New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Finally, It's about time.

So, did Obama offer only ONCE or did he spend 4 yrs since Bush's agreement trying to come up with a better one? The Dems were pushing Bush to sign an agreement...they were warned that they needed to come up with something better and not just take everyone out at once. Obama didn't even try. I used to think he did what he could, and because he couldn't get immunity for our soldiers then he had no choice. But since I've thought about it much more...I realize Obama didn't do sh*t. He had FOUR YEARS to change this deal. He offered ONE solution? What a failure....

His solution was to make sure no new agreement was in place, therefore when the SOFA expired they would be forced to withdraw, thus giving them the out they wanted and a "Ended the war in Iraq" campaign slogan for 2012.

The ugly truth is President Obama "ended" the war in Iraq about as responsibly as it was begun. So responsibly in fact we are now dropping bombs on Iraq and Syria.
 
So, did Obama offer only ONCE or did he spend 4 yrs since Bush's agreement trying to come up with a better one? The Dems were pushing Bush to sign an agreement...they were warned that they needed to come up with something better and not just take everyone out at once. Obama didn't even try. I used to think he did what he could, and because he couldn't get immunity for our soldiers then he had no choice. But since I've thought about it much more...I realize Obama didn't do sh*t. He had FOUR YEARS to change this deal. He offered ONE solution? What a failure....

You post shows you don't really have a clue. The Bush Sofa was signed in December of 2008. That specified the complete withdrawal at the end of 2011. (which would be 3 years, not four...but let's not quibble). The Bush sofa had some nebulous spec about what would happen if an American were accused of a crime, that there would be some kind of panel convened to determine jurisdiction...which could have resulted in one of our guys hoping for a fair trial in an Iraqi court....(not freaking likely)...luckily there were no instances where that happened...or at least any possibility was kept pretty hushed up.

The Bush sofa was ratified by the Iraqi parliament by a vote of 149 out of 275 members...so 126 either were opposed or didn't vote.

Negotiations for a new SOFA began in the fall of 2010. The sticking points were that US soldiers would be subject to Iraqi courts if accused of a crime and that Obama required that the Iraqi parliament vote on the agreement....The Iraqis would not agree to what they saw as an infringement on their sovereignty....and Maliki, thinking he didn't need US troops..turned it down.

So would you have preferred your son be subject to Iraqi law or US military law?
 
You post shows you don't really have a clue. The Bush Sofa was signed in December of 2008. That specified the complete withdrawal at the end of 2011. (which would be 3 years, not four...but let's not quibble). The Bush sofa had some nebulous spec about what would happen if an American were accused of a crime, that there would be some kind of panel convened to determine jurisdiction...which could have resulted in one of our guys hoping for a fair trial in an Iraqi court....(not freaking likely)...luckily there were no instances where that happened...or at least any possibility was kept pretty hushed up.

The Bush sofa was ratified by the Iraqi parliament by a vote of 149 out of 275 members...so 126 either were opposed or didn't vote.

Negotiations for a new SOFA began in the fall of 2010. The sticking points were that US soldiers would be subject to Iraqi courts if accused of a crime and that Obama required that the Iraqi parliament vote on the agreement....The Iraqis would not agree to what they saw as an infringement on their sovereignty....and Maliki, thinking he didn't need US troops..turned it down.

So would you have preferred your son be subject to Iraqi law or US military law?
Of course these loud idiots would never agree to having US Military subjected to Iraqi law...They are fvckin clueless idiots
 
His solution was to make sure no new agreement was in place, therefore when the SOFA expired they would be forced to withdraw, thus giving them the out they wanted and a "Ended the war in Iraq" campaign slogan for 2012.

The ugly truth is President Obama "ended" the war in Iraq about as responsibly as it was begun. So responsibly in fact we are now dropping bombs on Iraq and Syria.

The ugly truth is that the Bush Sofa sucked and Maliki would not agree to a new one....Obama would not and should not have agreed to allow US troops to stand trial in Iraqi courts.....it is idiotic to think they'd get a fair trial.

Maliki destroyed the morale and capacity of his own armed forces by selling flag rank positions to corrupt wannabees....those generals and colonels who had bought their jobs from Maliki ran at the first sign of danger....leaving their troops to fight on their own. Not sure how in hell you blame Obama for that, but you'll find a way....

US troops in country in 2014 would have made little difference unless they did the fighting...
 
I am sorry I can barely hear you over your incessant whining.

