New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Five Useless Habits

I think this is just semantics. When people stand up for their rights, they are accused of being "victims" . They don't use the word. As I fought for women's rights, I heard that line over and over" women see themselves as victims"..WE WEre! That label always comes from the oppressor, not the oppressed. Can you give me an example of how blacks and women use their causes as a crutch?

Semantics...? Well, I certainly agree that accusing the victims of prejudice and discrimination of “playing the victim card” is a rhetorical tool that's been used a lot in this country over the last 30-40 years. It's a defense mechanism, a way of shifting blame onto those who are being discriminated against. It's a way of saying “Hey, if you can't make it, that's your problem, not mine.”

It's really a manifestation of how our minds tend to work. If we treat others badly, we tell ourselves – and we look for reasons to believe – that it's because they deserve to be treated badly and not because we're being unjust. That's just human nature.

So no, I don't believe that blacks, or women, or any other victims of discrimination use their causes as a crutch – as a group. On the other hand, I do know individuals who use their status as victims as a personal crutch. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying these people aren't victims of unjust discrimination. They are, and their complaints are valid. But too often they use those complaints to justify failing to take positive actions to accomplish what they say are their goals. In fact or in effect they say, “Why bother? I won't be allowed to succeed anyway.” On one level that kind of response is understandable. But it's also a recipe for personal failure and disappointment, no?

Again, I'm not saying that attitude is prevalent among any particular group. But it exists. As far as I'm concerned, recognizing that it exists ought to be the starting point for a conversation about how best to combat it. That's where I part company with those who want to use its existence in others as a reason to avoid looking in the mirror.

Cheers.
 
Semantics...? Well, I certainly agree that accusing the victims of prejudice and discrimination of “playing the victim card” is a rhetorical tool that's been used a lot in this country over the last 30-40 years. It's a defense mechanism, a way of shifting blame onto those who are being discriminated against. It's a way of saying “Hey, if you can't make it, that's your problem, not mine.”

It's really a manifestation of how our minds tend to work. If we treat others badly, we tell ourselves – and we look for reasons to believe – that it's because they deserve to be treated badly and not because we're being unjust. That's just human nature.

So no, I don't believe that blacks, or women, or any other victims of discrimination use their causes as a crutch – as a group. On the other hand, I do know individuals who use their status as victims as a personal crutch. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying these people aren't victims of unjust discrimination. They are, and their complaints are valid. But too often they use those complaints to justify failing to take positive actions to accomplish what they say are their goals. In fact or in effect they say, “Why bother? I won't be allowed to succeed anyway.” On one level that kind of response is understandable. But it's also a recipe for personal failure and disappointment, no?

Again, I'm not saying that attitude is prevalent among any particular group. But it exists. As far as I'm concerned, recognizing that it exists ought to be the starting point for a conversation about how best to combat it. That's where I part company with those who want to use its existence in others as a reason to avoid looking in the mirror.

Cheers.

Thank you for your response. Can you please give me an example of a group that says , why bother I won't be allowed to succeed anyway? . There is something to what you say and I saw it in my husband and his life. He came from poverty and never dreamed of college...he had no hope of ever going. HOPE is very powerful. But he also knew being a white male gave him a lef up. When I was a girl I never dreamed of going to Harvard or sitting on the Supreme Court etc. does that mean I was a recipe for failure and disappointment? Sometimes we have to wear different glasses to see thru the eyes of others. When one is poor and black , they see themselves in the world differently....because the reality is they are seen differently. No one wants to be poor....but sometimes they lose hope as their reality is different from yours and mine, . I give workshops in prejudice and I always have a picture of eyeglasses because we will see the world through different eyes whether it be your gender your age , your looks etc.
 
Thank you for your response.

You're welcome, of course.

Renee said:
Can you please give me an example of a group that says , why bother I won't be allowed to succeed anyway?

No, I can't. Please recall that I just said that I don't believe that such a group exists.

Renee said:
There is something to what you say [...].

I'm glad to hear you say so, particularly as I think we're both saying basically the same things.

Renee said:
When I was a girl I never dreamed of going to Harvard or sitting on the Supreme Court etc. does that mean I was a recipe for failure and disappointment?

Certainly not! I'm not sure how you made that leap from what I've said in this thread.

Renee said:
Sometimes we have to wear different glasses to see thru the eyes of others.

Indeed.

Renee said:
When one is poor and black , they see themselves in the world differently....because the reality is they are seen differently. No one wants to be poor....but sometimes they lose hope as their reality is different from yours and mine.

Yes, of course. That's part of what I meant in my previous post when I spoke about the need to take positive action to combat negative, self-defeating attitudes. To be clear (I hope), I believe we have a general responsibility as a society to try to instill hope and provide opportunity -- and we could and should be doing a much better job of that. I'm not bashing any group for not being "bootstrappy" enough.

