New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flat earther hero melts down

Mytzlplk

Governor
as it turns out he really differs little from the little flat earthers we have to deal with -- they don't know squat about what they're talking about, yet feel as if they have an "informed opinion" worthy of consideration.

For example, they just never quit lying

"It doesn’t matter how many times the Hockey Stick is independently verified, (as is the case with the "climategate" people http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_controversy ) the anti-science crowd just hate, hate, hate it and Dr. Mann with a force that is beyond reason. Note that he offers no evidence against Mann or Monbiot or Flannery here — mainly because there isn’t any."

If you ever needed (more) proof that the professional deniers are driven by a mindless rage devoid of any actual science, I urge you to read James Delingpole’s latest piece.

It will nauseate you — consider yourself warned. But I think it’s important to dissect this hate speech in detail because Delingpole seems to think that hate speech isn’t hate speech if you just use rhetoric — the figures of speech, like metaphor.

Having spent a quarter century studying rhetoric and having just published a well-received book on this very subject — Language Intelligence: Lessons on persuasion from Jesus, Shakespeare, Lincoln, and Lady Gaga — I think I can safely say that is bullshit, though most likely only metaphorical bullshit (see below).

You may recall Delingpole’s 2011 meltdown on the BBC, where they got him to admit he is a hand-waving know-nothing: “It is not my job to sit down and read peer-reviewed papers because I simply haven’t got the time…. I am an interpreter of interpretations.” This pieces makes that meltdown look like the height of lucidity.

The piece is also worth examining closely because I think it is indicative of how the deniers and disinformers really feel — and we’ll know if that’s true if none of them denounce it.

The headline is “An English class for trolls, professional offence-takers and climate activists.” Delingpole is going to lecture us plebes on our native tongue.

Under the headline is the photo above, which is one of the popular pictures of the post-WWII Nuremberg trials in which Nazis were tried for “war crimes” and “crimes against humanity.” The Telegraph‘s caption is simply, “Not pictured: Monbiot, Flannery, Mann….” That would be George Monbiot, Tim Flannery, and Michael Mann.

Yes, that’s right, this isn’t hate speech just from Delingpole — senior editors at the paper must have signed off on all this. Oh, but it gets much worse.​
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/20...nging-is-far-too-good-for-climate-scientists/
 
OVER the past 15 years air temperatures at the Earth’s surface have been flat while greenhouse-gas emissions have continued to soar. The world added roughly 100 billion tonnes of carbon to the atmosphere between 2000 and 2010. That is about a quarter of all the CO₂ put there by humanity since 1750. And yet, as James Hansen, the head of NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies, observes, “the five-year mean global temperature has been flat for a decade.”


Temperatures fluctuate over short periods, but this lack of new warming is a surprise. Ed Hawkins, of the University of Reading, in Britain, points out that surface temperatures since 2005 are already at the low end of the range of projections derived from 20 climate models (see chart 1). If they remain flat, they will fall outside the models’ range within a few years.

http://freebeacon.com/science-earth-not-warming-over-last-15-years/

Temps not increasing along with carbon emissions, models incorrect, science not settled.

Period.
 
Sorry, not about to get involved in a debate regarding the efficacy of your religion.

I just posted the doubts and drawbacks of your side as stated by thr godfather of the climate change perspective. Your welcome to your own leaps of faith.
 
thanks for conceding your obvious ignorance, which is generally backed up profusely with bluster and BS.

You posted what amounts to already debunked garbage, given that this cherry-picking of a year with which to peddle manufactured "doubts" and fictitious "drawbacks" it isn't new, and is really just resurrected garbage. This kinda cherry-picking has been around at least since Phil Jones made his "not statistically significant" comment that was distorted all to hell by your flat earther masters.

