New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For conservatives.

Not for the slave labor. And effectively not for the employer either.
An employer is not obligated to extend a union contract. It's a choice. And it's a choice for the participants in the union, too. And they choose it because union members make much higher wages, on average. Of course, if someone has the choice to free-ride --to get the benefit of union representation without paying the dues-- that even better for the individual.
 
Compelled participation invites revolt.

Fact is unions are obsolete. A.I., robotics, and solar energy capture technologies (liquid storage forms most likely) will relegate one parent to raising a child(ren) as a primary and most useful job.

I see a renaissance of classical values as a very likely outcome with the demise of unions.
 
An employer is not obligated to extend a union contract. It's a choice. And it's a choice for the participants in the union, too. And they choose it because union members make much higher wages, on average. Of course, if someone has the choice to free-ride --to get the benefit of union representation without paying the dues-- that even better for the individual.
You have absolutely no idea how unions work do you?
 
Your example is flawed. Besides which, if the court held it was an unfair business practice to exclude the actual manufactuers - that has consistenly been within the courts' rights to decide.

It doesn't track to the union case, because in that case - the union nor the state had the right - to essentially take away the right of choice of the individuals. The unions were not on the hook to provide anything to the State - so that is completely different than your supplier situation. Yes, the employees who are represented by the union may loose out with people out there willing to work for less than they are- but that isn't the same thing as the union itself loosing out - as your supplier was loosing out above.

Additionally, I think you completely either don't undersand conservative principles or intentionally misrepresent them.But, by and large conservatives believe the courts have a place in determining unfair business practices, interpreting the rules, establishing precedent, etc. I would not agree with the court intervening in your example because they are dealing only with two parties and it is unclear that anything about their agreement ran afoul of the law. But, that is not the case here. The case we have here, is about individual freedom. The freedom of teh individual person to not participating or have their dollars facilitate speech and activities by an organization. And, if one princple overrides all others in conservativsim... is is that the right of the individual trumps the collective every time. So, conservatives are cheering because in this case the court said, we can not force these people to participate in this particular union in this particular situation - because they do not seem to get enough support from the union to qualify as a regular employee who would otherwise be getting significant support from the union. It was a win - for individuals. It has nothing to do with either the State or theUnion - other than to say - that neither one can infringe on the rights of the individual. That is a case the Conservative will get behind every time.

connie
My example deals with two parties -- the vendor and Wal Mart. But it indirectly deals with many parties -- all those who want to supply Wal Mart directly but can't, because it did a deal where it agreed only to work with one supplier. It's the same with union questions, where the purchaser of the services has agreed only to deal with the union. The only real difference is whether the intermediary is a non-profit union that represents the interests of working people, or rather a for-profit company, which represents the interests of its owners.

Even more direct examples come up, where corporations agree to use specific vendors for contract labor. For example, a corporation may do a deal with Pro Unlimited to be an exclusive provider of contingent workers. Would it be appropriate, then, for government to step in and say that Pro Unlimited remains bound to its half of the deal (prices, etc.), while the corporation is released from its half of the deal (the exclusivity)? In theory, a court could step in and force Pro Unlimited to continue representing everyone who works for that corporation, without being able to take a cut of any of their incomes. But a conservative court never would.
 
Funny little aside about the top post and the rest of this thread...The top poster leads with the word "imagine", but he goes on to describe pretty much the way Wal*Mart DOES do bidness!

Anyone who enters into a contract with Wal*Mart, has no one to blame but themselves.
It's not just Walmart, though. Exclusive supply contracts are quite common in business. And there's no push among conservatives to create "right to supply" legislation that deprives companies of that form of business deal. Normally, conservatives stand for freedom of contract -- at least the libertarian conservatives. But when it comes to unions that negotiate exclusive labor supply contracts, the conservatives push "right to work" legislation, to invalidate those negotiated terms.
 
You posted the definition in some attempt to prove a point.
I reported it.
It was probably deleted. It was inappropriate for any forum. It was (imo) not just the lame attempt to prove a point, but a veiled way to call me that specific name without being obvious. Other words could have been chosen. That you chose that one was no accident.
I remember posting that word once, as part of a block of text from the USPTO, rejecting an offensive trademark application. It was one of several examples of offensive trademark applications I posted, not to call anyone names, but to make the point that the USPTO has a long history of rejecting applications based on offensive terms, like Redskins. But, of course, in your mind it was all about you. How funny!
 
I remember posting that word once, as part of a block of text from the USPTO, rejecting an offensive trademark application. It was one of several examples of offensive trademark applications I posted, not to call anyone names, but to make the point that the USPTO has a long history of rejecting applications based on offensive terms, like Redskins. But, of course, in your mind it was all about you. How funny!

You made a post specifically to me.
It was offensive.
I am a bit surprised that you laugh at the idea of offending me.

I will expect it from now on.

8237468240_f3b9e33787_m.jpg
 
Look no further than the teacher's union to see just how crazy-powerful unions can get.

Not only do you get pension, 90% of your freakin' salary AFTER you retire for the rest of your life... but, they also have a monopoly on public teaching jobs. You HAVE to be a party of the union to get a teaching job at a public school. No competition there, just a straight monopoly.
 
You made a post specifically to me.
It was offensive.
I am a bit surprised that you laugh at the idea of offending me.

I will expect it from now on.

8237468240_f3b9e33787_m.jpg
If that's the incident you were thinking of, then what you're suffering from is called narcissism.
 
It's not just Walmart, though. Exclusive supply contracts are quite common in business. And there's no push among conservatives to create "right to supply" legislation that deprives companies of that form of business deal. Normally, conservatives stand for freedom of contract -- at least the libertarian conservatives. But when it comes to unions that negotiate exclusive labor supply contracts, the conservatives push "right to work" legislation, to invalidate those negotiated terms.

Wal*Mart is infamous for engaging in supply contracts and then fudging their end of the deal. When the other party deigns to complain, Wal*Mart says something like, "Do what you need to do. It's our lawyers against yours".
 
Back
Top