. Divorce is another example. A large minority of Catholics get divorced. My mother came from a "devout" Catholic family. Of the six siblings in the family, three got divorced, and at least four had extramarital sex (three were pregnant or had already had a baby at the time of their wedding).

I think she would have said to you that it wasn't divergent from the faith, as God doesn't require humans to be perfect -- merely that they attempt to avoid sin and that they must seek absolution when they have committed sin. (I'm not Catholic -- I have family members who married Catholics and I came within a whisker of doing so myself -- with the aforementioned girl).



I agree, entirely, that it's silly, which I suspect was his real meaning. Anyway, Pratchett's course on religion is remarkably similar to mine. Both of us were turned off to Christianity by having actualy read the Bible cover to cover:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/video/2009/dec/19/terry-pratchett-religion

His views are similar to my own, too, which is why I cited him.

Yeah. I like Star Trek (especially TNG), but they're an egregious offender on that front. Things regularly happen that just don't make sense if you take seriously things that happened earlier. There's a funny series of YouTube videos called "how it should have ended" that plays with some of these plot holes in sci-fi and fantasy films. For example, it shows you Lord of the Rings the way it would have actually played out in a universe filled with the powers we see through the course of the films: Gandalf would have summoned the giant eagles, who would have flown the ringbearer right to the volcano to destroy the ring: the end -- no fuss, not muss. But, instead, we have those eagles only popping up as a deus ex machina at points in the Hobbit and Lord of the Ring where a character needs to be saved from certain death, but remaining conspicuously absent when their abilities would spare a lot of pointless traveling by foot and bypass a lot of unnecessary battles.

I saw a single-framed cartoon on Facebook based on the same meme -- that the eagles could have just whipped Frodo on over to the mountain, no muss no fuss. As a devotee of Tolkien, I'm surprised that didn't occur to me.

If that's a principle you apply consistently, I guess I can't strike it down. In a sense, nobody can pass moral judgment on anyone else's beliefs, period, because we all lack that perspective.

I'm consistent about it when it comes to people's religious beliefs. Part of this is simply because I'm a constitutionalist. The rest is, for lack of a better term, good manners. I don't care much about religion in my own life, so I seen no reason to offend others because of their beliefs.
 
Interesting. At worst, I'd pick the historical Jesus as a pretty good philosopher, at least as he's described in the gospels. Now, you may hold that all philosophers are in some way charlatans and con artists -- I don't know.
It's the supernatural stuff that strikes me as charlatanism. Faith healing, magic tricks with loaves and fishes, etc. I prefer, say, Socrates. Like Jesus, he was very intereted in the ultimate nature of the world and in the question of morality, and like Jesus he was executed for being a threat to the state. But he thought about those things systematically and without recourse to the supernatural. Sure, he spoke about the gods, etc., but didn't claim any special knowledge about them, other than what anyone could get through reason. And he didn't pretend to perform any supernatural acts. He treated his stances as things that would stand or fall on the strength of their arguments, rather than as revealed wisdom to which people must submit for their salvation.

I saw a single-framed cartoon on Facebook based on the same meme -- that the eagles could have just whipped Frodo on over to the mountain, no muss no fuss. As a devotee of Tolkien, I'm surprised that didn't occur to me.

Same here. Guess it's a testament to Tolkien's writing skills, that he can ease people past such obvious plotting absurdities. Anyway, you should go to YouTube and look up "How it Should Have Ended." The Tolkien and Star Trek ones are particularly hilarious.
I don't care much about religion in my own life, so I seen no reason to offend others because of their beliefs.

I suppose that's admirable, but I push back against the idea that religious sensitivities must be coddled more than personal sensitivities. If I think a belief is dumb, I feel equally at liberty to say so regardless of whether it's a person's personally developed belief, or a received belief he took from some religious teachings. The tendency to walk on egg shells around religious beliefs, even among those who blunder through like defensive tackles on any other topic, just seems like a foolish double standard.
 
It's the supernatural stuff that strikes me as charlatanism. Faith healing, magic tricks with loaves and fishes, etc.

Well, there's at least some evidence that faith healing works -- even if you write it off as the ultimate expression of the placebo effect. I'm not certain how we as modern readers should interpret certain of the Biblical miracles -- including the resurrection, come to that. I'm a doubting Thomas, but even Thomas remained a Christian (and I'm not certain I am one).

I prefer, say, Socrates. Like Jesus, he was very intereted in the ultimate nature of the world and in the question of morality, and like Jesus he was executed for being a threat to the state. But he thought about those things systematically and without recourse to the supernatural. Sure, he spoke about the gods, etc., but didn't claim any special knowledge about them, other than what anyone could get through reason.

