Arkady
President
First, I'll just get out of the way, up front, that I oppose the death penalty, on the simple basis that it's immoral to kill people as a form of punishment. But, even setting that aside, this is disturbing:
http://www.salon.com/2013/09/12/in_texas_execution_for_association_partner/
Basically, in Texas, they have something called the "Law of Parties" which says the prosecution doesn't have to prove that a defendant killed or intended to kill anyone, if it can prove that he had a certain level of involvement in a felony that led to murder. In law school we learned about a similar concept -- the felony murder rule, which gets used to obtain murder convictions for, say, the get-away driver for a bank heist where someone gets shot, even if he was no part of the shooting or even of planning to shoot anyone. The Law of Parties concept appears to go even farther than the typical felony-murder rule, though, since in the present case the man is about to be executed for his involvement in the gang whose members committed the murder, even though he wasn't proven to have been on the scene, much less to have pulled the trigger.
Given that we're talking about a gang, here, I doubt the man is going to garner much sympathy, especially among conservatives. But a useful mental exercise is to recast the fact pattern into something functionally identical, but where you have a natural sympathy for the defendant. Here are a couple examples, tailored for conservatives:
You're a member of a radical pro-life group that breaks into abortion clinics at night and destroys their equipment, with the idea that this will slow them down in performing abortions, thereby saving innocent lives. During one break-in, your group is stopped by a security guard, and a fellow member of the group whips out a gun (that you didn't even know he had) and shoots the guard. You are now on death row for that murder, since you were involved in the commission of a felony, where somebody was murdered. Or, to take it a step farther, you weren't even involved in the break-in, but you were at group meetings where it was discussed and you knew it was going to happen, and knew the potential risk, but did nothing to report it.
You're a gun collector who is part of an organization that preserves WWI rifles. You agree to accompany a fellow organization member on a road trip to showcase both your collections at a gun show in another state.... without bothering to lock the weapons up for transit the way that's required (which, let's say, is technically a felony). Your colleague is driving when you get pulled over for a routine brake-light problem, he realizes that a search will reveal your felony, and he panics and runs over the cop, killing him. You are now facing the death penalty for involvement in the commission of a felony, where somebody was murdered. Or, to take it a step farther, you weren't even one of the people in the car, but you were involved in planning the gun show and did know that people were planning to bring in guns in a way that didn't comply with transportation laws, and you did nothing to dissuade them (e.g., you knew that the car didn't have a trunk to lock the guns up in, and that nobody was planning to go out and get a locking container to comply with the law).
I'd say that in each of those cases it's clear you're guilty of a crime and should be punished. But if you see the death penalty as a supreme punishment that should be reserved only for the most heinous of crimes committed by the most unredeemable of criminals, it's hard to see how any of those three examples (the real one in Texas, or the two I imagined) would qualify. A person who chooses to commit a lesser felony shouldn't be held to the same standard as a person who intentionally kills someone, merely because someone was killed in relation to that felony.
http://www.salon.com/2013/09/12/in_texas_execution_for_association_partner/
Basically, in Texas, they have something called the "Law of Parties" which says the prosecution doesn't have to prove that a defendant killed or intended to kill anyone, if it can prove that he had a certain level of involvement in a felony that led to murder. In law school we learned about a similar concept -- the felony murder rule, which gets used to obtain murder convictions for, say, the get-away driver for a bank heist where someone gets shot, even if he was no part of the shooting or even of planning to shoot anyone. The Law of Parties concept appears to go even farther than the typical felony-murder rule, though, since in the present case the man is about to be executed for his involvement in the gang whose members committed the murder, even though he wasn't proven to have been on the scene, much less to have pulled the trigger.
Given that we're talking about a gang, here, I doubt the man is going to garner much sympathy, especially among conservatives. But a useful mental exercise is to recast the fact pattern into something functionally identical, but where you have a natural sympathy for the defendant. Here are a couple examples, tailored for conservatives:
You're a member of a radical pro-life group that breaks into abortion clinics at night and destroys their equipment, with the idea that this will slow them down in performing abortions, thereby saving innocent lives. During one break-in, your group is stopped by a security guard, and a fellow member of the group whips out a gun (that you didn't even know he had) and shoots the guard. You are now on death row for that murder, since you were involved in the commission of a felony, where somebody was murdered. Or, to take it a step farther, you weren't even involved in the break-in, but you were at group meetings where it was discussed and you knew it was going to happen, and knew the potential risk, but did nothing to report it.
You're a gun collector who is part of an organization that preserves WWI rifles. You agree to accompany a fellow organization member on a road trip to showcase both your collections at a gun show in another state.... without bothering to lock the weapons up for transit the way that's required (which, let's say, is technically a felony). Your colleague is driving when you get pulled over for a routine brake-light problem, he realizes that a search will reveal your felony, and he panics and runs over the cop, killing him. You are now facing the death penalty for involvement in the commission of a felony, where somebody was murdered. Or, to take it a step farther, you weren't even one of the people in the car, but you were involved in planning the gun show and did know that people were planning to bring in guns in a way that didn't comply with transportation laws, and you did nothing to dissuade them (e.g., you knew that the car didn't have a trunk to lock the guns up in, and that nobody was planning to go out and get a locking container to comply with the law).
I'd say that in each of those cases it's clear you're guilty of a crime and should be punished. But if you see the death penalty as a supreme punishment that should be reserved only for the most heinous of crimes committed by the most unredeemable of criminals, it's hard to see how any of those three examples (the real one in Texas, or the two I imagined) would qualify. A person who chooses to commit a lesser felony shouldn't be held to the same standard as a person who intentionally kills someone, merely because someone was killed in relation to that felony.