ANd the rebuttal remains the same and was recently validated -- most of the warming has gone to the oceans. While you flat earthers may think "global warming " is ONLY about surface temps, us informed people know better.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/print.php?r=138

http://thinkprogress.org/climate/20...n-past-15-years-new-study-of-oceans-confirms/

you're welcome to remain ignorant too, which is why your wise to back out now before I kick your butt right square in.

you can have the last word for now -- I gotta scoot
 
Yiou oughta check the dates on my post, you're "dismissing" findings reeported April of this year.

You have an active imagination, I'll give you that, it matches your horseshit temperament

"you're welcome to remain ignorant too, which is why your wise to back out now before I kick your butt right square in"

There aren't many people who melt down so quickly over scientific debate of something still undecided.
 
Sorry delingpole junior, your dates don't mean squat, much as your dodging here doesn't, other than to label you as a dishionest dodgeboy.

The only reason I won't make more of a fed case outta your dishonest dodging (although it is highly amusing given the scarcity of posts by you or in threads where you don't charge some lib with real or imagined dodging) is because you've unwittingly made the case for me that you dodged.

That BS from the beacon doesn't say squat about anything but the ongoing controversy withing the climatolgy ranks about what exactly climate sensitivity to co2 is, which in no way undermines the almost 100% certainty that AGW is the reality, as the economist piece in its entirety makes clear.

A sensitive matter
The climate may be heating up less in response to greenhouse-gas emissions than was once thought. But that does not mean the problem is going away


Furthermore, I provided a link to what indicates the CS is likely on the higher end of things as opposed to the lower.

ANd in terms of predictions overall, they are pretty accurate http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/03/27/climate-change-models-predict-remarkably-accurate-results/

So, what are we left with delingpole junior -- AGW is the reality, and you've done nothing but show you don't understand what you read, assuming you even read it. WHatever uncertainty that exists as to what the exact value of climate sensitivity is in no way disproves or shows any "uncertainty" whatsoever about the reality of AGW, and the fact that you can't seem to understand something so simple doesn't undermine it either. It just establishes that your an ignorant blowhard.

eh delingpole junior?
 
I know I've rambled on this in the past but...let's consider the "science" around the health hazards to non-smokers, of secondhand smoke. I imagine most people assume this question was well-answered, some time ago. Most people would be wrong. In fact, this science is tenuous at BEST. If 50 is the median, 49 is "not hazardous" and 51 is "hazardous", this science would barely score a 51. So, why haven't we heard about this? Why isn't anyone challenging it? It's simple....nobody LIKES secondhand smoke. There's really nothing positive to be gained by proving it isn't hazardous.

The same SHOULD be true of the dingle-balls who're clinging to the idea that the global warming consensus isn't valid. What the hell is the point? Even in the microscopically remote instance that it IS proven invalid, so what? What would we possibly gain from that?

On another note, isn't it interesting that ALL of the more public flatearthers are fringesters and outliers, that don't enjoy the respect of their fellows? Why is that? The lickers at the flatearther's patoots, tell us that it's because no one else likes that they're farting on the consensus. But....maybe it's just because there are ALWAYS a few fringekooks as to ANY issue, who see an opportunity to have the cameras and microphones pointed their way?
 
I think to understand the dynmaics of it all, you have to separate the contrarian leadership from the flat earthers we deal with fair.

First, the obvious motivations of their masters:

If we spew 565 gigatons more carbon into the atmosphere, we’ll quite possibly go right past that reddest of red lines. But the oil companies, private and state-owned, have current reserves on the books equivalent to 2,795 gigatons -- five times more than we can ever safely burn. It has to stay in the ground.

Put another way, in ecological terms it would be extremely prudent to write off $20 trillion worth of those reserves. In economic terms, of course, it would be a disaster, first and foremost for shareholders and executives of companies like ExxonMobil (and people in places like Venezuela).

