New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Enemy combatant: the exception that eats the Constitution?

Arkady

President
Republican senators McCain and Graham are urging that the suspect's Miranda rights be ignored under the theory the law of war applies, and he's an enemy combatant. Keep in mind, we're talking about an American citizen who allegedly committed a crime in America. If our Constitution doesn't even apply in that case, when does it? I'm normally skeptical about "slippery slope" arguments, but we've been sliding down one unmistakably for years. First the government could do what it wanted in approved war zones. Then unapproved war zones. Then against non-citizens outside the US in non war zones. Then against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) outside the US in non war zones. Then against foreigners in the US. Now it looks like it will be against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) inside the US, so long as terrorism is involved. How long until it's extended to the war on drugs and ultimately the war on crime generally? When do we citizens draw the line and tell our government "no more."

In 50 years, will we be looking back and saying "first they came for the Muslims, and I said nothing, because I was not Muslim"?
 
where ya been? Sorry but Obama signed on to all of it. I realize he told all of you he wouldn't....but um yeah....he did.
 
where ya been? Sorry but Obama signed on to all of it. I realize he told all of you he wouldn't....but um yeah....he did.

Hmmm, you hate Obama because he isn't Bush, but want us to hate him because he is.....
 
Republican senators McCain and Graham are urging that the suspect's Miranda rights be ignored under the theory the law of war applies, and he's an enemy combatant. Keep in mind, we're talking about an American citizen who allegedly committed a crime in America. If our Constitution doesn't even apply in that case, when does it? I'm normally skeptical about "slippery slope" arguments, but we've been sliding down one unmistakably for years. First the government could do what it wanted in approved war zones. Then unapproved war zones. Then against non-citizens outside the US in non war zones. Then against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) outside the US in non war zones. Then against foreigners in the US. Now it looks like it will be against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) inside the US, so long as terrorism is involved. How long until it's extended to the war on drugs and ultimately the war on crime generally? When do we citizens draw the line and tell our government "no more."

In 50 years, will we be looking back and saying "first they came for the Muslims, and I said nothing, because I was not Muslim"?

Kinda scary to think about, isn't it?
 
Republican senators McCain and Graham are urging that the suspect's Miranda rights be ignored under the theory the law of war applies, and he's an enemy combatant. Keep in mind, we're talking about an American citizen who allegedly committed a crime in America. If our Constitution doesn't even apply in that case, when does it? I'm normally skeptical about "slippery slope" arguments, but we've been sliding down one unmistakably for years. First the government could do what it wanted in approved war zones. Then unapproved war zones. Then against non-citizens outside the US in non war zones. Then against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) outside the US in non war zones. Then against foreigners in the US. Now it looks like it will be against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) inside the US, so long as terrorism is involved. How long until it's extended to the war on drugs and ultimately the war on crime generally? When do we citizens draw the line and tell our government "no more."

In 50 years, will we be looking back and saying "first they came for the Muslims, and I said nothing, because I was not Muslim"?

The government has the vast majority of people in this country drunk on fear. Your odds of being killed, or injured in a "terrorist" attack in this country are VERY minimal. The government, however, has instilled the fear in its citizens hearts and minds, and it has allowed for them to do as they please in the name of security and safety of course. The word terrorism itself is so vague and subject to each individual persons personal definition that it leaves virtually anything a person does subject to being labeled with the word, and their rights subjectively taken away once labeled. The Bush administration certainly started it, and took very large chunks of our freedoms away (and the repubs still want to taken even more), which opened the door for the Obama administration to take even more (which he certainly has done and continues to do and expand upon, and his party will also continue to do so whomever their canidate is in 2016). It's the one thing that the two parties can actually agree on, US citizens deserve fewer and fewer rights every year so that they can eventually be completely safe by living in a world with mattress covered walls and restricted hand movement to prevent accidents, freedom of thought etc. but be completely safe.


We will never draw the line as citizens. This comment from Julie is a prime example, "I'm all for the "public safety exception" which delays Miranda until the suspect is questioned about possible immediate threats to the public." I personally feel there is a flaw in that type of thinking. When do they have to read him his miranda rights? Never, if they feel like it?


This young man should have been read his rights, and face trial in a civilian court at the mercy of his peers. Military tribunal shouldn't even be in the discussion, as I have heard people suggest on various news stations and sources.


Our security should never supercede the rights which are supposed to be granted to us. I also liked how Obama talked about us standing up for our principles, that must include having the government at its own discretion, kill US citizens when it sees fit. I was unaware of that principle in our countries history, looks like I have to go back to my 8th grade US history class.
 
The government has the vast majority of people in this country drunk on fear. Your odds of being killed, or injured in a "terrorist" attack in this country are VERY minimal. The government, however, has instilled the fear in its citizens hearts and minds, and it has allowed for them to do as they please in the name of security and safety of course. The word terrorism itself is so vague and subject to each individual persons personal definition that it leaves virtually anything a person does subject to being labeled with the word, and their rights subjectively taken away once labeled. The Bush administration certainly started it, and took very large chunks of our freedoms away (and the repubs still want to taken even more), which opened the door for the Obama administration to take even more (which he certainly has done and continues to do and expand upon, and his party will also continue to do so whomever their canidate is in 2016). It's the one thing that the two parties can actually agree on, US citizens deserve fewer and fewer rights every year so that they can eventually be completely safe by living in a world with mattress covered walls and restricted hand movement to prevent accidents, freedom of thought etc. but be completely safe.


We will never draw the line as citizens. This comment from Julie is a prime example, "I'm all for the "public safety exception" which delays Miranda until the suspect is questioned about possible immediate threats to the public." I personally feel there is a flaw in that type of thinking. When do they have to read him his miranda rights? Never, if they feel like it?