I think you're looking for a fight where there isn't one.

Cheers.
 
You're welcome, of course.



No, I can't. Please recall that I just said that I don't believe that such a group exists.



I'm glad to hear you say so, particularly as I think we're both saying basically the same things.



Certainly not! I'm not sure how you made that leap from what I've said in this thread.



Indeed.



Yes, of course. That's part of what I meant in my previous post when I spoke about the need to take positive action to combat negative, self-defeating attitudes. To be clear (I hope), I believe we have a general responsibility as a society to try to instill hope and provide opportunity -- and we could and should be doing a much better job of that. I'm not bashing any group for not being "bootstrappy" enough.

I think you're looking for a fight where there isn't one.

Cheers.


Why am I looking for a fight? I think we are pretty much on the same page and I just want to get an interesting discussion going . Sorry if you think I put you on the defensive.
 
Someone named John Hawkins penned an interesting column He titled " The 5 Attitudes That Will Cause You To Fail At Life In America". It has enough truth in it to make some people uncomfortable and angry I imagine. His five attitudes are these:


1) Expect a politician to fix your problems

2) Demand that the world change to suit you

3) Rely on the government to take care of you

4) Focus on pulling everyone else down instead of raising yourself up

5) Think of yourself as a victim

Looking at number one, I've always been amazed that their are people who actually believe that certain politicians really give a monkey's butt about them. Is anyone really that dumb?

Number five is the one, however, that really struck a cord with me. Some folks are so invested in "victimhood" they can't see past themselves. If you think yourself a victim, you'll surely be one, and will likely stay that way. The world owes them an apology, or so they presume, and they remain perpetually offended. Poor darlings.

For those of you who can't wait to tear this apart, here's the link:

http://townhall.com/columnists/john...ou-to-fail-at-life-in-america-n1655400/page/2

The TownHell columnist does a fine job with his catch-all supposed Dem attitudes.

He'd have given Mitt a standing ovation had he been there for his 47% comments.
 
Barble has a five year old anecdote from one woman she figures qualifies as a model for her perpetual obsession....a welfare queen.

That proves that all liberals and black people want Obama to pay their mortgage for them.

That's pure Limbaugh. Find the most outrageous thing anyone in the country has said on any given day and say "this is what they all belieeeeeeeeeeve!" Can't find anyone else in the world who thinks that? No problem. Just post the same video for five years.

This was a Rush inspired babblefest from the TP to the last winger rant.

Am I the only one who's noticed how they have been devolving lately? It's the result of none of their crap sticking to the wall for five solid years. It's really getting stupid. Jack Dallas is starting to look like the introspective moderate on the board.

I saw that clip and what I heard was a woman watching the economy implode, McCain saying that there isn't a problem and she was scared....scared for her job, her ability to keep her home, her ability to pay the bills....Gas in June 2008 was $4.50 here. She says "Obama gets elected and I won't have to worry" and these bozos say that means she thought Obama was going to pay her bills.
 
Gimme a point or two for at least clicking on the topshit. Alas....It only took me like three words into the guy's "work" to see that it was something shat into the red-hate-0-sphere.

Ya know what REALLY frosts my balls most about this silliness? It's that for a price, I could pen WAY better Obama-hate "product", than what's being foisted off on these poor saps.

Tell me about it. There are plenty of problems with this president. Yet the right seems to be stuck in lunatic mode. So much so that they make crazy the agenda being debated instead of legitimate problems.
 
You know, Zam, this could apply to a lot of people on both sides of the aisle. I see where they all can apply to those on the right just as easily as the 'author' wanted them to apply to those on the left.



I would agree that there are people on both sides of the political aisle who feel sorry for themselves and embrace victimhood.
 
Yeah....listing the top five wingnut memes that appear on PJ on a daily basis was a really eye opening and thoughtful "analysis". I'm sure the guy is a reputable psychologist and career counselor....right?

Hilarious that you feign believing that this guy just thought these up recently. There is no more standard fare on the hate radio menu. Just add, "This is what all liberals belieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeve!!!!!"

Hahahahahahaha!


Indeed, starting with the first and third, which reminds me of Raygun's "I'm from the gov, and I'm here to help" BS.

How about the uselessness of rewording rightwingnut idiocy and claiming originality?
 
I would agree that there are people on both sides of the political aisle who feel sorry for themselves and embrace victimhood.

That's not all there is, Zam. There are also those who seem to think the government should push their agenda around the world, and interfere in other countries affairs. More so on the right.
 
That's not all there is, Zam. There are also those who seem to think the government should push their agenda around the world, and interfere in other countries affairs. More so on the right.


When people talk about people "embracing victimhood," they are blaming the victim, not the victimizer.
 
Back
Top