New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Expand Social Security

Arkady

President
Here's an interesting article about the idea of expanding Social Security, and how that has recently become a matter that significant political figures talk about, whereas it was previously treated as radical and unrealistic:

http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/

The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;

http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron

That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.

For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.

The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.

In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.

Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.
 
Raising the federal minimum wage, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and expanding Social Security are all variations on essentially the same theme. I'll betcha (anecdotally) that if you were to poll "men and women on the street", at least 80% would be supportive of at least one of these. And, most of them would be dismissive of one or both of the others!
 
Raising the federal minimum wage, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and expanding Social Security are all variations on essentially the same theme. I'll betcha (anecdotally) that if you were to poll "men and women on the street", at least 80% would be supportive of at least one of these. And, most of them would be dismissive of one or both of the others!

I wouldn't argue with that. 80% of the general population might respond as you say.

But what percentage of that group would be basing their answer on faulty info?
Especially the Social Security question.
 
I wouldn't argue with that. 80% of the general population might respond as you say.

But what percentage of that group would be basing their answer on faulty info?
Especially the Social Security question.

As a political economist, I'm not prepared to opine. But...(as it's too late for me to retract!), I am prepared to opine that the vast majority of Americans are pretty much on the same page, no matter what they tell ya.
 
Here's an interesting article about the idea of expanding Social Security, and how that has recently become a matter that significant political figures talk about, whereas it was previously treated as radical and unrealistic:

http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/

The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;

http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron

That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.

For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.

The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.

In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.

Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.

I'm all for raising it.

And I couldn't agree more about the WP. Anybody that sees it as anything other than the rightwing rag its largely long been hasn't been paying attention or has some blinders on
 
Here's an interesting article about the idea of expanding Social Security, and how that has recently become a matter that significant political figures talk about, whereas it was previously treated as radical and unrealistic:

http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/

The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;

http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron

That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.

For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.

The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.

In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.

Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.
1) pro-expansionist government piece (shock)
2) social security contributions are already "progressive". That statists want to remove the cap so that they can transfer even more wealth is unsurprising. You want to force contributions beyond the cap? Ok -then force benefit payments commensurate with contributions... Otherwise you've stacked yet another layer of welfare (and statist lefties love stacking redundancies).
3) WAPO as conservative outpost is yet another indicator that lefty is being carried downstream in pinko whitewater rapids. The parallax is stunning.

"Everyone else is moving, but I'm standing still". Um, yes. Obama was elected, hence "I'm the new normal".

:-/
 
1) pro-expansionist government piece (shock)
2) social security contributions are already "progressive". That statists want to remove the cap so that they can transfer even more wealth is unsurprising. You want to force contributions beyond the cap? Ok -then force benefit payments commensurate with contributions... Otherwise you've stacked yet another layer of welfare (and statist lefties love stacking redundancies).
3) WAPO as conservative outpost is yet another indicator that lefty is being carried downstream in pinko whitewater rapids. The parallax is stunning.

"Everyone else is moving, but I'm standing still". Um, yes. Obama was elected, hence "I'm the new normal".

:-/
Yes, I'm calling for expanding the program and making it more progressive. Now that you've made a glaringly obvious description of the idea, care to reply on the substance? You act as if pointing out that my plan would make Social Security bigger and more progressive is, itself, a rebuttal. It isn't. Why is that a bad thing?

As for whether the Washington Post is conservative, or not, that's ultimately a label that's meaningless without context. By your standards, no doubt they're liberal, economically... as would be any outlet that isn't trying to roll back the entire 20th century of first-world economic progress. By my standards, though, and the standards of centrist opinion as defined by he citizenry of advanced nations generally, they're far right on military and foreign policy issues, center-right on economics, and somewhere in the middle on social issues. If you let the WaPo editorial board set tax policy, entitlement spending, and regulations according to their own beliefs, I'm wagering you'd get something to the right of average positions among OECD nations.
 