This young man should have been read his rights, and face trial in a civilian court at the mercy of his peers. Military tribunal shouldn't even be in the discussion, as I have heard people suggest on various news stations and sources.


Our security should never supercede the rights which are supposed to be granted to us. I also liked how Obama talked about us standing up for our principles, that must include having the government at its own discretion, kill US citizens when it sees fit. I was unaware of that principle in our countries history, looks like I have to go back to my 8th grade US history class.


Damn good post; I agree
 
I'm all for the "public safety exception" which delays Miranda until the suspect is questioned about possible immediate threats to the public. in this case, the possibility of bombs planted out there or the identity of co-perps.

I understand that what is gathered pre-Miranda is not admissable in Court.

http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-bulletin/february2011/legal_digest

oh, yeah, eff both McCain and his sister Lindsey.

From your link (my bolding):

...this law enforcement tool, which, although 26 years old, may play a vital role in protecting public safety while also permitting statements obtained under this exception to be used as evidence in a criminal prosecution.
 
a couple of points:
1. Information obtained prior to being Mirandized can be used in court against the accused, but the scope of the questions are restricted to determining existing threats.
2. The purpose is not to get info to help convict someone. It is to find out if there is reason to believe that there are more threats to the public. That is two different goals.
3. At present this looks like a criminal case and should be tried on a civilian court. If other evidence is discovered that shows these two guys were part of a larger plot that originated with a terrorist group then it would warrant a military court.

As far a living in fear.....I've met and talked to hundreds of people in the last couple of years....nobody talks about terrorism unless that has been in the news. No part of my life has changed because of the threat of terrorism. What do you do differently? What freedoms have you lost? Certainly I've been inconvenienced by the TSA and having to go through security at airports....but is there a freedom to go to my departure gate without taking off my shoes that I've lost and should be upset about?

To learn more about the exception to Miranda, read this. The exception has existed since 1980.

http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-bulletin/february2011/legal_digest
 
From your link (my bolding):
...this law enforcement tool, which, although 26 years old, may play a vital role in protecting public safety while also permitting statements obtained under this exception to be used as evidence in a criminal prosecution.

even better.
 
......only in rightwing world.

Ignorance is bliss right? Red, Orange, Yellow ring a bell? DHS creation, and expansion? We allow our government to establish these types of BS out of fear of another "terrorist" attack. If our population didn't fear it then why would we "need" it? There is no need for any of the crap that the government has been able to create since 9/11. Prior to 9/11 security and agencies should be ample enough to catch all but the best laid plans against this country, 9/11 only highlighted the inefficiency of our government and it's employees. I fear no terrorist attack what so ever, because the possibility of it is so dang small it isn't worth even thinking about, let alone spending billions on and infringing on peoples rights granted by the constitution.9+

Or is it just because: "The bureaucracy is expanding to meet the needs of the expanding bureaucracy."
 
Ignorance is bliss right? Red, Orange, Yellow ring a bell? DHS creation, and expansion? We allow our government to establish these types of BS out of fear of another "terrorist" attack. If our population didn't fear it then why would we "need" it? There is no need for any of the crap that the government has been able to create since 9/11. Prior to 9/11 security and agencies should be ample enough to catch all but the best laid plans against this country, 9/11 only highlighted the inefficiency of our government and it's employees. I fear no terrorist attack what so ever, because the possibility of it is so dang small it isn't worth even thinking about, let alone spending billions on and infringing on peoples rights granted by the constitution.9+

Or is it just because: "The bureaucracy is expanding to meet the needs of the expanding bureaucracy."

DHS was created from existing organizations....
 
Read him his rights then send him to Gitmo and water board the little bastard until he squeals like the pig he is
 
Read him his rights then send him to Gitmo and water board the little bastard until he squeals like the pig he is

We haven't sent anyone to Gitmo since about 2006 and we certainly haven't waterboarded anyone since Bush was president.

This kid won't need torture to talk. He drove over his own brother to escape. He'll talk.
 
Orange, Yellow ring a bell? DHS creation, and expansion? We allow our government to establish these types of BS out of fear of another "terrorist" attack. If our population didn't fear it then why would we "need" it? There is no need for any of the crap that the government has been able to create since 9/11.

All of these, AND the fear were created by a republican idiot in the oval office and republican controlled senate AND house. "Homeland Security" was the largest expansion of US government in history.
 
All of these, AND the fear were created by a republican idiot in the oval office and republican controlled senate AND house. "Homeland Security" was the largest expansion of US government in history.

I would not argue a single point that you made. I would expand upon it though, as in it has not gone away. The simplicity of the fear, orange, yellow, red, has gone by the way side, and rightfully so. The concept of fear of "terrorist attack" has not gone away, it's why we have the NDAA acts of recent years, and a further expansion and sustainment of the Patriot Act since Obama took over. Don't get me wrong, I voted Obama in 2008, in hopes of some sort of a level headed nonpolitical pro US hope and change canidate. I was wrong, I vote on the patriot act and NDAA acts, and he is NO different than Bush. That levels the playing field between the two parties, there is no difference between them on the issue.

Obama lost, completely, my support after the white paper emerged. I am economically and socially a liberal, for the most part, I am conservative on guns, government interference in our personal lives, well you get it some of the very basics. Obamas allowance of the patriot act, his NDAA actions, and his willingness to kill US civilians at his administrations choice, crossed a hell of a line. The same applies to the Boston bombing suspect being held without being read his miranda rights, it's a core concept of our experiment.

MR- I didn't say that DHS was created out of the blue, I said that it was created due to inefficient government offices. Again it was created because our government agencies cannot function correctly, waste money, and can not manage the jobs they are given. If our processes in the respective fields were efficient 9/11 would not have happened, instead we created DHS which runs at the same capability only employs a lot more people.
 
Back
Top