New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fixing our schools.

Arkady

President
Word is the Romney campaign is pivoting from focusing on the economy to focusing on education. If true, that's probably a sign that they think the economy angle is unlikely to play particularly well for them between now and the election. At any rate, it would be risky to put all their campaign eggs in that basket and then get a spate of positive employment reports and other good news over the course of the summer. So, having a fall-back focus (beyond coded racial appeals and other personal attacks) is a good idea.

He could do a lot worse than focusing on education. It's a supremely important issue -- long term, there are few things that make as much difference for our socioeconomic well-being than the quality of education our kids are getting. Countries can pop up or down in prosperity based on things like commodity price swings, natural disasters, and other forces largely outside their control. But, over the long term, the best-educated countries tend to be the most prosperous. It's also a good issue for a campaign because it is absolutely an area where the US could stand to improve. In international rankings, we've gone from leading the world in educational excellence to trailing between a few and a few dozen other countries (depending on how you measure us). Our neighbor to the north, for example, outscores us by significant margins in reading, math, and science, on international tests, and has a considerably higher percentage of its population that has completed higher education (about half the population, in fact).

So, what can we do to fix our schools? Romney being a Republican, we can expect him to focus on bashing the teachers' unions. Some criticism in that direction is fair, but I've yet to hear any Republican formulate that criticism into a constructive road-map for change, as opposed to mindless right-wing spleen-venting. Republicans typically act as if publicly shaming the unions is the alpha and omega of school reform. But you aren't going to succeed in shaming a union into changes that are bad for the majority of the union's members. That runs directly contrary to the whole purpose of a union, which is to work for the members.

If you want to improve our schools, you need to get buy-in from the unions, and to do that you need to push for reforms that are an improvement for the majority of union members. For example, if you want to impose more teacher accountability, you need to couple that with higher median pay, so that the majority of teachers wind up with a better deal: they have to put up with more second-guessing, and endure more career risk, but most of them take home significantly more pay to compensate for that. Changes of that sort aren't cheap, which is why Republicans don't propose them. But trying to brow-beat the unions into making changes that hurt the majority of their members has failed for decades, so anyone who is serious about reform needs to move beyond that strategy.

Much of the school-reform debate will focus on high-stakes testing. Unlike most liberals, I'm a fan of using standardized tests as quality control, for students, teachers, and schools. I'm not particularly worried that this will mean "teaching to the test." If the test is well designed, then teaching to it is a good thing -- or at least a much better thing than teaching to the whims of each individual teacher. The devil is, of course, in the details, so it's important that the assessments be done in a way that accounts for what the teachers and schools are working with. That's something that can be done with a well-managed system. For example, a teacher whose kids perform only at the 30th percentile in a subject may, in fact, be an extraordinarily good teacher, if the same pack of kids performed, on average, at the 10th percentile in the same subject the prior year. The system should work to reward teachers for helping out the kids who most need the help.

Having said that, I'm not married to the idea of high-stakes testing. Around the world, there are various systems that have used such testing to fantastic effect, but also systems that have little or no reliance on standardized testing and that, nonetheless, do extremely well (like Finland, which ranked second on the international PISA rankings, far ahead of the US). So, there's reason to think a great system can be had with or without such testing, if you can get high-quality teachers and strong commitment from families and communities to their children's education.

That brings me to one of the most important points. We must approach education reform practically, based on real world results. We don't need to reinvent the wheel. There are plenty of countries that have great education systems, including South Korea, Finland, New Zealand, Japan, Australia, the Netherlands, and, most helpfully, Canada. We should study what they do differently and learn from it. We can also look at systems in the US that do well. For example, Massachusetts routinely tops the NAEP tests, and if it were a country would rank among the best in the world. It also tops the list for higher education. We should be figuring out what successful places like Massachusetts and Canada have in common, and what they're doing differently from places like Mississippi or Mexico.

