New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

For conservatives.

You entirely leave out the concept of value add. And you ceaselessly compare apples to oranges. I'd imagine in our scenario the contract the supplier has with Walmart ends. Grown ups wait for contracts to end or buy them out. The union never ends. It transcends generations of workers and is not only long lived like a vampire but arguably a blood sucker parasite to boot.
Union contracts end, too.
 
Is it a good idea for the court to interfere with the freedom of contract of two sophisticated business entities, that way? Is it a good idea for it to unilaterally change the terms of a hard-bargained business deal? Is it wise for them to rule exclusive supply contracts unconstitutional?
Yes, the govt needs to be involved, for the same reasons they need to determine if some business has a monopoly, and for the same reason they have to regulate other utility prices. Conservatives are not opposed to all govt intervention no more than liberals think govt should be involved in everything. These are judgment calls. The rulings go both ways.

People of faith and businesses that want to project a certain faith or code of morals are obligated to abide by the nation’s laws. Example: a Christian couple running a bakery is forced by law to cater to a gay couple’s wedding. But abortion is a more grave matter (as far as sensible Christians are concerned) and the supreme court agreed. Now the govt is greatly trampling on sacred matters that are also of grave moral matter. Here they drew the line.

This is not a watershed moment, imo. In future cases of this nature it will still be judgment calls. And by a large margin your side has been winning for at least the past 50+ years.
 
Imagine you own a company that provides retailers with the shelves they use for in-store displays. After a long, hard negotiation, you have struck up a mutually beneficial deal with Wal Mart. They agree to make you their exclusive provider of such shelves, for a certain period, and in exchange you agree to provide them agreed pricing, and to ensure that all their orders get filled in a certain period of time. You're able to provide that pricing and those guarantees because the exclusive contract lets you line up sourcing at prices that wouldn't be available without an assurance of that kind of volume. But, some of your own Chinese suppliers, who make the actual shelves, don't like the fact Wal Mart won't buy from them unless they sell through your business . So, they bring a lawsuit, and, because they have a lot of political pull, the court strikes down that provision of your contract. You're still required to sell to Wal Mart at the same price, with the same obligations for timely order fulfillment, but you're no longer able to count on the volume, because any time Wal Mart can find cheaper supply directly from your suppliers, it's allowed to do so, notwithstanding what they agreed. Is it a good idea for the court to interfere with the freedom of contract of two sophisticated business entities, that way? Is it a good idea for it to unilaterally change the terms of a hard-bargained business deal? Is it wise for them to rule exclusive supply contracts unconstitutional?

Most conservatives would object to "Big Brother" stepping in and screwing around with a supply contract that way. Yet, it seems conservatives would be just fine with it in another context, where what was being supplied weren't goods, but rather labor. Unions have made exclusive-supply deals for labor with a number of companies, and so should Big Brother unilaterally come through and alter the negotiated terms of those deals, to allow the companies to ignore the exclusivity terms they agreed to, while continuing to bind the unions to any obligations they agreed to in exchange for that exclusivity? That kind of interference in contract would be anathema to conservatives in most contexts, but when it's seen as a way to take power away from labor, for the benefit of capital, they toss that principle out the window. Libertarian-minded conservatives should be particularly offended by such a concept, but since they're not honestly principle-driven, but rather driven by a desire for partisan political outcomes favoring the wealthy, they won't be.

I only scanned the news article about the ruling but how I don't think the above applies at all, if it ever did to any union deal, because the employers were going directly to the employees directly. The people covered were never public employees. They never worked for the state.
 
Yes, the govt needs to be involved, for the same reasons they need to determine if some business has a monopoly, and for the same reason they have to regulate other utility prices. Conservatives are not opposed to all govt intervention no more than liberals think govt should be involved in everything. These are judgment calls. The rulings go both ways.

People of faith and businesses that want to project a certain faith or code of morals are obligated to abide by the nation’s laws. Example: a Christian couple running a bakery is forced by law to cater to a gay couple’s wedding. But abortion is a more grave matter (as far as sensible Christians are concerned) and the supreme court agreed. Now the govt is greatly trampling on sacred matters that are also of grave moral matter. Here they drew the line.

This is not a watershed moment, imo. In future cases of this nature it will still be judgment calls. And by a large margin your side has been winning for at least the past 50+ years.
Except forcing an individual baker to make a cake or photographer to take pictures and to participate in a ceremony against their genuinely held and long established religious beliefs is unreasonable and clearly goes against the 1st amendment.