Yes, I'm calling for expanding the program and making it more progressive. Now that you've made a glaringly obvious description of the idea, care to reply on the substance? You act as if pointing out that my plan would make Social Security bigger and more progressive is, itself, a rebuttal. It isn't. Why is that a bad thing?

As for whether the Washington Post is conservative, or not, that's ultimately a label that's meaningless without context. By your standards, no doubt they're liberal, economically... as would be any outlet that isn't trying to roll back the entire 20th century of first-world economic progress. By my standards, though, and the standards of centrist opinion as defined by he citizenry of advanced nations generally, they're far right on military and foreign policy issues, center-right on economics, and somewhere in the middle on social issues. If you let the WaPo editorial board set tax policy, entitlement spending, and regulations according to their own beliefs, I'm wagering you'd get something to the right of average positions among OECD nations.
How does one conduct a rational discussion with so avowed a statist? As proven in almost every single post that offers a prescriptive element, your every impulse is to consolidate federal power and centralize execution of an ever-increasing caretaker agenda at cost of liberty. Then you stuff your thumbs under your lapels and congratulate yourself on how "centrist" you are (and how moderate the cockeyed internet left is in general) relative to this constantly invoked amalgam of 'modern advanced nations' (none of whom share our history, culture, regional differences across so many different areas, etc.).
If one must conjure invalid relativity among unlike things in order to appear reasonable, he's being dishonest. I don't eat Fruit Loops...so why would I accept analysis from that same cereal box?
It is fact that WAPO is historically lefty. The lefties on this board are, by no means, centrists (no matter how much you choose to invoke foreign powers). I suppose I could make the argument that relative to cannibalistic tribes of Borneo and Papua New Guinea, mine is a diet carefully steeped in social conscience.
Finally, I'll note that social security is already progressive and redistributive to an extent contrary to its purpose - and is fraudulent with respect to how it was sold to us generations ago. Naturally, those who do not prize liberty will seek to expand and magnify the worst aspects of SS by making those who draw the least relative to what they pay in...pay even more - while those who pay the least and draw the most have their ranks expanded.
Your unimpeded march to collectivism is not appealing to me - irrespective of your constant Madison Avenue-style efforts to rebadge it as modern progress. Soak it in brine, bury it in constant relativistic comparison to unlike nations, sugarcoat it, and make appeals to contemporary social convention. It's still just recycled collectivism, statism, and typical "progressive" unequal protection. I prefer that the march of history not goose-step.
SS is here to stay. I grudgingly accept it as safety net and - perhaps - supplemental retirement income. It ought not be expanded - and it certainly should not be made more onerous to those already footing its funding costs disproportionately.
 
In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.

In doing this, and in calling for removal of the high-income cap on Social Security taxes, you effectively undermine the promise made by FDR that Social Security is retirement insurance, rather than a scheme to tax the wealthy so that the poor can retire. There were, in the 1930s, strong opponents of the latter method. They still exist.
 
In doing this, and in calling for removal of the high-income cap on Social Security taxes, you effectively undermine the promise made by FDR that Social Security is retirement insurance, rather than a scheme to tax the wealthy so that the poor can retire. There were, in the 1930s, strong opponents of the latter method. They still exist.
Incrementalism. ACA is just like this as well. Single payer and direct state operation of health care is next.
 
Incrementalism. ACA is just like this as well. Single payer and direct state operation of health care is next.

I know, I know. But if you bring that up, the left will deride you as paranoid, while firmly ignoring their own history.
 
I know, I know. But if you bring that up, the left will deride you as paranoid, while firmly ignoring their own history.
Personally, I prefer it when we all advocate what we want in broad daylight. No misdirection. No subterfuge. No silly euphemisms. Just good faith competition in the marketplace of ideas.
I don't begrudge the fact that so many on the left put a premium on security such that it trumps liberty as our primary value. I think they are dead wrong, that this represents a stark departure from our national character, and that what they seek will deliver us an undesirable social order - but they should advocate for what they want just as conservatives should.
I really dislike the navigation as it plays out. Cloak and dagger stuff, re-branding and re-badging what are old ideas and calling them "new", "social ev0lution", and forward-thinking progressivism. None of this stuff is new.
Most of all, I'm sick to death of lefties who seek to characterize conservatives as constantly "scared" or paranoid, fearing terrorists under their beds, "bedwetters", gun-clingers, black helicopter-spotters. Who is it that panics regarding his fellow man's capacity to self-provide...who clamors for state needs-meeting. Geezers eating Alpo, children in the streets, horror!

