Arkady
President
A lot of posters here spent the Obama years claiming to be fiscal conservatives -- fretting about deficits and debt. Well, if you were one of them, here's your chance to speak up. Trump is promising the "biggest tax cut ever". Unless he's lying, that means the cut he proposed is going to have a bigger impact than what we saw in the Reagan and GW Bush years.
There will be the usual zombie economics claims that the cuts will pay for themselves through enhanced growth. So, let's check the history of what actually happened in those prior two eras, to see if that's right.
Jimmy Carter's last budget was for FY 1981. At the time, gross federal debt was 31.7% of GDP -- a figure that had been falling pretty steadily for decades, from a high of 118.9% back in 1946. That long run of improvement ended immediately after Reagan's tax cuts went in effect. By his last year in office, debt was 51.5% of GDP, which was the highest since the early 1960s. And it was continuing to rise. By FY 1993, GHW Bush's last budget year, it was up to 64.0%.
For a while, following Clinton's tax hike, we trended the other way. In Clinton's last budget year, debt was down nearly ten points, to 54.6% of GDP. But then we got the Bush tax cut, and again debt soared, to 82.4% of GDP in his last budget year, and still higher after that (with most of the Bush tax cuts becoming permanent.)
Tax policy isn't the full picture, of course. There were also factors like the orgy of increased military spending we had under Reagan and Bush (and that Trump is pushing to emulate). But receipts were a big part of it. On Reagan's watch, spending rose 2.3% annualized, in real terms, which is fairly modest, despite the big military spending. The problem is that revenue growth was absolutely pathetic in historical terms. Annualized revenue growth had been almost 50% higher in the 20 years before the Reagan presidency than on his watch. The Reagan tax cuts absolutely did not pay for themselves. They resulted in revenue trailing far below historical norms, such that even fairly modest spending growth was enough to blow the budget all to hell.
The same is true of the Bush years. Spending growth, despite the big military hikes, was below historical norms, and yet the deficit exploded, because revenues grew far below historical norms. The promise had been that his upper-class taxes would pay for themselves, by way of economic growth, but economic growth wound up being pathetic, and we went from having the biggest surplus in American history to having the biggest deficit in just three years.
So, don't fall for the hype. Big tax cuts mean big debt, even if you wind up keeping spending growth well below normal. If there were ever any real fiscal conservatives on the right, this is their chance to write their Congress members and stop this abomination before it gets going.
As for the details of the tax cut package, it's built very specifically as a gift to the wealthy. It includes things that won't matter at all to 99.9% of us, like a repeal of estate taxation (the exemption was already $5.45 million, meaning only about 0.1% of all estates pay any taxes). And it includes other stuff that helps out wealthy professionals but won't matter at all to the great majority of people (e.g., getting rid of AMT, which will impact less than 5% of people). There's also the further reduction of brackets, to make the code flatter -- saving the very rich millions, while shifting the burden to the working class. Trump also wants to slash the corporate rate by more than half, meaning the burden will be shifted from the investor class that owns those companies, to the middle and lower class.
There will be the usual zombie economics claims that the cuts will pay for themselves through enhanced growth. So, let's check the history of what actually happened in those prior two eras, to see if that's right.
Jimmy Carter's last budget was for FY 1981. At the time, gross federal debt was 31.7% of GDP -- a figure that had been falling pretty steadily for decades, from a high of 118.9% back in 1946. That long run of improvement ended immediately after Reagan's tax cuts went in effect. By his last year in office, debt was 51.5% of GDP, which was the highest since the early 1960s. And it was continuing to rise. By FY 1993, GHW Bush's last budget year, it was up to 64.0%.
For a while, following Clinton's tax hike, we trended the other way. In Clinton's last budget year, debt was down nearly ten points, to 54.6% of GDP. But then we got the Bush tax cut, and again debt soared, to 82.4% of GDP in his last budget year, and still higher after that (with most of the Bush tax cuts becoming permanent.)
Tax policy isn't the full picture, of course. There were also factors like the orgy of increased military spending we had under Reagan and Bush (and that Trump is pushing to emulate). But receipts were a big part of it. On Reagan's watch, spending rose 2.3% annualized, in real terms, which is fairly modest, despite the big military spending. The problem is that revenue growth was absolutely pathetic in historical terms. Annualized revenue growth had been almost 50% higher in the 20 years before the Reagan presidency than on his watch. The Reagan tax cuts absolutely did not pay for themselves. They resulted in revenue trailing far below historical norms, such that even fairly modest spending growth was enough to blow the budget all to hell.
The same is true of the Bush years. Spending growth, despite the big military hikes, was below historical norms, and yet the deficit exploded, because revenues grew far below historical norms. The promise had been that his upper-class taxes would pay for themselves, by way of economic growth, but economic growth wound up being pathetic, and we went from having the biggest surplus in American history to having the biggest deficit in just three years.
So, don't fall for the hype. Big tax cuts mean big debt, even if you wind up keeping spending growth well below normal. If there were ever any real fiscal conservatives on the right, this is their chance to write their Congress members and stop this abomination before it gets going.
As for the details of the tax cut package, it's built very specifically as a gift to the wealthy. It includes things that won't matter at all to 99.9% of us, like a repeal of estate taxation (the exemption was already $5.45 million, meaning only about 0.1% of all estates pay any taxes). And it includes other stuff that helps out wealthy professionals but won't matter at all to the great majority of people (e.g., getting rid of AMT, which will impact less than 5% of people). There's also the further reduction of brackets, to make the code flatter -- saving the very rich millions, while shifting the burden to the working class. Trump also wants to slash the corporate rate by more than half, meaning the burden will be shifted from the investor class that owns those companies, to the middle and lower class.