Do you really think a person asking for a Satanist wedding cake to be held at a naked ceremony is not also protected under this kind of thinking. It is and it is absurd thinking.
 
Imagine you own a company that provides retailers with the shelves they use for in-store displays. After a long, hard negotiation, you have struck up a mutually beneficial deal with Wal Mart. They agree to make you their exclusive provider of such shelves, for a certain period, and in exchange you agree to provide them agreed pricing, and to ensure that all their orders get filled in a certain period of time. You're able to provide that pricing and those guarantees because the exclusive contract lets you line up sourcing at prices that wouldn't be available without an assurance of that kind of volume. But, some of your own Chinese suppliers, who make the actual shelves, don't like the fact Wal Mart won't buy from them unless they sell through your business . So, they bring a lawsuit, and, because they have a lot of political pull, the court strikes down that provision of your contract. You're still required to sell to Wal Mart at the same price, with the same obligations for timely order fulfillment, but you're no longer able to count on the volume, because any time Wal Mart can find cheaper supply directly from your suppliers, it's allowed to do so, notwithstanding what they agreed. Is it a good idea for the court to interfere with the freedom of contract of two sophisticated business entities, that way? Is it a good idea for it to unilaterally change the terms of a hard-bargained business deal? Is it wise for them to rule exclusive supply contracts unconstitutional?

Most conservatives would object to "Big Brother" stepping in and screwing around with a supply contract that way. Yet, it seems conservatives would be just fine with it in another context, where what was being supplied weren't goods, but rather labor. Unions have made exclusive-supply deals for labor with a number of companies, and so should Big Brother unilaterally come through and alter the negotiated terms of those deals, to allow the companies to ignore the exclusivity terms they agreed to, while continuing to bind the unions to any obligations they agreed to in exchange for that exclusivity? That kind of interference in contract would be anathema to conservatives in most contexts, but when it's seen as a way to take power away from labor, for the benefit of capital, they toss that principle out the window. Libertarian-minded conservatives should be particularly offended by such a concept, but since they're not honestly principle-driven, but rather driven by a desire for partisan political outcomes favoring the wealthy, they won't be.


Your example is flawed. Besides which, if the court held it was an unfair business practice to exclude the actual manufactuers - that has consistenly been within the courts' rights to decide.

It doesn't track to the union case, because in that case - the union nor the state had the right - to essentially take away the right of choice of the individuals. The unions were not on the hook to provide anything to the State - so that is completely different than your supplier situation. Yes, the employees who are represented by the union may loose out with people out there willing to work for less than they are- but that isn't the same thing as the union itself loosing out - as your supplier was loosing out above.

Additionally, I think you completely either don't undersand conservative principles or intentionally misrepresent them.But, by and large conservatives believe the courts have a place in determining unfair business practices, interpreting the rules, establishing precedent, etc. I would not agree with the court intervening in your example because they are dealing only with two parties and it is unclear that anything about their agreement ran afoul of the law. But, that is not the case here. The case we have here, is about individual freedom. The freedom of teh individual person to not participating or have their dollars facilitate speech and activities by an organization. And, if one princple overrides all others in conservativsim... is is that the right of the individual trumps the collective every time. So, conservatives are cheering because in this case the court said, we can not force these people to participate in this particular union in this particular situation - because they do not seem to get enough support from the union to qualify as a regular employee who would otherwise be getting significant support from the union. It was a win - for individuals. It has nothing to do with either the State or theUnion - other than to say - that neither one can infringe on the rights of the individual. That is a case the Conservative will get behind every time.

connie
 
Which post? I have no recollection of calling you or any other poster here that, and I just searched my history and it didn't turn up any examples of me using that word. It turns up two posts where unwelcome language has been deleted, but in each case the context makes it clear that wasn't the word, and in neither case was it directed at you.

You posted the definition in some attempt to prove a point.
I reported it.
It was probably deleted. It was inappropriate for any forum. It was (imo) not just the lame attempt to prove a point, but a veiled way to call me that specific name without being obvious. Other words could have been chosen. That you chose that one was no accident.
 
Except forcing an individual baker to make a cake or photographer to take pictures and to participate in a ceremony against their genuinely held and long established religious beliefs is unreasonable and clearly goes against the 1st amendment.