Sorry, I know fear and bad faith when I see it.

We need to call these conniving sloths out.
:)
 
so so sum up -

even though expanding the base of congtributing workers, and raising the taxable income level and raising the tax rate - even though NONE of these things has fixed social security, you are convinced that the next round of increases will?

good thinking !!!
 
Why not just have our beloved central bank flow some of that $85B monthly QE bling to Americans SSI accounts instead of Wall Street/TBTF banks?
 
How does one conduct a rational discussion with so avowed a statist?

Well, you do it by coming at issues with a rational mind, rather than with religious devotion to anti-statism. If there are grounds for opposing a particular expansion of government, you should voice those grounds, rather than acting like pointing out that it's an expansion of government is self-evident refutation. Outside the libertarian cult, it isn't.

In fact, even that gives your rhetorical technique a bit too much credit. Half he time you aren't even trying to refute it on the basis of the policy being statist, but instead are trying to refute it on the basis of the supposed statist tendencies of the poster. We can just start by stipulating that I am a heretic, when it comes to your anti-state dogma, and then move on to discussing particulars. There's no point wasting endless paragraphs on trying to brand me a statist.

As proven in almost every single post that offers a prescriptive element, your every impulse is to consolidate federal power and centralize execution of an ever-increasing caretaker agenda at cost of liberty.

As you know, that is untrue. But, more to the point, it's irrelevant. Even if I were the reflexive statist of your fevered imagination, that would not add or detract one bit from the case for a particular policy. You might as well be saying, "you have cooties, so I'm not going to respond to your argument."

Then you stuff your thumbs under your lapels and congratulate yourself on how "centrist" you are (and how moderate the cockeyed internet left is in general) relative to this constantly invoked amalgam of 'modern advanced nations' (none of whom share our history, culture, regional differences across so many different areas, etc.).

The term "centrist" is, by definition, a relative term. There can't be a center without roughly equal suff on either side. So you need to define your context. I define mine in much the same way businesses do. When businesses benchmark themselves, they do it against their peers: other businesses of roughly the same size in the same industry. Well, the peers of the United States, for benchmarking purposes, are other large, wealthy democracies. That seems like the most meaningful context, and so that's the one I use.

We could, of course, benchmark against our own past history, instead. For example, the centrist tax position might be to want tax levels that are roughly average by the standards of the US over a particular identified historical stretch, where the right-wing approach would be wanting taxes lower than that, and the left-wing approach would be wanting them higher. For example, what's the average tax rate on the top bracket since WWII?

Or we could define the center in terms of position relative to American citizens generally. So, for example, if most citizens think Social Security should be preserved at current levels --neither expanded nor contracted-- then left would be to try to expand, and right would be to try to contrat. Or we coul define the center in terms of positioning relative to the major politicians who happen to be in power at the moment, such that the left is what leading Democrats want, the right is what leading Republicans want, and the center is somewhere in between. I fully admit I'm only "centrist" relative to some of those contexts. Others would make me a right- or left-winger. For example, if it were my call, I'd hike taxes on the top bracket, but not as high as was typical through much of living memory (the top bracket paid between 70% to 92% for half a century, and I wouldn't push that high), so I guess by that view I'm to the right.

Finally, I'll note that social security is already progressive and redistributive to an extent contrary to its purpose - and is fraudulent with respect to how it was sold to us generations ago.

It may be different from the sales pitch made to our great-grandparents, but so what? This country was once sold to a pack of slave owners on the basis of preserving their rights to beat and rape their slaves however they saw fit. Times change, and I'm arguing they should change with Social Security. If you have an argument against that change, make it. Merely pointing out that it is a change is only an argument if a person is such a reactionary that change, itself, is a self-evident negative.

