New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Eventually, the youth gets it...

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...rman-youth-blast-merkels-multicultural-utopia

They finally figure out it isn't capitalism that is screwing them. In Europe, it's probably too late. But we still have a chance here in America, if the kids are paying attention to what's happening there.
Should they blame Christianity, instead?
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...rman-youth-blast-merkels-multicultural-utopia
"Of course you can’t exactly blame Europeans for their newfound tendency to lean right (so to speak). Between the Paris attacks and the wave of sexual assaults that took place across the bloc on New Year’s Eve, the EU electorate has come to associate refugees with violent crime. The bloc is in fact so frightened that pepper spray and gun sales are soaring as Europeans arm themselves against what they increasingly view as a hostile foreign invasion and an usurpation of Christian values."

Do you blame capitalism for European imperialism across the Middle East and Africa?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scramble_for_Africa
 
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...rman-youth-blast-merkels-multicultural-utopia

They finally figure out it isn't capitalism that is screwing them. In Europe, it's probably too late. But we still have a chance here in America, if the kids are paying attention to what's happening there.
There has always been a pool of reactionary, xenophobic, nationalistic youths for a certain kind of politician to draw on in Europe. Hitler rode such people to power. They formed the backbone of his brownshirts. But is there any sign that, right now, that pool is large?

This is a bit dated, but shows what the breakdown was among youth voters in 2013:

http://www.spiegel.de/international...ular-among-german-youth-in-poll-a-921849.html

At the time, the center-right and far-right combined with 39%. There were four major left parties (SPD, Green, Left, and Pirate), which combined for 55%. So, as in the US, the youth leaned heavily to the left... albeit less so than in prior elections. Hard economic times have a history of pushing the youth to the extremes, and if there are charismatic leaders on the right, that can mean young people can wind up moving mostly that way. That was the recipe for the NSDAP. Hopefully we're not repeating that today.
 
and another thing - if Germany let's in millions of "refugees"who need public assistance, then who's going to pay the ultra high taxes that made Germany such a utopia?

Xenophobe! Racist! Just let them all in, appearing "tolerant" is more important. Now make sure all your hem lines are below the knee or else you deserve to get raped.
 
There has always been a pool of reactionary, xenophobic, nationalistic youths for a certain kind of politician to draw on in Europe. Hitler rode such people to power. They formed the backbone of his brownshirts. But is there any sign that, right now, that pool is large?

This is a bit dated, but shows what the breakdown was among youth voters in 2013:

http://www.spiegel.de/international...ular-among-german-youth-in-poll-a-921849.html

At the time, the center-right and far-right combined with 39%. There were four major left parties (SPD, Green, Left, and Pirate), which combined for 55%. So, as in the US, the youth leaned heavily to the left... albeit less so than in prior elections. Hard economic times have a history of pushing the youth to the extremes, and if there are charismatic leaders on the right, that can mean young people can wind up moving mostly that way. That was the recipe for the NSDAP. Hopefully we're not repeating that today.

At some point even the frog realizes he's being boiled...
 
Should they blame Christianity, instead?
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...rman-youth-blast-merkels-multicultural-utopia
"Of course you can’t exactly blame Europeans for their newfound tendency to lean right (so to speak). Between the Paris attacks and the wave of sexual assaults that took place across the bloc on New Year’s Eve, the EU electorate has come to associate refugees with violent crime. The bloc is in fact so frightened that pepper spray and gun sales are soaring as Europeans arm themselves against what they increasingly view as a hostile foreign invasion and an usurpation of Christian values."

Do you blame capitalism for European imperialism across the Middle East and Africa?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scramble_for_Africa
Why blame Christianity? Clearly Europe isn't Christian anymore.
 
There has always been a pool of reactionary, xenophobic, nationalistic youths for a certain kind of politician to draw on in Europe. Hitler rode such people to power. They formed the backbone of his brownshirts. But is there any sign that, right now, that pool is large?

This is a bit dated, but shows what the breakdown was among youth voters in 2013:

http://www.spiegel.de/international...ular-among-german-youth-in-poll-a-921849.html

At the time, the center-right and far-right combined with 39%. There were four major left parties (SPD, Green, Left, and Pirate), which combined for 55%. So, as in the US, the youth leaned heavily to the left... albeit less so than in prior elections. Hard economic times have a history of pushing the youth to the extremes, and if there are charismatic leaders on the right, that can mean young people can wind up moving mostly that way. That was the recipe for the NSDAP. Hopefully we're not repeating that today.

The [Unwelcome language removed] classes in Europe and the US can and should stop mass migration but don't. The backlash is natural and to be expected. It is rational to be against such large numbers being allowed to immigrate legally or otherwise.
 
The [Unwelcome language removed] classes in Europe and the US can and should stop mass migration but don't. The backlash is natural and to be expected. It is rational to be against such large numbers being allowed to immigrate legally or otherwise.
It is certainly expected. The rise of fascism in the 20s and 30s also had a large component of xenophobic backlash against migration. At the time, it was unassimilated Jews from Eastern Europe coming into Austria and Germany who were inspiring the fear and anger of the nativists and nationalists. This time the "religious other" role is being played by Muslims from the Middle East, but the dynamics shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone, since at a psychological level the same thing is happening.

It's too bad that few people in the US speak foreign languages well, since it cuts way back on how many "primary sources" they can engage with. One of the more eye-opening experiences I had was reading a bunch of German newspapers from the late 1920s, as part of a project. The anti-semitic, xenophobic propaganda in those papers was quite reminiscent of a certain kind of right-wing propaganda we see in the US today.
 