Iran could receive somewhere between $30 billion and $50 billion upon signing the agreement, said congressional officials briefed by the administration.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-suggests-compromise-on-iran-sanctions-1429308388

They did scuttle the talks [Unwelcome language removed].

You are so uninformed that it is painful to read....

The money that might find it's way to Iran is related to assets that were seized as part of the sanctions. They'd get their money back...

There were two parties to the negotiations over a new SOFA. Maliki refused to accept the requirements that Obama had....so tell me, would you have put US military personnel under the jurisdiction of Iraqi courts? That is the only way Maliki would accept.
 
You post shows you don't really have a clue. The Bush Sofa was signed in December of 2008. That specified the complete withdrawal at the end of 2011. (which would be 3 years, not four...but let's not quibble). The Bush sofa had some nebulous spec about what would happen if an American were accused of a crime, that there would be some kind of panel convened to determine jurisdiction...which could have resulted in one of our guys hoping for a fair trial in an Iraqi court....(not freaking likely)...luckily there were no instances where that happened...or at least any possibility was kept pretty hushed up.

The Bush sofa was ratified by the Iraqi parliament by a vote of 149 out of 275 members...so 126 either were opposed or didn't vote.

Negotiations for a new SOFA began in the fall of 2010. The sticking points were that US soldiers would be subject to Iraqi courts if accused of a crime and that Obama required that the Iraqi parliament vote on the agreement....The Iraqis would not agree to what they saw as an infringement on their sovereignty....and Maliki, thinking he didn't need US troops..turned it down.

So would you have preferred your son be subject to Iraqi law or US military law?

I've never said that Obama should have kept our soldiers there anyway....he had to bring them home, he had no choice. I'm just saying I don't believe he did what he should have. I think he's a pretty crappy negotiator if in 3 yrs they couldn't come up with a good deal. The more I hear about this, the more I'm convinced Obama didn't want to keep them there...he'd promised to end the war and bring them all home and that's what he was determined to do. What happened since is on his shoulders.
 
You are so uninformed that it is painful to read....

The money that might find it's way to Iran is related to assets that were seized as part of the sanctions. They'd get their money back...

There were two parties to the negotiations over a new SOFA. Maliki refused to accept the requirements that Obama had....so tell me, would you have put US military personnel under the jurisdiction of Iraqi courts? That is the only way Maliki would accept.

You are so brainwashed its [Unwelcome language removed] pathetic.

50billion dollars is 50 billion dollars regardless of whether its in assets they currently can't access or not. All for signing a deal they have absolutely no intention of honoring.
 
I've never said that Obama should have kept our soldiers there anyway....he had to bring them home, he had no choice. I'm just saying I don't believe he did what he should have. I think he's a pretty crappy negotiator if in 3 yrs they couldn't come up with a good deal. The more I hear about this, the more I'm convinced Obama didn't want to keep them there...he'd promised to end the war and bring them all home and that's what he was determined to do. What happened since is on his shoulders.

What happened since would have been no different if US troops had been in the country unless we did the fighting.

Obama did come up with a good deal....Maliki would not accept the requirement that US troops, accused of a crime, stand trial in a military court instead of an Iraqi one.....

Maliki killed the negotiation primarily because things were pretty stable in 2010 and he didn't think he needed US troops....

As far as ISIS goes, they succeeded because the Iraqi army ran away. They ran because their senior officers got on the first helicopter out of town when ISIL got close. You tell me, what did Obama have to do with the collapse of the Iraqi army..which we had paid billions to equip and train?
 
I've never said that Obama should have kept our soldiers there anyway....he had to bring them home, he had no choice. I'm just saying I don't believe he did what he should have. I think he's a pretty crappy negotiator if in 3 yrs they couldn't come up with a good deal. The more I hear about this, the more I'm convinced Obama didn't want to keep them there...he'd promised to end the war and bring them all home and that's what he was determined to do. What happened since is on his shoulders.
Maybe he should have invaded Iraq because they had WMD's ...No wait that idiot (your hero W Bush) did that...Fvck the occupation of Iraq...Time for it to end...Thank You President Obama for ending that fiasco
 
You are so brainwashed its [Unwelcome language removed] pathetic.

50billion dollars is 50 billion dollars regardless of whether its in assets they currently can't access or not. All for signing a deal they have absolutely no intention of honoring.