If we look at those things seriously and honestly, we'll move beyond some of the cliches. For example, I seriously doubt Canada achieved its enviable educational success by bashing its teachers unions. In fact, it looks like those unions may even be tougher than their American counterparts:

http://educhatter.wordpress.com/201...why-are-canadian-teacher-unions-so-resistant/

Similarly, given the heavy unionization in places like Northern Europe, I see no reason to believe unions are a big impediment to superb education. Instead, the most glaring correlation with educational quality is poverty. Poor states and countries don't do well. But it's not just a question of GDP/capita. Most of the countries that outrank the US in educational achievement also have lower GDP/capita than us. They also tend to have much lower income inequality. For example, South Korea is much poorer than the US, in terms of GDP/capita, but has a much lower Gini index of inequality, meaning what wealth it does have is well distributed throughout the society. That seems to help educational performance.

When you take a look at American schools, you realize our best schools do quite well, it's just that our worst schools do so much worse than their international counterparts that it drags our total performance down. When a state like Massachusetts excels, it's less because they have an extraordinary number of really good schools as because they just have a lot fewer really bad schools. And that, in turn, is less about school administration than it is about wider demographic phenomena like localized poverty (slums). If someone like Romney wants to get serious about fixing our schools, he'll need to focus on fixing our wealth inequality issues and repairing our poor communities.

One other factor to consider is culture. If you want kids to want to excel in school, you need a culture that prizes education. You can't turn your nose up at the "intellectual elitists." You can't dismiss science when it becomes politically inconvenient. You can't treat proud ignorance as a kind of folk wisdom. You can't use "Ivy League" as a pejorative. If a society sets education up as a path to social status (showing kids they get "bragging rights" for such achievement), kids will internalize that and work hard at school. If society treats education as somehow effete or inauthentic, kids will internalize that, too, and that culture of anti-intellectualism will undermine efforts to fix our schools.
 
I would really love to discuss the education issue with you, Arkady, but...I'm not going to waste my time, wading through, and arguing against your preconcieved notions about me and those who think as I do.....

To say nothing of the fact, that, based on the tone of your post, I feel I would only be wasting my time....
 
We really do not have a problem with our schools here.They are just fine,turning out quality students. We also turned back the breaking of the Teachers Unions by Kasich and his merry gang.

We have quality Teachers and get this. After years of declne Dayton was named the best city in the Country for living standards and cost of living! I am not surprised as you can see the huge change. We are the crossroads of America. I just crossed I70 and trucks were lined up all they way down the road! Driving,not stopped.
Cincinnati came in 15th!:eek:)
 
I would really love to discuss the education issue with you, Arkady, but...I'm not going to waste my time, wading through, and arguing against your preconcieved notions about me and those who think as I do.....

To say nothing of the fact, that, based on the tone of your post, I feel I would only be wasting my time....

Doc,I think you have preconceived notions of what Arkady is. He is very open minded and willing to discuss. I have argued with him for years and still like him:eek:)
 
I have "Preconcieved notions," eh?

In the FIRST Paragraph:

“So, having a fall-back focus (beyond coded racial appeals and other personal attacks) is a good idea.”

In the SECOND Paragraph:

“Romney being a Republican, we can expect him to focus on bashing the teachers' unions.”

“I've yet to hear any Republican formulate that criticism into a constructive road-map for change, as opposed to mindless right-wing spleen-venting.”


Perhaps you are correct, MaryAnne.

When I have to slough through two paragraphs of that, I tend to have the "preconcieved notion" that those who post such tripe just may have a few "preconcieved notions" of their own.....
 
Romney's solution is simple.....bash unions and offer vouchers so families can flee the public school system and transfer money to the privates. it's the corporate way.
 
the educational system has been in decline for many, many years...the job of a teacher is to teach...if the ones they are paid to teach, fail, the teacher failed his/her job. you dont reward people doing a poor job with a raise..you fire them. every job on the planet has challenges and problems,,and no one thinks they are paid enough. if you dont think your choice of employment will pay what you want,,,do something else...its your choice...
 
Again...neither Private, nor Charter schools seem to face the same issues.