It is certainly expected. The rise of fascism in the 20s and 30s also had a large component of xenophobic backlash against migration. At the time, it was unassimilated Jews from Eastern Europe coming into Austria and Germany who were inspiring the fear and anger of the nativists and nationalists. This time the "religious other" role is being played by Muslims from the Middle East, but the dynamics shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone, since at a psychological level the same thing is happening.

It's too bad that few people in the US speak foreign languages well, since it cuts way back on how many "primary sources" they can engage with. One of the more eye-opening experiences I had was reading a bunch of German newspapers from the late 1920s, as part of a project. The anti-semitic, xenophobic propaganda in those papers was quite reminiscent of a certain kind of right-wing propaganda we see in the US today.

Short of murdering or beating people there is nothing wrong with closing your borders to foreigners entering your country en masse. Nothing wrong with nationalism (that doesn't engage in violence) at all.
 
Doesn't matter, does it? We are a secular country thanks to people like you who have argued that way.

Do you think Jesus ever said no to something? He did.

Not only that if Europe acted like you would have them when the Muslims first went on Jihad there'd be no Europe or possibly Christians today.
 
Doesn't matter, does it? We are a secular country thanks to people like you who have argued that way.

Secular or not, it's useful to examine questions from the perspective of how they would be perceived by various historical moral thinkers. When it comes to Jesus, or Immanuel Kant by way of the categorical imperative, or any of countless other thinkers in history who came at moral questions with something akin to the Golden Rule, the present crisis is fairly clear cut. If you and those you loved were among the refugees -- on the run from a murderous war in your homeland and looking for somewhere to shelter from the storm, what would you want others to "do unto you"? Whatever it is, morally that's what you should be doing right now for those refugees.

You said "there's nothing wrong with closing your borders to foreigners entering your country en mass." By what standards do you conclude that? Certainly there is something wrong with it if you look at it in light of the Golden Rule and you wouldn't want those borders closed to you if you were on the other side facing what those refugees are facing.
 
Die for your sins.
‘Depart from me, for I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.... Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me. Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life."

You expect to see Jesus one day, right? Are you working on your explanation for why, when he came to you as a stranger in need, you turned him away?
 
Secular or not, it's useful to examine questions from the perspective of how they would be perceived by various historical moral thinkers. When it comes to Jesus, or Immanuel Kant by way of the categorical imperative, or any of countless other thinkers in history who came at moral questions with something akin to the Golden Rule, the present crisis is fairly clear cut. If you and those you loved were among the refugees -- on the run from a murderous war in your homeland and looking for somewhere to shelter from the storm, what would you want others to "do unto you"? Whatever it is, morally that's what you should be doing right now for those refugees.

You said "there's nothing wrong with closing your borders to foreigners entering your country en mass." By what standards do you conclude that? Certainly there is something wrong with it if you look at it in light of the Golden Rule and you wouldn't want those borders closed to you if you were on the other side facing what those refugees are facing.

What's clear is that these kinds of people you cite are the distinct minority. The majority are basically hedonistic, uneducated and, in some cases, homicidal, young, single males, at least some of whom are already radicalized. The very fact that you would ignore the very clear truth about these people, in favor of your utopian "all together now" collectivist dream, is as good a reason as any to start marginalizing those who share your views (the sooner the better).
 
Last edited:
It is certainly expected. The rise of fascism in the 20s and 30s also had a large component of xenophobic backlash against migration. At the time, it was unassimilated Jews from Eastern Europe coming into Austria and Germany who were inspiring the fear and anger of the nativists and nationalists. This time the "religious other" role is being played by Muslims from the Middle East, but the dynamics shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone, since at a psychological level the same thing is happening.

It's too bad that few people in the US speak foreign languages well, since it cuts way back on how many "primary sources" they can engage with. One of the more eye-opening experiences I had was reading a bunch of German newspapers from the late 1920s, as part of a project. The anti-semitic, xenophobic propaganda in those papers was quite reminiscent of a certain kind of right-wing propaganda we see in the US today.


english is the universal language of business....

its too bad so many "migrants" come here to work/conduct business expecting the natives to speak their language....
 
Secular or not, it's useful to examine questions from the perspective of how they would be perceived by various historical moral thinkers. When it comes to Jesus, or Immanuel Kant by way of the categorical imperative, or any of countless other thinkers in history who came at moral questions with something akin to the Golden Rule, the present crisis is fairly clear cut. If you and those you loved were among the refugees -- on the run from a murderous war in your homeland and looking for somewhere to shelter from the storm, what would you want others to "do unto you"? Whatever it is, morally that's what you should be doing right now for those refugees.

You said "there's nothing wrong with closing your borders to foreigners entering your country en mass." By what standards do you conclude that? Certainly there is something wrong with it if you look at it in light of the Golden Rule and you wouldn't want those borders closed to you if you were on the other side facing what those refugees are facing.
No, no... we are a secular society. Our religion is a matter of a personal exercise in morality. We had an immigration moratorium from the 1920's to the 1960's (40 years) and it did us no harm and arguably is allowed for the a national identity building that purposed the country in a positive fashion.
 
english is the universal language of business....

its too bad so many "migrants" come here to work/conduct business expecting the natives to speak their language....
I've never met one of these migrants who comes here expecting the natives to speak their language. I've met some who struggle with English (which, by the way, is brutally difficult to learn). But for the most part they make excellent progress. I'm always humbled by the fact that nearly all Latin-American born immigrants I meet speak English better than I speak any other language, despite major efforts on my part. And immigrants from the Middle East are even more impressive -- they tend to run the gas stations in this area, and they all speak such good English, with only minor accents, despite coming from language traditions that are so far from our own. I've never tried to learn Arabic or Farsi, but I have picked up a bit of Russian and Mandarin, so I realize that the difficulty of learning a new language is exponentially greater the more that language differs from your native one.
 
Back
Top