New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Energy Independance

Citizen

Council Member
isn't it funny, with as much oil as Saudia Arabia, Iran & many middle east countries & even Russia have, none of them are even close to energy independant.


Does anyone here really think America can become energy independant?


I don't think that will ever happen for any country until we develop an energy soucre NOT based on fossil fuels
 
isn't it funny, with as much oil as Saudia Arabia, Iran & many middle east countries & even Russia have, none of them are even close to energy independant.


Does anyone here really think America can become energy independant?


I don't think that will ever happen for any country until we develop an energy soucre NOT based on fossil fuels

"Energy independence" is relative and I don't see absolute independence necessarily, as our desired end. As an overly-simple for instance, let's say that we import 40% of our petro. If we get it all from the middle-east or we get it all from the Western Hemisphere, doesn't it make a significant and relevent difference in a whole host of ways?

OR...let's say we reach where we CAN get all we need from western sources, but we're in a position to tell say...the Saudis, that we're willing to buy their product on OUR terms (presumably, because they'd offer it up at a price we like). Doesn't that make a difference?
 
"Energy independence" is relative and I don't see absolute independence necessarily

Whether you see it as necessary or not has nothing to do with what I asked.
 
Well, it would require that any economy produce as much energy locally as it uses and that the rate of supply keeps up with demand constantly. Given that reserves are finite and demand could potentially be in one of two projectories, up or down, the key would be to control demand first, make the best use of supply second. Hence, smart grids, alternate fuels or energy sources, conservation, efficiency, standards, pricing, etc are all tools that one would look at to manage energy usage. This is not that hard a problem to grasp if one looks at it objectively. The key is that the right will never agree to one parameter which the nation insists upon : energy production and usage must not despoil our environment to the point where we regress to times past or look like Shanghai or Peking on a smoggy day. Take a look at movies based in LA from the late 60s and early 70s...smog everywhere, cars spewing black and white smoke...
 
"Energy independence" is relative and I don't see absolute independence necessarily, as our desired end. As an overly-simple for instance, let's say that we import 40% of our petro. If we get it all from the middle-east or we get it all from the Western Hemisphere, doesn't it make a significant and relevent difference in a whole host of ways?

OR...let's say we reach where we CAN get all we need from western sources, but we're in a position to tell say...the Saudis, that we're willing to buy their product on OUR terms (presumably, because they'd offer it up at a price we like). Doesn't that make a difference?

Actually...I DID answer your question, by suggesting that it's bogus. If it makes no sense for us to make absolute energy independence our goal, the question of whether or not we CAN do it, is moot.

For of COURSE we could do it, if we were willing to pay the exorbitant cost, without any plausible expectation of positive return. But...since we aren't quite THAT thick, I suppose maybe the answer is that we can't do it! So....we could do it if we wanted to, but since we don't want to, we can't do it. There........
 
well you are wrong. Its that simple. So being wrong of course you feel no need to actually address the problem, because you refuse to admit there is a problem in the first place.

thats just how the Con's seem to deal with the problems they create also. Just refuse to sadmit there is a problem, then you have no problems.
 
well you are wrong. Its that simple. So being wrong of course you feel no need to actually address the problem, because you refuse to admit there is a problem in the first place.

thats just how the Con's seem to deal with the problems they create also. Just refuse to sadmit there is a problem, then you have no problems.

I'm guessing your response was to me, so I'll say that I made no effort whatsoever, to "deny the problem". In fact, "the problem" isn't even in evidence in this thread as of yet. All's I can say is that I perceive a problem, but I don't think the solution to the problem I perceive, necessarily involves absolute independence.
 
isn't it funny, with as much oil as Saudia Arabia, Iran & many middle east countries & even Russia have, none of them are even close to energy independant.


Does anyone here really think America can become energy independant?


I don't think that will ever happen for any country until we develop an energy soucre NOT based on fossil fuels

Agreed
 
..we can and we will because eventually we will either realize the cost of maintaining access to oil is too high or the oil will eventually run out...
 
What is the benefit of absolute energy independence? Are you suggesting that America should not engage in international trade?
 
Yes we can...

DOE estimated 100 year supply of oil in 2003. That was with all known reserves tapped and un-touched most has been mapped. They estimated about 50 years of relatively inexpensive and then the price climbs. This was before China and India really started cranking up...

Basically we have no choice! YES if we can wrap our mind around NUKES, WIND, SUN and Water?

isn't it funny, with as much oil as Saudia Arabia, Iran & many middle east countries & even Russia have, none of them are even close to energy independant.


Does anyone here really think America can become energy independant?


I don't think that will ever happen for any country until we develop an energy soucre NOT based on fossil fuels
 
I'm guessing your response was to me, so I'll say that I made no effort whatsoever, to "deny the problem". In fact, "the problem" isn't even in evidence in this thread as of yet. All's I can say is that I perceive a problem, but I don't think the solution to the problem I perceive, necessarily involves absolute independence.

Then we are looking at either different problems, or looking at the same problem with a differing point of view.
 
Yes we can...

DOE estimated 100 year supply of oil in 2003. That was with all known reserves tapped and un-touched most has been mapped. They estimated about 50 years of relatively inexpensive and then the price climbs. This was before China and India really started cranking up...

Basically we have no choice! YES if we can wrap our mind around NUKES, WIND, SUN and Water?

wHAT WOULD REALLY BE GREAT TO SEE IS FUSION. i DON'T THINK IT IS OUT OF REACH. iT ALWAYS WILL BE OUT OF REACH AS LONG AS WE DON'T INVEST IN DEVELOPING IT.
OOPS, damn capslock....

we need zero penalty energy . Of course to have that we will need to completly alter our financial systems etc....
 
Back
Top