Zam-Zam
Senator
Joe Biden was sworn into the Senate in 1973, the year before Richard Nixon resigned the presidency. Apparently the young senator was taking notes. Pres. Biden echoed his predecessor last week by claiming executive privilege over tapes of an important presidential discussion. The current president’s argument, however, is much weaker.
Special counsel Robert Hur interviewed the president in October about Pres. Biden’s handling of classified material during his time as a senator, vice president and private citizen. Mr. Hur recorded the conversation to prepare a transcript, which was subsequently released to the public. The House now wants the audio file, and two committees have subpoenaed it. Despite releasing the transcripts, the Biden administration has invoked executive privilege to conceal the tapes.
The assertion of privilege isn’t based on the interview subject’s status as president. The Supreme Court explained in U.S. v. Nixon (1974) that executive privilege pertains to “presidential communications in the exercise of Art. II powers.” Mr. Hur spoke with Pres. Biden about his personal conduct before his inauguration, meaning presidential communications weren’t at issue.
Pres. Biden has instead claimed, at Attorney General Garland’s request, that he can assert privilege over the Justice Department’s “law enforcement functions.” That is how the president justifies concealing not only the tapes of his interview with Mr. Hur but also those of his ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer, a private citizen.
Whatever the application of executive privilege to Justice Department investigations of private citizens, it can’t be used to conceal tapes after transcripts have been released. Pres. Biden waived whatever privilege might protect these interviews when he released their contents in full.
Complete text: Biden, Nixon and the Hur Report - WSJ
The tapes themselves must be particularly embarrassing for the President...Why else would they be withheld from the voting public after the transcripts have been released?
The Biden transparency...