Do you really think a person asking for a Satanist wedding cake to be held at a naked ceremony is not also protected under this kind of thinking. It is and it is absurd thinking.
Well I tend to agree with you. But there are all kinds of scenarios where I would hope reasonableness or fairness prevails? For example, can I as a store owner refuse to let a muslim shop there, or buy a whip? But neither can a Muslim hotel owner insist that I follow shariah law or not be served, in this nation. Yet in another matter --- I would not want laws to force a landlord to rent out his home to a gay couple or even a hetero couple that is cohabitating if it offends his beliefs in sin. But does not our laws say they have to? I think it does? At least --- Christians have a better chance fighting more ostensible serious moral matters, like today's ruling, and little chance overcoming other issues, especially when public opinion is swaying more and more against them.
 
Funny little aside about the top post and the rest of this thread...The top poster leads with the word "imagine", but he goes on to describe pretty much the way Wal*Mart DOES do bidness!

Anyone who enters into a contract with Wal*Mart, has no one to blame but themselves.
 
Yes, the govt needs to be involved, for the same reasons they need to determine if some business has a monopoly, and for the same reason they have to regulate other utility prices. Conservatives are not opposed to all govt intervention no more than liberals think govt should be involved in everything. These are judgment calls. The rulings go both ways.

People of faith and businesses that want to project a certain faith or code of morals are obligated to abide by the nation’s laws. Example: a Christian couple running a bakery is forced by law to cater to a gay couple’s wedding. But abortion is a more grave matter (as far as sensible Christians are concerned) and the supreme court agreed. Now the govt is greatly trampling on sacred matters that are also of grave moral matter. Here they drew the line.

This is not a watershed moment, imo. In future cases of this nature it will still be judgment calls. And by a large margin your side has been winning for at least the past 50+ years.

"""But abortion is a more grave matter (as far as sensible Christians are concerned)"""

This is the crux. You're okay with the guvmint quantifying relative gravity. In other words, you're okay with the Court's ruling because it supports YOUR feelings.

Some of us think it better that we find a path that does include a guvmint entity adjudging gravity in this manner.
 
"""But abortion is a more grave matter (as far as sensible Christians are concerned)"""

This is the crux. You're okay with the guvmint quantifying relative gravity. In other words, you're okay with the Court's ruling because it supports YOUR feelings.

Some of us think it better that we find a path that does include a guvmint entity adjudging gravity in this manner.

"doesn't", not "does"
 
The Supreme Court has ruled.
We really don't need to continue to rehash it.

stock-footage-a-stamp-is-printing-the-word-rejected-in-red.jpg
 
Not for the slave labor. And effectively not for the employer either.

Exactly. I have a client who is attempting to not renew their contract right now. It has gotten really ugly. Not only can you basically not resign - you can not open another non-union company either and just close your other business. There is practically no way to get out of the union strong hold short of going out of business and declaring bankruptcy.
 
Imagine you own a company that provides retailers with the shelves they use for in-store displays. After a long, hard negotiation, you have struck up a mutually beneficial deal with Wal Mart. They agree to make you their exclusive provider of such shelves, for a certain period, and in exchange you agree to provide them agreed pricing, and to ensure that all their orders get filled in a certain period of time. You're able to provide that pricing and those guarantees because the exclusive contract lets you line up sourcing at prices that wouldn't be available without an assurance of that kind of volume. But, some of your own Chinese suppliers, who make the actual shelves, don't like the fact Wal Mart won't buy from them unless they sell through your business . So, they bring a lawsuit, and, because they have a lot of political pull, the court strikes down that provision of your contract. You're still required to sell to Wal Mart at the same price, with the same obligations for timely order fulfillment, but you're no longer able to count on the volume, because any time Wal Mart can find cheaper supply directly from your suppliers, it's allowed to do so, notwithstanding what they agreed. Is it a good idea for the court to interfere with the freedom of contract of two sophisticated business entities, that way? Is it a good idea for it to unilaterally change the terms of a hard-bargained business deal? Is it wise for them to rule exclusive supply contracts unconstitutional?

Most conservatives would object to "Big Brother" stepping in and screwing around with a supply contract that way. Yet, it seems conservatives would be just fine with it in another context, where what was being supplied weren't goods, but rather labor. Unions have made exclusive-supply deals for labor with a number of companies, and so should Big Brother unilaterally come through and alter the negotiated terms of those deals, to allow the companies to ignore the exclusivity terms they agreed to, while continuing to bind the unions to any obligations they agreed to in exchange for that exclusivity? That kind of interference in contract would be anathema to conservatives in most contexts, but when it's seen as a way to take power away from labor, for the benefit of capital, they toss that principle out the window. Libertarian-minded conservatives should be particularly offended by such a concept, but since they're not honestly principle-driven, but rather driven by a desire for partisan political outcomes favoring the wealthy, they won't be.