Naturally, those who do not prize liberty will seek to expand and magnify the worst aspects of SS by making those who draw the least relative to what they pay in...pay even more - while those who pay the least and draw the most have their ranks expanded.

Expanded Social Security would expand the liberty of millions in retirement. They'd have more freedom to enjoy their golden years, rather than sitting under the yoke of exceedingly tight financial circumtances.
It's still just recycled collectivism, statism, and typical "progressive" unequal protection.

To be clear, the plan I call for provides exactly equal protection. Every person would pay into Social Security and draw out of Social Security based on formulas that are blind to race, ethnicity, religion, political affiliation, gender, etc. In fact, I'm calling for a MORE equal system, in that unearned wealth wouldn't be privileged with a Social Security exclusion. If you earn a given amount by actually performing productive labor, and I get the same amount through inheritance or a gambling windfall or capital gains, we both pay into the system the same amount, rather than the unequal protection of balancing the Social Security system on the back of the laboring class.
 
Here's an interesting article about the idea of expanding Social Security, and how that has recently become a matter that significant political figures talk about, whereas it was previously treated as radical and unrealistic:

http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/

The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;

http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron

That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.

For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.

The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.

In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.

Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.



i think the problematic piece is the definition of 'equally'.

The middle class person pays his share on $100k earnings
the Trust fund 'brat' paid his share...but then does not pay on his investment portfolio.

Ok, I can understand this.

If we're talking equally....then what if the trust fund 'brat' paid ten or twenty fold thatof the middle class earner in the years preceding his 'brattiness'...based on his then expended 'sweat of brow'.

I just dont understand the negative cast... (whereas, I do not argue against the need to tax the brat and worker alike...)
 
It may be different from the sales pitch made to our great-grandparents, but so what? This country was once sold to a pack of slave owners on the basis of preserving their rights to beat and rape their slaves however they saw fit. Times change, and I'm arguing they should change with Social Security. If you have an argument against that change, make it. Merely pointing out that it is a change is only an argument if a person is such a reactionary that change, itself, is a self-evident negative.

Well, if you think a promise made by government to the citizenry is a matter of "so what" then I'm not certain where to begin.


To be clear, the plan I call for provides exactly equal protection. Every person would pay into Social Security and draw out of Social Security based on formulas that are blind to race, ethnicity, religion, political affiliation, gender, etc. In fact, I'm calling for a MORE equal system, in that unearned wealth wouldn't be privileged with a Social Security exclusion. If you earn a given amount by actually performing productive labor, and I get the same amount through inheritance or a gambling windfall or capital gains, we both pay into the system the same amount, rather than the unequal protection of balancing the Social Security system on the back of the laboring class.

The blindness doesn't extend to age. You are requiring, via this "blind" system, that one age group pay the bills of the other, thus ensuring unequal treatment of the citizens affected by the plan.
 
In doing this, and in calling for removal of the high-income cap on Social Security taxes, you effectively undermine the promise made by FDR that Social Security is retirement insurance, rather than a scheme to tax the wealthy so that the poor can retire. There were, in the 1930s, strong opponents of the latter method. They still exist.

What I'm calling for is identical to what we already did for Medicare, by removing that tax cap, making the system more progressive. That changes the rules, of course, but so does any change of law.

When Bush pushed through his big tax cuts, with the largest cut being to the top bracket, you could have said he effectively undermined the promise Clinton made of a more progressive tax system back in 1993. I don't think there's any value in analyzing proposed policies that way -- better is just to argue each one on its individual merits, rather than trying to figure out if it is consistent with some previous intent. We're talking about legislation here, not judicial interpretation.

Com to think of it, with Medicare we did more than just remove the tax cap -- Medicare tax rates are actually higher for those earning over $200,000 ($250,000 for maried filing jointly). Perhaps that's an even better solution than what I proposed -- don't just remove the cap, actually increase the SS withholding rates on income past that point.

