Havelock
Mayor
I think this is just semantics. When people stand up for their rights, they are accused of being "victims" . They don't use the word. As I fought for women's rights, I heard that line over and over" women see themselves as victims"..WE WEre! That label always comes from the oppressor, not the oppressed. Can you give me an example of how blacks and women use their causes as a crutch?
Semantics...? Well, I certainly agree that accusing the victims of prejudice and discrimination of “playing the victim card” is a rhetorical tool that's been used a lot in this country over the last 30-40 years. It's a defense mechanism, a way of shifting blame onto those who are being discriminated against. It's a way of saying “Hey, if you can't make it, that's your problem, not mine.”
It's really a manifestation of how our minds tend to work. If we treat others badly, we tell ourselves – and we look for reasons to believe – that it's because they deserve to be treated badly and not because we're being unjust. That's just human nature.
So no, I don't believe that blacks, or women, or any other victims of discrimination use their causes as a crutch – as a group. On the other hand, I do know individuals who use their status as victims as a personal crutch. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying these people aren't victims of unjust discrimination. They are, and their complaints are valid. But too often they use those complaints to justify failing to take positive actions to accomplish what they say are their goals. In fact or in effect they say, “Why bother? I won't be allowed to succeed anyway.” On one level that kind of response is understandable. But it's also a recipe for personal failure and disappointment, no?
Again, I'm not saying that attitude is prevalent among any particular group. But it exists. As far as I'm concerned, recognizing that it exists ought to be the starting point for a conversation about how best to combat it. That's where I part company with those who want to use its existence in others as a reason to avoid looking in the mirror.
Cheers.