Ark, conservatives are just FINE with Big Brother, Big Courts, Big Gub-ment or Big anything else stepping in with regards to things they agree with.

The very SECOND that they remain consistent within the context of something they DON'T agree with, they'll have a conniption fit.

Just you wait until a religion (or NON-religion) they don't agree with uses this as a precedent to something even more heinous.

SCOTUS created said precedent, and screw Alito's claim of a "narrow ruling" that will exclude blood transfusions and immunizations. That's BS.

Until we get one of these majority clowns replaced.. we're screwed and only God can help us. They are now on a veritable hyper-activist ROLL.
 
Last edited:
Imagine you own a company that provides retailers with the shelves they use for in-store displays. After a long, hard negotiation, you have struck up a mutually beneficial deal with Wal Mart. They agree to make you their exclusive provider of such shelves, for a certain period, and in exchange you agree to provide them agreed pricing, and to ensure that all their orders get filled in a certain period of time. You're able to provide that pricing and those guarantees because the exclusive contract lets you line up sourcing at prices that wouldn't be available without an assurance of that kind of volume. But, some of your own Chinese suppliers, who make the actual shelves, don't like the fact Wal Mart won't buy from them unless they sell through your business . So, they bring a lawsuit, and, because they have a lot of political pull, the court strikes down that provision of your contract. You're still required to sell to Wal Mart at the same price, with the same obligations for timely order fulfillment, but you're no longer able to count on the volume, because any time Wal Mart can find cheaper supply directly from your suppliers, it's allowed to do so, notwithstanding what they agreed. Is it a good idea for the court to interfere with the freedom of contract of two sophisticated business entities, that way? Is it a good idea for it to unilaterally change the terms of a hard-bargained business deal? Is it wise for them to rule exclusive supply contracts unconstitutional?

Most conservatives would object to "Big Brother" stepping in and screwing around with a supply contract that way. Yet, it seems conservatives would be just fine with it in another context, where what was being supplied weren't goods, but rather labor. Unions have made exclusive-supply deals for labor with a number of companies, and so should Big Brother unilaterally come through and alter the negotiated terms of those deals, to allow the companies to ignore the exclusivity terms they agreed to, while continuing to bind the unions to any obligations they agreed to in exchange for that exclusivity? That kind of interference in contract would be anathema to conservatives in most contexts, but when it's seen as a way to take power away from labor, for the benefit of capital, they toss that principle out the window. Libertarian-minded conservatives should be particularly offended by such a concept, but since they're not honestly principle-driven, but rather driven by a desire for partisan political outcomes favoring the wealthy, they won't be.
You need a better attorney.
 
I'm fine with continuing to debate Roe v. Wade. But, let's recall, it's a case that was decided 7-2, and has survived for 41 years, through all kinds of different court lineups, so it's unlikely it's going anywhere. The cases that just came out today, on the other hand, were closely decided by five arch conservatives, and probably wouldn't survive a single timely death by one of them. That seems like a more productive area for argument.

Anyway, on a side point, I've dug into the union case and realized it's a lot narrower than I thought. It doesn't amount to a generalized striking down of union exclusivity principles, but rather just applies to public unions. I'll need to read it in its entirety, when I have more time.
Appears to me that the libs on scotus are the ones that are wrong on this issue.
 
But neither can a Muslim hotel owner insist that I follow shariah law or not be served, in this nation. .

Why not? What would happen if you went to a moslem hotel and they told you you must follow Sharia law (wherein it does not egregiously broach U.S. law)? Wouldn't you just leave? How would that loss of commerce affect the hotelier? If it didn't affect him commercially then still so what? This particular example imparts choice on both parties.

If a landlord doesn't rent to cohabitators or gays so what? Won't someone else get that business? Won't the landlord lose out physically but maybe come out ahead spiritually(if only in his mind)?

Counterintuitively do you know when black business ownership was very high. Before the Civil Rights movement. Blacks had to have places to shop and so many black owned business thrived at the time. Look into it. It is very interesting stuff.

No, MLK did a great thing for this country beyond just equal rights. He boosted the economy greatly. Holding a people down is very expensive in many ways. Freedom creates wealth.
 
The operative principle for me is that of liberty. Those scenarios which tend to handcuff the individual in favor of the aggregate - particularly where government agency is employed (either in execution or guarantee).
One of the rights of the individual is to participate in an aggregate, whether it be a firm, a union, or a government. The individual gives up some rights to the group, in order to have a proportional share of say over what the aggregate does, hopefully with greater overall value to the individual by way of the grouped power.
 
Back
Top