According to his students, one of Socrates' last statements was that he owed a chicken as sacrifice to one or another of the Gods in the Greek pantheon (I can't remember which -- that particular classics class was pushing 35 years ago).

And he didn't pretend to perform any supernatural acts. He treated his stances as things that would stand or fall on the strength of their arguments, rather than as revealed wisdom to which people must submit for their salvation.

True enough. Neither did he act as the basis for a religion.


Same here. Guess it's a testament to Tolkien's writing skills, that he can ease people past such obvious plotting absurdities. Anyway, you should go to YouTube and look up "How it Should Have Ended." The Tolkien and Star Trek ones are particularly hilarious.

I will -- sounds right up my ally.
 
If I think a belief is dumb, I feel equally at liberty to say so regardless of whether it's a person's personally developed belief, or a received belief he took from some religious teachings.

All beliefs are taught. You weren't born with any innate beliefs, they were taught to you by another person.
 
All beliefs are taught. You weren't born with any innate beliefs, they were taught to you by another person.
Some beliefs are innate -- the belief that eating with address the feeling of hunger, for example. They're things that even very primitive animals have, and that people have before they have the communications skills to learn them from anyone else. Other beliefs are newly developed by a person. If the only way a person could get a belief was from someone else, then there'd be no beliefs other than those innate ones, since someone had to have the idea first. So, I don't think it's true that all beliefs are taught. Most beliefs, I suppose, are taught.
 
Some beliefs are innate -- the belief that eating with address the feeling of hunger, for example. They're things that even very primitive animals have, and that people have before they have the communications skills to learn them from anyone else. Other beliefs are newly developed by a person. If the only way a person could get a belief was from someone else, then there'd be no beliefs other than those innate ones, since someone had to have the idea first. So, I don't think it's true that all beliefs are taught. Most beliefs, I suppose, are taught.

I would not consider hunger a belief. It's a neuro-chemical biological process, not subject to external influence. People who starve themselves or are forced to starve are still hungry, they just won't or can't satiate the hunger...but they still feel it.
 
Where are your numbers being generated? I know that my devoutly Catholic first "serious" girlfriend used no birth control (we were either fortunate or unfortunate, depending on your perspective, that we didn't make a baby). And I think if you talk, one on one, to Catholics using birth control, the feel bad about it, know that it's a sin, and know that if they go to their graves having committed the sin without having been absolved of it via the offices of the church, they will "roast for all eternity."

I don't know a single catholic girl that believes birth control to be a sin regardless of the teachings of the church. And, you don't have to have a sin absolved via the offices of the church, as confession isn't mandatory to my knowledge nor is it rooted in Christ's teachings. It is recommended but all priests and deacons that I know have stated that it isn't mandatory. The number of Catholics receiving communion vastly outnumbers those showing up for confession or reconciliation as they are calling it now.

Additional Comments: Most Catholics I know do not believe that all Catholic doctrine is the true word of God A few deacons and priests I know do believe the Pope is infallible but they also weasel out of his word being the word of God given that each pope puts his own spin on church doctrine. Catholics in the U.S. certainly aren't homogenous in their beliefs.
 
Last edited:
I would not consider hunger a belief. It's a neuro-chemical biological process, not subject to external influence. People who starve themselves or are forced to starve are still hungry, they just won't or can't satiate the hunger...but they still feel it.
Hunger isn't a belief. The idea that it will be satiated by eating is.
 
I don't know a single catholic girl that believes birth control to be a sin regardless of the teachings of the church. And, you don't have to have a sin absolved via the offices of the church, as confession isn't mandatory to my knowledge nor is it rooted in Christ's teachings. It is recommended but all priests and deacons that I know have stated that it isn't mandatory. The number of Catholics receiving communion vastly outnumbers those showing up for confession or reconciliation as they are calling it now.

Additional Comments: Most Catholics I know do not believe that all Catholic doctrine is the true word of God A few deacons and priests I know do believe the Pope is infallible but they also weasel out of his word being the word of God given that each pope puts his own spin on church doctrine. Catholics in the U.S. certainly aren't homogenous in their beliefs.

Well, perhaps things have changed -- my experience is a depressingly long time ago. My then-girlfriend experienced a deep;-seated angst about going on, or even using, birth control. Yes -- she was having sex beyond her beliefs, and felt anguish about that, too.

But I do agree that American Catholics are not homogenous in their beliefs.
 
Back
Top