Now, part of this, is because they can actually HIRE better teachers. Even if the pay may be somewhat equal with their Public School counterparts, Private and Charter schools offer better benefits, particularly with the "clientele."

Kids at Private Schools are NOT automatically smarter, or, better than kids in Public Schools.

BUT...they tend to have PARENTS who are much more involved, as well as better procedures in regard to DISCIPLINE (Again...having Parental involvement helps this greatly...)
 
Again...neither Private, nor Charter schools seem to face the same issues.

Now, part of this, is because they can actually HIRE better teachers. Even if the pay may be somewhat equal with their Public School counterparts, Private and Charter schools offer better benefits, particularly with the "clientele."


Kids at Private Schools are NOT automatically smarter, or, better than kids in Public Schools.

BUT...they tend to have PARENTS who are much more involved, as well as better procedures in regard to DISCIPLINE (Again...having Parental involvement helps this greatly...)


Want to bet,Doc? We have had school after school charged with fraud here in Ohio. One guy had 36 charter schools and they all were caught cheating and many closed. So much money was wasted on useless Charter schools because they milked the system.
 
I have "Preconcieved notions," eh?

In the FIRST Paragraph:

“So, having a fall-back focus (beyond coded racial appeals and other personal attacks) is a good idea.”

In the SECOND Paragraph:

“Romney being a Republican, we can expect him to focus on bashing the teachers' unions.”

“I've yet to hear any Republican formulate that criticism into a constructive road-map for change, as opposed to mindless right-wing spleen-venting.”


Perhaps you are correct, MaryAnne.

When I have to slough through two paragraphs of that, I tend to have the "preconcieved notion" that those who post such tripe just may have a few "preconcieved notions" of their own.....

Would you point out where that is false,Doc? Romney is already saying just that. Give us your version.I have already answered you on Charter schools here.
 
So, you think that Public Schools do just as good of a job as Private Schools?

Do the grades, and test scores support that?
 
The issue isn't budget and teacher unions and necessarily bad teachers.....

The problem is our schools do not exist in a bubble, and we expend a tremendous amount of resources educating people beyond their potential as well as educating kids who don't actually care, and parents check out with regards to their children's schooling, and teachers can not do it all themselves.

My issue with teachers unions are that yes, they protect lazy inept teachers. I am not talking simply ineffective teachers... this is hard to quantify and I do have issues with standardized testing as away to test teacher effectiveness. But, I think that many of us have had one or two of these teachers over the years, that just obviously don't give a crap and are showing up to get their years in and call it a day. THOSE are the kinds I would like to see kicked out. I have a friend of a friend who is a teacher, and she is late all the time, she calls out sick all the time and is always in arears with her leave, she is always getting her grades in late. She has been reprimanded many times for personal calls at work. She has even been caught on her ipod during class time. She is worse than the students, and it is so difficult for them to fire her, that basically she just ends up getting shuttled from school to school.

But, like I said, I think that is only a small nugget of the problem. The real problems are that we waste resources and lack of parental oversight and involvement. In schools where the parents put a premium on education and enforce homework, etc at home - the students do well. That is accross the board in this country - and prior to nationalizing educational standards. So, if our students are not doing well, in large part that rests with problems with parents and homelifes. If a child's homelife is in chaos, they are not going to be able to focus and do well in school.

So, we have two issues then the social issues are impacting schooling. so, does throwing more money at schooling - do anything to fix the underlying problems. No. So, should we simply try to throw more money at education? No.

The other issue is how we allocate resources. And, I am not talking special ed issues here. I think that we do have an obligation to provide an appropriate education for special needs kids. I am talking about wasting resources on kids who could care less. Who show up to school intoxicated or on drugs. Who cut class frequently or are discipline problems. Kids who don't come to school, and don't do their work. I think that we drastically underestimate the impact of leaving students like this in a regular public school setting. For one, they are quite simply a bad example to other students. And, students who are on the edge of being bad students themselves do not need to be influenced by kids like this. And, kids there who actually are trying to learn - do not need to be affected by the kids who aren't there to learn.