If you run an oil company, this sort of write-off is the disastrous future staring you in the face as soon as climate change is taken as seriously as it should be, and that’s far scarier than drought and flood. It’s why you’ll do anything -- including fund an endless campaigns of lies -- to avoid coming to terms with its reality. So instead, we simply charge ahead. To take just one example, last month the boss of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Thomas Donohue, called for burning all the country’s newly discovered coal, gas, and oil -- believed to be 1,800 gigatons worth of carbon from our nation alone. http://oilprice.com/The-Environment...ont-Want-us-Talking-about-Climate-Change.html

IN the case of their minions here, it's all about saving face after being so abysmally wrong about it for going on a decade now.

Your point on the risk/benefit analysis is well taken. WHat I've never understood and questioned for years now, is how this same crew could follow Bush/Cheney into Iraq with the accompanying expense by so many measures based on Cheney's 1% doctrine, while they freely ignore what is likely to be something close to if not a 100% certainty in the next IPCC as to the cause of climate change, which puts the entire planet at risk from the ravages of it.

Their campaign and that launched by the tobacco industry long ago is frequently noted in criticism of the AGW denial industry.
 
The Fox/Mitt/GOPs shout that the world's only hope of economic survival, is to cut, slash, and drill. To me, that sounds like a darn good theme for the next Mel Gibson movie. There's a better way. The world is primed for the next "bubble". Green energy would be our Godsend in this regard.

The actual number of people whose livelihoods would be directly impacted by an overtly anti-dino energy regime, is surprisingly small. Even the vast majority working for or investing in the current dino-economy, could be advantaged by wonderous new opportunities. So...IF the perpetuation of dino serves so few, why are we still debating the question?

Well...for the same reason that 91% support universal background checks, but Congress is going to refuse to legislate them. The gun and dino marketeers are few. But, the Fox/GOPsters are cheerleading for them. And, all the Fox/GOPsters care about, is fighting the "good fight" against the evil other.
 
well, there's also the question as to what we do next dude, once reliance on oil is over. http://www.financialsense.com/contr...ise-of-the-petrodollar-system-dollars-for-oil

which of course, has long been a bipartisan affair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carter_Doctrine

some think the days of the petrodollar are numbered anyway, and/or will be before the oil dependency is broken

While the existence of and solutions for AGW are obvious, what the ramifications of the solutions will be aren't, because I suspect they will present problems of their own in this country, once the petrodollar credit card is cut up, as well as for the rest of the world. http://gulfnews.com/business/features/what-comes-after-the-petrodollar-1.604366
 
Temperatures fluctuate over short periods, but this lack of new warming is a surprise. Ed Hawkins, of the University of Reading, in Britain, points out that surface temperatures since 2005 are already at the low end of the range of projections derived from 20 climate models (see chart 1). If they remain flat, they will fall outside the models’ range within a few years.

http://freebeacon.com/science-earth-not-warming-over-last-15-years/

Temps not increasing along with carbon emissions, models incorrect, science not settled.

Period.

Actually if you read this you would see that the observed temperatures so far are consistent with the models. It is only IF temperatures REMAIN flat that the models will need to be revised--as they were revised several times in the 1980s and 1990s to reflect higher-than-expected warming. No climate scientist or intelligent person has ever suggested a linear relationship between carbon emissions and temperature increase. The science of how much carbon emissions are driving up temperatures is not entirely settled; but our models today are surely better than those of the 1980s and 1990s, which drastically underestimated the effects of carbon emissions, while the fact of anthropogenic global warming is evident to all but the (often willfully) ignorant.

As for what to do, I think nuclear and solar power, and conservation, are gonna be the biggest parts of the solution. Natural gas, which is less harmful than coal or oil, has a future as well. We also need to be prepared for rising ocean levels and more extreme weather events.
 
Science is pretty certain it has the explanation for why atmospheric temps haven't risen quite so much as the models might've predicted, over the last decade or two. It's about increasing NON-greenhouse gas polllutants, reflecting solar radiation. Perhaps the flatearthers are going to start farting that the "solution" is for us to pollute more, rather than less. Otherwise, science suggests that as we reduce our emissions of non-greenhouse gas pollutants and they begin to dissipate, we'll lose their reflectivity benefit.
 
Back
Top