Anyway, Social Securiy has always been redistributive. The poor and lower-middle class always got a higher average return on their "investment" than the rich and the upper-middle class. For the vast majority of people, that redistributive aspect isn't even debated. But theres been this special exception, just for the very rich, which cuts off how redistributive it is at their level. Where's the sense in that?

Think of it this way. The average return on a dollar of SS contributions is higher for someonewho earns $25,000 per year than for someone who earns $50,000 per year. And it's higher for someone who earns $50,000 per year than for someone who earns $75,000 per year. And higher for someone who earns $75,000 per year than fo someone who earns $100,000 per year. And so on. Yet, for no discernible reason the return on a dollar of SS contributions for someone who earn $125,000 per year is identical to the return for someone who earns $150,000 per year. Even someone who earns $10 million per year isn't subsidizing the system one penny more than someone who earns $125,000.

If it's OK to have the upper-middle and lower-upper class contribute escalating subsidies for the retirements of the less fortunate, why is it not OK to extend the same principle on upwards? Why have this system, reminiscient of feudal lordshp privileges, that claims growing subsidization of poorer people's retirements is illegitimate once it makes a meaningful impact for the super rich? A professional earning in the low six figures has his take-home pay materially lowered by the taxes that are effectively used to enhance the retirements of the working class, but a multi-millionaire's take-home pay does not have a similarly material reduction.

I can imagine an intellectually consistent plan to remove the wealth redistributive aspect of Social Security entirely. But I can't see a justification for keeping the redistributive aspect, but effectively phasing out its impact so that it makes no material difference to the ultra rich. Other than the fact they're the ones who fund the polical campaigns, and therby buy the politicians, why should they get that special deal? Why should workaday professionals have their lifestyles meaningfully changed by subsidizing the less fortunate retirees, while their bosses' bosses' bosses' don't have tht kind of meaningful diminution?
 
Incrementalism. ACA is just like this as well. Single payer and direct state operation of health care is next.
I doubt direct state operation of health care is next. That's not where most other wealthy nations have gone, and it's not a natural transition from Obamacare. More likely would be increasing government involvement in capping allowable rates of return for the private insurers, and engaging in some price fixing, akin to what they have in countries like Switzerland or Germany. The way we handle utilities is somewhat similar. It's not a traditional free market, but neither did it lead down a slippery slope to total government control of power supply.
 
Personally, I prefer it when we all advocate what we want in broad daylight. No misdirection. No subterfuge. No silly euphemisms. Just good faith competition in the marketplace of ideas.
I don't begrudge the fact that so many on the left put a premium on security such that it trumps liberty as our primary value. I think they are dead wrong, that this represents a stark departure from our national character, and that what they seek will deliver us an undesirable social order - but they should advocate for what they want just as conservatives should.
I really dislike the navigation as it plays out. Cloak and dagger stuff, re-branding and re-badging what are old ideas and calling them "new", "social ev0lution", and forward-thinking progressivism. None of this stuff is new.
Most of all, I'm sick to death of lefties who seek to characterize conservatives as constantly "scared" or paranoid, fearing terrorists under their beds, "bedwetters", gun-clingers, black helicopter-spotters. Who is it that panics regarding his fellow man's capacity to self-provide...who clamors for state needs-meeting. Geezers eating Alpo, children in the streets, horror!

Sorry, I know fear and bad faith when I see it.

We need to call these conniving sloths out.
:)
I know it's easier on the brain to attack straw men, but it's unproductive. When there are new ideas, you need to deal with them on their own merits, not pretend they're something you'd find easier to debate.

As for your idea that fear is driving the liberals, you're mistaking compassion for fear. I don't want expanded Social Security because I think I'm likely to rely on it. I'm one of those people who gets to stop paying into Social Security half-way through the year, and the change I propose would most likely be worse for me. It would, however, be good for my countrymen generally, and that's why I support it. That isn't panic, it's patriotism. Its empathy.
 
Back
Top