So, I think that we should have a school or two per district set up to house all those "problem" students. Clean them out of our regular schools. Run those places like prisons. Let our regular schools not have to be run like prisons complete with metal detectors and locker searches. Provide the majority of students with an environment conducive to learning. Not one that is like running a gauntlet of trouble makers every day. It will also be better to allocate all the resources like police forces, etc at one school rather than all the schools.

Additionally, provide opportunities and paths for non-college bound kids. Lets face it, many people simply are not bright enough to hack it in college. And, sending them there, only serves to devalue the college education because standards get lowered, and only proves to frustrate many of them.... so they leave with debt and no real education..... So, provide track for kids who just are not ever going to be college material so they get a quality basic education and are prepared for some level of work.

And, I do think we need to be able to put those decisions back into the hands of the local governments. Perhaps we can have national goals, but each locale is so different. It will be easier for well healed locals to meet those requirements than those in less well off areas. So, allowing the locales to make the decision on how best to meet educational goals, and quite frankly what their residents and students can achieve, would make the most sense in an allocation of resources.

I think that we do have to accept though in all of this. That there will be those who don't value education and who want to live in ignorance. I do not think that it is a valuable use of recourses to convince them otherwise. Use them on the people who wnat to improve and better themselves.
 
Voucher solutions are nearly always proposed in a form that they're essentially just stealth tax cuts for the rich.... they're designed to be too small to make private school affordable for the working class, so that mostly they're just supplemental income for those wealthy people who were going to send their kids to private school one way or the other. If the vouchers are a bit bigger, such that they let a few upper-middle-class people opt for private school, that has drawbacks, too, in that it takes some of the best students and most engaged parents out of the public school, making it worse, and thus worsening the quality of education received by the majority of kids. The only voucher system that would get around this problem would be one with vouchers so big that even the poor could afford private school. But, even that is potentially risky if there aren't sufficient private school options in the area (for example, picture an area where the only local private school is religious -- you could wind up forcing someone to either choose to have his kid indoctrinated in a faith he doesn't share, or to go to a public school that has had the money sucked out of it). Overall, I'm not terribly optimistic about vouchers.
 
Never mind, Mary Anne.

ALL Republicans think exactly as Arkady stated.

There are NO problems with Public Schools, and/or the Public Teachers Union.

Republicans are the cause of all our problems in education, just like everything else.....
 
Like I said, browbeating unions hasn't gotten us anywhere, and there's no reason to think it will start to get us anywhere. So, anyone serious about school reform needs to think more constructively than that. One way or the other, your URL linked to a story about Joe Paterno.
 
...And that, in turn, is less about school administration than it is about wider demographic phenomena like localized poverty (slums). If someone like Romney wants to get serious about fixing our schools, he'll need to focus on fixing our wealth inequality issues and repairing our poor communities....

I think you've defined why the education reform movement has proved to be of limited effectiveness. It's not enough to evaluate individual teacher merit and reward accordingly, rewrite work rules or teacher benefits. Those have been tried in various guises for onwards of 30 years with--as you say--mixed results and many education policy examples to choose from.

Much more difficult politically is recognizing the relationship between poverty, income stratification and educational outcomes, and translating that relationship into an education policy.

Sooner or later, the question always revolves around the undesirable social and political consequences to rising income inequality.
 
Never mind, Mary Anne.

ALL Republicans think exactly as Arkady stated.

There are NO problems with Public Schools, and/or the Public Teachers Union.

Republicans are the cause of all our problems in education, just like everything else.....

You are putting words in my posts I did not type. I never mentioned Republicans.I did say,"Our Schools are fine." They arein my area.I did say Charter schools are money making schemes. That has been proven right here by the many charged with theft,others closed.

I also said in other posts that we stopped Kasich and his merry gang dead in their tracks. We did.Kasich has been mostly out of sight since that fiasco and Republicans are trying hard to undo the damage they did on voting rights. Getting rid of the bill they voted for while it is already on the ballot. Key Stone Cops here in Ohio.
 
Back
Top