Arkady
President
Here's an interesting article about the idea of expanding Social Security, and how that has recently become a matter that significant political figures talk about, whereas it was previously treated as radical and unrealistic:
http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/
The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;
http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron
That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.
For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.
The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.
In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.
Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.
http://www.salon.com/2013/12/15/tak...beats_back_conservative_social_security_plot/
The entire article is worth reading. however, there were a couple things I wanted to call out for attention. First, the column points to a paper that, though old, contains some excellent analysis of Social Security that remains relevant today;
http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/1997/06/summer-saving-aaron
That includes the argument that justifying Social Security cuts by the fact the worker/retiree ratio is set to drop doesn't make sense, when you realize the worker/population ratio will actually remain quite high. In essence, although the workers of tomorrow will support more retirees than the workers of the past, they'll actually be supporting so many fewer non-working spouses and children that the dependency burden will be down somewhat, an observation that causes the "crisis" to evaporate, when viewed from a society-wide perspective.
For example, in 1960, there were 65,778,000 jobs for a population of 179,323,175. Thus, each worker supported about 2.73 non-workers. Today, there are 144,386,000 jobs, for a population of 313,900,000. Thus, every worker is supporting only 2.17 non-workers. That's a huge difference. Even if you assumed every new SS beneficiary didn't work, we'll still only be looking at each worker supporting a little over 2.6 non-workers, at the height of the "crisis," which is still a damned sight better than what we had in the 1960s. It's just that those being supported by the workers will be old people, instead of kids and housewives.
The second item I wanted to call attention to is the idea of expanding the tax base in order to shore up enhanced Social Security benefits. Currently Social Security, unlike Medicare, allows rich people to stop paying into the system part way through the year. We experience this as a windfall -- I get used to living on lower paychecks until sometime in June, for instance, and then suddenly get bigger paychecks for the balance of the year, because I'm not required to contribute to the system all year the way middle class people have to. Take away that tax cap, and you've secured Social Security, at present benefits levels, as far into the future as anyone can make meaningful projections.
In order to pay for higher benefits levels, all that would be needed is to expand the tax base, so that we aren't just taxing money people earn through real labor. For example, presently, if I earn $100,000 by the sweat of my brow, I am required to pay a share of that into Social Security, but if I get the exact same $100,000 by cashing checks from an investment portfolio, I don't have to pay in a dime. If we simply make everyone pay into Social Security equally --both the laborer and the trust fund brat-- the added revenues could fund better retirements... enough, even to make up for the catastrophic failure of 401ks as a retirement vehicle, in this post-pension era. Basically, Wall Street screwed over future retirees, but by taxing Wall Street equally, we could set them right again.
Finally, I wanted to call attention to the column's labeling of the Washington Post as increasingly right-wing. I agree. They've long been right-wing on foreign policy and military issues. They're Neocon central, and mostly editorialize in favor of whatever Likud wants the US to be doing. But, more recently, they're even quite conservative on economic issues. They remain center to center-left on social issues, and generally come out in favor of Democratic candidates, but overall they sit about where Joseph Lieberman does on the political spectrum. As the column points out, their idea of a left-leaning opinion piece on Social Security is something penned by a Romney-aligned Wall Streeter, who calls for benefits cuts.