So essentially either you were uninformed or dishonest when you said:
we have an Administration who is willing to essentially give the Iranians 50 billion dollars
 
You are so uninformed that it is painful to read....

The money that might find it's way to Iran is related to assets that were seized as part of the sanctions. They'd get their money back...

There were two parties to the negotiations over a new SOFA. Maliki refused to accept the requirements that Obama had....so tell me, would you have put US military personnel under the jurisdiction of Iraqi courts? That is the only way Maliki would accept.

So then WHY is the 50 Billion being called a SIGNING BONUS? You're wrong....it is NOT money that was already theirs, it is over and above the assets that were frozen! Your president is negotiating with terrorists and your good with that! Wow!

The State Department on Monday would not rule out giving Iran up to $50 billion as a so-called “signing bonus” for agreeing to a nuclear deal later this year, according to comments made to journalists following reports that the Obama administration had formulated a plan to release tens of billions of frozen Iranian funds.
http://freebeacon.com/national-secu...t-rule-out-50-billion-signing-bonus-for-iran/

Experts have said this multi-billion dollar "signing bonus" option, which was first reported by the Wall Street Journal, could be the largest cash infusion to a terror-backing regime in recent memory.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...ent-wont-rule-out-50b-signing-bonus-for-iran/

Reports have indicated that the US would authorize a release of $30-$50 billion in cash to Iran with the signing of a final deal ahead of a June 30 deadline, which comes in addition to over $11 billion in assets that were unfrozen in the interim agreement signed November 2013.
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/194376#!
 
So then WHY is the 50 Billion being called a SIGNING BONUS? You're wrong....it is NOT money that was already theirs, it is over and above the assets that were frozen! Your president is negotiating with terrorists and your good with that! Wow!

The State Department on Monday would not rule out giving Iran up to $50 billion as a so-called “signing bonus” for agreeing to a nuclear deal later this year, according to comments made to journalists following reports that the Obama administration had formulated a plan to release tens of billions of frozen Iranian funds.
http://freebeacon.com/national-secu...t-rule-out-50-billion-signing-bonus-for-iran/

Experts have said this multi-billion dollar "signing bonus" option, which was first reported by the Wall Street Journal, could be the largest cash infusion to a terror-backing regime in recent memory.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...ent-wont-rule-out-50b-signing-bonus-for-iran/

Reports have indicated that the US would authorize a release of $30-$50 billion in cash to Iran with the signing of a final deal ahead of a June 30 deadline, which comes in addition to over $11 billion in assets that were unfrozen in the interim agreement signed November 2013.
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/194376#!

So "freebeacon" says according to "comments" made...by whom? Did you notice who wrote this article?
Adam Kredo is senior writer for the Washington Free Beacon. Formerly an award-winning political reporter for the Washington Jewish Week, Kredo’s work has been featured in outlets such as the Jerusalem Post, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Fox news says "according to the WSJ"....The fox news article was written by Ari Yashar...a writer for Arutz Sheva - Israel National News....

And IsraelNationalNews says the US would authorize the "RELEASE" of $30 to $50 billion in addition to $11 billion already released....

and you think you've made the case for Sicko's previous comments? You have represented Israel's views very well....
 
Last edited:
So essentially either you were uninformed or dishonest when you said:
we have an Administration who is willing to essentially give the Iranians 50 billion dollars

How is that dishonest? IF THEY SIGN THE DEAL [Unwelcome language removed] ARE THEY NOT GOING TO BE GETTING 50 BILLION DOLLARS???
 
So "freebeacon" says according to "comments" made...by whom? Did you notice who wrote this article?
Adam Kredo is senior writer for the Washington Free Beacon. Formerly an award-winning political reporter for the Washington Jewish Week, Kredo’s work has been featured in outlets such as the Jerusalem Post, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Fox news says "according to the WSJ"....The fox news article was written by Ari Yashar...a writer for Arutz Sheva - Israel National News....

And IsraelNationalNews says the US would authorize the "RELEASE" of $30 to $50 billion in addition to $11 billion already released....

and you think you've made the case for Sicko's previous comments? You have represented Israel's views very well....

Soooo any Jews reporting on this or any Jews commenting on this should be disregarded then?....gotcha....o_O
 
Soooo any Jews reporting on this or any Jews commenting on this should be disregarded then?....gotcha....o_O

Why no...not at all. I think all of our news should come directly from Israeli government sources when it has to do with Iran....that way we are guaranteed to go to war.
 
Back
Top